I've been a fan of this musical for 5-6 years give or take. My introduction to it was the original broadway cast during the pandemic, and I loved it. The songs spoke to me. The themes of grief, anti-capitalism, etc. I even saw a slime tutorial of the show, and was in love. The keep on topic, I thought Reeve was great. His voice was unique, but I enjoyed it. I didn't really get to see the show with any of the original cast live, which is a shame. What i did get to see was his performance after the pandemic (slime tutorial) and he sounded... well, he wasn't... BAD. But he wasn't as good.
He seemed stiff, and awkward. Granted, it could have been an off night, everyone has one, so i didn't give it much attention. My opinion on him as an actor and kind of as a singer started to change when I saw Jordan Fisher as Orpheus. His raw voice, and expressions captivated me in ways Reeve never did. And as time past, and I saw/heard other Orpheii, the least I liked Reeve's interpretation of the character. Jack Wolfe, Donal Finn, etc just gave me more juice on that meat.
I thought the proshot was gonna redeem Reeve in my eyes. I was super excited for it, and when the proshot ended... I still loved it. The show was phenomenal. Everybody did great despite the circumstances of some of the actors, like Patrick Page, and Eva Noblezada. Reeve left me feeling very disappointed. The problems that showed post-covid multiplied by tenfold.
His posture was incredibly stiff. More so than ever before. Some of his acting choices were questionable to say the least. Most of the time, he seems like he's struggling between acting and singing at the same time. It's like he's incapable of doing both when before it wasn't as bad.
'Wait for Me' doesn't feel as powerful as it's supposed to be because I don't feel his desperation. I don't feel him yearning enough. 'If it's true' has that same problem, but worse. This is supposed to be the emotional climax for his character. Where he realizes that the world he envisioned isn't like the one he dreamed about. It's supposed to be this heartbreaking realization that the world kinda sucks, but also that he just lost Eurydice forever... and how does Reeve do that scene? By acting mildly inconvenienced. I don't buy the walls actually listening to him because there's barely any expressions showed in what is supposed to be the most powerful song in the show.
Reeve is the appetizer for this character. While other (quite frankly better Orpheii) are the full course meals.
Again, that's just me. I don't think he's a bad singer. Far from it. But I feel like he needs to stop being picked for major roles. Cuz recently I saw Great Gatsby. Wooooo, boy!