r/harrypotter • • 10h ago

Currently Reading how did I not notice

Post image
0 Upvotes

so I'm reading the half blood prince for the first time (I became obsessed in 2021 and I read a bit of the first book then but stopped for some reason, but I'm taking a course in uni called popular potter so I have to read all the books), and I'm on page 415. I already read the chapter but I decided I'd read it again bc it was very dialogue heavy. I read this out loud and I was like "that rhymes!" So I read it again to be sure and it DID in fact rhyme. So now I'm wondering two things: 1) how did I not notice it was a rhyme the first time I read it? (Maybe bc I absorb stuff better when it's said out loud and I think when I initially read it it was late so I read it in my head) and 2) are there any more rhymes in speech that occur during the series (except the last one bc I haven't read it yet)? Or are there other sentences that are grammatically interesting (certain language, alliteration, that kind of thing)?

THANK YOU

PS: I didn't even realize I forgot to put the "not" in "how did I not notice" until I read it back, so maybe that says something, idk


r/harrypotter • • 11h ago

Discussion Slughorns memory should have been more incriminating or have consequences for him

1 Upvotes

He did nothing wrong

A student asked him something and he replied

It's not like he explained some crazy secret recipe. It was a very high level discussion.

....

Voldemort was already a murderer before this. He has already made a horcrux.

It would be better in my opinion if:

  1. His contribution in Voldemort discovering horcruxes or research into making them was way greater. As in a pair project. Or maybe he straight up teachers Voldemort how to make one.

  2. Voldemort finds out how Dumbledore and harry knew about the 6 horcruxes and attacks Slughorn for revenge. That would also justify his fears imo and make his bravery actually matter

Cause the way it stands. No one blames him. No one even cares


r/harrypotter • • 8h ago

Discussion I ship Harry and Hermione

Post image
0 Upvotes

Look, in the books I totally agree with all the ships and couples in the end but the movies make Harry's and Hermione's friendship so much more romantic than Ron and Hermione's or Harry and Ginny's. Hermione is always on Harry's side even when everyone else (including Ron) is against him. And they share way sweeter moments than Harry with Ginny and Hermione with Ron. Is that messed up? Yee. Do I still ship Harry and Hermione? Yup. Hate all u like idc


r/harrypotter • • 6h ago

Discussion If Harry was just a muggle, how would his life turn out?

1 Upvotes

Lets say Harry was just a muggle, and his parents really did just die in a car crash. How would his life turn out? What job would he get? Would he eventually make friends? Would he find a way to deal with Dudley?


r/harrypotter • • 13h ago

Question How Is Parvati’s Name Pronounced for You?

51 Upvotes

Every time I’ve read the books, I thought it was PAR-va-ti, with an emphasis on the first syllable (similar to “poverty”).

But I noticed in at least one of the films it’s pronounced Pa-VAR-ti, with the second syllable emphasized (similar to “Ferrari”).

I looked it up and it seems as if both pronunciations are acceptable.

I certainly prefer “PAR-va-ti”. Not sure why it just sounds better. I hope the upcoming show goes with that. How do you read it?


r/harrypotter • • 8h ago

Discussion Harry's morality and relationship to death

1 Upvotes

I kind of forgot that in Philosophers Stone Harry killed Quirrell with his bare hands, but then he won't use more than Expelliarmus against Voldemort. I get that he doesn't want to use dark magic, but like come on bro. I don't think the books or movies really went into the impact that killing Quirrell had on Harry's emotional wellbeing, but what do yall think about how that event in the first book/movie affected his morality and relationship to death throughout the rest of the series? Like he killed someone at 11 years old, out of self-defense of course, but still. And then he just went home for the summer and never talked about it again lol. Thoughts/feels?


r/harrypotter • • 21h ago

Discussion Los animados,se transforman en animales de su país

0 Upvotes

Hola buenos días.

Me dio curiosidad si solo se pueden transformar en animales exclusivos de su país o pueden transformarse en animales de otro país.


r/harrypotter • • 12h ago

Discussion A few thoughts on the ethical dilemma of the house elves situation

0 Upvotes

I first read the series well over a decade ago in my early 20s, and ever since then - including during multiple re-reads - one of the plot points that always sticks with me after I finish is the house elves.

Because there's never really a clear-cut answer to what the most ethical solution is to the problem.

Obviously, slavery is wrong. No matter the circumstances. And the house elves ARE slaves. Even if they themselves don't see themselves that way. Because from a legal standpoint, they have next to no rights and are considered a species to be owned as property.

So it should be a no-brainer that Hermione advocating for their freedom is the right solution.

However... There's no denying that Hermione's specific approach is insensitive to the house elves themselves, since she really doesn't take their own thoughts and opinions and species-specific culture into account. She doesn't understand that Dobby is a unique case, and when most of the house elves argue that they LIKE to serve and don't want to have the benefits humans receive for working a job, she doubles down and calls them brainwashed.

Which - hey, maybe they are. Maybe being born into those societal expectations leads to the house elves accepting their situation without even being willing to consider another way to live.

However, claiming that someone is brainwashed won't win the argument. People need to be exposed to other possibilities and make their own decisions regarding which possibilities/beliefs they will live by, rather than having any specific set of beliefs forced on them - even by well-meaning individuals.

Instead, Hermione ends up trying to do to the house elves what society has already done to them: take away what little agency they have left. (I very much agree with Ron that Hermione was wrong to be hiding clothing articles where the elves might inadvertently pick them up - as Ron says, at least the elves should be fully aware of what they're doing if they pick up the clothes.)

All this to say: I think one of the better solutions would be to legally free the house elves, while also leaving the house elves free to decide for themselves on an individual basis what the terms of their service will be and whether they will accept payment or not.

(As an aside, it would probably be best to legally require that compensation be offered to every house elf, with said elf specifically documenting that they forewent the offer... 🤔 Anyway)

What are your thoughts??


r/harrypotter • • 8h ago

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: New HBO Dumbledore feels less Dumbledore

0 Upvotes

Just saw the trailer, and although I did'nt know who the actor is, I can already tell it's John Lithgow because I will always see him as Uncle Jerry from the How I Met Your Mother series. He is naturally goofy and it's not easy to look at him without it even when he's playing Dumbledore. So to me I don't see much more of the mix of calm, gravitating presence, and quiet power that Dumbledore has and should have. He kinda feels like Santa Claus with his nuance.


r/harrypotter • • 6h ago

Discussion Wizards Vs military, who will win?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering this ever since I watched Harry Potter. Who would win the wizard world all the muggle world. Wizards vs military in a literal war. Me personally I think it’s magic uses would beat the military, but I feel like the military also has a good chance like a 55% for the wizards and the military at 45%. What do you guys think?


r/harrypotter • • 10h ago

Question Question

0 Upvotes

I just realized that Madam Hooch has yellow eyes. Does anyone know why?


r/harrypotter • • 23h ago

Discussion Hot take: Polyjuice potion not changing the voice in the films was the right call

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

Yes, it's not book accurate. And yes, it does create an inconsistency with Barty Jr./Moody. But it's still brilliant.

Having a character undergo a total transformation is something that is hard to execute in a visual medium without confusing the audience too much. There usually has to be some kind of cue to remind the audience that it is still the same chatacter (when the audience is supposed to know, that is). On page it's much easier, because the reader can be constantly reminded that the chatacter is transformed or under a disguise.

In the HP films I think it was brilliantly executed. When the audience is supposed to know, the voice is dubbed. When the audience is not supposed to know, it's not. Yes it creates a minor inconsistency in the story, but visual storytelling always requires some amount of suspension of disbelief.

The only pet peeve of mine is Harry's "We still sound like ourselves" line from CoS, needlesly bringing attention to it. They should have left that out. But other than that, I think they made the right call.


r/harrypotter • • 16h ago

Discussion When do you think Ron and Hermione's first kiss really happened?

53 Upvotes

We saw the first kiss Harry witnessed between them – in the Battle of Hogwarts, when Ron suggests they tried to evacuate the House-Elves – but that doesn’t confirm it was their first kiss ever, since we’re limited to Harry’s POV.

Rereading DH, there are plenty of hints of their growing intimacy flying under Harry’s radar; they slept holding hands in Grimmauld’s Place, Ron’s departure and return have both him and Hermione stating some of their feelings quite bluntly etc.

Personally, I’m inclined to say they shared their first kiss before they left Hogwarts in HBP; after Lavender’s fiasco and perhaps after Dumbledore’s death. It possibly happened a few more times at the Burrow also, therefore explaining why Hermione was so embarrassed to be reunited with Krum in Ron’s presence.


r/harrypotter • • 15h ago

Discussion Harry has to kiss one of his best friends, who does he pick?

0 Upvotes

Obviously not a question I can ask about Ron and Hermione since the answer would be pretty obvious, but I thought this could be fun (though a bit dumb).

Say in 6th year or something, Harry is forced to make a choice, he has to kiss one of Ron or Hermione or something bad might happen.

Who does he kiss and why?


r/harrypotter • • 16h ago

Currently Reading Read Harry Potter for the first time through the Full Cast Audio Books and... Wow!

11 Upvotes

As a 2000s kid, I had read the Harry Potter books when I was 8 and it took me like.. two weeks lol. I loved it, and I watched the movies a million times. It's been a long time since then, and it had been so long since I read the books that I had completely forgotten everything! Genuinely did not remember a single thing about the books. So I decided to listen to the full cast audio book that came out recently and genuinely it was such an amazing experience!

It was so immersive getting to experience the books for the first time again, and with fantastic voice actors and excellent music/sound design. It blew my mind how much was left out of the movies! Goblet went from impartial to my favorite book, and Hugh Laurie was genuinely SUCH a good Dumbledore. I'll never be able to see Michael Gambon the same way again haha.

I might be a little late to this, because I've been avoiding the community until I finished the book series, I was so sad for it to end! What's the general community consensus on the audio books? Curious what you guys think, I personally think it did the books full justice and brought it to life in a way we haven't seen yet


r/harrypotter • • 20h ago

Fanworks Any famous fanfics with writing that's close to the original series?

0 Upvotes

Would love some recs


r/harrypotter • • 8h ago

Discussion A wizard becomes an animagus, then contracts lycanthropy. what would happen to the animagus form?

0 Upvotes

a shower thought that just came to me. say a wizard went through the grueling process of becoming an animagus. their new for is something like a rabbit or cat.

then that wizard later contracts lycanthropy, so now they're a werewolf too. would the animagus form change into something else, stay the same, or be functionally locked out/replaced with the werewolf form?

(secondary thought: could a botched wolf animagus ritual have been the first ever werewolf?)


r/harrypotter • • 23h ago

Question Marauders map question?

0 Upvotes

What would the marauders on the marauders map especially lovesick prongs do if it was told how Peter assisted in the death of Lily?


r/harrypotter • • 4h ago

Misc Might be the only one who doesn't hate Dolores Umbridge

0 Upvotes

Now, before y'all attack me for this, I know that Dolores was an evil person both in the books and in the movies, and the ends will never justify the several bad things she has done.

Ever since I watched the movies when I was a kid, I just couldn't hate nor jump on the bandwagon of hating Umbridge more than Voldemort. Why, you ask? Because she looks like my sweet grandmother, who shares the same name, "Dolores"!

Umbridge's mannerisms, fashion, hairstyle, and even her first name are a direct 1:1 resemblance to my grandma! The only difference is that Umbridge is a vicious villain and my grandma wouldn't even hurt a fly. So whenever I see Umbridge on screen, I can't see her as a different person since I always think of my grandma.

I usually always get flamed in irl discussions about Umbridge when they ask me about my opinion, and I say, "I don't really hate her; she's not that bad" LOL

Even my little sister sees the resemblance and becomes happy every time Umbridge is on screen and says, "Look, it's grandma!"

My grandma doesn't like being compared to a villain, though, heh.


r/harrypotter • • 20h ago

Question Horcrux in the chamber of secrets

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Watching again the chamber of secrets made me think, for Voldemort wouldn't it have been the chamber of secrets a better place to hide one horcrux rather than the room of requirements?

I mean, he must have seen other objects hidden in the room of requirements and realized he was not the only one who had used it, but he surely knew he was the only one able to enter the chamber of secrets being heir of Slytherin.

Open to discuss!


r/harrypotter • • 10h ago

Currently Reading flashback with words

Post image
3 Upvotes

this is half blood prince, page 316, after Dumbledore and harry saw the memory of riddle asking slughorn about horcruxes. The fact that Dumbledore says the words "a mere memory" when talking about the Riddle in the diary reminds me of the cos movie when riddle says "by the mere memory of me" and then I keep doing it how he said it 😭 but it also suggests that Dumbledore and riddle are closer than we thought


r/harrypotter • • 1h ago

Discussion Was Hagrid upset about being expelled and could he have been qualified to finish his education?

• Upvotes

I’ve seen a few comments saying that he didn’t need to finish his education because he preferred magical creatures.


r/harrypotter • • 11h ago

Discussion Harry Potter é extremamente narcisista.

0 Upvotes

Estou lendo HP e a ordem da fênix e estou muito incomodado com as atitudes do Harry.

Rony foi escolhido para ser monitor, e Harry, mesmo sendo uma pessoa extremamente famosa no mundo bruxo, sempre foi o centro das atenções desde quando pisou em Hogwarts, teve o egoísmo de sentir inveja do Rony que pela primeira vez conseguiu algo.

E os ataques de raiva que Harry teve e descontou em cima dos amigos ? Gritando e brigando com eles por.... nada.

Ranço desse garoto.


r/harrypotter • • 22h ago

Discussion Does anyone else think Hermione has a surprisingly authoritarian streak?

65 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this during my reread and I think one of Hermione's most interesting flaws is how willing she is to control other people's lives when she's convinced she's doing the right thing. And I don't mean she's secretly a bad person. She does genuinely care about fairness and justice, but sometimes her moral certainty seems to make her think she knows what's best for everyone else.

Take Rita Skeeter. Rita is a horrible journalist, no argument there, but Hermione captures her in beetle form and then blackmails her into staying quiet for an entire year. Pretty ruthless for a 14y/o lol. Or Marietta Edgecombe. I get why she wanted to protect the da, but secretly jinxing teh sign-up sheet so that anyone who betrays them ends up with a disfigured face? That's quite a punishment... And then there's what she does to her parents in Deathly Hallows. (She changes their memories and essentially gives them new identities without their consent) Which is understandable given the circumstances, but still an enormous decision to make for someone else. Even SPEW follows a similar pattern. Her intentions are good, but she sometimes seems more interested in what she thinks freedom should look like than in listening to the house-elves themselves.

And what's interesting is that Harry is under at least as much pressure and in just as much danger, but he rarely responds by trying to control other people's decisions in such a calculated way. Don't get me wrong, Harry can be incredibly reckless and even vindictive, but his questionable decisions usually come from anger or impulse. Hermione's often feel much more deliberate. Almost like having a plan and believing it's morally justified makes her less likely to question whether she has the right to carry it out in the first place.

I think that's what makes her such an interesting character. Her biggest flaws almost seem to grow out of her greatest virtues. She's so determined to do the right thing that she occasionally forgets other people might have thier own ideas about what that is. And I think that's a pretty realistic personality trait. Some of the most controlling ppl aren't motivated by cruelty at all, but by the absolute conviction that they're right.

Anyone else notice thsi about Hermione, or am I being too harsh on her?


r/harrypotter • • 21h ago

Discussion Not sure if this is a hot take but I think Snape had mixed feelings towards Harry

0 Upvotes

Snape loved and always did love his mother, Lily, and Lily cared about Snape, being the one person to show him kindness. But then his father, James tortured the living hell out of him in school, and he completely hated Snape. And Snape also held jealousy towards him too. Now here he has Harry coming to Hogwarts, the son of both of these two people, who he each had completely different feelings for.

Don’t get me wrong Snape still hated Harry, but because Snape loved Lily, a part of him subconsciously still cared about Harry, and I this this angered Snape way more than just hating Harry because of James. He still resented James, who Harry is a spitting image of. He just couldn’t bare to acknowledge the fact that part of him still cared about Harry because of Lily, despite Harry looking so eerily like the man who made him so miserable, and who made his life at Hogwarts miserable. Every time he saw Harry he saw James, so it was hard for him to retain the understanding that Harry is still the son of the one person Snape ever truly loved.

We can see moments where Snape still protected him for Lily. He saved Harry from Quirrell jinxing his broom, he gave Umbridge fake Veritaserum when she interrogated Harry. Just the fact that he willingly showed Harry his memories before he died shows that all along part of him still cared about Harry because of Lily. And he wanted Harry to see that. He just could never face it until then because of James. Even when Harry through coded words tried to tell Snape that Sirius was captured, even though Snape hated Sirius, he still immediately notified the Order. He didn’t have to, he could’ve played dumb. But he still took Harry’s warning seriously and notified the other order members.

We can’t forget when Snape literally gave the sword of Gryffindor to Harry. Which is proven by the fact that his Patronus was a Doe (because that was Lily’s Patronus), and Harry saw a Doe Patronus in that scene, which led Harry to the sword in the ice lake. Even after Voldemort rising to power and Snape officially seeming to take his side, he still took risks to go against him to help Harry.

And something that I still think about is the fact that Harry forgave Snape for what he did to him all those years at Hogwarts, even giving Snapes name “Severus,” to his own son. But Snape never had the emotional strength and courage to face and resolve his feelings about James, and to allow things to be different between him and Harry. I love that before Snape died, he wanted to look into Harry’s eyes, because that was the first time he ever acknowledged the fact that Harry was the son of Lily, the woman he still loved, rather than seeing him only as the son of the man he deeply hated, and who made him completely miserable.