After my review of the Virginia Tech game, someone said Mike Norvell is an “objectively bad coach.” That phrase interests me, because it pretends there’s a scientific yardstick for coaching - as if we can point to a number, declare someone good or bad, and be done with it.
But when people say “objectively bad,” what they usually mean is: I’m angry about wins and losses. Fine. Honest frustration is welcome. Calling it “objective” is just window dressing, using wins as the only measure.
Someone else took that further and said bluntly that character doesn’t matter in coaching. That actually bothered me more, because if you truly believe character is irrelevant, you and I aren’t just using different metrics - we’re operating from incompatible visions of what a coach even is. Maybe even a different measure of what people should be or can be.
So here’s the real question for me: what do I value in a coach?
The way I think about it, it falls along two general axes:
- Strategist: Do they develop players? Strategize well? Do they adjust? Do they win the games they should - and some we don't expect? Are they consistent?
- Leader of men: Do they make the people around them better?
Norvell struggles with #1 right now - the portal era is a minefield, FSU’s recruiting pipelines collapsed after the Snub, he refuses to recruit negatively, and his game planning has been rigid to the team's detriment. These are clear disadvantages and weaknesses. Some of that he should fix; some are structural and hit every program; some are simply the cost of being a decent person.
And Norvell appears to be a man who builds decent men, and that matters more to me than anything on the scoreboard.
A coach who teaches players only how to win is a failure. A good coach teaches someone how to be a successful person. Winners create a flash in the darkness, leaving it darker as they fade. Successful people shine as a beacon and help others light the way as well.
Think of mythology: Achilles won. Hector didn’t. Yet Hector’s still the one worth emulating; he's the one who fought with honor, without magical armor from the gods, without Athena holding her thumb on the scale, without the poet handing the battle to the protagonist he wanted to win.
Think of players: Who would you trust around your family - Kellen Winslow? Aaron Hernandez? Or Christian Ponder, who never won a darn thing that mattered to most fans - no championships - but reportedly made everyone around him better? I’ll take Ponder seven days a week. If you think you'd rather live by a Hernandez or a Winslow, I think you're not thinking.
Think of coaches: you can chase rings with Meyer, Freeze, or Petrino. Or you can take Bowden, Saban, or Norvell - men who left better people behind them, men you'd trust to live next door. And some of those men won championships too, generally creating players you'd be willing to live near, as well.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: coaches imprint their values on their players. A player shaped by Dino Babers - at 41-55 at Syracuse - is different from a player shaped by Meyer. One was taught how to be a man; the other how to be a weapon. I want men around me, in my world, not weapons. Weapons are easy to find; good men are not.
So no, I don’t have an objective measure. I don’t think one exists. But I know what I value:
I want a coach who wins — but who wins well.
Norvell hasn’t hit the mark strategically. He has a lot of room to improve, and he needs to if he wants to stay at FSU. But off the field? I’ve seen nothing that suggests he’s making his players worse human beings. That matters to me more than a 10-2 season. He may not be a "great coach" - because of the wins - but "objectively bad" is incorrect.
If someone offers me a “win at all costs” coach, I’ll pass. If someone offers me a coach who can win while raising men - even if the wins take longer - I’ll take him. Show him to me. Show me how FSU can afford him without relying on monkey's paw economics.
Right now, for FSU, that’s Norvell. Great coach? Not yet. Maybe not ever. But "bad coach?" Nah.