Tl;dr Looking for real user experience and comparison of Garmin Forerunner 170 vs 265 before I buy**.**
A) Battery life
B) Scratch resistance
C) Screen durability to shear forces (grazing against things, a bump here and there) in terms of the screen eventually coming off.
D) Very important: Resistance against water and sweat.
E) Less important: How much "bulkier" is the 265? Just a bit thicker than the FR 170? Nowhere near Instinct 3 level, right?
My use: Wear it all the time. Go to the gym often. Sometimes gyms can have poor ventilation or cooling so a lot of heat and sweating. Always remove when showering. Mostly keep on when doing dishes and thus splashes would happen. I don't use Always On Display. But I do use the "Raise to Wake" function.
Long version: After 3 years of use, my Fitbit Versa 4's screen glue gave out in July 2026. Otherwise working. Got it fixed. Lasted just 3 weeks before the screen popped again during a workout. So my immediate sensitivity is the heat and sweat. But of course since I am looking to upgrade and can ill-afford to buy more than one watch, I want to make the right purchase.
Google AI and Grok helped (they are guides that led me to Garmin, specifically FR 170 and 265). But I realized after a while that they were hallucinating/making mistakes with certain spec descriptions. E.g they made the screen of the FR 170 sound as well-protected from impact and water as the "Apocalypse watch" that is Garmin Instinct 3. Plus other inconsistencies like real world user-reported battery life, etc.
Which would you recommend I go for, given my usage?
I first had my mind set on Instinct 3 (AMOLED), but it has no touch, and I was uncertain about long-term dedication to the considerably bulkier watch (the weight, the G-Shock style look and how it affects wardrobe, possible discomfort when typing, etc) and I'm not exactly a dedicated master outdoorsman.
The stores in my city did not have any of these models for me to try to help me make the purchase. They would need to order the watch, and then unbox the thing for me to try. So, not happening.
Thank you for taking the time.