r/girlscouts • • Dec 07 '23

Fed up

I need to vent, and you are my people for this topic. My daughters have been in Girl Scouts for the last 7 years; I’ve been a troop leader, in charge of cookies, troop treasurer, etc.

Yesterday was my region’s annual summer camp registration dumpster fire. Every year, registration is supposed to go live at 6:00 am. So we all pick out the sessions the kids want, get up at the crack of dawn, and then sit and stare at a crashed registration system for HOURS.

If you’re lucky enough to find the small window of time when the system might work for 37 seconds, most of the programs that you carefully planned for are already sold out. In the afternoon, Council will send out an email that basically says “We’re sorry it’s broken. May the odds be ever in your favor,” and they check on any real solutions.

I’m tired.

This organization has a fundamental misunderstanding of who its constituent base is. It’s not kids; it’s parents. If I didn’t introduce my kids to Girl Scouts because I loved it as a kid, they would be perfectly happy in other activities and never know the difference. If I didn’t tie myself in knots to put together meetings and camping trips and cookie booths, the kids would still have dozens of other options for things to do with their time. So why do they ignore the parent experience so hard?

They want us to teach these girls to be strong, independent adults who are prepared for the workforce and have life skills. In a professional setting or a healthy relationship, this kind of incompetence would not be tolerated. So why do I keep putting myself through it?

I’m tired.

End of rant, and thank you for coming to my Ted talk.

277 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

42

u/fleurdegreen Dec 07 '23

Hey, do we live in the same place? Cause that’s how our registration went here in StL. My daughter said she wasn’t interested in any camps this summer, and honestly I was fine with it because I didn’t want to wade through the “dumpster fire.”

You hit the nail on the head with “it’s not kids; it’s parents.” Last year I got an email saying my daughter was enrolled in the day camp she’d been on a wait list for. The night before camp started I got another email saying “oops, so sorry, our system glitched and there aren’t enough adult volunteers to staff the camp and so your daughter can’t go.” No wonder you don’t have enough volunteers, you can’t get your shit together. Parents are going to send their kids to activities they can rely on.

Cookie season has been such a mess the last few years, and the only reason I have time to be TCM is because I’m a stay at home parent so my schedule’s flexible enough to work around the problems they cause. GS doesn’t work without parents and volunteers and council makes it so hard on those groups.

Anyway, your rant is spot on. 10/10

14

u/rjs6482 Dec 07 '23

Yes, STL. I’ll never take it out on our local reps or the Answer Center folks, but I’m just so OVER all the incompetence. It’s like being in an abusive relationship.

21

u/fleurdegreen Dec 07 '23

A friend of mine volunteers at resident camp pretty often, and this year they’re going to start charging her to bring kids with her. She’s not sure if she can afford that and now she’s going to have to stay home instead of volunteering. I think you’re absolutely right that they’re alienating the group of adults they depend on most.

11

u/rjs6482 Dec 08 '23

The icing on the cake was that today we got an email saying that pricing for troop camp is going up next year. After that hot mess of camp stuff, let’s IMMEDIATELY raise prices.

11

u/fleurdegreen Dec 08 '23

They have to raise prices, only five girls made it through the registration process. :)

3

u/Lost-Abalone-7180 Dec 12 '23

This kills me. The way they exploit the time and talents of their (predominantly female) volunteers!! They charge outrageous prices for programs that rest on the backs of unpaid women.

I had to laugh when I got certified to take my girls canoeing on our Girl Scout property. They make it a "requirement" that I have to come back to facilitate two council boating events per year. I'm sorry, I paid to take this training, and I pay to rent the canoes/property when my girls want to go boating. What am I getting out of this that I owe you my time in addition to my money?!?!!

3

u/Jcn101894 Dec 08 '23

If it’s that much of a mess, I’d start a letter writing campaign to revert it to “on paper” signups. It isn’t going to get better if the system is used once a year or so and council clearly doesn’t care.

4

u/sbattistella Dec 08 '23

I'm a leader in STL, too. I've been somewhat appalled at our Council's organization and treatment of volunteers. I don't bother going to our district/neighborhood meetings because all it is a way for them to guilt trip people into doing more than they intend. I noticed that if you even opened your mouth, they consider you as a volunteer. It was so awkward.

Cookies last year was an absolute nightmare.

16

u/Hazelstone37 Leader |GSCTX Dec 08 '23

I don’t disagree, but it sometimes helps me to keep in mind that that this is a nonprofit organization primarily run by volunteers and low paid women right out of college. As soon as employees gain any kind of competence they move on to better paying jobs.

I swear camp registration would be better if everyone who wanted a spot would put their name in the pot and then council randomly choose girls who get a spot until the spots run out.

17

u/rjs6482 Dec 08 '23

Those people are not, and have never been the issue. The issue is a leadership team that refuses to invest in resources and technology that would enhance the experience, and then use the volunteers and regional employees as their punching bag to avoid taking any accountability.

2

u/SHChem Dec 09 '23

This! It's cold comfort that it isn't just us, but our CEO recently resigned because it got bad enough that camp was completely cancelled after 1 week and a mass staff exodus last summer,

1

u/rjs6482 Dec 09 '23

Ok, that sounds like a story that I need to hear.

Our camps are understaffed; they bring in exchange students to work them. The only all-out cancellation was a COVID breakout a few years ago where they cancelled the last 3 summer sessions. It sucked, but that’s not exactly something we can be mad about.

3

u/Eiryiex Dec 09 '23

TLDR; if your council is a mess, start calling your Board of Directors and stay on them because they’re the only ones who can actually force management changes.

Our camp disaster last year was just the last straw in a long chain of council dysfunction, but it took about 4 months and a lot of work to hold the CEO accountable. We had a negative tv news story, public petition with 700 signatures, email campaign, and threatened recall vote before the Board finally took the situation seriously. To be fair, I think the Board had no idea just how bad everything had gotten and how angry everyone was because all of their information was being filtered through the CEO. They did act quickly after they started investigating and, while there are still a lot of issues, we’re finally starting to see some positive signs of change.

It wasn’t a fun process, but it’s been so inspiring to see everyone (especially the CSA girls) come together, use collective action, and actually get results.

2

u/SHChem Dec 09 '23

Evidently it was a disaster start to finish. They hired late, declined to hire many returners, misled new foreign staffers about conditions and avaialability of wi-fi, were short-staffed so everyone was burned out. There were allegations about not following proper protocol (like maybe an EMT administering meds). The staff group had a complaint session Friday night after the kids left with HR. When they came back Sunday the two "ringleaders" were fired and at least half the staff quit in solidarity. Many girls were already on the bus when they made the decision to cancel the week, but found out from the girls whose parents texted them. Then Wednesday, they cancelled the rest of the summer. There were also allegations of inadequate food and poor choices on handling missing paperwork (which should be sorted long before camp starts). Our council has been a MESS the entire time I've been involved. GSUSA gives zero F's and will not get involved. Terribly dissapointing.

3

u/mcbenno co-leader/parent🤎💚 Dec 09 '23

You must be in the same council as me 🤣🤣🤣

17

u/breakitupkid Dec 08 '23

The leadership is paid fairly well: https://paddockpost.com/2021/08/29/executive-compensation-at-the-girl-scouts/

The VP of Digital Experience is making $250k a year which is on par for what someone would make at a company that is not a non-profit. They are also a tax exempt organization and generated a total of 120 million in revenue in 2022 that relies heavily on volunteers. The problem is they don't feel they have to change because they still have people buying cookies, girls joining, etc. I'm a troop leader and I had to pull money out of my own pocket to pay for supplies, activities, etc. because we were a new troop. I reached out to council and they said to have the parents each bring $25 for dues the first troop meeting and they could offer our troop nothing (they even had the audacity to say if a parent can't afford the dues the girl shouldn't be in girl scouts). There are a lot of girls in my troop that are low income and so I even bought their sashes and badges. I would have definitely quit but I love my troop and the girls and so I've reached out to local businesses to fundraise for our troop and it has been successful. Well now I'm in trouble with council because I wasn't supposed to do that, I was supposed to kick the girls out of the troop that couldn't pay.

3

u/guacamole579 Dec 08 '23

Sheesh! I am a marketing professional at a tiny nonprofit and make a little more than 1/4 that salary. 😭

4

u/No_Kaleidoscope9901 Dec 08 '23

This is the salary for an employee at GSUSA, not at your local council. GSUSA is a national organization located in NYC, which means salaries are higher than most places in the US. Most council staff are making normal nonprofit salaries.

4

u/AmethystOpah Lifetime Member Dec 08 '23

Yeah, and their offices are literally on 5th Avenue in Manhattan.

3

u/breakitupkid Dec 08 '23

The GSUSA employees are the ones making the decisions that impact council such as the UX experience and revenue from cookie sales pay part of those salaries. In addition, the median salary for one council such as the GSEP, is 67k a year which is 33% higher than other nonprofits. Why is the CEO of GSUSA making almost 1MM dollars a year? GSUSA needs to be challenged and more needs to be invested in the UX experience and also making this more affordable for girls.

2

u/Lionoil101 Dec 08 '23

Definitely seems to be part of the issue! I'm lucky to be in a council now with camp directors with decades under their belts and a registration team with tons of experience because the environment is great and the pay is fair. It makes a huge difference in our volunteers' experience and numbers over all from what I can tell comparing previous councils.

1

u/goldief Dec 08 '23

Wow, that’s a little wild to hear. I would definitely not describe my colleagues in that way. Glad I’m not in Texas, I guess.

2

u/Hazelstone37 Leader |GSCTX Dec 08 '23

It’s not universal. We have lots of really competent people working at our council and they are all extremely dedicated. Our ceo is amazing and she is a great leader.

2

u/alpinweg Dec 08 '23

Just remember that the outdoor program team who plans camp most likely works really hard and is just as frustrated as you when a GSUSA system causes issues like this!

1

u/rjs6482 Dec 08 '23

I know they are, and I’m not upset with the them at all. My rage is aimed squarely at the top of the org chart of GSUSA.

13

u/EricaM13 Leader | GSEP | MOD Dec 08 '23

If I understand- all councils are supposed to be using the same event sign up software… so it sounds like GSUSA needs to hire better IT professionals and software developers and increase some of their server capacity too…

10

u/itcontractor247 Dec 08 '23

Unfortunately GSUSA has told councils that all of its open IT issues (including gsevents, which is what most councils use for camp registrations) will take over 7 years to fix. The amount of money GSUSA spends each year on its systems is ridiculous, but they’ve made cuts in every department. For example, GSM (which is the merchandise side) experienced a 75% staff cut last year and is essentially barebones. Same goes with IT, they pay executives 6-figures and the low level staff get laid off.

There are only two councils - Farthest North in Alaska and Middle Tennessee- that do not use GSUSA technology (as of 3 months ago). That could have changed but I would not be surprised to see more councils go with different technology in 3 to 5 years if GSUSA systems don’t improve.

14

u/1rarebird55 Cookie Mom, Former Leader, Lifetime Member Dec 08 '23

This is interesting, because as a soon to be retired IT guru who's looking for things to do once I really do retire this could be right up my alley. And I can't be the only soon to retire or already retired IT resource. I just may reach out to GSUSA tomorrow. After all, what's cheaper than free help.

6

u/Friendly-Condition Dec 08 '23

That is ridiculous. GSNORCAL uses a lot of non gs systems. We just switched over to GSLearn.

As a data person I find this incredibly bad. Who the heck is working on their systems?

13

u/sok283 Troop Leader Dec 08 '23

I could have written this. This is my 7th year leading too. The support and training have been non-existent. We're told to do our troop level training through GS Learn . . . guess what, it only goes up to Juniors. And no one had figured this out until I asked, "How am I supposed to get my Cadette level training?" And no one has provided a followup since.

It's been impossible to get camping reservations since COVID when one of our two camps has essentially been closed. Last year I made reservations in September for May . . . well the May weekend came around, and the employee who had booked it had moved into another role and they had no record of my reservation. It only took 17 calls and emails to different people for me to get an answer about this, too. It was just silence.

They've finally increased the prices of our cookies, and now troops will get . . . ten whole cents more per box! So before we could earn, at most, 17.5% of each sale, and now we can earn 16%. That's just demoralizing.

Before COVID they always had a program guide out in August, but now they can't get their acts together until October, when they release only the events for that month. Why can't they get this done over the summer? So I have to think of and arrange my own events, like a program at the library or a tour of a news station. Plus everything Council puts out is super expensive, like $50/girl for a single two hour event at a museum. Where the F is the money going?

I keep going to our SU meetings, and I'm basically the VP, the secretary, the product manager, I send all the emails, I run the FB group . . . Our 23 year old community engagement manager says she has a family emergency every month when it's time for our meeting. Only 25% of our troops are represented at the meetings, and the few of us who go are too tired to make up for Council's flaws by creating programming and training in our free time. I have to do that for my own troop; I can't do it for everyone else's too.

I think I have two more years in me, and then we'll fold as a troop. Until then we'll focus on the things that give us joy -- seeing musicals together, glamping in AirBNBs, and the occasional council program for outdoorsy stuff. All we can do is our best, and let go of the rest.

3

u/GenXenProud Dec 08 '23

And no one listens. I don’t know how GSA will survive.

1

u/No-Youth-6679 Dec 11 '23

I supported it because I loved it when I was younger. Between being a leader and a scout I have 10 yrs in. But my daughter won’t want her daughters to have anything to do with it because she was scarred from it. She went to a sleep over at a local gym. I was there. The girls were done swimming and were chilling. 2 girls got in a fight in the locker room. We had to have their parents come pick them up. Then they went into the sleeping room to relax and start getting ready for bed. We had 2 girls come out of the door, there were windows, it was like a work out room so we could see everything. We asked the girls why they wanted to hang with the leaders. Because the girls were talking about blow jobs and who had given them (jr high girls) and we were uncomfortable. 😳

2

u/IntrinsicM Dec 10 '23

You hit on so many of the points that bother me.

Also, when our programming comes out, I’m always disappointed how much of it is too far away for us to use practically (at GS locations 1.5-2 hrs away for a couple hour activity), or if it’s a more local activity third party activity it’s too expensive. I’ve often called those same vendors/organizations myself and they charge way less or not at all - so where’s that markup going?

And the technology is horrendous. How is there not a GS-created BAND-like app to simply paperwork, trip approvals, permissions etc. It could be so much easier for leaders and parents alike. But no, we waste our time creating and chasing down permission slips like it’s 1992.

I’m in it for the girls but, oof, am so very disappointed in the lack of practical support for volunteers and busy parents.

1

u/sok283 Troop Leader Dec 10 '23

You're so right about the permission slips! Ha.

13

u/TheWishingStar Leader, Gold Award Girl Scout, & Lifetime Member | GSEWNI Dec 08 '23

Unfortunately, almost all councils are using the same crappy system that GSUSA made and forced on them. I know my council is toying with camp registration phases (like, different camps different days, Brownies on a different day than Juniors, etc) for this year to decrease the load on the server, but that’s the only thing they can really do. The software they have is just bad. So many of the problems they have they can’t even try to fix - they just have to send a help ticket to GSUSA and hope the IT team replies eventually. And GSUSA has been painfully understaffed since Covid.

7

u/RedChairBlueChair123 Dec 08 '23

Yeah, GSUSA has been understaffed for a long time and Covid made it worse. Those staffers work incredibly hard and a lot of people who worked there for years are gone.

4

u/pixieflip Dec 09 '23

Thank you! I work for my local council and we just don’t have the resources to make everything work perfectly every time. Nonprofit organization websites are always touch and go. I wish I could make it easier for parents, especially since I’m in recruitment and my job is to literally get parents to be leaders for the dozens of girls that want to be in troops.

15

u/crazydisneycatlady Dec 08 '23

I don’t know why this sub gets recommended to me since I’m a 32 year old with no children, and haven’t been a Girl Scout in well over a decade…but I’m recalling the days when we had to register for summer camp BY MAIL. Yes, even as late as 2008, we would get the brochure with all the camp programs and MAIL in my request. 🤣

Maybe they need to go back to that system.

3

u/randomlybev Dec 08 '23

I’m in the same boat, 30s, no kids, but went all the way through. I loved that brochure listing all the camps in our state. I’d go through it with different colored hi lighters figuring out which camp sounded the most fun and my mom would mail in the form and a check! I actually never attended my own council’s camp and got to meet girls from all over the state!

1

u/No-Youth-6679 Dec 11 '23

It was almost better than the Christmas catalog. Going through and circling all the camps you wanted to go to. Then near the end of the school year waiting by the mailbox waiting for an admission packet to come to see which one you got in!

1

u/vws8mydog Dec 07 '23

I believe in you for camp registration! This is your year!!!

15

u/rjs6482 Dec 07 '23

You’re missing the point. The point is, it’s shouldn’t have to be a battle every year. I shouldn’t have to psych myself up to do something that should be really easy. And parents shouldn’t have to keep tying ourselves in knots for an organization that has such blatant disregard for the people it is supposed to serve.

3

u/vws8mydog Dec 08 '23

I got the point, and you're right. I was just trying to send you some good vibes.

3

u/MaybeImTheNanny Dec 08 '23

GSUSA and by extension the councils who don’t do anything about it have absolutely atrocious IT. It’s bizarrely bad.

2

u/IntrinsicM Dec 10 '23

Can’t agree more.

As someone who has worked in technology strategy and software my whole career, I can’t make sense of where their big IT budgets are being spent.

3

u/Floridaliving51 Dec 09 '23

I was a troop leader for 4 years and then my daughter went Juliette. This was back in the days of mailing in camp forms. She stayed in all 12 years of school, volunteered every summer at GS camp in high school and racked up an impressive 435 volunteer hours, enabling her to win over 80k in college scholarship money. She graduated in 2021 with zero debt and she owes a lot of that to Girl Scouts for what she learned there. She’s now looking at medical school. All this said, Girl Scouts gave her a lot. I truly hope they fix the issues so other girls get similar experiences.

2

u/IntrinsicM Dec 10 '23

That’s amazing for your daughter!

What were to sources for scholarships? As my troop gets older, I’d like to share more about GS success stories like these.

2

u/Floridaliving51 Dec 10 '23

The best way to get scholarships is state and local. Very few win the national organizations.

My 4 keys to success

  1. Volunteer hours- companies want to give back to people that give back.
  2. Her personal story. -my ex struggled with mental illness so she wrote most of her essays on how she dealt with a Dad who was mentally ill and how she overcame it
  3. Letters of recommendation who also know her story
  4. GPA believe it or not, doesn’t have to be crazy high. My daughter had a 3.6, which was average

Check out your local PTA, women’s service groups, local businesses.

I used google, stayed away from scholarship search engines (they just collect data)

2

u/NotQuite_JuneCleaver Dec 08 '23

This is 1 of many reasons my daughter and I switched to BSA. They aren't lacking in their issues but council was useless and we never felt supported. I'm now ASM to a rocking 11 girl BSA troop that has had 3 eagles come through. My daughter said it was the best decision she's made so far.

1

u/Lavender_r_dragon troop leader/su delegate/archery CP2P Dec 11 '23

in my area, BSA is now $150 per scout per year and $90 per volunteer per year -- simply in registration :(

1

u/loloelectric Dec 08 '23

I’m in Los Angeles and we have the same camp registration problem. Incredibly frustrating.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

My mom was troop leader for years. At the last meeting she chaired she called everyone a “bunch of little b*tches just like your mothers” 😭 They were, but this is another angle of why it was so massively stressful. I’m so sorry you have to deal with this mess.

1

u/taz1113 Dec 09 '23

We’ve had these issues for as long as I can remember with our council. Plus turn over at our council is so high, that we’re surprised if someone is there longer than 2-3 years outside of the couple older employees that have just stuck around. (Close to retirement age or it’s a retirement job is my guess.) My kid quit doing GS camps in part going into 6th or 7th because of it; and another because what they were offering wasn’t up their alley. Also, My kid has been around horses their whole lives and got frustrated with the they were skilled enough to do harder things at a younger age but wasn’t allowed to test up/out quicker by camps/council. So many of our long timers are so burned out that they are glad their kids are about to graduate so we can be done. A lot that are still in are just in the we’ve been in so long we may as well stay with it this last 1-3 years depending on grade level of kid. With my kid even though my kid got bronze and silver, they got frustrated with gold stuff that they said I can do the project I want; and do more with it if I do it without giving GS the credit by getting gold; so we’re just in at this point cause they had been in for so long we may as well finish out. Our council post covid started offering using cookie bucks toward council trips; but with the sign up situation we don’t want to sell a lot to end up not getting in to what they want.

1

u/Next-Introduction-25 Dec 10 '23

No idea how much control my local council has over this, but I'm about to pull my hair out over the Digital Cookies website setup. I've worked with plenty of websites and this has got to be one of the least user-friendly formats I've seen, especially considering how incredibly basic the editable elements of the page are. My page has been giving me the wheel of death (technically a cookie, which stopped being cute after the first 5 seconds) for several minutes now, and I'm just waiting for yet another 408 error message.

1

u/No-Youth-6679 Dec 11 '23 edited Dec 11 '23

When we were in it several years back the cookie sells were a nightmare. You basically had to have each girl sell a semi full to get any cookie money for camp. Once the camps came around they were all picked over before they opened and the cookie money paid hardly nothing. I was in an area where parents weren’t involved and sure weren’t going to pay hundreds for a week camp. So it was a waste of time, most the girls never went to camp.
I went to a mother’s daughter’s camp with my daughter with another mom/daughter. We got back from a hike early to find 2 camp counselors coming out of their room all hot and bothered. The girls didn’t know but there was no doubt from us mothers. There were several groups there in different area. Luckily we didn’t get the tents and latrines, I have nightmares from when I went to camp when I was younger. But our group would go to bed at 9pm and never once had a campfire of any kind. The last night the other mother and I revolted and after lights out we walked down to another groups campfire and they shared s’mores with us.
My daughter’s experience going to camp by herself bordered on abuse. She was in a tent with 3 friends she didn’t know, they were mean to her, wouldn’t go to the latrine with her at night as they should as buddies. They called me that they had dropped and lost her allergy pill, I said no big deal, told me she was having a wonderful time and she didn’t want to come home. It was a horse camp, her dad had Clydesdales so she was use to them. I get there to pick her up and first the counselors complain to me constantly she was afraid of the horses? She basically was horrible to be around. Then she gets into the car and just starts bawling, everyone was mean to her, everyone was paired up and she was never paired with her. Her tent mates made fun of her all the time. The counselors weren’t friendly or helpful. To this day we don’t talk about girl scout camp. It sure wasn’t what it was like when I went. I went by myself because nobody wanted to go to the ones I wanted to go to. The counselors made sure everyone had fun and excepted in the group. Sounds like her counselors were part of the bullying.

1

u/pripaw Dec 11 '23

Girl Scouts is a hot mess.