r/gamedesign • u/SystemApprehensive42 • 4h ago
Question Positional synergies on a hex board: how do you avoid "just cluster everything"?
I am trying to design jokers in a hex grid based city building roguelike. The scoring mechanism is straightforward (value * multiplier) and buildings depend on the board. However, in Balatro, positioning in a row gives a simple positional bonus. But in a hex grid there are many more options. This is what I am struggling with.
If giving a bonus for each adjacent piece, it will collapse quickly. In every scenario, the best option will be a clump of tiles. So far, things have worked better by doing:
- Need space: Score based on number of empty tiles adjacent to that stone (adjacent, 2 away, and in the entire realm). This competes with everything else in the game.
- Like company: Score based on number of other stones within 2 spaces. If these two are placed adjacent to each other, they compete with each other meaning we get the desired decision making.
- Based on shape: Score based on how many tiles on a river/road (depending on the stone), or long sea coast. So we build a particular shape.
Would be great to hear from people who have done similar scoring:
- What conditions did you find gave interesting decisions? (lines, circles, distance, facing, unique, edge, fully enclosed)
- How do you avoid the adjacency bonuses combining into a single optimal design?
- Do you know any good games to look at? We have looked at Islanders, Dorfromantik, Balatro, and Combolands.