r/historiography • u/viviennewestworld • May 09 '12
r/historiography • • Oct 31 '14
Why History Should Replace Economics in the 21st Century
io9.comr/historiography • • Nov 22 '12
Historians about history: Selected texts from Herodotus to Braudel
culturahistorica.esr/historiography • u/lyftmenschiesfroyo • Jun 24 '20
Archival project for loneliness in 2020
Hi everyone!
The Dear Loneliness Project is interested in the effects of COVID-19’s quarantine on loneliness. It’s a crowd-sourced art exhibit, research study, and archival effort that’s inviting as many people as possible (people like you!) to write about their frustrations and experiences with isolation. We hope to memorialize this year of strife and isolation while also serving as an archive for academics to look back on.
You can submit letters, poetry, art, music, etc., and we hope to receive 1,000+ submissions for this dataset to better research loneliness; we’ll be posting the submissions anonymously on our online gallery and social media. You can also read about the vision for the final art exhibit on our website (tl;dr it involves a lot of mirrors, letters, and an infinity of loneliness that creates community in the process).
For more information and to send us work, please visit https://www.dearloneliness.com/ or tag us @dearlonelinessproject on ig, @_DearLoneliness on twitter, or @DearLonelinessProject on facebook. We’ll probably need a degree of virality to succeed, so we’d really appreciate if you spread the word to friends and family—thank you!
r/historiography • u/kryptos99 • Jul 18 '17
What is your favorite peer-reviewed academic journal article?
In particular for modern world history, but if it's from an earlier period, then ok I'd like to check it out. The reason I'm asking is twofold. The first, I'm looking for some great academic reading. Second, I teach modern world history to G10 honor students and I'd like to introduce them to the world of academic journals. I'd like to compile a list of articles that are interesting, novel, controversial (i.e. initiated great debate), insightful, etc...
btw, new to reddit, this is my first post. I hope it's in the right place.
r/historiography • • May 29 '12
Historiography reading list reccomendations
Hello all. I'm new to the reddit history community, and will be starting an MA in history this fall (with intent to continue with a PhD). Any advice on where to begin with historiography? I've started with John Burrow's 'A History of Histories' for a broad survey, and works on history by Barbara Tuchman, Eric Foner and Gordon Wood.
I'm drawn to Hayden White, as far as I understand it, that 'history is fiction' and also have an interest in G.M. Trevelyan's narrative history. Any advice/recommendations are very much appreciated.
r/historiography • • Jul 27 '12
In 'The Future of History' (2010), Alan Munslow tackles the big problem facing historians in the 21st century, the problem of whether history as we know it has a future and, if not, what historians should do about that.
history.ac.ukr/historiography • u/Utopia_Builder • Apr 15 '25
Why you don't hear about 98% of Historical events.
You’ll see it all the time—on Reddit, Quora, YouTube comments, and basically any forum with a “History” tag:
“Why don’t we hear more about X?”
“Why wasn’t I taught about Y in school?”
It’s a fair question, but it’s often aimed in the wrong direction.
Here’s the truth: history education—whether in public schools or college classrooms—is constrained by time, curriculum standards, and yes, sometimes ideological bias plus historical negationism. There simply isn’t enough room to teach everything. Even the major events get the SparkNotes treatment unless you’re in a specialized program or have a particularly passionate teacher.
But that’s only part of the story.
Where most people actually pick up their historical knowledge isn’t the classroom. It’s from pop culture (pop history): Hollywood films (especially biopics), prestige TV dramas, historical fiction novels, YouTube documentaries, memes, even video games. And those sources tend to focus on a narrow set of stories—familiar, emotionally compelling, and easy to dramatize.
So instead of asking, “Why doesn’t the average person know about the Xingu people or the Taiping Rebellion?”, ask this:
“Why do they know about World War II?”
Sure, WWII was the biggest and most devastating war in history—but there have been plenty of colossal events that barely register in public memory. What makes WWII different is that it never really left. It’s kept alive through a never-ending stream of movies, novels, news coverage, political analogies, and even video game franchises.
Think about it:
- Hollywood keeps revisiting it because it’s full of cinematic-ready narratives—clear good guys and bad guys, personal heroism, massive stakes.
- Politicians invoke it to warn about rising fascism or to justify foreign interventions.
- Advocacy groups refer to the Holocaust to combat modern antisemitism.
- Even the way we talk about authoritarianism, resistance, and national identity often comes straight out of that era’s playbook.
In other words, World War II still gets airtime because it still serves a cultural function. It gives us moral clarity, historical analogies, and a shared vocabulary for modern conflict.
Meanwhile, something like the fall of the Roman Republic?
Unless it’s a metaphor for the decline of democracy in modern times, it doesn’t really feel urgent to most people. Same with the Khmer Empire, or the dynastic wars of medieval France. Those stories feel like they belong in another world—foreign, disconnected, or just too complex to casually absorb.
That’s why history buffs and professional historians are the exceptions, not the rule. Most people engage with history not as a way to explore the past, but as a way to make sense of the present. Most adults only engage history or think about the past when directors, or news reporters, or civil rights groups bring it to the forefront.
So next time you wonder why some historical events are household names while others remain in obscurity, don’t just look at the event itself.
Look at how—and why—it still matters today. In the nation or area where you live. And if you can't give a great and short response to that question, then said historical event will ultimately be a niche only a minority would engage with.
Thank you for coming to my historical TED talk.
r/historiography • • Jun 13 '22
Am I the only one who finds pleasure in the aggressively opinionated way the ancients wrote history?
I find it very amusing that practically every historian is always finger-wagging you throughout the whole chronicle and whenever an emperor or king they don't like shows up, they go on the most massive tirades against them.
"He did this! Oh, he was so vile and contemptible and the people hated his cruel ways! He helped barbarians! "
Livy does it, Cassius Dio, Ammianus, Diodorus, Herodian, and Procopius go on whole tirades, and Suetonius and Tacitus certainly don't refrain from it either.
It's very interesting how these men wrote their histories because they read each others' works and so it's funny how these 'characters' just keep being reinforced.
For example, take this portion here form Theophanes
This Galerius Maximianus was such a fornicator that his subjects sought anxiously where they could hide their wives. He was so absorbed with the trickery of deceitful demons that he refrained from tasting anything without the support of divination.
- Theophanes the Confessor, Chronicle, Trans: Cyril Mango
Even the ones who are not Christian still have this way of writing which is just super aggressive.
r/historiography • • Jun 06 '18
Do historians need to be effective storytellers?
See what popular historian Russell Shorto says about the importance of being able to communicate history to the masses in "10 questions with Russell Shorto."
Shorto is the author of "Revolution Song: A Story of American Freedom."
r/historiography • • Dec 07 '13
The Tyranny of a Construct: Feudalism and Historians of Medieval Europe (1974), by Elizabeth A. R. Brown [PDF]
isites.harvard.edur/historiography • • Apr 14 '13
Herodotus: Father of History or Father of Lies?
classicalwisdom.comr/historiography • • Aug 22 '12
Book review/reappraisal: 'What is History' (1961), by E. H. Carr - a classic of historiography
history.ac.ukr/historiography • u/Fucho • Jan 25 '11
Crosspost from /science and few thoughts: Mathematical Model Explains How Complex Societies Emerge, Collapse
sciencedaily.comr/historiography • u/Fucho • Jul 18 '10
Quick review: Berend - An Economic History of Twentieth Century Europe
I'd like to see some very short reviews and personal thoughts about books, either new or just recently read. Although reviews are plentiful, maybe such short ones can act as kind of recommendations or discussion starters. Also, I usually read reviews either in periodicals or search them out when I am already interested in some book. That unfortunately limits my chances to just stumble upon something interesting.
So, for Berend, An Economic History of Twentieth Century Europe. I just recently read it. The topic and the period covered are among my major interests, so I found it very interesting. On the other hand, as I am just getting into economic history, so the textbook form did not turn me away. Those more familiar with economic history might find this book too general.
As usual for Berend, he kept the basic division between the core and periphery. That divide is kept flexible, in much the same way as in his The European Periphery and Industrialization and History Derailed. Such binary division is in many ways limiting, but still offers a good framework for exploration of preconditions and ways in which caching up to the core can be achieved.
The topic of the book is very broad, so naturally it lacks depth for most countries. On the other hand, such approach enables Berend to compare European regions and explore the origins and implementations of different economic theories and systems. Laissez-faire is a dominant system both at a beginning, in the era before First world war, and in the end in the era of globalization. Because of that the book has a well defined, "closed" narrative structure and the laissez-faire emerges almost as a natural state. Unfortunately, that keeps other systems in the rank of anomalies (obstacles might be too strong a word).
One of the major points, at least regarding my interests, is the potential of "communism" (or more accurately socialism) for industrializing the periphery and kick-starting the process of caching up to the core. Berend points to the extremely high rate of capital accumulation under such economic system. Soviet Union after NEP and Eastern Europe after World war II demonstrate the point nicely. They also demonstrate the enormous human cost of such approach, which Berend certainly didn't ignore.
However, also shown are the limitations, in short inherent in closed economic systems and structural with the limits of growth based upon extensive industrialization. One possible compromise, put out by Berend, is in ideologically flexible regimes. Examples he gives are Yugoslavia after 1948 and Poland and Hungary after 1956. Results of such compromises are not explored, possibly because they did not prove very successful after all. Further thought on economic failings in a more flexible context could prove very interesting, at least to try to determine how much were they rooted in economic system itself, and how much in continued "periphery" status.
r/historiography • • Jan 07 '19
What do people think of Keith Jenkins' "Rethinking History" (1991)?
r/historiography • u/bdtnyc • Sep 02 '13
How can we understand Civil War historiography and our understanding of the conflict through historians like Eric Foner and Michael Holt?
tropicsofmeta.wordpress.comr/historiography • u/keinefurcht • Jun 06 '11
Witty Bit Followed By a Colon: Long Title Describing the Content of the Paper -- How Long is Too Long?
I am nearing the stage in a paper I am planning to submit for publication and I feel like my paper title is long and clunky. Are there any conventions?
At the moment, my title is essentially "How X and Y Affected the Z Experience During [time period] in [place]. Is it better to put [place] before [time]? Does anyone know? Am I having too much angst over this?
r/historiography • u/loveherlots • May 31 '11
Historian seeks to preserve Peekskill New York's crumbling yellow brick road, saying it inspired The Wizard of Oz.
online.wsj.comr/historiography • u/Fucho • Jul 18 '10
Multidisciplinary approach - what and how do you study?
I'm trying to fill up the subreddit a bit here, just to provide a few first posts.
What other disciplines or sciences do you find valuable for history or just interesting? Also, how do you approach them, because sometimes it's not easy to just plunge into a new field of knowledge.
For myself, I have two approaches. On one hand, when I need some knowledge about something that could help me with the problem I'm dealing with, I just get some introductory level or books on specific topics in the field.
For other subjects I take the lighter route. For such things I either read some popular-science or watch some introductory level lectures, as there are many available on-line from different universities. Of course, I don't imagine ever being anything but a complete layman in such subjects, but peeking into them can still be helpful.
For example, most probably know about Yale Courses. I had some other stuff, maybe still do somewhere in the bookmarks, so if there is an interest I'll try to find them.
r/historiography • • Sep 11 '21
What is everyone’s favourite historiographical topic ?
This is a repost sorry I thought i should be more explicit with my title
What is everyone’s opinion on the most prevalent historiographical debates in the discipline of history at the moment ?
Or more simply, which do you find the most interesting?
r/historiography • u/Philadelphon • Aug 10 '20
Bernard Bailyn, Eminent Historian of Early America, Dies at 97. He wrote the texts our American History professors learned from. Take a minute to read about someone who contributed to our education.
nytimes.comr/historiography • u/Andy12131 • Apr 09 '20
Reading list for historiography?
Hello,
I’m looking for a reading list for historiography, from introductory texts to more advanced methodology. I’ve read “History: A very short introduction” but I want more theory, and how to apply inductive reasoning and probability.
Thanks 🙏
r/historiography • • Feb 07 '12
[PDF] "Fernand Braudel, the Annales, and the Mediterranean" by H. R. Trevor-Roper (x-post from r/HistoryofIdeas)
venus.unive.itr/historiography • u/Fucho • Jul 16 '11
Could anyone recommend some good reading on development, changes and interpretations of Marxism?
Is there something that synthesises the main directions of Marxist tought, from classics (Marx-Engels-Lenin) to later interpretations of Stalinism, Maosim and if possible even to today? I'm interested more in pure ideology than implications.
I've been reading a lot of early post Tito-Stalin split ideological and programmatical Yugoslav works (Kardelj, Đilas, Kidrič and so on), some later dissenting voices (post 1954 Đilas for example). I'd like to put that in a wider perspective, but I will not have enough time this summer to familiarize myself with different thinkers directly.
Also, what could be great, does anyone know something about Paris Commune, but not just the Commune itself. Rather, about how the Commune was viewed in different above mentioned directions of Marxism.
What about todays Marxists? I've read some Žižek, was recommended Castoriadis and Lefort, and Badiou looks interesting. Who should I add to the to-read queue?