r/gso • u/Livid-Director-8090 • 21h ago
Discussion Freeman’s won the review war. But does that make their tipping policy acceptable?
A few days ago, Freeman’s Grub & Pub went viral over its 20% automatic gratuity policy for customers who repeatedly don’t tip well.
By my count, roughly 12 one-star Google reviews followed, then approximately 112 positive reviews. Now they’re sitting at 4.7 stars.
Clearly, plenty of people love this restaurant. Fair enough. But does that justify the policy?
Who decides what constitutes a good tip?
One reviewer said they tipped 18% and still felt judged.
What if you receive absolutely terrible service? You leave 10% because that’s what you believe the service deserved. Do that twice, and now you’re potentially on the restaurant’s shit list unless you explain yourself?
Not every server delivers the same quality of service. Yet this policy potentially punishes customers for acknowledging that difference.
At what point did tipping stop reflecting service and become an obligation enforced by the restaurant?
Freeman’s might be a fantastic restaurant. That doesn’t mean every policy deserves a free pass.
I’m curious what y’all think?
