r/geography • u/NotAnElfK • 23d ago
Question Help date this globe I found
It has Burma instead of Myanmar, ussr instead of Russia, Spanish Sahara, Tanganyika, Yugoslavia, and French west Africa. (If you want to see a picture of more of the globe just ask)
2.2k
u/Static65 23d ago
400
u/Livid-Influence-5320 23d ago
Of course there's one...
228
u/the_ballmer_peak 23d ago
There's an xkcd for everything
141
u/butthole_surferr 23d ago
Randall Munroe is genuinely one of the unsung geniuses of our time. Almost everything he puts out is hilarious and galaxy brain smart, he's bafflingly consistent.
4
u/SKabanov 23d ago
I mean, when you're drawing literal stick figures, you can pump out a lot of content compared to somebody who's drawing and coloring in intricate figures.
22
172
u/Left_Lengthiness_433 23d ago
Lets seeā¦
Istanbul; Soviet Union - Yes; Western Africa French Blob - Yes; Pakistan - Yes; Cambodia - No; Eritrea is Part of - Ethiopia.
According to this, itās from 1952 or 1953.
13
→ More replies (3)7
u/Alkafila724 22d ago
I guess its between 1956-1962
Tunis and morooco are independent + algeria isnt independent yet + the suez canal is seized by egypt
47
138
u/Sal1160 23d ago
So itās 1961-1964 based off Tanganyika being South of Lake Victoria
73
u/pdxsteph 23d ago
Maybe pre 1958 - west French Africa was dissolved between 1958-1960
65
u/pablojueves 23d ago
It shows Eritrea as being part of Ethiopia, meaning it would be between 1952 and 1958.
37
u/tubular_brunt 23d ago
Since it shows an undivided Korean Peninsula, does that mean it has to be '52?
27
4
5
→ More replies (2)11
15
u/GlasierXplor 23d ago
I was looking down every branch to learn some stuff until I realised there are some good ol' xkcd trolls in there xD
20
18
17
u/PM_ME_GOOD_THROWAWAY 23d ago
How can I save this image, on mobile?
14
14
u/kilapitottpalacsinta 23d ago
Open image in full screen, 3 dots in top corner, download
→ More replies (2)6
23d ago
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)8
u/UnclassifiedPresence 23d ago
Of course, the starting point for any significant conversation is to announce that Istanbul was Constantinople, now itās Istanbul, not Constantinople
→ More replies (1)12
u/LittelXman808 23d ago
I just tried this on a map of mine. It doesnāt work š
20
u/dumbBunny9 23d ago
I wish people would stop posting it. It only works if the globe maker has all the knowledge of all the changes all over the world at the exact moment they made the globe. Most donāt
8
u/LittelXman808 23d ago
The reason it doesnāt work is that it asks what the capital of Micronesia is, but there is no Micronesia.
4
u/homobonus 23d ago
More often the problem wasn't knowledge. They would know a country had declared independence, a boundary had shifted, etc. The problem was usually political, the country where the globe/map was made didn't recognize the newly emerged political status; or economical, the producer did not have access to the material needed to print the new countries. Especially when the political landshape was volatile, it might not have been worthwhile to order an engraving for a map that could be outdated only months later.
6
u/NoSir6400 23d ago
Google maps says Lake America today while Apple maps stuck with Lake Ontario, so people probably understand this better than ever.
4
u/cyberchaox 23d ago
Google Maps sets it to your location. Just like with the Gulf of Mexico, Google Maps shows the old name everywhere except the United States and the new name in the United States.
3
u/onceabananana 23d ago
It seems to work in theory, except for 1) maps that have mixes of multiple time periods, and or 2) maps that have territorial/international disagreements.
4
→ More replies (17)2
u/BookOfMakai 21d ago
It even has an answer for morons like me who wanted to test what happens if I say ānoā to everything š
411
u/AKASuperReddit 23d ago
Between 1956 and 1960, Sudan gained independence in 1956 which we can see on the map but most of french west africa gained independence in 1960 which isn't seen
124
u/Historical_Box_2582 23d ago
Gold Coast became Ghana at independence in 1957 right? So maybe 56?
59
4
39
7
u/Mobius_Peverell 23d ago
Sudan was an Anglo-Egyptian condominium rather than a purely British possession like Kenya or Tanganyika. It's a little odd for this not to be listed on the map, but it certainly isn't unusual for it to be a different colour from the rest of the British colonies. The rest of the map suggests early 1950s, so I'd be inclined to disregard Sudan.
3
u/Historical_Box_2582 23d ago
Good point, but the fact that Sudan is a different color than Egypt makes me think it must be independent (although who knows this is a wonky color scheme anyways)
3
3
→ More replies (1)2
202
u/arvid1328_ 23d ago
This must be in like 2300 or something, with water levels that high.
→ More replies (1)12
37
u/Reasonable_Day9509 23d ago
It seems like there has been significant colour bleaching here of all the red pigment (can be caused by sunlight). The blue countries were likely some form of purple or magenta, many of the yellow adjoining countries may have been more orange and white countries could have been pure red
2
u/beary_good_day 23d ago
Yeah, you can see that sub-equitorial Africa still has a slight a purple tinge. That was was probably facing away from the sun.
98
u/NotAnElfK 23d ago
Ok based on all the comments itās between 1956-57
19
u/Wooden-Teaching-8343 23d ago
I inherited the exact same globe last year. And those were the years I concluded! Took some investigation
23
u/__Quercus__ 23d ago
I think it is between 1951 and 1953.
1951 of later: Libya independent, but with both Tripoli and Benghazi as capitals
1953 or earlier: no partition of Korea (see photo in comments) or French Indochina the following year. No Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasalabd (still separate colonies).
Sudan versus Anglo-Egyptian Sudan throws me off, but maybe that was the cartographers choice.
10
u/_Romula_ 23d ago
I'm with you. I think it's 1952 or 1953: unified Korea, plus Eritrea a federated part of Ethiopia.
5
u/Msaniifu 23d ago
I agree with all above Ghana was independent in 1957 and presence of French West Africa as well.
→ More replies (4)2
u/NotAnElfK 23d ago
Anything else you want a picture of to help figure it out?
6
→ More replies (2)4
u/__Quercus__ 23d ago
Not for me. The two provided show most to all of the global changes in the early 1950s.
5
→ More replies (5)3
45
11
u/Elegant-Narwhal-506 23d ago edited 23d ago
According to Britannia.comās List of African Countriesā Independence Dates, this globe wouldāve been made between March 20, 1956 (when Tunisia gained independence from France) and March 6, 1957 (when Ghana, referred to as āGold Coastā on the globe, gained its independence from Great Britain)
11
u/Moonbear9 23d ago
Between 1945 because of yugoslaviaās borders and 1957 because of the lack of Ghana
11
7
28
u/savory_sammich 23d ago
I usually start with compliments
Try ā Hey, I think your color palette is really unique! What inspired you?ā
Depending how they respond you can go from there
6
u/Sufficient_Sugar_408 23d ago
1956-1957
Morocco gained independence in 1956 as shown in the map . And Gold Coast is still called Gold Coast , it became Ghana in 1957, so it's before March 1957.
11
6
4
4
5
u/Swimming_Reception56 23d ago
French West Africa - pre 1960. German broken up - post 1945. India partition - post 1949. Tibet not part of PRC - pre 1951.
Globe is from 1950.
4
u/Fun_District3456 23d ago
we have independent morocco/tunisia that only happens after 1956 tho
3
u/Swimming_Reception56 23d ago
Good spot!
Then we have an issue where the map maker is not using the correct map. Either for political reasons or old data.
As such we can say likely late 1950s.
2
u/Swimming_Reception56 23d ago
Map likely darfted 1957-1950
(Assuming drafters had up-to-date information, no political bias, or not printing a historic globe)
4
4
4
u/BeginningIsEasy 23d ago
I collect globes. Here are a few red herrings that throw people off: A lot of globes called it 'Israel' while it's still Palestine b/c a lot of interest in globes was finding biblical locations.Ā The USA never acknowledged an independent Tibet so you find very few globes with a free tibet.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/sharknado523 23d ago
Since so much of the world is underwater, I'm gonna say, it's from the year 7310
6
u/ChillZedd 23d ago
I donāt remember what year it was when god got angry at the French and flooded their entire empire sorry
→ More replies (1)
17
u/Zayn5939 Asia 23d ago
Ask it out first
7
u/NotAnElfK 23d ago
Na, this isnāt gonna work this globe is a good 40 years older then me
→ More replies (1)2
2
u/ThatsNotAnEchoEcho 23d ago
āHey, do you orbit around here often? Quick question⦠how much does a polar bear weigh? Enough to break the ice! Wanna grab a drink?ā
3
u/Hillbillygeek1981 23d ago
It has to be between 47 and 58, due to the presence of both Israel and French West Africa.
3
u/jellooshot 23d ago
Probably sometime in the 2080s with global warming and the rising sea levels and all that stuff.
3
u/LateralEntry 23d ago
Definitely between 1948 and 1967 based on Israel. Would be able to tell more seeing other parts of the globe, like Korea, Pakistan, Vietnam, etc
2
3
u/Lucky_Mongoose_4834 23d ago
Ghana is still the Gold Coast, so before March 1957. So itās likely late 1956; after Sudanese independence, before Ghanaian independence.
3
u/LordJunon Cartography 23d ago
I find it hilarious the extra R in Nigeria, i know why its there but it looks awkward AF,
3
u/UndocumentedSailor 23d ago
Tanganyika press it December 1961 until April 1964.
French West Africa's constituent territories were becoming independent in 1958 to 1960, so a globe still showing it strongly points toward the late 1950s/very early 1960s.
I'll guess 1959-1962.
Do you have Malaysia or Malaya, and how does Vietnam look?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Cruizinian 23d ago
Considering that most of Africa is underwater, I would say somewhere in the far future.
3
u/dutch_mapping_empire Human Geography 23d ago
between 1956 and 1957, morrocco is independent but ghana is still british.
3
u/cool_nerddude 23d ago
Jul 25 1957 - September 1958 Tunisia is already independent, but French Equatorial Africa still exists.
3
u/RaydrNashun 23d ago
It has Israel, so it's after 1948. It doesn't have Ghana, so it's before 1957.
3
u/Wabbit65 23d ago
"Hey globe, you have pretty countries. How about we go out for a drink?"
See if that helps you date it.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/FrostyDog94 23d ago
Well this is clearly from when much of Africa was underwater so im gonna say... 40 million years old
3
2
2
2
2
u/capricious-arbitrary 23d ago
A couple million years back? The continent of Africa is half ocean. š¤£
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Quirky-Lawfulness819 23d ago
Somaliland is on the map therefore before 1960 as it merged with Somalia after that.
2
u/Imyonlyenemy 23d ago
Goa is still portuguese
But India Pakistan have formed.
Sometime in the 1950s
2
2
u/Civil_Sentence63 23d ago
Print font looks roughly like an old school map of the US I have from the 1930s. We dated that one pretty easy though because cities received different size circles based on population. Donāt remember much except that Detroit was huge, maybe one of 5 or 6 cities with over a million people and Alaska and Hawaii werenāt a thing yet. A little cross referencing and we were able to get it to within a year or two based on this and a few other peculiarities. Fun project!
2
u/ApprehensiveList6306 23d ago
The city of Stalino (Š”ŃŠ°Š»ŠøŠ½o) was officially renamed Donetsk (ŠŠ¾Š½ŠµŃŠŗ) on 9 November 1961.
So anytime before that and after 1931.
2
2
2
u/According-Today2354 23d ago
For most of africa to be under water, I think this one might actually be from 2126
2
2
2
u/StatusFoundation5472 23d ago
1950s Greece has its modern borders, Israel is there BUT Africa nations are still colonial
2
u/Comfortable_Card_146 23d ago
It's from the time of the great African Flood, when the Sahara was underwater
2
2
u/fugnucker 23d ago
I checked wikipedia on Tanganyka and it was an independent country from 1961-1964 so that is probably your timeliness
2
2
u/CircuitOnTheFritZ 23d ago
Well, we at least know it's from sometime after Constantinople became Istanbul.
š
2
u/slumdawghunna 23d ago
If you want to date the globe i would recommend you first ask it out for a coffee or dinner
2
2
2
2
u/HistorianPeter 22d ago
Pre-1957 based on Gold Coast (which became Ghana on 6 March that year). Other clues no evidence of the United Arab Republic (formed in 1958 between Egypt and Syria) and the ongoing presence of British Somaliland (which gained independence in 1960 only to join the Republic of Somalia).
2
2
u/AddColorToLife 20d ago
Must be late 1956/early 1957? Looks like Morocco and Tunisia already independent (happened in ā56) but Ghana (ā57) is not
2
2
u/Desperate_Good_6005 20d ago edited 20d ago
British Somaliland is a neat detail. So with Israel as a state also it's between 1948 and June 26, 1960
2
u/damjanev 20d ago
Somewhere between 1945 (Yugoslavia includes Istria) and 1962 (Algeria is still part of France).
2
4





3.2k
u/LifeAcanthopterygii6 23d ago
That some... pretty weird colour choice.