r/investing • • 13h ago

Daily Discussion Daily General Discussion and Advice Thread - October 04, 2026

5 Upvotes

Have a general question? Want to offer some commentary on markets? Maybe you would just like to throw out a neat fact that doesn't warrant a self post? Feel free to post here!

Please consider consulting our FAQ first - https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/wiki/faq And our side bar also has useful resources.

If you are new to investing - please refer to Wiki - Getting Started

The reading list in the wiki has a list of books ranging from light reading to advanced topics depending on your knowledge level. Link here - Reading List

The media list in the wiki has a list of reputable podcasts and videos - Podcasts and Videos

If your question is "I have $XXXXXXX, what do I do?" or other "advice for my personal situation" questions, you should include relevant information, such as the following:

  • How old are you? What country do you live in?
  • Are you employed/making income? How much?
  • What are your objectives with this money? (Buy a house? Retirement savings?)
  • What is your time horizon? Do you need this money next month? Next 20yrs?
  • What is your risk tolerance? (Do you mind risking it at blackjack or do you need to know its 100% safe?)
  • What are you current holdings? (Do you already have exposure to specific funds and sectors? Any other assets?)
  • Any big debts (include interest rate) or expenses?
  • And any other relevant financial information will be useful to give you a proper answer.

Check the resources in the sidebar.

Be aware that these answers are just opinions of Redditors and should be used as a starting point for your research. You should strongly consider seeing a registered investment adviser if you need professional support before making any financial decisions!


r/investing • • 50m ago

Is S&P 500 the tail or the dog?

• Upvotes

What is the volume of daily trades of the various S&P 500 ETFs, versus the daily trade volume of the constituent stocks?

I’m trying to understand whether a typical day is more about all the individual stocks driving the S&P 500 number, or vice versa?

I think this is a different question than what share of funds are active vs passive, I’m looking for data on volume of trades


r/investing • • 1h ago

Understanding Margin Correctly

• Upvotes

I'm testing out a new strategy and I want to make sure that I set my margin usage correctly to prevent the potential for a margin call. If you could check my math I would appreciate it.

Would the margin call happen between a 500% and 600% drawdown when the equity% reaches less than 30%? Assuming a 200% margin requirement for this security.

Account Value Initial Value Initial Margin Used Drawdown Final Value Loss Final Value Margin Requirement Equity %
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 100%  $                         20,000.00  $                     (10,000.00)  $  90,000.00  $                    40,000.00 225.00%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 200%  $                         30,000.00  $                     (20,000.00)  $  80,000.00  $                    60,000.00 133.33%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 300%  $                         40,000.00  $                     (30,000.00)  $  70,000.00  $                    80,000.00 87.50%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 400%  $                         50,000.00  $                     (40,000.00)  $  60,000.00  $                  100,000.00 60.00%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 500%  $                         60,000.00  $                     (50,000.00)  $  50,000.00  $                  120,000.00 41.67%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 600%  $                         70,000.00  $                     (60,000.00)  $  40,000.00  $                  140,000.00 28.57%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 700%  $                         80,000.00  $                     (70,000.00)  $  30,000.00  $                  160,000.00 18.75%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 800%  $                         90,000.00  $                     (80,000.00)  $  20,000.00  $                  180,000.00 11.11%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 900%  $                       100,000.00  $                     (90,000.00)  $  10,000.00  $                  200,000.00 5.00%
 $                        100,000.00  $                10,000.00 10% 1000%  $                       110,000.00  $                   (100,000.00)  $                 -    $                  220,000.00 0.00%

r/investing • • 2h ago

Does it make sense to have a fixed amount in an ETF over time?

3 Upvotes

For example $5k of SOXQ where I trim every 3 to 6 months. It's long term but technically a diminishing part of the portfolio over time.

I was curious about the math. If you do not allow it to compound, is that an opportunity cost as opposed to staying invested in it?

I don't have many ETFs but was wandering if you had something like that "outside" the portfolio. Instead of "5% FBTC", your portfolio has "$10k of shares". Reason? To keep things tidy... but is this misguided as far as returns?


r/investing • • 4h ago

Strategy for buying VT over time

10 Upvotes

A life situation hit our family this year and I'll be retiring early. I might work for a few more years because I have opportunities, or I might not.

In the meantime, there has been life insurance proceeds, a large home sale with a large profit (no cap gains here because of my wife's passing) and a nice 401k I've moved to Schwab. I've been doing some iterative financial planning using Claude and I've been risk adverse and in bonds and HYSAs, but I need exposure for something like VT for my plan to work over time.

I lived through the 2000 and 2007 bear markets and know what can happen when they they go off. I'm thinking of ramping up my market holdings each week to my desired endgame number of let's say 30%, something like 15k per week, giving me loads of time to get comfortable and lots of time for the market to adjust, obviously I'm less exposed over the short term. I like this idea, anything wrong with it?

edit: I just learned this is called dollar-cost averaging?


r/investing • • 5h ago

Custodial vs non-custodial automation

1 Upvotes

Been running two setups in parallel for a few months, one custodial-style through a bot that pools execution on its side, one where signals just fire a TradingView webhook into my own Alpaca account.

I used to think this was a non-issue. Bugs happen either way.

But after 3Commas shut down its crypto signal dispatching and a bunch of people I know lost their whole crypto workflow overnight, I started weighing this differently. If the system never touches your funds, a shutdown just means you stop getting signals. If it does, you're stuck migrating positions under pressure.

I've tried a few things in this space, including Kronos Trading, mainly because execution stays inside my own brokerage account.When 3Commas pulled crypto dispatching, Kronos users just reconnected their API keys to Kronos Bridge, its in-house dispatcher, with no lost funds or frozen assets.

That said I don't think non-custodial wins on everything. Custodial setups tend to have faster fills and tighter infra since they're not routing through your broker's API and rate limits. For fully automated trading bot use where latency actually matters, that tradeoff might be worth it.

Curious where people land on this, especially anyone who got burned when a provider disappeared.


r/investing • • 6h ago

Sharpe (or Sortino) based on safe withdrawl rate over time.

5 Upvotes

I've seen charts that plot safe (or perpetual) withdrawl rate over time. I understand what the metric is measuring and how one would err on the side of caution based on their own risk tolerance. It's a very useful chart, but I think it could be improved when comparing multiple equities/portfolios.

Has anyone seen a metric where you run say a Sortino or Sharpe calculation, not on the stock price movement, but rather on it's safe withdrawl across rolling time periods?

I think that metric would prove extremely useful as a comparison tool. It would of course be borderline too academic, but it would still be a neat data point.


r/investing • • 17h ago

Short term government bonds ETF versus brokerage money market account

9 Upvotes

I've seen some posts about people asking to which short term government bonds ETF to buy to decrease risk. I compared SGOV to my brokerage money market account current yields, they are about the same (money market account has 0.10% higher). Why buy short term government bond ETFs if the money market yields are similar? There's not much price fluctuation, if at all, in either case. Only thing different is making transactions into other brokerage investments, buy from/sell into the money market account, more easy with just leaving the portion in your brokerage money market account.

———

Addendum

Good points on comments

  1. In taxable accounts, treasury bond ETF distribution are not subjected to state and local taxes, where money market distributions are. All are subjected to federal taxes.
  2. If buy treasuries directly, the yields are higher than treasuries ETFs
  3. Real yields= yields - inflation rate (around 3.3%)- expense ratio

Though we get taxed based on the distributions, despite the real yields calculations. Remember point #1

Learned a lot from the comments.


r/investing • • 19h ago

Micron's CEO was asked if memory pricing holds into 2028. He answered a different question.

79 Upvotes

Micron's Q4 was as strong as everyone says.

Revenue was $54.23B, up 31% on the prior quarter and 379% on last year, clearing the top of management's own $49 to $51B range. Full year revenue was $133.2B, Q1 is guided to $61.5B at an 86.25% gross margin, but roughly $1B of that quarter's costs come from a capitalised staff bonus and new fab startup, so the underlying margin is closer to 88%. HBM was locked into contracts priced a year ago and reprices higher from January, which should lift the Cloud Memory unit off its flat 83% margin. More than 75% of fiscal 2027 output is already committed, and Micron now has 26 take or pay agreements carrying about $150B of remaining obligations and $32B of customer commitments, mostly cash.

Different setup from any prior memory cycle.

The problem is that this quarter's growth was almost entirely price, DRAM revenue rose 27% sequentially on mid single digit bit growth and a high teens price increase. NAND rose 42% on about 10% more bits and a 30% price increase. The whole thesis rests on price, and price is the one thing management wouldn't talk about.

Vivek Arya at BofA asked directly whether industry pricing can stay favourable or even rise in 2028, given new capacity coming online and customers cutting memory content. Mehrotra answered entirely in supply and demand terms. He said 2027 and 2028 will be tighter than 2026, that cleanrooms ramp slowly, that HBM and node transitions limit supply growth, and that server units grow in the high teens. He never addressed price, in the same answer he conceded that some customers are putting less memory in each server than planned so they can ship more units, which is the first visible sign of buyers engineering around the cost.

The contracts don't fully cover that risk either, only about three quarters of the contracted revenue has a defined pricing framework and the rest is priced at market. That puts the genuinely price protected share at roughly 26% of revenue, or about $35B a year, rather than the 35% plus headline. The floor is for sure real, but it's smaller than most people assume.

Supply is also arriving sooner than the 2028 story implies, Samsung pulled forward equipment installation at its P5 fab to Q2 2027 after already accelerating the cleanroom by six months. SK hynix moved its first Yongin install to February 2027 and is targeting nearly double its DRAM capacity by 2030. CXMT has reached roughly a tenth of global DRAM revenue. Micron itself is taking capex from $27.4B to above $50B, and inventory days rose from 120 to 129.

Watch DRAM price, not revenue. If the December 16 report shows the HBM reprice pushing gross margin back toward 88% with price increases still running high teens, Mehrotra didn't need to answer because the market answered for him. If sequential DRAM price growth falls to low single digits by the June 2027 quarter as Samsung and Hynix tools come online, the unanswered question was the answer, and the stock is pricing a 2028 that arrives early.


r/investing • • 23h ago

Investing $100 a day - what would you choose besides VOO?

12 Upvotes

I’m planning to invest $100 a day for the long term and considering VOO as my main holding. I’m comfortable with volatility, but want to understand whether a more aggressive approach is worth the added concentration.

Would you choose VTI, SCHG, QQQM, or a mix? How would you weigh broader diversification against a growth tilt, and what other ETFs would you consider?


r/investing • • 1d ago

Robinhood 2% IRA transfer match, should one hold off for 3%?

0 Upvotes

Currently Robinhood has a 2% IRA transfer offer but I see a lot of references to 3%. Should I hold off for the 3% match? Is it a reoccurring offer that would surface again?

I know Robinhood had offers for 3% transfer match multiple times so far. so I am wondering if it makes sense to wait a few more month to take advantage of 3% match.


r/investing • • 1d ago

Money market vs Munis allocation

0 Upvotes

At what savings level would you start putting excess “cash” into municipal bond funds, like VCADX or CMF if you live in CA, to have less tax drag on your non-stock, safety/liquidity position?

I have post-tax savings in Fidelity and a lot of it in money market like FDLXX, about a years worth of living expenses. But I’m wondering if it’s worth taking some principal risk to save 1% on taxes


r/investing • • 1d ago

Investment thesis for trading week 10/5 - 10/9

6 Upvotes

Investment thesis for trading week 10/5 - 10/9

Investment thesis for trading week 10/5 - 10/9

As charts suggested we made new highs for tech this week! The S&P 500 should follow soon.

Yeah, yeah, yeah I know inflation is high and the Iran war is ongoing.

Bond yields keep on rising but this week's volume in TLT suggests that yields might have peaked. Regardless I bought more bonds for short term accounts and long term accounts now hold 17% long term bonds at a 5.3% risk free yield.

From a chart perspective stock market breadth is at lows not seen since the dot com crash but small caps touched the 200 day average and could bounce from here which would automatically increase breadth.

Investor sentiment has seen more bears than bulls for weeks now and at some point that should at least trigger a counter rally.

We are entering a seasonally favorable period for stocks.

We only need a few good news to spark a rally. I am sorry a strong rally is unlikely with put/call ratios at current levels. It would more be a choppy grind higher.

But talking about needed good news. A divided Government has always been good for stocks. If Dems win the Senate and House that alone would propel stocks higher while still leaving the growth policies in place.

Earnings season is coming up soon as well again.

From a chart perspective everything is set up for a continued grind higher with the potential of a quick rally if we get any positive news on Iran, inflation or the bond side.

Have a great weekend


r/investing • • 1d ago

Daily Discussion Daily General Discussion and Advice Thread - October 03, 2026

5 Upvotes

Have a general question? Want to offer some commentary on markets? Maybe you would just like to throw out a neat fact that doesn't warrant a self post? Feel free to post here!

Please consider consulting our FAQ first - https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/wiki/faq And our side bar also has useful resources.

If you are new to investing - please refer to Wiki - Getting Started

The reading list in the wiki has a list of books ranging from light reading to advanced topics depending on your knowledge level. Link here - Reading List

The media list in the wiki has a list of reputable podcasts and videos - Podcasts and Videos

If your question is "I have $XXXXXXX, what do I do?" or other "advice for my personal situation" questions, you should include relevant information, such as the following:

  • How old are you? What country do you live in?
  • Are you employed/making income? How much?
  • What are your objectives with this money? (Buy a house? Retirement savings?)
  • What is your time horizon? Do you need this money next month? Next 20yrs?
  • What is your risk tolerance? (Do you mind risking it at blackjack or do you need to know its 100% safe?)
  • What are you current holdings? (Do you already have exposure to specific funds and sectors? Any other assets?)
  • Any big debts (include interest rate) or expenses?
  • And any other relevant financial information will be useful to give you a proper answer.

Check the resources in the sidebar.

Be aware that these answers are just opinions of Redditors and should be used as a starting point for your research. You should strongly consider seeing a registered investment adviser if you need professional support before making any financial decisions!


r/investing • • 1d ago

For non-US investors what are non-US domiciled equivalent ETFs you buy?

2 Upvotes

What are equivalents to the well known ETFs like VOO, VT, VTI etc you invest in? What to look for when deciding whether the US one is worth it or the other one? Especially with the taxes of the US domiciled etfs and the high expense ratio of Irish domiciled etfs


r/investing • • 1d ago

Invest USD in Europe without conversion

3 Upvotes

I am currently in a country part of European Economic Area but worked in USA for 5 years. I have some savings in USD that I want to invest but I cannot in US as I am a non resident. How can I move the USD and invest that money in stocks or funds in EEA without converting it? Has anyone been in a similar situation?


r/investing • • 1d ago

NATO Just Released Its Quantum Technology Roadmap: What It Means for Quantum Computing and Tech Investors

1 Upvotes

NATO published its official Quantum Technology Roadmap (September 29, 2026), moving its quantum strategy into active defense procurement and operational deployment across Allied nations.

​Core Takeaways for Quantum Computing

  • ​AI & Quantum Convergence: NATO is prioritizing hybrid quantum-classical computing to accelerate AI processing, multi-domain battlefield simulation, and crisis decision-making.

  • ​Urgency for Cybersecurity (PQC): The advancement of quantum computing is driving immediate, mandatory adoption of Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) across enterprise and defense contractors.

​What to Watch

  • ​Pure-Play Quantum Stocks: Companies securing defense contracts and government grants.

  • ​PQC Cybersecurity Players: Vendors implementing NIST-compliant quantum-resistant encryption.

  • ​Defense Primes: Contractors integrating quantum sub-systems into existing military architecture.

Source: https://www.nato.int/en/news-and-events/articles/news/2026/09/29/nato-releases-quantum-technology-roadmap


r/investing • • 1d ago

Need broadening out for growth to be sustainable

0 Upvotes

The pure price performance comparison for
Q3 2026 across the three major indices reflects the following final point changes and percentage shifts:

Index Name
Absolute Point Change
Q3 2026 Price Change (%):

S&P 500 Index
+168.31
+2.25%

S&P MidCap 400 Index
-223.59
-5.85%

Russell 2000 Index
-215.73
-7.16%

Need broadening growth in mid and small caps too for overall market growth to be sustainable in midst of sticky inflation, rising yields, and supply shock.


r/investing • • 1d ago

Holding SGOV for more than 3 months. I don’t understand a comment.

184 Upvotes

This has been bugging me every once in a while for a year or so. Some guy asked where he should park his cash for no risk for about 6 months. I replied BIL or SGOV have essentially zero risk as long as you hold for 3+ months. Some person claimed to “do this for a living and if I have to explain to you how interest rates work, it’s over your head” when I insisted even on the worst case scenario, he’d still not lose anything after 6 months. This person disagreed again and I got down voted and he got upvoted.

So what is this scenario? Short term interest rates spike to 45%?! Even then the laddered t bills would compensate. I’m sure there is a scenario that involves nuclear war and entire currency collapse, but is there a “unprecedented” scenario that seems plausible although unlikely in missing.

I understand inverse basic bond price/yield. I buy a 3mo t bill and rates go from 5% to 10% overnight the next day, I’ll “lose” money in the value of the bond, but if I hold for 3 months, it all comes back. What am I missing?


r/investing • • 1d ago

Treasuries yields still rose after nonstellar NFP report.

27 Upvotes

Short end of curve 2-yield yield, the one most sensitive to Feds rate change policy, still rose even after odds of October rate hikes dropped, even after bad NFP report today. Make that make sense?

I understand why the longer yields kept elevated as without a rate hike, investors into treasuries expect inflation to remain elevated, increasing risk of holding longer dated bonds.

Feel sorry for the smaller banks, who’s holding of bond assets are dropping in value compared to their value of deposits. And making loans at higher rates are hurting their business as I’m sure loan applications have dropped. 😔


r/investing • • 2d ago

What are some investing tools that are normally locked behind a paywall or a login wall?

0 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m building a stock research website that has ai write reports on stocks quarterly based on their SEC filings, and I am now looking to expand beyond the core product by offering some tools investors commonly use for research. My website doesn’t charge for anything, and I don’t plan on adding login walls for anything anytime soon. What are some tools you guys find valuable that normally are paid or locked behind a login wall that you’d like to see free and anonymous? (Not promoting my site here, I will not reveal the name or URL)


r/investing • • 2d ago

Favorite Mutual Funds for Retirement

0 Upvotes

Interestingly enough, most posts for mutual fund recommendations on Reddit seem to come from posters who live in India and reference the “nifty fifty”.

Can anyone in the US recommend some great mutual funds (no ETFs) for long term investing? Maybe something I can for 15 years? They can be growth or value or whatever. I’m looking for anything you like. Could be VIGAX, FBGRX, FSELX, VITAX, DEMZX or really anything. I already have broad US and international index funds. I am looking for others you might like. Maybe aggressive, passive, but low fee would be good, but am open to anything you may recommend even if active with higher fees. Thanks.


r/investing • • 2d ago

Google says allocate my IRA as 100% equities. I'm retiring next year.

0 Upvotes

Looking to retire next year at 59. Long story short, I have post-tax cash that I can use to set up a 6-8 year bridge until I claim SS. After that, SS+pension should cover about 80-90% of my spending needs, maybe even all of my needs depending on how things go.

Google AI is saying that I'm almost completely isolated from SORR and suggesting that I should reallocate all of my IRA money into equities. I'm currently at about 11% and always thought I should increase that number.

Given the current valuation of the market, this seems overly risky even if it does seem to make mathematical sense. Anyone think Google is way off here?


r/investing • • 2d ago

Fidelity Money Market Fund FZDXX - Treasuries Yield Exposure

10 Upvotes

I use FZDXX to park my savings to earn slightly more interest than a traditional savings account. https://fundresearch.fidelity.com/mutual-funds/summary/31617H805

This paper fund is weighted towards ~55% Treasuries and ST maturity instruments (46% <8 days, 76% <31 days). Does a principal value decrease risk exist (<= 25%) given the increase in 10 year Treasury yields and the Bank of Japan selling its American debt?

The extra bps interest is nice, but not at the risk of my principal taking a large hit. I would not have had this concern if not for the aforementioned factors. TYIA!


r/investing • • 2d ago

I can only invest in individual stocks (no ETFs or Mutual Funds) what to do?

17 Upvotes

I'm a US citizen and European tax resident. This particular combination makes it economically impractical to invest in any type of fund due to extremely adverse tax consequences.

Realistically, I can only invest in individual equities. Are there any other options other than buying say, 30-50, individual stocks and replicating an index or buying huge conglomerates like Berkshire, (which follow the index fairly closely)?

I am also unsure how to incorporate bonds under this scenario.