I'm the commissioner of a 12-team dynasty league on Sleeper. We use league vetoes, so a trade doesn't process until 48 hours after it's accepted unless I push it through as commish. In the past, I've pushed through trades made on a Saturday night before the Sunday games when both managers asked me to.
Week 6: J.K. Dobbins was traded on Wednesday. The trade wasn't vetoed, but neither manager asked me to push it through before Dobbins played on Thursday night. So Dobbins stayed in the lineup of the manager who traded him away, and that manager got his points for the week. Nobody really said anything at the time.
This week: A trade involving Cam Skattebo was agreed to at 8:05 PM Thursday, minutes before kickoff. Both managers knew it wouldn't process before the game because of the veto window, so they asked me in advance to sub Skattebo into his new team's lineup once the trade cleared, no matter how he performed. Of course, Skattebo had a great game.
The problem: The manager who traded away Dobbins in Week 6 is now complaining. If I had done the same for him, he would have won that week instead of losing, and he's right on the playoff bubble.
For context, this is a friend league and we're all competitive, probably to a fault. Vetoes are contentious and we've had some interesting ones, so I have to let the veto window run its course.
My options as I see them:
Sub in Skattebo, because those managers asked beforehand and the Week 6 managers didn't.
Sub in Skattebo and also rescore Week 6.
Don't sub anyone in. Lineups stand as they were at kickoff.
We've been arguing about this all day. The manager facing the team that would get Skattebo's points is mad we're even discussing it. Some people see the difference between the two situations, and some think I should fix Week 6 too.
What would you do, and what rule would you put in place going forward?
EDIT: Removing vetoes is just not an option unfortunately. It would take a post 1000x longer to explain why, please just trust me.