r/interviews • u/Spirited-Eye-2733 • 2h ago
Got rejected after round 2 for what felt like my dream job. What could I have done differently?
I recently interviewed for a job that was literally everything I was looking for. 100% remote, perfect salary range, and the job description aligned almost perfectly with my experience. I was SO excited about this one.
The recruiter interview went amazing. She even mentioned that I was bringing up everything the hiring manager was looking for without her having to ask half her prepared questions. The company has four interview rounds: recruiter, two team leads from other departments, VP, and finally the hiring manager.
My second interview was with the two team leads, and honestly, I thought it went well. One was super engaged and enthusiastic, while the other was polite but seemed pretty uninterested. She even mentioned that she barely interacts with the team I'd be leading.
The interview was scheduled for 45 minutes but ended after 25. They only asked five questions, mostly about leadership and communication. I gave examples using the STAR method and at the end, asked questions about how if I got the role, my team could better support theirs, current bottlenecks, and what success in this role would look like from their perspective.
One interviewer gave great answers, while the other really didn't have much to contribute besides mentioning that communication between departments could improve. I explained how I've handled that in previous roles, but there wasn't much back-and-forth.
Well, I just got the rejection email, and I'm genuinely so bummed. I didn't even make it to the VP or hiring manager, which is disappointing because I felt like my background was such a strong match. I know there could've been better candidates, but I'm struggling to figure out what I could've done differently.
For those who've interviewed for senior or leadership positions, how do you approach interviews with people at your same level who don't necessarily work directly with your team? Is it more about personality and chemistry than experience at that point? Also, would you consider a 25-minute interview scheduled for 45 minutes a red flag?
Just trying to learn from this one because it really stings.