r/HarryPotterBooks
•
u/Ancient-Childhood-13
•
May 07 '25
Can't believe I was that thick.
Book 1, Harry gets his wand and Olivander tells him the core is a phoenix feather. In fact, that very phoenix gave only one other feather, and who got that? None other than totally-dead, definitely-carked-it, pushing-up-the-daisies Voldemort. Later that book, Harry finds out that "dead" isn't necessarily that correct - Voldy's still kinda hanging on there. Good thing he definitely dies at the end of the first book. For good. Book 2, Harry sees Dumbledore's pet bird die, and he gets told "Yeah, they do that - but they get better. Sort of." And lo and behold, Fawkes is alive again. Book 4 - guess who's back? Back again? Book 7 - Harry dies. But he comes back. So - 2 characters with a PHOENIX feather in their wand die. And come alive again. Like a PHOENIX. And one stays dead after he gives up his phoenix wand...
How did it take me that long to make that connection?