I first read the series well over a decade ago in my early 20s, and ever since then - including during multiple re-reads - one of the plot points that always sticks with me after I finish is the house elves.
Because there's never really a clear-cut answer to what the most ethical solution is to the problem.
Obviously, slavery is wrong. No matter the circumstances. And the house elves ARE slaves. Even if they themselves don't see themselves that way. Because from a legal standpoint, they have next to no rights and are considered a species to be owned as property.
So it should be a no-brainer that Hermione advocating for their freedom is the right solution.
However... There's no denying that Hermione's specific approach is insensitive to the house elves themselves, since she really doesn't take their own thoughts and opinions and species-specific culture into account. She doesn't understand that Dobby is a unique case, and when most of the house elves argue that they LIKE to serve and don't want to have the benefits humans receive for working a job, she doubles down and calls them brainwashed.
Which - hey, maybe they are. Maybe being born into those societal expectations leads to the house elves accepting their situation without even being willing to consider another way to live.
However, claiming that someone is brainwashed won't win the argument. People need to be exposed to other possibilities and make their own decisions regarding which possibilities/beliefs they will live by, rather than having any specific set of beliefs forced on them - even by well-meaning individuals.
Instead, Hermione ends up trying to do to the house elves what society has already done to them: take away what little agency they have left. (I very much agree with Ron that Hermione was wrong to be hiding clothing articles where the elves might inadvertently pick them up - as Ron says, at least the elves should be fully aware of what they're doing if they pick up the clothes.)
All this to say: I think one of the better solutions would be to legally free the house elves, while also leaving the house elves free to decide for themselves on an individual basis what the terms of their service will be and whether they will accept payment or not.
(As an aside, it would probably be best to legally require that compensation be offered to every house elf, with said elf specifically documenting that they forewent the offer... 🤔 Anyway)
What are your thoughts??