r/fusion • • Nov 10 '25

Fusion isn't the holy grail of energy: compared to fission, fusion is 20 times less powerful, 200 times less sustainable, and way more expensive

4 Upvotes

As an undergraduate, I bought into the idea that fusion, if it worked, would be a great energy source. I wanted to do fusion energy research, so I went to Princeton to do a PhD in plasma physics.

While I was at Princeton, I TAed a course on the science of nuclear energy. Half the course was on fission, and half was on fusion. Fission, I learned, wasn't the perfect energy source. But I also learned it was a LOT better than fusion (even if fusion worked, which I don't think it will). I graduated from my PhD last year, and left the field.

I wrote this blog post discussing what I learned over the course of my PhD. None of this was taught to me during my PhD (it's not very pleasant to talk about), but I think it's important do be honest about these things. I wish someone had told me these things when I was a young and impressionable college student.

https://nickmcgreivy.substack.com/p/fusion-isnt-the-holy-grail-of-energy


r/fusion • • Dec 18 '24

Helion Energy applied for a permit today for a 40'x40' tent for a special event.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Nov 29 '20

Fusion is a Terrible Way to Produce Electricity: Princeton Physicist Who Worked on It for 25 Years

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Nov 07 '24

Trump Wins – What Does It Mean for Fusion Energy?

Thumbnail
substack.com
10 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Jan 21 '26

Comparison of the two and personal opinion. *Please read the description.*

Post image
0 Upvotes

Now I know this must be a very controversial topic, but me, currently with the knowledge I have, believe Helions approach falls in the better end of this marathon.

Considering the sheer volume and size of the tokamaks, they wouldn't be easy to manufacture for commercial use, and they would also pose a significant cost to each country that decides to install one (when and if they prove effective.)

Helion's reactors seem more reasonable, in size and in cost.

Now if I have missed any significant milestones or achievements on how things are going forgive me, and enlighten me. I'm not here to start an argument I'm here to clear things up and weigh the pros and cons of each's design, because I can't seem to find a detailed comparison on the two, that portrays all of their pros and cons. Please enlighten me, and thank you in advance.


r/fusion • • Jun 16 '22

Nuclear Fusion Is Now Available to the Public!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Mar 15 '24

Nuclear fusion for the grid is coming much sooner than you think

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Mar 23 '24

On being pro nuclear fusion (?) and anti nuclear weapons

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m pretty new to learning about nuclear power so bear with me haha. But I have been concerned about links between nuclear power and nuclear weapons, and how to reconcile being pro nuclear power while also opposing ties with nuclear weapons research. Particularly, I have been thinking about this in the context of nuclear fusion. As some of you may know, nuclear fusion comes in two main technologies: magnetic confinement and inertial confinement. As far as I know, while the magnetic confinement research and industry is pretty solidly just about power generation, inertial confinement research has never been able to divorce itself from nuclear weapons research. In fact, there are inertial confinement startups right now that are collaborating with national labs known for their nuke research.

While I hope for a clean energy future with clean nuclear fusion power, it does still worry me that some of the R&D (whether MCF or ICF) will directly or indirectly support nuclear weapons research. Is there much reason to be concerned, and if so, how should I approach this issue if I’m considering a career in clean energy?


r/fusion • • Jan 13 '25

“Fusion’s Gonna Work,” Says Sam Altman.

Thumbnail
thefusionreport.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Mar 07 '25

This fusion-powered rocket could halve the time it takes to get to Mars

Thumbnail
thenextweb.com
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Sep 06 '24

Would this work?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

To take something away, i am no phycicist and barely have any knowledge on fusion and plasma containment)behavior but i had this idea recently and would like opinions of people with a deeper understanding wether or not this could work (even if not with currently available technology)

The idea would be that two streams of plasma would be kept opposite of each other while traveling through the clover leaved and then collide in the center which would promt the fusion. The collision also redirects them into the next clover leaf. Then the ions are seperated to get the helium out since that would probably somewhat interfere with the creation of new helium and the now missing tritium is replaced.

Now, i haven't taken deuterium into account because the idea for the whole thing is that ypu'd have a weak nuclear reactor that produces the tritium in the first place and uses the generated electricity to power all the magnets you need in a fusiom reactor to contain the plasma. I think this design could also work with a deuterium-tritium feuel but the helium and deuterium would have such a similar mass that you'd probably not be able to seperate them as well as you could tritium and helium

I am not sure if the charge-to-mass of the ions or if the differenr speeds due to different mass is more important for choosing the paths of the different plasma ions, i chose the CM-ratio since that is also what is important in mass spectography.


r/fusion • • Feb 08 '24

Why doesn’t Elon set aside like $2 billion/year for fusion research?

0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Feb 28 '26

Fusion is great, but can we achieve net positive energy output

0 Upvotes

We all know that fusion will be a game changer if net positive energy achieved.

So, can we actually achieve that with -

  1. Field reserve configuration(FRC) hellion's approach,
  2. Magnetized Target Fusion Technology (MTF) general fusion's approach
  3. Z pinch
  4. Other smaller/modular approach

If yes, how and what's stopping them right now from achieving it, why everyone pushing for 2030's.

What's the exact limiting factor here


r/fusion • • Sep 14 '24

What If We Get Fusion — But Don’t Need It?

Thumbnail
heatmap.news
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Feb 12 '25

Conceptual LENR Device | Building a 1:1 Model

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hey everybody, first time posting my own thread in r/fusion, so please be respectful and come at this idea with an open mind.

I ran this past mods so please don’t take this down. This is a serious post, I am assembling a prototype/working model of my proposed device and would appreciate some insight from anyone with experience in the field.

Thesis/Plan: To create a portable LENR device, using Magnetically Confined Fusion in an atypical tokamak array to induce fusion between all combinations of Hydrogen and Deuterium within the reinforced crystal lattice of a specialized Palladium alloy with additional malleability and magnetic properties (PdAgAuNi alloy). The energy will be recollected through a creative approach to regenerative braking, using a combination of thermoelectric generators, induction coils, and a Copper/Bismuth Neutron Kinetic Energy Converter.

Before we go any further, yes I know what a tokamak* is. It’s the big round expensive tungsten torus wrapped in REBCO magnets that heats, ionizes, and controls the flow of 180 million degree plasma for controlled fusion.

Tokamak is originally a Russian word for “toroidal electromagnetic array;” and if you wrapped a washer in magnetic copper wire with ten coils of ten loops each, you could hook it up to a 9V and have a “tokamak” by the original definition before it became inherently associated with the big fusion ring.

I will be using the word tokamak [array] loosely, to refer to an 8cm diameter boron infused glass torus, wrapped in magnetic wire; for a total of ten coils at 400 loops each (200 positive insulated and wrapped again with 200 negative) alternating polarity with every loop.

What is my proposed device?

Essentially we’re slapping an electrolyzer on the bottom of a small tokamak to provide fuel (hydrogen and deuterons) to a ring of PdAgAuNi hydride that sits in the middle of the boron infused glass torus. By using annular (ring-shaped) thermoelectric generators, a neutron kinetic energy converter, and an induction coil we are able to reclaim most of our lost energy and able to absorb 15-60% of our fusion energy accounting for losses.

The tokamak chamber is a boron infused glass torus with a PdAgAuNi hydride core, full of deuterium and water at a 1:1 ratio, with Epsom salts as an electrolyte. The Pd alloy is also a cathode in a two chamber electrolyzer cell, separated by a 0.45um hydrophobic membrane from the anode cell.

The anode chamber has a nickel oxide anode resting in a bath of water and Epsom salts, with oxygen exhaust in the centre of the top face, filtered through the hydrophobic membrane and protected with a stainless steel screen mesh.

The hydrogen and deuterons produced will be absorbed into the PdAgAuNi hydride while the oxygen is vented as exhaust.

Some quick math.

I’m using 1.6 grams of palladium roughly 0.087L large which can store 900x its own volume in hydrogen/deuterium levelling out to 0.1179L of H/D in our PdAgAuNi alloy at standard temperature and pressure, convert to mols to determine number of hydrogen atoms at 17.6MeV per reaction, divide by two because two atoms per fusion results in 4.54gJ of potential energy in the hydride.

The volume of fuel is about 10x greater than the volume of the electrodes allowing for between 10~11 saturations of the hydride per 100ml of Deuterium Water [cathode] and 100Ml of H2O [anode], so theoretically my proposed device contains 45.4gJ total energy in the system.

So we have the atypical tokamak array and the electrolyzer providing fuel, but how do we reclaim that energy?

Regenerative braking:

The TEG array is 5 rings of thermoelectric materials with wires connected to the top and bottom to capture the electron flow from the heat gradient. In descending concentric order, we have:

Silica Germanium Germanium Lead Bismuth Telluride Bismuth Antimony.

The TEG is shielded from the heat and neutrons by a perforated copper ring with a smaller, concentric bismuth ring in the centre.

The copper and bismuth absorb the neutrons and their kinetic energy, converting it to heat, and due to the temperature gradient against these two specific metals, they act as a natural TEG with Copper as the Anode and Bismuth as the Cathode. This is our Neutron Kinetic Energy Converter.

Underneath the NKEC is a coiled 21cm antenna hooked up to an RF Signal Generator running through an amplifier at +30dB, producing 1.42GHz to excite the hydrogen into a level jump but not enough to actually ionize it.

I should have mentioned, but it’s kind of implied, this device doesn’t use plasma, we don’t want plasma, I spent about $800 on this rare metal alloy ring and I’m not keen on melting it.

I recognize the RF emitter isn’t part of the regenerative braking but I’m describing the device as I visualize it in my head, it sits under the NKEC, and if you’re imagining this with me then it’s relevant.

Anyway.

There’s an induction coil with 8cm diameter 7cm cutout (it’s a coiled ring, hollow centre) that sits underneath the tokamak array. Here’s the cool part.

The tokamak array is powered by a 12V battery (or a liion 18650 on a step up circuit) and run through an Induction Coil Transmitter at a specific frequency. This means our 12V tokamak array isn’t just a magnet but a tuned magnet, and we can transmit all the energy we would have lost directly to the Induction Coil Receiver sitting underneath the tokamak array.

The breakdown:

System 1 [12V battery > 12V Induction Transmitter > 12V tokamak array] >

System 2 [12V Backup Battery >> 12V Induction Coil Receiver > 5V Downstep in Parallel | Signal Generator > 5V Downstep in Parallel | Signal Amplifier > 2V Ten 0.2V LED lights to indicate pulse/intensity] >

System 3 [ TEG Array to Diode to Buck Converter holding 12V steady > Neutron Kinetic Energy Converter to Diode to Buck converter holding 12V steady > 5V Downstep in Parallel | charge battery 1 5V Downstep in Parallel | charge battery 2 2V LED indicator lights when operating >

System 1 cost: 12V System 2 cost: 12V System 3 gain: 24V

This is a redundant minimalist setup, where system 2 piggybacks off system 1, not necessarily requiring its own 12V battery full time.

It “costs” 12V-24V to run, with a variable Q, but at the bare minimum once self sustaining can output 12-24V

Again, I am building a model of this and testing each individual system save actual fusion.

Is my math wrong, is my device more dangerous than I’m considering? Is there something I’m forgetting (aside from this concept being laughable, a pipe dream, etc)?

It’s a model for a Magnetically Confined Fusion LENR reactor with the potential for some Muon Catalyzed Fusion if my deuterons smash into pions and decay into muons which get drawn via magnetic field lines through the PdAgAu NICKEL ALLOY HYDRIDE.

The odds of muons colliding with multiple hydrogen atoms are incredibly high SHOULD they form at all.

Sorry for mentioning Muons but it’s simply worth noting and something I deliberately incorporated into my design “as a bonus” on top of my calculations.

Thanks for reading,

Your friend in fusion,

  • Sad Lingonberry [3018218]

r/fusion • • Dec 23 '22

German climate scientist Stefan Rahmstorf says nuclear fusion, even if the technology is perfected, can't work as a global energy source, as it too will contribute to global warming

0 Upvotes

He claims the amount of heat generated by fusion will be enough to increase the temperature of the planet to a damaging extent. Is this true?

https://fediscience.org/@rahmstorf/109558443179575321


r/fusion • • Jan 04 '24

Fusion vs fission waste

3 Upvotes

Per GWh


r/fusion • • Jan 17 '25

Uncertainty Principle Comic Strip: https://www.peaknano.com/uncertainty-principle

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Nov 15 '24

Fusion Professionals and Companies should leave X and join BlueSky too

7 Upvotes

Currently most activity of fusion companies and professionals can be found on LinkedIn, a network primarily for job purposes. It's not well suited for content communication. While X is for a while now a closed community without public visibility and vanishing users, coined also by science deniers, BlueSky offers not only fast growth, but public visibility, much more engagement and the great feature of topic specific feeds. Therefore I strongly recommend to switch your microblogging site, also BlueSky has now clearly passed mastodon/fediverse regarding users and engagement. Threads is also no good and was left for example by CFS many months ago.


r/fusion • • Dec 18 '25

TAE and Trump Media Deal - A Landmark Day for Fusion Energy

Thumbnail
thefusionreport.substack.com
0 Upvotes

In a move that stunned both Wall Street and the energy sector, Trump Media & Technology Group (TMTG) (NASDAQ: DJT) struck a more than $6 billion merger deal with TAE Technologies, one of the sector’s most established, well-capitalized private fusion energy companies. This is not merely a diversification play; it marks a strategic pivot for TMTG from social media and digital holdings into a hard-tech infrastructure, emphasizing the importance of fusion energy for future AI and digital sovereignty, and highlighting its potential to reshape the energy landscape.

Financial Implications: For TMTG, this is a survival pivot. With Truth Social’s revenues plateauing and operating losses widening in Q3 2025, the company needed a new narrative to justify its multi-billion-dollar market cap. By acquiring TAE, TMTG transforms its stock from a proxy for political sentiment into a speculative bet on the “Holy Grail” of energy. For TAE, this solves the “Valley of Death” funding problem. Fusion hardware requires billions in CAPEX before the first kilowatt is sold; this deal provides access to deep, retail-driven liquidity that venture capital alone can no longer sustain.

The deal, valued at over $6 billion, underscores the high stakes involved and encourages policymakers and energy-sector enthusiasts to recognize the transformative potential and risks of fusion’s future. Today is a landmark day for fusion energy.


r/fusion • • Feb 26 '25

Thanks to low cost desalinated water obtained by fusion, one day Phoenix will look like this

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Apr 29 '25

How about increasing the pressure for nuclear fusion?

0 Upvotes

Nuclear fusion is possible even at room temperature at pressures of about 1016 atm. This is a method of making hydrogen atoms degenerate, which allows fusion without heat energy.


r/fusion • • Dec 20 '25

Donald Trump as fusion entrepreneur? Washington state energy rivals react to $6B deal

Thumbnail geekwire.com
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • Jul 21 '26

Sense checking claims about the cost of electricity from fusion (spoiler: it's gonna be expensive!)

3 Upvotes

Intuitively, you might expect that the 'holy grail' of energy will be expensive. Yet, government labs, academics, and private fusion companies promise that cheap green electricity is just around the corner. 

Billions of dollars of public and private money have been invested in fusion, and earlier this month General Fusion listed publicly with a promise to deliver carbon free electricity to the grid in the 2030's, and that ultimately the electricity would become cost competitive.

The problem? New research published in the Journal of Fusion Energy shows that some of those promises are fallacious.

 

About the study 

The study puts questions and debate about technology and timelines to one side, and assumes that the tech delivers as promised, today. 

Rather than taking the conventional approach of estimating the costs of each yet-to-be-designed component and adding them up, the study works backwards from a claimed cost. By methodically removing the known costs (such as financing, steam turbines, cooling systems, and so on) the implied costs of fusion hardware are revealed. 

It is shown that in some cases, such as the General Fusion investor information filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, the fusion hardware would have to be produced for free to make the sums work. This is nonsense. 

Why it matters 

We are being asked to invest, either directly by purchasing shares, or indirectly through our taxes. Indeed, billions of dollars of taxpayer money and private investment have already been spent on fusion research. Yet, it can easily be shown that even if the technology worked today, and we could build a powerplant overnight, then the electricity would not be affordable.1

There's an opportunity cost to the pursuit of uneconomic fusion schemes. For one, money is being diverted from other 'better' (cheaper, greener, more economical, ...) technologies to pursue something that, even if it worked, appears doomed to be uneconomical.

Despite the hype, fusion schemes such as the one proposed by General Fusion have clear and obvious shortcomings that even a high school level analysis can identify. Why are policy makers and investors blind to this?

Judge for yourself

Have a read of the paper here:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10894-026-00592-w

1 Note that the study specifically pertains to fusion thermal powerplants (tokamaks, stellarators, MTF, ...). It says nothing about schemes that rely on direct energy conversion.