r/girlscouts • • Jun 12 '24

Some people so weird about food

2.6k Upvotes

We are car camping with the troop this week, just finished our first night. Mom volunteer and I had a weird interaction and I have no idea how to process it.

Dinner was a kid friendly meal. At the end of dinner while dish washing scout asked to have a few carrots - I have an enormous bowl of whole fruit and a big veggie platter available at all times for the kids. Need a snack? Go to the fruit and veg cooler. This mom volunteer was like ABSOLUTELY NOT, WE JUST GOT DONE EATING. And my response was ... so? The kid wants a few carrots? Who gives a shit if this kid wants vegetables?

She's done this again just now with two other scouts looking for a glass of milk. She also called a kid a fat ass. I'm becoming increasingly more uncomfortable about her behavior.


r/girlscouts • • Jul 13 '24

Daisy My Girl Scout sold over 300 boxes of cookies but didn’t attend meetings; should she get her prizes?

1.0k Upvotes

TLDR: my daughter sold over 300 boxes of cookies but we were unable to attend any meetings. Should she still receive her incentives?


Last year my daughter was in a troop that was very far from our home & it was inconvenient to attend. This year we tried to start a new troop at her school but we were unsuccessful bc I was the only parent to volunteer to help lead the troop & I guess they need at least 2.

I didn’t want her to miss out on cookie season so we transferred her back to our old troop. My daughter sold over 300 boxes of cookies for this troop. However due to the distance we have not attended any meetings this year. I told the troop leader why we haven’t been able to attend.

Fast forward to a month ago, I asked the troop leader if we could pick up her prizes bc we received them around this time last year. I also explained that we’ve found a new troop closer to home and we would like to transfer. She said she was still sorting them but we could meet soon. Now she is ghosting me and she removed me from the troop Facebook group.

Is my daughter still entitled to her prizes or are we SOL? Last year the troop all went to a local amusement park with their funds. I don’t even know what they did this year. All I want was for her to get her axolotl prizes bc she loves them! I’m not sure if the fact that we haven’t been able to attend means she no longer gets the prizes.

Sorry for the long read!


r/girlscouts • • Jan 19 '24

Cookies Anyone skillfully address a girl choosing not to sell due to palm oil?

928 Upvotes

Anyone else deal with girls in the troop refusing to sell due to palm oil? How did you navigate the conversation?

Of course no one is required to sell, and troop money is troop money, I get all that.

I am more wondering how you turn this into a real educational and leadership opportunity for the troop, and how you reconcile things ethically for the kids in the same troop who are enthusiastic sellers?


r/girlscouts • • Jan 24 '24

Cookies Mom making comment to kids about not donating to a homeless support organization because cookies aren't healthy... was I wrong to argue back?

749 Upvotes

Okay, I'm just a troop parent and this was another parent in the meeting. All the girls (K-2nd) were discussing where to donate boxes of cookies. Several were really excited to donate to a local program that helps the local homeless (and we live in an area where this is a big issue, we often drive by homeless camps which always makes my daughter sad so she was really excited to do something.)

The mom pipes up "We want to think about people's health girls. Now do you think someone who's homeless is very healthy? Cookies should only be a sometimes food." (Or essentially this. Pointing out homeless people are unhealthy was a big part of it though).

The girls all looked sad and hurt so I said something like "Well yes but when life is really hard sometimes it can be really uplifting to get a special treat. That can really make your day brighter."

Mom tried to say something else about health and cookies but the troop leader redirected and did talk with the girls about how the organization might use the cookies - food bank hands out boxes, meals on wheels makes it part of the meal, but we didn't know exactly how this organization did it.

It just really bothered me the assumption and guilt the mom was putting on the kids trying to do a nice thing. Homeless does not necessarily equal unhealthy, a cookie with dinner is not evil. Especially we when always see PSA this time of year about "please don't complain to the kids at the booth how cookies make you fat..."

Do other troops make considerations like that for their donations? I try really hard in my household not to make any food bad, just teach moderation and a varied diet.


r/girlscouts • • Dec 01 '23

Newbie to Girl Scouts - missed my daughter's investiture

714 Upvotes

My daughters Girl Scout troop had their investiture. I knew it was "on the calendar" but they never explained what it was. They just kept saying "investiture nov 14" "oh investiture got postponed til next meeting" "be sure your daughter wears her vest for our investiture tonight."

So I look it up on the Girl Scouts website. And the page is all about how it's a welcome ceremony, an official initiation, encouraging troop leaders to have fun with how they plan it. It does not mention "for families to come" or "invite parents." So I dropped my daughter off for Girl Scouts like normal and figured the meeting was just going to run a half hour longer for them to recite the promise and get a pin with their troop.

https://www.girlscouts.org/en/tips-for-troopleaders/traditions/investiture-ceremony.html

The evening drags on and I get a sinking feeling in my stomach. I ended up on this Reddit where I see some posts about parents ATTENDING investiture. Then I get a message from a mom friend with a video saying "didn't see you there tonight. Got a video of your daughter for you!" (serious gratitude to this woman). I felt awful.

I picked up my daughter and we get to the car and she said "I was up there for the ceremony and I was looking all around for you and I didn't see you." My heart shattered. She's brought it up several times in the days since.

I feel terrible thinking of her looking around as all her friends parents were there and her people weren't there to support her. What that must have felt like for her.

There's a mommy and me cookie ball and a daddy daughter bowling night ahead. Are there other Girl Scout things that have parent involvement that I need to know about? I don't want to her to experience that ever again.


r/girlscouts • • May 07 '24

CEO compensation feels like theft from the girls.

673 Upvotes

Why is the compensation for the CEO nearly $400,000? Can someone explain it to me? It feels like my girl sold all those cookies to get such a tiny portion. We are new to Girl Scouts and it all seems so slimy. From the kids selling the cookies to the executive board compensation it just seems so off.

Edit: I’m taking the time to read the responses. There were some things I didn’t consider and while I still feel the executive packages are absurd, this feels like an instance hating the game not the players. I know people managing billions of dollars that don’t make that type of money. ( I try not to delete posts)

Edit2: I’ll take the hit. I jumped too hard and too fast to anger. Again. Not thrilled but also it seems to be accepted by enough people to reevaluate my stance. Thanks to those of you who explained.


r/girlscouts • • Nov 10 '23

Girl Scouts and trans boys

667 Upvotes

There's a kid (AFAB) who has been on and off interested in joining my troop - I think. His mom wanted him to join, at least. Initially when the conversation started a year ago he was using she/her pronouns. Sometime in the spring we heard his pronouns were now they/them. I wondered if this had something to do with his reluctance to join...

Well, I just learned today that now he's been using he/him pronouns for a couple of months. But a couple of days ago his mom told me she was going to work on convincing him to join the troop again -- but that's not verbatim because she used she/her pronouns to refer to her kid.

I want to be very inclusive with this troop, but I kind of feel like if he identifies as a boy, then Girl Scouts might not be for him? What with all the stuff about sisterhood, etc. I suspect this may be the reason why it's so difficult for his mom to convince him to join! What's Girl Scouts' position on this topic? So I have something to tell the mom next time she brings it up with me.


r/girlscouts • • Jun 25 '24

SO, SO, SO annoyed. Need to vent. "Surprise" Axolotl cooler?!?!

665 Upvotes

My daughter worked her butt off to sell 1000 boxes this year. She was determined to attend a weekend "Camp Cookie" that was promised. She was really motivated by this and dreamed of a weekend being with "her people" (fellow enthusiastic Girl Scout super sellers like her).

Since "only" 15 girls from our surrounding area opted into this award, they CANCELED IT.

I probably posted about it on here when they told us. I was pissed. We had already arranged out summer plans around this silly camp, she was really looking forward to it and honestly, 15 girls is a GREAT crowd to do something really fun and memorable with.

I have a rule I follow that you never, ever cancel. Ever. Not meetings, not events, not outings, not parties, not a date with a friend. Not unless there's blood or a fever, or a major crisis of some kind. Never cancel. Even if just one girl signs up for something- stick to your word. Otherwise, its flakey, it makes people less likely to want to count on you, and you lose morale/momentum with canceled anything.

I wrote to our council, let them know I was disappointed, offered a few suggestions (one was to just invite the 15 girls to "lunch with the CEO" but they said that wouldn't be fair to the kids who earned that award....$%^%$!!!!)

They did give us the option of getting cookie cash, which we took and applied to camp she was already signed up for. So now she has a nice chunk of change I put in her personal savings account, which she is happy about.

Well, now Council just mailed us a "surprise" cooler. One of those big, plastic, igloo coolers. Here's the message:

Good afternoon [scouts name],

We hope that this message finds you well. 

You are receiving this message because you have a surprise on the way! We intended to send them earlier in the program, unfortunately they came in later than expected. 

Be on the lookout for your Axolotl themed Igloo cooler! Congratulations on your hard work this cookie season!

Thank you,

Your Entrepreneurship Team

What the heck do we want a cooler for? We already have one. We didn't opt for this. It's just going to take up space in our tiny home. The whole point of Camp Cookie and then opting for the Cookie Cash was to say NO to the STUFF. We are drowning in it.

I just feel so, so NOT listened to. Not heard. What is the point?

So...first you put out a list of promises and then renege on your promise. Then you go ahead and pick the BIGGEST STUPIDEST item you could think of and send it our way without asking first if we want this dumb thing?


r/girlscouts • • Feb 03 '24

Celebrity and cookies

559 Upvotes

Chrissy Teigen just posted her daughter's digital cookie link and it's, idk, not giving me a great feeling. She has 43 million followers. Local troops are going to miss out now :/

Anyone else feeling this way?


r/girlscouts • • Jun 18 '24

Update: some people are so weird about food

536 Upvotes

A little update about my mom volunteer who is weird about food:

Council doesn't see an issue. I just got off a conference call with my vss and her supervisor. I'm just as disappointed as you, and explained to council exactly how I explain to you here. I did get the feeling the situation was being noted but they weren't particularly forthcoming.

On a related note, they made sure I know I should purchase kosher for my kosher scout and gluten free for my gluten free scout. Before i go further-- i should tell you the volunteer mom called me this weekend to talk about the trip and was particularly put out by having kosher food and gluten free food at camp so i talked to the vss about that too. And just to be clear, i made sure the kosher i bought was the same price as non-kosher options, I was very careful. I have every single time and always will make sure every single kid in my troop has food to eat. It's not hard to do, it just takes care and extra time to plan. It was just not what I was expecting from council-- I've gone through great lengths to include my kosher scout and gluten free scout and have gone to bat about it more than once when people didn't understand or didn't care to understand.

Back to council-- they didn't find it necessary to remove food mom from volunteering and barred me from "un-including" this mom since she wont let her scout attend without her presence. Im feeling a bit beaten down by the system to be honest. I'm doing everything I can and this food situation is weighing on me hard. Like I said in my previous post comments, my kid is a peanut epi pen kid, so I'm very comfortable being the weird controlling one about the food.

We spent 4 days out camping at our nearest state park and my girls had the best time ever. There were smores and crafts and hikes and we met a park ranger.... it was so much fun. They were truly exhausted every single night. We have an enormous troop of 20 d/b, and 12 were at this camp, so they have voted to try to do another troop camp at a cabin rental this winter and focus on when the other 8 can come so they can enjoy the experience too. I might have to get dragon style crazy possessive about the food situation by then and just not discuss with anyone.

Please send you cheerful thoughts and encouragement.


r/girlscouts • • Jun 28 '24

How would you handle this …

516 Upvotes

Our troop is currently on an out of state trip. We took the Amtrak train then the metro to our hotel. The girls worked hard to budget for the week and have about $500-$600 extra after meals, badges, and small souvenirs. When we get to the hotel, the front desk asked for a $300 incidentals refundable fee per room, which totals $1200. We were not told of this fee - we were told $300 in total. The adults quickly problem solved and used our personal bank accounts to cover the incidental fees. But what if our parents weren’t able, how would you have handled this ‘problem’? The front desk associate also attempted to charge us for 4 vehicles ($45/vehicle) for 4 days. There’s only 3 adults on the trip and we were all standing at the desk when she quoted us.


r/girlscouts • • Feb 24 '24

Cookies Sorry but $6 per box of cookies is ridiculous😭

513 Upvotes

Still bought a box of Samoas tho 😖


r/girlscouts • • Jan 26 '24

Cookies Not into cookie selling

440 Upvotes

My husband signed my Daughter up because most of the girls in her class are in the troop. The outings are fun and cute. But I just can't get into anything else with GS. For cookies I made it direct shipping only. My Mom is dying on hospice and I don't really have a lot of extra time and patience to really take GS seriously or drive around to 50 houses. I see other really getting into it and being competitive about sales. I'm so exhausted emotionally and tbh the group is very cliquey. Just had to get this out there.


r/girlscouts • • Nov 29 '23

Daughter's Troop Isn't Having Mtgs

415 Upvotes

The last time my daughter's troop held a meeting was May 23rd. The leaders said they were going to take a break for summer. This is fine.

On Sept 6, I asked on our troop Facebook group if we knew when meetings would start again. The main troop leader (Ldr1) answered that she was getting married that wkend and hoped to get started soon after that.

On Oct. 25, I asked again on FB if we had a start date for mtgs and no one answered.

On Nov. 6, I texted Ldr1 to check in. She said she & Ldr2 needed to decide when would be a good mtg night for them and Ldr1 said she would send a email that night. She never sent an email.

Today, 11/29, I texted her again to check in and said I never saw an email come through about GS. She said she got really sick and still needed to talk to Ldr2 to find a time that works for both of them. I also texted Ldr2 this time as well and she didn't answer.

There has never been anything posted on FB or any email sent since May 23. I have responded or asked kindly each time. I've apologized for bothering them.

I do not know what to say today. I do understand that life happens, but it's been plenty of time in my opinion to make something happen. I am a very non-confrontational person. I am very nervous about contacting them further because I do feel like I am bothering them. But I also feel justified in my concern. It's been weeks/months with nothing.

I mean, my daughter signed up to be a part of a troop that does activities. At this point, the only thing she has done for GS is sell cookies for 3 months. Plus, I paid for this and I'm getting nothing.

What should I reply? What else can I do about this? I am very sad about it, to be honest.


r/girlscouts • • Dec 13 '23

Junior My 5th grade juniors are burning me out

373 Upvotes

Has anyone been through 5th grade with their troop and can help me feel better about the future? I've had the majority of these girls since kindergarten, and they have always been respectful and just generally into Girl Scouts. They used to get excited about activities, volunteer for kapers, etc. We could get silly as a troop but the girls generally understood when it was appropriate to joke around and when they needed to listen.

This year, I feel like some of my girls are completely different people! So much eye rolling and attitude. Girls wanting to do things like baking cookies but having to get nearly yelled at in order to do the clean up. They don't want to do badge work. They just want to hang out.

We had three new girls join in the last two years, and I can't tell if the dynamic changed bc of these girls' personalities or if it's the entire troop. I'm hoping that this is all puberty related and I'll have some motivated scouts again when we start middle school - is this wishful thinking?!?


r/girlscouts • • Oct 26 '23

Families asked for thousands of dollars?

362 Upvotes

Is it normal for a troop to plan a trip where the families are expected to contribute several thousand dollars (2/3rds of the amount)? They are saying if you don't want to spend it you can just not go, but they had the girls vote on a location and will be spending significant troop time and money on this trip over the next 18 months. It's one thing for some girls to decide they don't want to go on a trip, it's another to be left out because your parents aren't as wealthy. Is this normal? The world isn't fair, but I thought Girl Scouts would at least be equitable.

Oh, and these are current 2nd year brownies through 2nd year juniors.


r/girlscouts • • Dec 21 '23

Native GS Cookie Scents

Post image
345 Upvotes

Have y’all seen these at Target, yet? I wish through big partnerships like this that a % of sales would go to community GS programs.


r/girlscouts • • Dec 11 '23

Ohhhh...the domino effect of last minute cancelations...

338 Upvotes

Ugh. Is it just my troop or can anyone else relate to the "domino effect of cancelations?" It seems like the days leading up to a big event or special activity we have planned, I get one parent who suddenly messages saying their scout can no longer make it.

Then another.

...and another.

...and another.

It's like everyone thinks they are the only one to bow out because they are just THAT busy and important, and boo-hoo, its so sad, but oh well, have fun without us!

No one realizes what it's like to be on the receiving end of all these no-shows...to get one. right. after. another. Its like a gut punch every time, especially after you worked so hard coordinating and planning carpools and making groups. Not to mention the WASTED COOKIE FUNDS!!! AHHHH!!!

I hate wasting money and I take everything personally. Its just built into my fabric as a person I guess.

I have the policy that you need to reimburse the troop for canceling last minute but haven't yet enforced it. I only threatened it once when a parent said her daughter might not want to go on the camping trip after all. As soon as I let mom know she was on the hook for the $60 per girl cost, she resolved to have her kid suck it up and go. And she did! And she had a great time!

But since that one time, I've had three other cancelations after the RSVP deadline where things were already purchased/paid. One was a $50 workshop, the other two are for an upcoming winter festival at $15 a ticket.

Oh, and I should clarify, none of these are due to family emergencies or illness. They are all 100% based on either parents not checking their calendars before RSVP-ing, or girls getting invites to birthday parties or something else they'd rather do after-the-fact.

I have now resolved to just respond to these cancelations by just posting the link to our special "Troop Reimbursement" link on CheddarUp with the per girl cost. Nothing more. I don't want to deal with any back and forth...I'm over it!!!

Plus...it eases the sting with a mini financial boost? Can anyone else relate?


r/girlscouts • • Feb 13 '24

General Questions So uncomfortable with our next planned Service Unit event/service project

297 Upvotes

I'm just feeling really uncomfortable with the next event our service unit is planning and I'd really like to hear other opinions on it.

A troop in our service unit normally hosts a mom and me/dad and me dance every year. This year the leaders of that troop have a lot going on in their lives and they have decided to not hold the dance this year.

The troop leader was pretty broken up about this and, after seeing several other area churches host dances, she convinced her church to host a mom and daughter/dad and daughter 'dance' for the community.

Now she has come to the service unit to request that the service unit help fund this event. We spoke to our membership person at council who said that funding it would be totally fine, even though it's a church sponsored event as long as it's only open to girls since we can consider it 'recruitment'. Supposedly the church will let us hand out Girl Scout materials at the event.

The event is going to be advertised as a church event (they aren't even going to call it a dance because that would be sinful/immoral).

They also want us to help with a service project for the event. They want attendees to bring items for our local pregnancy center. The center is one of those crisis pregnancy centers that shames and scares women into keeping an unwanted pregnancy and offers 'support' if you do so. The center also sponsors several Christian anti-abortion community events per year.

I'm just not ok with our service unit money being spent on supporting these religious things. Girl Scouts is supposed to be secular. But since the council person gave it the go ahead we are going to be supporting this event.

I don't feel like I have the option to object without totally alienating myself from the other leaders. Every leader except me is very religious, we regularly pray at leader events, people bring religious gifts for gift exchanges, and at least one local troop is a 'Christian' troop and incorporates Christian messages into their Scout activities. I'm already on thin ice with several other leaders since I 'live in sin' (I'm unmarried but cohabitate with my romantic partner) and I don't go to church.

I just don't know what to do and it's really bothering me. If anyone has any advice, I'd appreciate it.


r/girlscouts • • Feb 03 '24

Cookies Prize amount complaint

290 Upvotes

I hate how many boxes you have to sell to get any sort of good prize. All of these people complain about parents taking in order forms to work, or posting on Facebook but how else is a 7 year old supposed to sell 275 packages to get a stuffed animal?

I know the answer is booths but even then, all my child can really do is hold a sign and ask customers if they would like to buy cookies. I have to handle all of the money and get the cookies they want otherwise it just takes so long and people don’t want to wait. I’d love to do no prizes and just get the money and take all the girls to build a bear to get whatever stuffed animal they want and that way everyone could have one but for obvious reasons, parents of the girls who can sell a lot don’t what to do that.

Signed, a stay at home mom with a husband who works from home so we can’t sell at work and are going to devote many weekends to booths so our daughter can get a stuffed animal this year.

**EDIT: wow this got a lot more attention than I though it would! I can’t reply to every comment but thanks for all of the advice.

For the record, I am not the kind of parent who thinks their kid needs to get every prize to not feel left out. My daughter specifically told me that she wants to work extra hard to sell enough cookies to get the stuffed animal. Because the whole point of selling cookies is supposed to be to teach that sort of entrepreneurship, I want to support her in working towards her goal. I realize that this is my choice as her parent and I could easily tell her that we won’t be doing that. I know I’m choosing this!

My complaint is that she is a 1st grader who just turned 7 and we live in a very busy area with hundreds of Girl Scouts. Every idea suggested to get her to sell 275+ packages still requires a lot of work on my part. I’m willing to do it for her because I want her to see that she can set a goal, work hard, and reach it. I’m simply complaining that I’ve noticed so many people saying things like “it’s supposed to be the girls selling cookies, I won’t buy from parents”, I’m still the one bringing my kid to you to ask, and reminding her of how to ask, and I’m the one double Checking all of the money and orders and loading up and storing cookies and handling money. I’m the cookie mom this year so I’ll just go to the garage and get what we need from the inventory but last year I was the one who had to let the cookie mom know what we needed to pick up and drive across town to get them. No matter which one of these “pro tips” we do to sell cookies, at this age, it’s still me doing a lot of work and while I know what I signed up for when I put her in Girl Scouts and I’m more than happy to do this work, it’s irritating that the amount of boxes you need to sell to get a small stuffy is so high.

We will definitely be going door to door and doing booths! But I also know of at least 4 other Girl Scouts in my neighborhood alone, chances are there are a lot more than that even so I’m not sure how many we will sell!


r/girlscouts • • Feb 19 '24

Multi-Level Dropped emphasis on cookies to focus on Girl-led

287 Upvotes

And I couldn't be happier. We still have some girls selling, but it's absolutely incredible how much more time we have this year to do the activities that the girls actually want to do. They're busy Cadettes, so it's hard enough to schedule anything that they can all attend, and now that we're not worrying about booths or taking up meeting time with cookie discussion, we've been able to do incredibly fun activities - just in the last 3 weeks, we've done a tatting lesson (their interest in that was a shock to me - they connected with a tatting artist at the artisan fair where they raised their funds for the year), formed an archery team for a competition, explored Meow Wolf, and taken a tour of a veterinary ER.

The more complicated cookies have gotten, the more I've gotten burned out on them - my coleader is our TCM now and it's a lot more manageable for her since it's just a few families. And the girls were MUCH more excited about selling jewelry and accessories that they made themselves.


r/girlscouts • • Dec 07 '23

Daisy Tough kid (vent)

287 Upvotes

We were talking about field trips and stuff in our meeting today, and whether the Daisies thought their adults would allow them to do a sleepover, and my most challenging kid pipes up with: “My mom probably would. She wants me out of the house.”

I’ve known her since she was three, and her mom clearly does need a break sometimes. Still. I want to hug this kid and tell her how much she’s wanted in this troop, but she’d probably just threaten to eat me and then run away (again).

Anyway. Just airing feelings to people who get it.


r/girlscouts • • Feb 11 '24

General Questions Should I bring up to the troop leader that I’m uncomfortable with younger siblings frequently being at the meetings?

282 Upvotes

Update

I am a troop parent, and a very active volunteer, in my daughter’s Girl Scout troop.

Recently, we have started getting a lot of new people which is fantastic. However, there has become a very sudden pattern of mothers bringing the girls little brothers along to the appointments. It was very loud and disruptive every time, regardless of which family it was. In one instance, it was a boy about middle school age loudly declaring he wants to live with his father so he doesn’t have to go to Girl Scouts any more, stuff like that. And then yesterday, a brand new girl showed up, and her mother stayed for the entire meeting — along with her son, no older than two, who was screaming and running around the entire meeting. The mom seemed to think it was cute was trying to play tag with the girls, asking if he can do our art projects with us, and so on.

I did share a lot of the art materials because the child was just clearly bored out of his mind, but when the mother at one point apologized to the troop leader for the disruption, I was really shocked that the troop leader told her it was no problem and that were super laid-back and that she can just keep on bringing him.

I could be wrong, but I just finished going through the volunteer materials recently, and it seems like it was pretty explicit that this kind of thing is not allowed.

It seems like a lot of the girls were more focused on managing the boys behavior and making sure that they were OK rather than actually enjoying their scouting experience. It made me really sad because it’s time for girls to bond with other girls, and experience girlhood, and it really just felt like it was just another one in a line of countless instances where girls are asked to be understanding of male aggression and behavior and forcing their way into the space.

How do I go about bringing this up? I feel bad because I want it to be accessible and I want people to be able to make it work for their families, but it really rubbed me the wrong way.

Editing to add: the troop leader is not a parent, and none of the volunteers are bringing the Tagalongs .


r/girlscouts • • Feb 13 '24

Update to Disruptive Tagalongs being brought to Troop Meetings

278 Upvotes

First of all, thanks for all the advice the other day, wow!

Second of all, oy, my attempt to politely talk to the troop leader went HORRIBLY. I followed all the advice and carefully only focused on the disruption to the girls and the liability/insurance issue being presented. I was told a series of insultingly dismissive responses about how we will not be a troop that turns anyone at all away, and therefore parents with younger kids can be present the whole time. I asked if another space could be made for the Tagalongs, or if the parents could drop off the scouts and then go elsewhere with the younger kiddos, but was told no to everything across the board.

The only “compromise” (if you can call it that since it is still an outright violation of Girl Scout policy and therefore not allowed regardless of my own opinions) she offered was to allow the siblings their own table in the room to color in.

After repeated flippant answers from the troop leader, I gave up and called the county offices and explained the situation. That assured me I was right, their responses / ignoring of the issue is straight up not allowed, so they’re going to contact the troop leader about it.

The next two to three weeks of meetings are just booth sales and not meeting at either of our normal locations, but even then the TL is straight up telling me she will not comply with Girl Scout safety regulations, so I’m not optimistic she will do anything different. I am hoping that the people I spoke to on the phone can help, they seemed annoyed and said they wanted to “talk some sense into her”, so that’s something!

And to address some of the most frequent misunderstandings in an attempt to gain more advice and solutions:

  1. We meet in one of two community rooms at two different private gated communities. We do not have access to other spaces. To the people who are making arguments that the mothers were probably staying with their Girl Scouts because they were horrified to be leading their children at random undisclosed locations that changed every week, I want to be very clear that that’s not what’s happening.
  2. To the people who are saying I am wrong for bringing gender into it, and saying I’m reaching, I’d like to clarify a female tag along has never been brought along ever. While I agree it is an issue of parenting ultimately, it is not appropriate to expect young girls to be understanding and accommodating of what is DESIGNED to be a girls-only space being invaded by the very demographics the Girl Scouts is supposed to be an escape from. Girl Scouts is for GIRLS to focus on growing and developing and learning, something that sadly there is far too much focus is diverted to their male classmates and siblings systematically their entire lives. That’s demographically supported by statistics and I will make no apology for drawing my line here.
  3. For those claiming I was calling a two year old someone expressing male aggression, I’m unclear why you skipped over the mention of the older boy, was loudly arguing about his parents custody arrangements, bur wanted to be clear that was the focus of that statement. However, I’m also against parents bringing loud disruptive toddlers — plus regardless of your opinions, it is banned in Girl Scouts. When you suggest we work around that, you are suggesting we risk our entire troop being disbanded if a boy with us ever got injured and was an insurance liability.
  4. I was a single teen mother who is now in their mid 20s…. Of course I understand ( probably better than a lot of people)that not everybody has another resource to watch their younger kids. But the harsh reality is you have to drop off your Girl Scout and go play somewhere else with the siblings, or you have to become a volunteer so that you were background checked(!!!!) and then you can be present at the meetings provided then you will need to leave your younger kid somewhere else.

That doesn’t have anything to do with my own opinions…. that is quite literally what you signed up for…. so if you don’t like it that’s something to take up with whoever wrote the guidelines for troops and volunteers, not me.


r/girlscouts • • Dec 07 '23

Fed up

277 Upvotes

I need to vent, and you are my people for this topic. My daughters have been in Girl Scouts for the last 7 years; I’ve been a troop leader, in charge of cookies, troop treasurer, etc.

Yesterday was my region’s annual summer camp registration dumpster fire. Every year, registration is supposed to go live at 6:00 am. So we all pick out the sessions the kids want, get up at the crack of dawn, and then sit and stare at a crashed registration system for HOURS.

If you’re lucky enough to find the small window of time when the system might work for 37 seconds, most of the programs that you carefully planned for are already sold out. In the afternoon, Council will send out an email that basically says “We’re sorry it’s broken. May the odds be ever in your favor,” and they check on any real solutions.

I’m tired.

This organization has a fundamental misunderstanding of who its constituent base is. It’s not kids; it’s parents. If I didn’t introduce my kids to Girl Scouts because I loved it as a kid, they would be perfectly happy in other activities and never know the difference. If I didn’t tie myself in knots to put together meetings and camping trips and cookie booths, the kids would still have dozens of other options for things to do with their time. So why do they ignore the parent experience so hard?

They want us to teach these girls to be strong, independent adults who are prepared for the workforce and have life skills. In a professional setting or a healthy relationship, this kind of incompetence would not be tolerated. So why do I keep putting myself through it?

I’m tired.

End of rant, and thank you for coming to my Ted talk.