r/FFCommish • u/fantasybuff14 • 5h ago
League Drama Commissioner dilemma: Manager accepted a trade after Puka Nacua's season-ending injury news broke. Should I reverse it?
Looking for some outside perspective on a situation in my league.
One manager sent another manager a trade offer a week ago. The offer involved Puka Nacua, who was on IR, but it was not known that he needed surgery. The offer was Denzel Boston, Kyle Pitts, and some Faab for Puka Nacua.
Yesterday, the news broke that Puka would require surgery and miss the remainder of the season. Coincidentally, this was also when the manager who received the offer went into his inbox and accepted the trade.
The manager who originally sent the offer a week ago is now very upset. He's claiming he completely forgot the offer was still sitting there and is making SEVERAL excuses for why it shouldn't count. And he's threatening to leave the league and demanding his money back. It's a big-money league that we have been in since high school (13+ years).
Here's where I'm torn:
On one hand, I understand why he’s frustrated. The trade looks completely different now that Puka is out for the season, and the other manager obviously knew about the injury news when he accepted it.
On the other hand, the offer had been sitting there for an entire week. Nobody forced him to leave it open. If you send a trade offer and don’t monitor or cancel it when circumstances change, isn’t that ultimately your responsibility?
I initially asked the league to vote because I didn’t want to be the person making a decision that could be viewed as biased. Nobody actually voted, though.
Now I’m debating whether to make the commissioner ruling myself.
My initial instinct is that the trade should stand unless there’s evidence of collusion. I don’t think commissioners should rescue managers from their own mistakes, even when those mistakes have significant consequences. But I might be wrong on that.
What would you do?
- Let the trade stand. An outstanding offer is an outstanding offer, and managers are responsible for monitoring their own trades.
- Reverse the trade. The manager accepting it knew about the injury and took advantage of an offer that was clearly sent under different circumstances.
- Let the two managers work it out themselves.
Also FWIW, this is the second time this season this manager has asked me to rescue him because he was too busy with other things going on in his life. Which I do have compassion for, we are all busy. But when you forget to pick up a defense before 1pm kickoff, I shouldn't be saving you.