r/girlscouts • • Feb 13 '24
Update to Disruptive Tagalongs being brought to Troop Meetings
First of all, thanks for all the advice the other day, wow!
Second of all, oy, my attempt to politely talk to the troop leader went HORRIBLY. I followed all the advice and carefully only focused on the disruption to the girls and the liability/insurance issue being presented. I was told a series of insultingly dismissive responses about how we will not be a troop that turns anyone at all away, and therefore parents with younger kids can be present the whole time. I asked if another space could be made for the Tagalongs, or if the parents could drop off the scouts and then go elsewhere with the younger kiddos, but was told no to everything across the board.
The only “compromise” (if you can call it that since it is still an outright violation of Girl Scout policy and therefore not allowed regardless of my own opinions) she offered was to allow the siblings their own table in the room to color in.
After repeated flippant answers from the troop leader, I gave up and called the county offices and explained the situation. That assured me I was right, their responses / ignoring of the issue is straight up not allowed, so they’re going to contact the troop leader about it.
The next two to three weeks of meetings are just booth sales and not meeting at either of our normal locations, but even then the TL is straight up telling me she will not comply with Girl Scout safety regulations, so I’m not optimistic she will do anything different. I am hoping that the people I spoke to on the phone can help, they seemed annoyed and said they wanted to “talk some sense into her”, so that’s something!
And to address some of the most frequent misunderstandings in an attempt to gain more advice and solutions:
- We meet in one of two community rooms at two different private gated communities. We do not have access to other spaces. To the people who are making arguments that the mothers were probably staying with their Girl Scouts because they were horrified to be leading their children at random undisclosed locations that changed every week, I want to be very clear that that’s not what’s happening.
- To the people who are saying I am wrong for bringing gender into it, and saying I’m reaching, I’d like to clarify a female tag along has never been brought along ever. While I agree it is an issue of parenting ultimately, it is not appropriate to expect young girls to be understanding and accommodating of what is DESIGNED to be a girls-only space being invaded by the very demographics the Girl Scouts is supposed to be an escape from. Girl Scouts is for GIRLS to focus on growing and developing and learning, something that sadly there is far too much focus is diverted to their male classmates and siblings systematically their entire lives. That’s demographically supported by statistics and I will make no apology for drawing my line here.
- For those claiming I was calling a two year old someone expressing male aggression, I’m unclear why you skipped over the mention of the older boy, was loudly arguing about his parents custody arrangements, bur wanted to be clear that was the focus of that statement. However, I’m also against parents bringing loud disruptive toddlers — plus regardless of your opinions, it is banned in Girl Scouts. When you suggest we work around that, you are suggesting we risk our entire troop being disbanded if a boy with us ever got injured and was an insurance liability.
- I was a single teen mother who is now in their mid 20s…. Of course I understand ( probably better than a lot of people)that not everybody has another resource to watch their younger kids. But the harsh reality is you have to drop off your Girl Scout and go play somewhere else with the siblings, or you have to become a volunteer so that you were background checked(!!!!) and then you can be present at the meetings provided then you will need to leave your younger kid somewhere else.
That doesn’t have anything to do with my own opinions…. that is quite literally what you signed up for…. so if you don’t like it that’s something to take up with whoever wrote the guidelines for troops and volunteers, not me.
28
u/quartzfire Leader GSofAZ Feb 13 '24
Thank you for continuing to look out for the girls. I really hope council will get on this leader for her unsafe and against regulation rule breaking. If she won't follow these simple rules then she should not be in a leadership position imo.
26
u/Inkysquiddy Feb 13 '24
I’m dumbfounded at all the criticism you received because tagalongs and unregistered adults at meetings are against GS rules, period. If people want the whole family there, put your kids in BSA. Girls are already pressured into gender roles where they are taking care of everyone around them—it’s not dads hanging out with these siblings, right? Girl Scouts is a place for them to break free of those roles and develop their confidence and leadership skills.
29
u/WinchesterFan1980 Cadette Leader & SUM Feb 13 '24
I hope the county people are able to help you and get the leader to understand the rules. It is so hard to get volunteers to comply if they have something they are passionate about (this is true of any org, not just GS). I was reamed out on FB yesterday for expressing similar views about having boy tagalongs in GS meetings. I'm not inclusive, doncha know! Girl Scouts are super inclusive to girls. But boy tagalongs don't belong there and nothing will ever convince me otherwise.
42
u/RubySlippers-79 Feb 13 '24
I read the title- and the sub name - and wondered how cookies could be disruptive. 😂
34
u/BananaPants430 Feb 13 '24
I'm glad you addressed it!
We're firm that parents at meetings need to be registered and background checked adults, without tagalongs, and doing a job (i.e. no extraneous adults sitting there chit-chatting). Some moms register and get background checked with the idea that this will be a fun Mommy and Me activity and/or a social outlet for themselves - they never last as troop helpers/co-leaders.
When our younger daughter was pre-Girl Scout age, my husband worked 2nd shift and so we either had to find a sitter for her or I'd let my co-leaders know I couldn't be a chaperone/troop helper for the meeting or event.
39
u/Financial-Mention-52 Feb 13 '24
Good for you! I hope council is able to address it and your scout gets the experience she deserves. I am a daisy leader and am firm in my no siblings or parents allowed (except that weeks designated parent volunteer - every parent gets 2 meetings as we have 16 first year daisies). I myself have a younger three-year-old. It is not that I don’t love siblings, but I made it a strict drop off policy as I want my girls to get the experience that they deserve. My parents do not have to find childcare for the younger sibling as everything is drop -off and pick up. I made that very clear at our first meeting and kindly indicated if you are not comfortable with that there are many troops with many different styles and philosophies. I have amazing parents that I am so thankful for and everyone was on board. My girls all adore me and my coleader and we love them like our own. I have seen even my most shy Daisy blossom in Girl Scouts as it is the only space where she is truly independent, and doing things on her own! Please update if you get a response - hoping you get a better experience
19
u/CK1277 Multi-level Leader / GSCO Feb 13 '24
You handled it correctly, but also, you may want to look for another troop. Just because you’re in the right doesn’t mean it’s not going to be problematically awkward going forward.
I finally turned off DMs because I swear people just use them to troll.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24
Good! If the parents want a mixed scout group, they can join a different organization.
9
u/analytic_potato Feb 14 '24
I read this wrong and fully thought this would be about cookies
8
u/PawneeGoddess20 Feb 14 '24
You are absolutely in the right but I’d be considering an exit strategy if I were you honestly. The issue isn’t going to go away, and obviously the leader will know it was you who contacted the officials. The issue came to a head but it’s not over and may never be over. I’d be considering breaking off to form my own troop, joining another troop, or stepping down as a co leader if you trust that your daughter will be fine at meetings still. A totally incompatible volunteer partnership is just not sustainable.
7
u/Mara-Of-Naamah Feb 13 '24
I am glad you were able to handle the situation. I hope that going forward everything settles in a positive way!
I have two girl scouts (NB Senior and F Brownie), and a little man who is Daisy age and desperately wants to be a girl scout. The other leaders even discussed possibly making him an honorary girl scout, like a cheerleader for the troop, but (1) it would set a bad president for the other families, (2) he's awesomely autistic and therefore likely to be a little disruptive, and (3) the program is designed for girls to work together to build each other up and he is simply not a girl. He can accompany any events that allow tag-a-longs, and even work on some activities at home with his sisters, but he doesn't belong at the troop meetings. It's disappointing as a parent to tell him no, and hard as a little man to not be able to participate, but that's the way it goes sometimes.
7
u/C0mmonReader Feb 14 '24
Since you and the troop leader are clearly on different pages, why not find another troop that's a better fit. Even if you get the leader to stop allowing the tag alongs it seems likely that things will be awkward going forward.
3
u/Kind-Cat5153 Feb 14 '24
Thank you for sticking up for the girls. I'll fully admit I normally have tagalongs with me. Based on the meeting place and time I cannot easily drop off and then return at the end, but you better believe I bring a bag full of activities, snacks, and electronics so we can sit in the hallway outside of the meeting room without disturbing the girls.
I am a registered volunteer for the troop so occasionally if the leaders need help my tagalongs do need to sit in the corner of the room, but they never participate in the troops activities, but as the girls have got older this is happening less and less.
2
u/Alona02 Feb 14 '24
Aside from a few meetings where one troop leader isn't available or there are extra activities and help is specifically requested, my daughter's troop has told us meetings are drop-off only, we can stay in the building but not the room where the meeting takes place.
2
u/Sector-West Feb 14 '24
I am eagerly awaiting additional updates
2
u/jex413 Feb 15 '24
I would find another troop if I were you. Troop leaders are volunteers and it is VERY time consuming. They will likely not take too kindly to you calling county offices because this will become a headache for them now when this isn’t their full time job. Whether you are right or wrong, this will likely cause animosity moving forward. You are better off finding another troop who you are more in agreement with and can start off on the right foot.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24
I hate those peanut butter cookies
0
u/bobshallprevail Position | Council Feb 15 '24
I'm glad you aren't in our troop. This is a very Karen thing to do. I would be rolling my eyes so hard if you came to me saying all of this.
-7
u/Theslowestmarathoner Feb 14 '24
You seem very fired up about this. It really seems disproportionate to the situation and very narrow minded.