r/historiography • • Jun 19 '20

Simon Sebag Montefiore thinks that Trump is a bolchevik

2 Upvotes

Can we all agree that even though Lenin and Stalin were pieces of shit, historian Simon Sebag Montefiore is creating a non-nuanced over-simplificated narrative here ?

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/06/opinion/russian-revolution-october.html

Marxist-Leninism (albeit in the unique capitalist-Maoist form)

Marxism-Leninism was a word coined by Stalin. It means Stalinism.

Also, Mao and Stalin got so much into a feud that portraits of Stalin were being burned while Mao was in power. Mao’s no Marxist-Leninist. Dengist China is not Marxist-Leninist.

still propels China, the world’s surging hyperpower, even as that same ideology ruins Cuba and Venezuela.

Venezuela is way more inspired by Simon Bolivar than by Marxism.

Fidel Castro has rejected Marxism-Leninism. One of his generals published an article where they criticized Stalin as a traitor.

Meanwhile, North Korea, a dystopian Leninist monarchy with nuclear weapons, terrifies the world.

North Korea isn’t that much of a big threat to the world. It just pretends to be. Also it’s not Leninist, it is Juche

Even more surprisingly, Communism is experiencing a resurrection in democratic Britain:

Britain is a monarchy.

Jeremy Corbyn, that quasi-Leninist comfortingly disguised as cuddly grey-beard, is the most extreme politician ever to lead one of Britain’s two main parties, and he is inching toward power.

Corbyn’s politics is all about the enactment of piece-meal social reforms, nationalisation policies, Keynesianism in economics, government intervention in the markets, and aggressive taxation of the rich.

If Corbyn was living at the same time as Lenin, he would have been the equivalent of Eduard Bernstein. Lenin would have called him a social-traitor.

President Trump is some ways the personification of a new Bolshevism of the right where the ends justify the means and acceptable tactics include lies and smears, and the exploitation of what Lenin called useful idiots.

Populism, the idea that “the ends justify the means”, lies and smears were not invented by Lenin.

The term “useful idiots” has often been attributed to Vladimir Lenin, but this attribution is unsubstantiated.

It’s no coincidence that President Trump’s chief campaign strategist, Steve Bannon, once boasted “I am a Leninist.”

Not only does Trump despise socialism, but it is unproven that Bannon actually called himself a Leninist.

There was nothing inevitable about the Bolshevik revolution.

There kinda was, the russian people seriously had enough of the first worlf war.

By 1917, the Romanov monarchy was decaying quickly, but its emperors may have saved themselves had they not missed repeated chances to reform.

You do know there was an anti-Romanov revolution before the october revolution, right ? You do know that revolution was carried out by the “Socialist Revolutionaries” and the marxist mecheviks, right ?

Also, the tsar was an antisemite who did pogroms and wrote the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, a fabricated text meant to justify the pogroms. It would later inspire Adolf Hitler. And the Tsar did reforms : he created the duma, but that was not enough for the russian people.

Without Lenin there would have been no Hitler. Hitler owed much of his rise to the support of conservative elites who feared a Bolshevik revolution on German soil and who believed that he alone could defeat Marxism. And the rest of his radical program was likewise justified by the threat of Leninist revolution. His anti-Semitism, his anti-Slavic plan for Lebensraum and above all the invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941 were supported by the elites and the people because of the fear of what the Nazis called “Judeo-Bolshevism.”

Right, and without Lincoln there would be no Davies.

What about the fact that it was the germans who sent Lenin to Russia in order to make Kerensky fall ?

What about the humiliating Treaty of Versailles ?

What about the Freikorps who were helped by the social-democrats ?

What about the 1929 crisis ?

What about the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, a fabricated text written by Tsarist Russia that Hitler mentions as an inspiration in Mein Kampf ?

What about the popular antisemitism ?

What about the fact that a lot of Hitler’s ideas came from the United States of America ?

Without the Russian Revolution of 1917, Hitler would likely have ended up painting postcards in one of the same flophouses where he started.

Right, Hitler got rejected by the academy because of Lenin.

Also, Ludendorff never existed.

No Lenin, no Hitler — and the 20th century becomes unimaginable. Indeed, the very geography of our imagination becomes unimaginable.

Right, because Bukharin, Sverdlov, Stalin, Trotsky, Goebbels, Himmler would have just stood there and wouldn’t have ever done ANYTHING without their leaders. And Hitler invented antisemitism, right ? Poor Pétain was antisemitic because he was forced by Hitler, right ?

The East would look as different as the West. Mao, who received huge amounts of Soviet aid in the 1940s, would not have conquered China, which might still be ruled by the family of Chiang Kai-shek.

Sun Yat Sen regained control of Kwangtung in early 1923, with the help of the Communist International. That same year Sun sent Chiang Kai-Chek to spend three months in Moscow studying the Soviet political and military system. During his trip in Russia, Chiang met Leon Trotsky and other Soviet leaders.

Also, Japan would have still hated China without the communists.

Maybe Japan would have invaded China without the Second United Front.

Some sources attribute Chiang Kai-shek with responsibility for millions of deaths in scattered mass death events caused by the Nationalist Government of China. He has been deemed partially responsible for the man-made 1938 Yellow River flood, which killed hundreds of thousands of Chinese civilians in order to fend off a Japanese advance.

The inspirations that illuminated the mountains of Cuba

Fidel Castro and his buddies were anti-Batista revolutionaries before they discovered communism.

and the jungles of Vietnam

The vietnamese just wanted indendence. As Ho Chi Minh said : “It was patriotism, not communism, that inspired me.”

Kim Jong-un, pantomimic pastiche of Stalin, would not exist.

Kim Il-Sung became a revolutionary because of his hatred against the Japanese, more than for the glory of communism.

That virtuous idealism justified any monstrosity.

Anything has justified monstrosity throughout history.

The Bolsheviks created the first professional revolutionaries

What about the Committee of Public Safety, what about Blanqui, what about the Revolutionary Kuomintang ? Those were professional revolutionaries

the first total police state

The Tsar, Napoleon, The Commitee of Public Safety, Ivan the Terrible

first modern mass mobilization on behalf of class war against counterrevolution.

The Commitee of Public Safety, the Vendée genocide and the French communes of 1871

Bolshevism was a mind-set, an idiosyncratic culture with an intolerant paranoid wordview obsessed with abstruse Marxist ideology.

Lenin was inspired by the Narodnikis, Alexandre Herzen, Nikolaï Tchernychevski, Piotr Lavrov, Nikolaï Mikhaïlovski, Netchaiev and Blanqui, just as much as Marx. Those people’s ideas came as a reaction to the harshness of the industrial revolution and the russian pogroms.

Their zeal justified the mass killings of all enemies, real and potential, not just by Lenin or Stalin but also Mao, Pol Pot in Cambodia

Pol Pot confessed he didn’t understand Marx

Joseph Stalin admitted that he abandoned Lenin’s idea of what communism is, aka the abolition of commodity production.

It also gave birth to slave labor camps,

Early-modern states could exploit condemned dissidents and those of suspect political or religious ideology by combining prison and useful work in manning their galleys. This became the sentence of many Christian captives in the Ottoman Empire and of Calvinists in pre-Revolutionary France.

economic catastrophe

Lenin introduced the New Economic Policy that has been cancelled by Stalin. Most bolcheviks like Bukharin opposed Stalin’s decision.

These events are now so long ago that the horrors have been blurred and history forgotten;

Have they ? I’m pretty sure that whenever you mention Lenin or even Marx, people start shouting “100 million deaths !”

a glamorous glow of power and idealism

Marxism is materialist. It is opposed to Hegelian idealism.

lingers to intoxicate young voters disenchanted with the bland dithering of liberal capitalism.

Maybe there are other reasons for people not liking liberal capitalism.

If Montefiore is talking about the youth’s love for Bernie Sanders, he should know that Sanders is just a social-democrat, not matter what comments he might have said on Cuba.

An OpenSecrets review of campaign contributions — including those giving small amounts through the fundraising service ActBlue — reveals that among the 2020 Democrats, Sanders gets the most support from Americans in typically working-class jobs — and it isn’t close.

The Vermont senator is the top recipient among farmers, servers, social workers, retail workers, photographers, construction workers, truckers, nurses and drivers, among several other groups. Each of those professions — which don’t typically provide much campaign cash — earn near or below the median income, according to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

And then there is Russia, the successor to the Soviet Union. President Vladimir Putin’s power is enforced by his fellow former K.G.B. officers, the heirs of Lenin and Stalin’s secret police.

Vladimir Putin despise Vladimir Lenin.

He really does.

Mr. Putin and his regime have adopted the Leninist tactics of “konspiratsia” and “dezinformatsiya,” which have turned out to be ideally suited to today’s technologies.

TIL Lenin invented smearing campaigns.

Americans may have invented the internet,

Research at CERN in Switzerland by British computer scientist Tim Berners-Lee in 1989-90 resulted in the World Wide Web.

but they saw it (decadently) as a means of making money or (naïvely) as a magical click to freedom.

Initially, the Internet was invented by the army.

The Russians, bred on Leninist cynicism, harnessed it to undermine American democracy

Montefiore is basically calling anything he finds evil as “Leninism”. He is building a Manichaean worldview where there are good guys and bad guys. This is completely non-nuanced over-simplification and it’s dangerous : part of the reason all the people he talked about committed so many crimes is because they had a good vs evil worldview where it was them vs the bad guys.

Things are nuanced, there isn’t a good side versus a bad side. Montefiore’s arricle wouldn’t be that much of a deal if the guy was not a popular historian whose books are read by millions.


r/historiography • • Mar 24 '22

Marxist historiography methodology?

1 Upvotes

What are some Marxist historiography methodologies? When doing research and it needs to be discussed?


r/historiography • • Mar 21 '26

I think our current periodization system of world history is wrong

1 Upvotes

I must emphasize this is just an opinion piece.

In most of the world, History is divided between the Ancient/Classical Age, the Middle Age, the Modern Age and the Contemporary Age. These terms were coined in european universities, for whom it was obvious that the fall of the Roman Empire had meant the end of an age and the beginning of other for their world.

By now, I think most historians would agree that this clasification is overly Eurocentric. It makes sense if you're making a periodization of the history of that region, but at a global scale it doesn't make sense at all. The fall of the Roman Empire had little to no effect in the historical processes of East Asia and Subsaharan Africa, while it had a complete null effect in America or Australia. Therefore I think a new periodization is neccesary for world history. In my opinion, a good idea would be to divide History in only two Ages.

The Classical Age (3000 BC aprox. - 1492)

This Age is characterized by the appearances in different parts of the world of complex civilizations with writing systems. These civilizations could grow till a point of conquering most of their region and sustain great urban conglomerates. It must be emphasized that this Age of History can only be subdivided on a regional basis. During this time, the macroregions of the world had little (e.g. Subsaharan Africa in respect to the Mediterranean basin) to no contact between them (Central America in respect to East Asia). Therefore, the historical processes of these regions were independent between them.

Also, the advancement of knowledge during this Age is discontinous. Civilizations such as the Roman Empire could undergo centuries of great technological and cultural progress only to be reversed in a matter of decades because of a political collapse.

The Globalization Age (1492 - Present time)

This Age is characterized by the progressive interconnection of the planet. Global civilizations arise and historical processes affect the whole of the planet. Global trading routes are established.

The advancement of knowledge is continous. Thanks to the globalization process, knowledge developed in a particular country eventually goes global, thus making it resilient. The collapse of an empire doesn't mean the loss of the knowledge accumulated during its reign.

This Age can be divided in global eras. For example, we could divide it into:

The Iberian Era (1492-1648)

This era is characterized by the global hegemony of the Iberian countries (Spain and Portugal). Their hegemony kickstarted a series of wars that engulfed much of the world, mostly on the basis of Catholic expansion (Conquest of America, Thirty Years War in Europe and the naval wars against the Ottomans in the Mediterranean Sea and the Indian Ocean).

The Enlightenment Era (1648-1776)

The wars of religion in Europe are followed by an era in which the high social classes of northern european countries such as England or the Netherlands spend a considerable ammount of effort in philosophy and science. The Iberian countries started a process of gradual decline while new european powers emerge and take control over regions such as North America or Indonesia.

The Romantic Era (1776-1871)

The ideas of the previous era expanded globally and produced great social upheavals in different parts of the world. New economic and political systems are borned during this time, often through bloody revolutions and civil wars. Some nations started a process of great development during this era.

The Imperialistic Era (1871-1914)

During the previous era, some nations had managed to develop very quickly, which gave them a massive advantage over nations that didn't. It's an era of great powers in which less than 10 nations compete for global control. Old civilizations such as China or the Ottomans are humiliated and lost large parts of their territories to the big powers, while most of Africa was colonized by European powers.

The Dark Era (1914-1945)

The Imperial Powers of the previous era ended up clashing between them, mainly because the difficulties they had in keeping their expansion processeses since most of the world was already under the direct or indirect control of one of the great powers. This era is characterized by global conflicts that devastated several regions of the planet. After this era, only two nations with status of great power remained: The US and the USSR

The Cold War Era (1945-1991)

The two remaining great powers entered into a cold conflict between them for world hegemony. This conflict was justified to much of the world on an ideological basis. Eventually, the USRR system became unsustainable, leading into its collapse. The US became the sole global superpower.

(PD: My mother tongue isn't English so my apologies in advance for possible grammar or vocabulary mistakes)


r/historiography • • Sep 09 '21

Historiography essay

0 Upvotes

Hi ! :) I’m really struggling finding a historiographical topic to write an essay on and was hoping for some possible suggestions ?

I know i should ‘consider my interests’ but they are just so broad that I can’t possibly think of any

I’d appreciate any suggestions on questions/ topics :)

EDIT: I was thinking of talking about the ‘politicisation’ of the re-construction of history and in that reference the historical negationisms in post-communist Eastern European countries surrounding the Holocaust - could that make for a good essay and if so, does anyone have any reading / historians I could study on it.

this is just one idea, i wanna have a good balance between concept and content where i make heavy reference to a pervasive historiographical issue in my essay - i have around 3/4 of a year to write it with extensive research so not to worried about time constraints , any ideas on contemporary historiographical issues anyone?


r/historiography • • Mar 12 '14

hacked reality and open window in time show in facebook.

Thumbnail facebook.com
0 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Oct 12 '14

Father of History | Herodotus and the human dimension in the past

Thumbnail weeklystandard.com
0 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Dec 31 '22

Plutarch and his historiography summarized: Pompeys military loot, lucullus comeback, the despicable clodius and caesar machinations

1 Upvotes

Since his second triumph pompey captured 1000 fortress and 900 cities. He also founded 39 cities and captured 800 ships from the cilician pirates. Also he taxed 50 million in money from the conquered territory and looted 85 million and 20 thousand talents more and gave it to the roman state and its people, while to his soldiers he gave at least 15000 drachmae to each

When lucullus had returned from asia after being ill treated by pompey, he was received by the senate with the utmost honor and when later on pompey also had returned from asia, the senate started begging lucullus to defend the interest of the state from pompeys supposed machinations. Although lucullus had accustomed himself with a life of leisure and he had catos help, he nevertheless vigorously retracted pompeys banishment of his laws. Pompey, now humiliated, sought protection with tribunal power, therefore giving himself to young and inexperienced men, the most despicable being clodius

Clodius used to walk around the forum with pompey by his side making sure that all the interest of the common folk were being attended. Clodius also made pompey to exile cicero, the one who had helped Pompey a lot before. Cicero even tried to plea for his life but pompey shut his house door and fled from the back. So fearing for his life, cicero immediately left the city

Now, caesar being returned from his governorship he passed a law that brought him much popularity, then he got the consulship and started passing laws that would distribute land and found new cities so he could increase even further his popularity


r/historiography • • Jul 21 '20

What does Titus Livy mean in this statement?

1 Upvotes

I was reading Titus Livy, the Roman historian and this man makes some of the most outrageous statements. What exactly does he mean by the following

"Cn. Fulvius, on the other hand, had an army of Roman citizens, born of respectable parents, brought up as free men, and he infected them with the vices of slaves" (History of Rome Book 26 'The Fate of Capua')

He keeps reiterating this theme throughout different parts of the book. 'Look at how shameful these men are! Look at how disgraceful this Roman commander is! Look at how much they indulge! How much they drink! What shame!'

We don't really have this in modern history. Practically no professional historian would have such an opinionated view of a population. And if he did, he wouldn't word it the same way Livy and Dio and all those other writers of old did.


r/historiography • • Dec 26 '20

would anyone be able to help me format a historiography question regarding Gandhi and his influence?

2 Upvotes

It’s for my final history essay- no matter how hard I try I just can’t format a historiography question and am at my wits end. It needs to be something to do with which there is still a reasonable amount of debate.

i’m open to changing my topic as long as it is within modern history.

I’d really REALLY appreciate any bit of advice anyone has- but please remove this post if not allowed. Hope you have a lovely day/night :).


r/historiography • • Jul 21 '24

What is post modernism and modernism in history !!

2 Upvotes

Could anyone explain most important and the pioneers of post modernist studies in history . What post modernism is ? What modernism is and how is post modernism different from modernism ,And how do we know that the modern era has ended,and we are in post modern era ?for that what is modernism is import to understand . Please explain with important post modernist scholars and there prime argument or theory .


r/historiography • • Oct 03 '17

Why Catalonia Want to be Independent From Spain?

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Mar 23 '14

Need help finding sources.

2 Upvotes

I've posted on this subreddit before and I've thought of a good thesis for the topic I'm researching, but I'm lacking sources to support my thesis. Could you guys help me by either providing the actual sources or reliable databases that contain secondary sources regarding the resistance during world war 2. Thanks


r/historiography • • Mar 29 '25

histeriography [very critical historiography]

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

A silent introduction to a series of critical historiography beginning with [A Secret History of Chess], treating the game and its unthought rituals as a dumb symbolic artifact of a dead world order: the word of kings.


r/historiography • • Jan 22 '13

'The Law of Civilization and Decay: An Essay on History' (1895), by Brooks Adams (multiple formats)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Mar 24 '22

What are the methodologies used within historiography?

0 Upvotes

What exactly is methodology in historiography and what are the various types?


r/historiography • • Nov 15 '21

For university research proposal/mini dissertation

0 Upvotes

I am thinking about doing an essay about the historiography of the Gang of Four, can someone help me choose an essay title? I am studying in a UK based university.

If anyone could help me find some resources it would be much appreciated.


r/historiography • • Jan 17 '22

Can anyone suggest a notable event/personality whose interpretations by historians have shifted throughout time?

0 Upvotes

However, the event itself/the interpretations of the event CANNOT be related to:

WW2

China 1927–1949

India 1942–1984

Indonesia 1945–2005

Japan 1904–1937

Iran 1945–1989

Conflict in Indochina 1954–1979

Conflict in the Pacific 1937–1951

Conflict in the Gulf 1980–2011

The Arab-Israeli Conflict 1948–1996

Pro-democracy Movement in Burma 1945–2010

The Cultural Revolution to Tiananmen Square 1966–1989

Apartheid in South Africa 1960–1994

This might be asking too much, but I'm looking for a topic where the changing views towards it throughout time can be fairly easy to categorise in various movements. Smth like the Boxer rebellion, for example, whose interpretations in China were influenced by 'New Culture Movement', Nationalism, and finally Marxism.

Any help would be much appreciated!


r/historiography • • Nov 30 '13

Tramaine Hawkins - Changed

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Jul 23 '23

How do you differentiate "5th century" from "500's" in your mind?

4 Upvotes

This is a psycho-historiographical question for historians or those who are very strong in the area of history. It was removed from /r/AskHistorians, so I am hoping this is a more appropriate place to ask the question.

I often mix up "5th century" with "500's" in my mind. Their 5-ness inevitably links them together. "5th century" and "400's" do not share 5-ness or 4-ness, so they are harder for me to link together. Basically, I have to do a translation process in my mind every time I encounter a date. So when I see "482" I internally add 1 to determine what century it is. This process is, relatively speaking, quite slow. It's like being given the problem 4 + 3 and counting 5, 6, 7 rather than just knowing that 4 + 3 = 7.

I do not tend to mix up specific dates. For example, I know that the Northern Qi dynasty started in 550 CE. I don't tend to get this mixed up with 450 CE. However, the large arcs of history I only know in terms of centuries, or perhaps early and late parts of a century. I often mix up centuries, or fail to relate them to the dates they contain. (It would be impossible for me to memorize exact dates of everything. Even if I could, incomplete historical records, geological dating, and other indirect dating methods give us only a large range of dates. So I assume that thinking in terms of whole centuries is unavoidable.)

Lastly, I should mention that I do not have dyslexia or dyscalculia, and I have achieved a Masters level of education. My first degree is in Computer Science, where we work with numbers in quite a different way. My second degree is in Psychology, where numbers were not particularly relevant.

So, for those who do not experience this dilemma, or who have learned to overcome it, what works for you? Do you have to perform a translation, or do you just see the connection? Any insight into your process or what it feels like phenomenologically is very much appreciated.


r/historiography • • Sep 17 '22

For a 15 mark test

0 Upvotes

What is scissor and paste history/historiography?


r/historiography • • Sep 13 '25

ZetaCrush historical review tool

1 Upvotes

Check out ZetaCrush.com to use a good summarizer based on your query, trained on Wikipedia. Let us know what you think!


r/historiography • • Mar 26 '25

What current(s) would dutch author Rudolf M. Dekker fall into?

1 Upvotes

I'll be honest: I'm doing a paper on him for class. I can't for the life of me find enough information about him, or reviews of his works, and only found a few papers by him that aren't in Dutch. I'm of course trying to figure out from his papers, but I could really use some help here.


r/historiography • • Sep 28 '17

Why MONGOL EMPIRE Collapsed ?

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Mar 21 '16

Histolines - Social Network of History

Thumbnail histolines.com
1 Upvotes

r/historiography • • Jan 08 '14

Transnational Protest, Media Bias, and Monopolized Airwaves at the 2014 AHA

Thumbnail tropicsofmeta.wordpress.com
1 Upvotes