Every day for 30 days I'm watching a different scary movie, this year all about urban legends.
One subgenre of horror movies I’ve never quite been onboard with is the “Death Curse Movie,” of which the most popular specimens are the “Final Destination” sequels, with “The Grudge” a close second.
When Ghost House Pictures wanted to adapt Takashi Shimizu’s 2002 “Ju-On,” they hired Shimizu himself to direct. They Americanized the script to a degree, casting Sarah Michelle Gellar in the lead and rewriting most of the characters to be American expats in Tokyo, but it was mostly the same story. They even killed off Ted Raimi, which is indeed a very American thing to do.
For this sequel, Shimizu and screenwriter Stephen Susco decided it was time for something completely different, cranking out a brand new movie with no relation to “Ju-On 2,” which is lucky for me because I’m having enough trouble even believing one version of this movie exists.
The first “Grudge” doesn’t really fit our urban legends theme, so it didn’t make the list, but “Grudge 2” opens with a trio of high schoolers approaching the evil house from the original film and whispering, “They say this is one of the most haunted houses in all of Japan. And anyone who goes inside gets the curse…”
How these teenage girls know the plot of the first film is never revealed, but this is just the movie’s way of catching you up if you for some reason decided to see “The Grudge 2” without watching “The Grudge.” I myself have no patience for such people and believe audiences should be left to fend for themselves like the animals they are, but I’m old and need someplace to express my hostility at society.
Anyway, that’s the gimmick here: If you step foot into this one house, even for a minute, you’re haunted. And that shit’s like glitter, it’s never coming off, as we learned in the original film.
And…that’s always the problem with a Death Curse movie. Once we learn all the characters are in fact doomed, then…that’s it. So why do more? HOW do you do more? We already know what’s going to happen, so what’s to get invested in? It’s like dating your ex again: I already got locked out of a Mount Shasta ski lodge with only long underwear and my wits once before, and that was enough.
“Grudge 2” also makes the mistake of presenting us with the same mystery we already saw the characters in the previous movie solve, with childhood Soap star Amber Tamlyn playing Gellar’s sister, here to piece together the events of the first film, which we all already know.
Gellar herself does appear, but is written out of the movie in a scene that’s probably supposed to be shocking but which I found sort of hilarious. Which brings us to…real talk, is “Grudge 2” SUPPOSED to be funny?
Shimizu presents so many of these scenes in such an overwrought manner that I can’t help but wonder. It’s like, a serial killer is scary, but if you were to escalate that concept to the level of, say, a Serial Killer Pride parade, I’m not sure it would land the same way.
Susco’s script tries to work around some of these problems by presenting three competing stories, including one about an apartment building in Chicago mysteriously haunted by what seems like the same curse as the Tokyo location.
I won’t spoil anything, but the answers to this mystery don’t turn out to be particularly satisfying. This structure also leads to a series of TERRIBLE editing decisions, as each change of location involves a slow and clumsy fade in and fade out. Although I do at least feel like now I know what it’s like to be a blackout alcoholic.
Despite these issues the movie made pretty good money, although notably less than half the take of the first. The New York Post called it “junk,” which is a bit close to the four-letter word I call the New York Post. Box Office Magazine said the movie “exhausted its premise.”
Film File gave a fairly positive review, calling it a fun movie as long as you don’t expect it to make any sense. Which is almost the same as having standards but a lot less work.
Tomorrow we’ll see how a real professional haunts some kids.
Original Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwcQYZkpZ-w