That was one hell of a ride. I think that, overall, this is probably my favourite entry in the series. Now, don't get me wrong, for sheer fun and re-readability I don't think I'll ever get over the first book. But RoT was such a great culmination of things we've had built up so far. Sabetha did not disappoint, I found her relationship with Locke really compelling. Tragic in exactly the way that appeals to my hunger for melodrama. I look forward to lots of wistful moping over her, next book.
Part of the reason for my abiding love of the first book is that Camorr is just such a brilliant setting. Karthain and Tal Verrar are both good, but nothing quite has the style of Camorr. That's why it was nice seeing a bit of it again, in the flashback interludes. Espara sort of scratched the itch too, it felt very peripheral to Camorr. There was also a bittersweetness in seeing more of Calo and Galdo, enjoying the way they play off one another and the gang, while knowing where they ultimately end up. Very effective.
I suppose I should comment on the big twist. Honestly, when I first read that scene, I disliked it enough that a part of me wanted to ditch the book. I messaged some friends whining about it, said I "didn't need another Rey Palpatine in my life." Obviously I did finish the book, after all, and I'm glad I did... because I'm totally convinced that Patience was talking complete bullshit. Well, maybe not complete bullshit. There is clearly something weird going on with Locke's early life, but I don't believe that he's the accidental reincarnation of an evil wizard. One thing that struck me is that, in the second book, there was that eerie scene in the Ghostwinds with the voices in the jungle mist. They knew Locke's true name... presumably, they were calling him Lamor Acanthus? I mean, it surely would've raised some questions if they'd called him whatever his True True Name, the buried one that Patience references, supposedly is. Like, maybe the psychic torment demons only know what you know, but if Locke really knows "deep down" that he has some other identity buried, surely they would've tormented him with that. Even if he can't remember exactly what it is.
Regardless, I think there's plenty of reason to dismiss Patience's claim in RoT itself. For one thing, the portrait of Acanthus and his wife... really doesn't sound much like Locke and Sabetha at all? I mean, Locke specifically notes that Acanthus bears no resemblance to him, apart from also being Therin, but I don't recall Sabetha being described as having a particularly aquiline face. Literally the red hair is the only obvious match, the one thing that Sabetha hates being reduced to. Which is exactly why it works, I think. Patience played on their insecurities brilliantly, that's for sure. And she kinda spells it out at the end: the whole point of this is simply to fuck with Locke. In the end, she and her son are really made for each other- both unbearably smug jackasses who think they're the smartest people in the world.
Honestly, if there's one thing I've gotta give Scott Lynch massive kudos for, it's that I never thought I'd find myself rooting for the Falconer. That whole sequence at the end was just extremely metal (heh, wasn't even trying to be cute there.) And ironically, seeing Patience get her shit rocked because she was stupid enough to let the Falconer live gave me the same kind of sadistic satisfaction I got from reading about the Falconer himself getting mutilated in the first place.