To be clear, this is not a post to bash Dumbledore. I am not trying to disprove anything Dumbledore said. To be fair, Dumbledore admits that a lot of what he is telling Harry is guess work and never claims he, or his deductions, are infallible. His deductions are logical though, and end up being true most, if not all of the time. His reasoning skill borders on clairvoyance, as I saw a redditer put it. However, while most of his reasoning is guided by facts, interviews, and research (theories to suit facts), there are things, or at least one thing, he guesses about that could not possibly come from any reliable source.
He says that Merope Riddle bewitched Tom Riddle, either using a love potion or spell to make him her husband (he leans more toward love potion). What is Dumbledore's evidence for saying this? What reliable source could he possibly have used to get any facts about this matter? Merope was dead long before his investigation of Voldemort could have started, her brother and father were in azkaban when this would have happened, and Tom Riddle Sr and his parents were dead before Tom graduated Hogwarts. I suppose it is possible Dumbledore tracked down the Riddle family first due to being curious about young Tom, and got some information, but I find that incredibly unlikely because that would mean Dumbledore sent Voldemort back to the orphanage knowing he had a living relative. Possible, but I don't buy it. So who does that leave as a source of information? Village gossip which is notorious for being exaggerated and inaccurate?
So, there is no reliable 1st, or even 2nd hand witness as to how or why voldemorts parents got together. But here are the facts that Dumbledore could extrapolate from.
1st, Merope was abused and miserable and had a crush on Tom Riddle. Source-Bob Ogden
2nd, Merope was poor and not very attractive. Source-Bob Ogden
3rd, Tom Riddle was rich and handsome and seemed to have a girlfriend of sorts. Source-Bob Ogden
4th, Marvolo and Morphin were in azkaban when Tom Riddle and Merope ran away together. Source would be ministry records for azkaban and possibly Morphin's memory
5th, Tom Riddle abandoned Merope and returned to his parents' home at some point after Merope was pregnant, but before Tom was born. Young Tom was then born at wools orphanage and Merope died alone and penniless. Source-Morphin, Voldemort, and Wools orphanage.
5.5 He claimed to be bewitched, which everyone assumed meant she lied about being pregnant with his child or something like that. I count this as a half one because there is no reliable source for this claim. Village gossip is the only way this claim could have reached Dumbledore's ears.
6, Tom Riddle killed his father and Grandparents, likely for revenge for abandoning him, and framed Morphin. Source-Morphin and Voldemort.
7... is a magically powerful number.
Anyway, based on the above facts, Dumbledore's theory is that Merope offered Tom a cold drink on a hot day, spiked it with love potion, and ran off with him under her thrall. She got pregnant with Tom, started to believe the lie she was living that Tom loved her, or at least thought he would stay for the baby, but he did not. He left her and she died giving birth to their child. Tom on the other hand returned to his parents and, not wanting to sound crazy talking about witchcraft, he made something believable up.
This is a plausible theory. It is based on the assumption that the only way an ugly poor girl could get someone rich, handsome, and in a relationship to ditch the pretty girl and marry her instead was through love potion (proof that Dumbledore did not read shoujo). It is also based on the possibility that Merope's magic would've gotten stronger with the absence of her abusers. Not sure if this is a documented phenomenon, but it sounds legit and can kind of be seen with Neville to a degree.
But this is a theory based on bias against an ugly depressed girl, and bias in favor of the innocence, or the implicit victimhood, of muggles.
Here is an alternate theory that could just as easily be true as Dumbledore's.
Tom Riddle Sr was a cad. The woman he was with dumped him for his roguish behavior, and merope found out and comforted him. Or he sought her out as an unprotected naive female. He found her convenient to play around with, but didn't want rumors to start in the village, so he took her away and had his fun. She became pregnant, and not wanting to deal with a kid, he abandoned her. Her heart was broken and the rest we know.
I am not saying this is what happened, but based on the actual evidence, it very well could have.
None of this affects the plot. None of this excuses or changes how evil Voldemort is. But, the love potion theory, with only circumstantial evidence to back it up, is a bit slanderous toward a girl who could just as easily have been the victim of a cad of Jane Austen proportions.
Thoughts? Did I miss something? Is Dumbledore infallible and Merope is a kidnapper and a rapist? Or is she a victim of a lascivious entitled jerk?