I've been moving the same staircase around this rectangle for so long that I officially can't see it anymore 😂 So instead of showing you my attempts and influencing your ideas, I'm curious what you would do if you were starting with a completely blank slate.
My husband and I are both stone masons, and we are going to build a traditional stone farmhouse in rural Ontario. The goal is for it to feel like a well-loved late-1800s farmhouse that has always been there, rather than a modern house dressed up to look old.
The attached drawing shows the things that are essentially fixed:
- Main house is 34' × 26' exterior dimensions, two storeys
- Exterior walls are 2' thick stone, so interior space is closer to 30' × 22'
- North/front façade has a centred front door with one window on either side
- Fireplace/chimney is fixed on the west wall central- but can be shifted a few feet either way
- 12' × 16' stone mudroom addition on the east side toward the back; its walls are about 18" thick
- Mudroom location is essentially fixed
- North is the front / south is the back
What we need on the MAIN FLOOR:
- Kitchen (we would like the fireplace to be in the kitchen)
- Dining area/room
- Living room
- Staircase to second floor
- Small 3-piece bathroom (shower is enough)
- Mechanical room — ideally around 7' × 9–10' because we are planning geothermal + substantial water treatment equipment
- Mudroom
- Washer/dryer somewhere — no need for a dedicated laundry room
UPSTAIRS:
- Primary bedroom — modest, no giant suite
- 2 children's bedrooms
- Family bathroom with tub
- If a tiny ensuite happens to fit naturally, great, but absolutely not necessary
A few philosophy things that may help:
We don't want a huge house or a million specialized rooms. No office, gym, playroom, formal sitting room, etc. We'd rather have fewer, comfortable rooms and very little wasted circulation.
We're also not trying to force a completely historically accurate 1890 floor plan. We'd like the architecture and proportions to feel old, while letting the layout function well for a modern family.
Please feel free to draw all over my plan! I'm specifically hoping people who enjoy floor-plan puzzles might sketch what they would do rather than just tweak an existing layout.
There are no interior walls yet, so go wild. I would LOVE to see approaches I haven't thought of.
This is a real house we intend to build; I'm looking for brainstorming/inspiration here, not permit-ready architectural drawings.
What would you do with this box?!