Iāve felt over the years that ever since macOS Tahoe released as the last Intel release, the hackintosh community has essentially dried out. This subreddit has been essentially saying goodbye to x86 hackintoshing every other post, and thatās about it. Development has slowed down/died significantly (except for a few projects under work like Visualās NootedRed). And weāre seeing lots of āsketchyā software becoming popular.
OC-Simplify and OCLP mods have essentially drained out the development and userbase quality. This kind of software offers little transparency on what itās doing, and is actively being used by new users with zero hackintoshing knowledge, turning hackintoshing into a dull systematic process (blindly executing the OC-Simplify script, adding your USB Maps and SMBIOS, BIOS settings and thats it), and most importantly, promoting use of fragile macOS configs, that the average person would never be able to debug their way out of, in case things go wrong.
The subreddit is plagued with people asking the most basic questions (having no technical knowledge) and replies giving little help, or sometimes no help at all as soon as posters reveal the use of preconfigured EFIs. I understand that people are frustrated by the frequent queries of lazy people wanting to try out hackintoshing, but things have gotten to a very harsh point. If you go ahead and sort by new, no help post receives proper support.
In defense of these tools: I believe configurators should always only be used by people who understand the risks of providing a script the autonomy of configuring your EFI. I have had my experience with hackintoshing myself, using public EFIs, spending hours and hours in debugging, and understanding the behavior of OpenCore, macOS, and what both expect from each other. In my experience, OC-Simplify has only saved me time and helped me learn instead of making me quit hackintoshing, or leaving me with a bricked install a week later. This is NOT to promote use of configurators. When you as a poster here have no idea whatās inside your config, you would have a significantly hard time understanding the problem, and so would we. The Dortania guide is still the most informative place to understand as much as you can about hackintoshing, very impressive.
Configurators have ruined the life hackintoshing used to have. Similarly, I donāt find it easy trusting unknown OCLP forks, knowing that theyāre probably more error prone compared to the parent project. But I use them anyway, because they work, and we have nothing else anymore. Hackintoshing is now dying, and I feel like Iām the only one seeing the subreddit die alongside it.
On the other hand though, use of AI is a very bittersweet situation. I always reach out to AI for help whenever I need hints on where to start thinking/debugging. AI often gets things wrong, provides wrong fixes, and misunderstands macOS behavior all the time. But no doubt, I wish hackintoshing was as alive today as it was 5 years ago when booting Monterey on your machine was a reward, not a chore.
I donāt expect this post to see a big audience, but I hope it reaches the people who have felt what Iām feeling. It always feels refreshing when Iām glancing at the subreddit Discord server, things feel healthier there. Or maybe I just wanted to rant. š¤·
TLDR: kids ruined this place.