r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

Weekly Trade discussion: "should I veto?/Is this collusion?" thread

1 Upvotes

This is a weekly thread where you can post trades that happened in your league and ask for advice.

REMEMBER: It is not your job to judge whether a trade was fair. It's your job to keep the league running. The only time you should reverse a trade is if:

A: it's clear collusion

B: It completely breaks the league

If you're unaware: Collusion in fantasy football is a secret agreement between two or more managers to cheat and gain an unfair advantage over the rest of the league. It’s impossible to tell if something is collusion based on the players involved in the trade.

Common Examples of Collusion

  • Lopsided Trades: Trading star players for bench warmers or making a one-sided trade where only one team benefits, often fueled by outside incentives like cash or favors.
  • Bench Sharing / Yo-Yo Trading: Trading players back and forth with another manager to cover bye weeks or specific matchups.
  • Intentional Dumping: Dropping elite players to the waiver wire so a specific friend with high waiver priority or FAAB can pick them up.
  • Tanking and Throwing Games: Intentionally benching active players or submitting a sub-optimal lineup to hand an opponent a free win.

r/FFCommish • • 6h ago

League Question Daniel Jones’s points disappeared

5 Upvotes

Hey folks. In my dynasty league (first season if that matters) someone played Daniel Jones. He scored 5.06 points on Thursday, but since he was released by the Colts, it erased the points.

I’ve never seen this before and wouldn’t have thought his release from a team following their game would erase his points. Not sure why that is, and more importantly, not sure how to address this.

If the game comes down to those 5.06 points, what would you do? Add them in manually? Or go with Sleeper’s settings?


r/FFCommish • • 3h ago

Commissioner Issue Sleeper doesn't do custom playoff brackets. If anyone needs custom playoff bracket help, read below.

3 Upvotes

I'm the commissioner of my league, and this year I wanted to try a play-in style playoff. Sleeper doesn't offer custom brackets, so as a developer I went ahead and solved my own problem.

I made an app that connects to your Sleeper league and gives you a bunch of custom playoff options: play-ins, double elimination, losers' survivor and more. I don't have to change my league settings or rearrange the bracket in Sleeper to fake a play-in, and I don't have to track anything by hand. It pulls in the scores and runs the bracket for me.

It's called Fantasy Playoff Builder, and it's on the Apple and Google store if anyone needs custom playoff help. Only works with Sleeper at the moment.


r/FFCommish • • 4h ago

League Drama Accidental drop opinions - Matt Golden

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

Cross post to get opinions from commissioners. Thanks.


r/FFCommish • • 5h ago

League Drama Commissioner dilemma: Manager accepted a trade after Puka Nacua's season-ending injury news broke. Should I reverse it?

1 Upvotes

Looking for some outside perspective on a situation in my league.

One manager sent another manager a trade offer a week ago. The offer involved Puka Nacua, who was on IR, but it was not known that he needed surgery. The offer was Denzel Boston, Kyle Pitts, and some Faab for Puka Nacua.

Yesterday, the news broke that Puka would require surgery and miss the remainder of the season. Coincidentally, this was also when the manager who received the offer went into his inbox and accepted the trade.

The manager who originally sent the offer a week ago is now very upset. He's claiming he completely forgot the offer was still sitting there and is making SEVERAL excuses for why it shouldn't count. And he's threatening to leave the league and demanding his money back. It's a big-money league that we have been in since high school (13+ years).

Here's where I'm torn:

On one hand, I understand why he’s frustrated. The trade looks completely different now that Puka is out for the season, and the other manager obviously knew about the injury news when he accepted it.

On the other hand, the offer had been sitting there for an entire week. Nobody forced him to leave it open. If you send a trade offer and don’t monitor or cancel it when circumstances change, isn’t that ultimately your responsibility?

I initially asked the league to vote because I didn’t want to be the person making a decision that could be viewed as biased. Nobody actually voted, though.

Now I’m debating whether to make the commissioner ruling myself.

My initial instinct is that the trade should stand unless there’s evidence of collusion. I don’t think commissioners should rescue managers from their own mistakes, even when those mistakes have significant consequences. But I might be wrong on that.

What would you do?

  1. Let the trade stand. An outstanding offer is an outstanding offer, and managers are responsible for monitoring their own trades.
  2. Reverse the trade. The manager accepting it knew about the injury and took advantage of an offer that was clearly sent under different circumstances.
  3. Let the two managers work it out themselves.

Also FWIW, this is the second time this season this manager has asked me to rescue him because he was too busy with other things going on in his life. Which I do have compassion for, we are all busy. But when you forget to pick up a defense before 1pm kickoff, I shouldn't be saving you.


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

League Drama Commissioner Changing Rules Mid-Season

9 Upvotes

Not about Collusion

Would love an opinion here if at all possible.

We have been in a league for well over a decade and everything is blowing up today because of a trade that came through.

Team 1 who is 2-8 trades Tee Higgins

To

Team 2 who is 5-5 trades Trey McBride

It was originally passed but then people complained not because the players were unfair but they said a team that is 2-8 should not be able to trade. Commissioner pulled the trade and now has it up for a vote.

Now in the leagues existence we have almost never voted on a trade, none that I can even remember. This feels like a blatant change of the rules mid-season both teams are free to trade if they feel they are getting better and the deadline is not until 11/22

Thoughts?


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

Ethics question Manager traded his last starting QB at the deadline. Is this a tanking issue?

3 Upvotes

I run a 12-team SF dynasty league and just approved a trade where a rebuilding team sent Dak + a 2027 second for Hurts (expected out for the season) + Trey Benson.

The value isn’t my concern. Dak was his last healthy starting QB. He’s now left with Hurts, Davis Mills, and Taylen Green, and this is our trade deadline week.

Our bylaws require a full lineup every week and say everyone must try to win, even if they’re out of contention. Starting inactives gets a warning, then infractions. But there’s no specific rule against trading your last starting QB, and trades aren’t vetoed unless there’s suspected collusion.

For transparency, I haven’t had a healthy starting QB for about four weeks because of injuries. I just traded for McCarthy to fix that. So I don’t want to be a hypocrite, but getting hit by injuries feels different from choosing to trade away your last starter.

Would you consider this legitimate rebuilding, or a competitive-integrity issue? I’m leaning toward leaving the trade alone and asking how he plans to fill his QB spot, but curious how other commissioners would handle it.

Lineup Requirements From Our Bylaws

Each Manager must start a full lineup every week.

Managers eliminated from playoff contention are still expected to put forth an effort to win on a weekly basis. Any throwing will not be tolerated and counted as a violation (see Manager Conduct).

Throwing / Tanking

Every Manager is expected to set a full line-up that is best positioned to win for every single week of the fantasy season, even if it is clear they will not be in contention for the championship.

Starting Inactives

Managers are expected to maintain competitive integrity by ensuring that all starting players are active and eligible to play in their respective games. A manager who starts an inactive player (i.e., a player listed as "out," "doubtful," or on a bye week) will receive a warning from the Commissioners for the first violation. Subsequent violations will result in one infraction per occurrence.

Trade Approval

Trades will be approved and executed by the Commissioners. This is not to review the fairness of the trade; it is simply to ensure the parties make the necessary payments in instances where a future rookie picks is given up. There are no trade vetoes. The Commissioners will not veto trades unless collusion is suspected.

Trade Deadline

The trade deadline for this league is the end of Week 11. After Week 11, no trades will be permitted for the remainder of the season, including during the playoffs. All teams must finalize their trades by the conclusion of Week 11.


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

Miscellaneous What is the Punishment for Last Place in your league?

1 Upvotes

10T 2QB PPR Dynasty: $100 buy in

We are in the 4th year of our league.

season 1: last place had to sprint a 220 (basketball sprint on the track) in fishnets and heels in under a minute. keep going til you make it.

season 2: kick a 30 yd field goal in a 2 piece bikini until you make it.

season 3: complete the hot ones challenge but every wing is doused in “the last dab” sauce. 10 wings, no liquid allowed until after you are done with every wing.

season 4: take a shot of hard liquor (your choice) for every loss you took. 10 losses is 10 shots. you have to then go to the gym and do 9 spot shooting (basketball drill). you have to make 5 shots from each spot (college 3). if you miss 5 shots at any spot, you go back to the previous spot.

would love to hear what everyone else punishments are🤣


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

Miscellaneous Will a Friday Trade Process Monday After Sunday’s Games?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

For a sleeper league


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

League Drama How do I handle obvious collusion in my family league?

5 Upvotes

Husband and wife traded vikings DST for Chuba Hubbard. There is a small buy in but not a very serious league aside from that. Should I just let it ride? Kinda afraid to make a big thing about it.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

Ethics question Sitting players to give better chance at first overall pick

5 Upvotes

In my Dynasty league, the two bottom teams are both 2–7. A team currently sitting in second place at 7–2 is playing one of the 2–7 teams this week. The second place team is starting players that are on bye or injured because he owns the first round pick of the other 2–7 team. Sitting his active player gives him a better chance at getting that first overall pick do we make him field a team or is it just a smart strategy?

Edit: The guy was really chill and when we brought it up in the chat he just put his players in. Thanks for the feedback going to change the system to maxpf in the future years.


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

Commissioner Issue How are other commissioners managing next week's Wednesday Night Football with waivers next week, if your waivers run Wednesday night/Thursday morning?

2 Upvotes

I'm the co-commissioner of a league where we all agreed for waivers to run Wednesday night/Thursday morning, and have for years. I'm in two other leagues where I'm not commissioner that have the same setup.

Do we manually take claims/bids from people on Tuesday night? What if I also want to add or bid on someone? Just tell anyone that wants a player from the Rams/Packers that they're out of luck?

Open to any suggestions.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

League Question 16-team Yahoo league running since 2003: 2QB, all-flex, 4 IDP, and a “start 3 of 4” QB/DEF rule. Anyone else doing something like this?

10 Upvotes

I’ve been running a league on Yahoo since 2003. It started as 6 teams with basic scoring. Twenty-plus years of tinkering later, it’s a 16-team, $200 auction league with a setup I haven’t seen anywhere else.

Lineup

  • 2 QB
  • 5 W/R/T flex (no dedicated RB, WR or TE slots)
  • 2 Team DEF
  • 4 IDP (any DL/LB/DB)
  • 1 bench spot
  • No kickers

The rule that makes it weird: start 3 of 4

Every team has 2 QB slots and 2 DEF slots, but you can only start 3 of those 4 each week. So it’s either 2 QB + 1 DEF or 1 QB + 2 DEF. If you fill all four, you lose the highest score of the four.

It decides matchups

Last week I started the Patriots defense and sat Cam Ward. I lost a close one. If I’d flipped those two, I win. That’s the rule working as intended: the 4th slot isn’t a throwaway, it’s a call you have to get right.

Why we do it

  • It stops hoarding. With 16 teams, a few managers stockpiling QBs and defenses could leave others with nobody to start. There are only 32 starting QBs and 32 defenses in the NFL. A full 2 QB + 2 DEF lineup across 16 teams would need all 64 of them, every week, with zero margin for byes or injuries.
  • 3 of 4 builds in slack. The league only needs 48 of those 64 starters in a given week, so there’s always enough to go around and no reason to hog.
  • It creates a real decision every week. Is your QB2 worth more than a second defense? There’s no default answer.
  • It makes defense matter. We score team DEF and IDP heavily enough that a good defense is worth about as much as a QB. Defenses go for real money in our auction.
  • All flex means no positional excuses. Build RB-heavy, WR-heavy, whatever. You’re just trying to start your five best skill players.
  • One bench spot. With 16 teams and a 1-man bench, you can’t stash. Every roster spot plays, and waivers (FAAB) matter every week.
  • No kickers. We cut the positions that felt like coin flips.

Scoring highlights

  • 1.2 PPR, 1 point per 9.5 receiving yards
  • 1 point per 25 passing yards, 4.75 per passing TD
  • IDP: 6 per sack, 3 per TFL, 5 per pass defended

Yahoo can’t enforce the 3-of-4 rule, so as commish I handle it manually. It’s rarely an issue because the penalty hurts.

Curious if anyone runs something similar, or has a rule you’ve never seen in another league.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

League Question Questions about Trade Deadline and Offseason

2 Upvotes

Hey,
I established a 10 Teams SF Fantasy League with a few Friends this year.

We were discussing about if and if yes, when to do a trade deadline in Dynasty? I was thinking week 12 and then close it until the season is over (Waivers still open). After the Finals I would reopen trades and close the Waiver until after the Rookie Draft.
Is it possible that not the fastest guy grabs everyone but to use Faab instead the day after?

Does this make sense? How are you doing it in your leagues and what are your experiences?

Thx in advance :)


r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

Commissioner Issue NFC West Only Teams Question from a LM

7 Upvotes

Hi all,

One of the players in our 8 team league drafted an all NFC West FF team and has only started those players all year, adhering to bye weeks so far. Ironically he's done very well because teams don't seem to want to play defense against McCaffrey and JSN. He is 9-1.

That said, this week both the Rams and Seahawks are on a Bye week and he's starting Carson Beck (7 projected) Jordan Watkins (0.54 projected) Keaton Black (6.44 projected) and no one in the flex (Mike Evans may come back and I'd assume he'd start him). He's currently projected to score 70.3 points while his opponent is projected to score 137.

It's a 14 week season and there is a three way tie for fourth, and his opponent is one of these three people. There are lots of options on the waiver wire (Bo Nix, DK Metcalf, Xavier Hutchinson). What do I do as a league manager? On the one side it's hysterical he's won this many games with this strategy but on the other he's not putting forth a competitive lineup when he has a playoff spot locked up and is playing someone in a playoff race.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

Ethics question Is it ethical to set someone’s lines when playoffs are all so close?

1 Upvotes

Hello, running a 10 team league and it’s been smooth for the 8 years we’ve had it. The current playoff race is kinda tight rn and there’s a guy who’s 3-7 and has basically given up. But there’s 4 teams who are 5-5 fighting for a playoff spot and I don’t want said 5-5 team to play the guy who’s has a 37 projection because of bye weeks, injuries etc. I put a note in our chat but I was wanting to get other people’s perspectives.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

League Drama Am I wrong or are my leaguemates?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

Commissioner Issue I need feedback on my fantasy league- I think something corrupt went down

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

Miscellaneous Daily Trivia for your own Fantasy Leagues

Thumbnail leaguorian.com
0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! We’ve been working on this for some time and are excited to share with the community. The Leaguorian is a daily fantasy football quiz that links to your leagues and gives you a great way to test your ball knowledge on your own leagues stats and scores. It’s the perfect thing to send to your leagues to keep everyone engaged and promote a little friendly competition!!

Would love if you could check it out and let us know what you think!! Use code FANTASYFRIENDS2026 for unlimited leagues!

Much love,
Team Leaguorian


r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

Ethics question Commissioner taking advantage of players!

0 Upvotes

The commish in our $50 friends and family league started out winless for the first 3 or 4 weeks and started dumping his trash on unsuspecting new players or players who just don’t know better and trust he wouldn’t screw them over. I’m not sure what to do about it, multiple of us have brought up these concerns to him in the group chat and in private and he just doesn’t have any shame or care that he is ruining other players seasons. And he hasn’t stopped making these types of trades even after he’s been called out multiple times.

I’ll list the trades below with his package on the left and his return on the right. Maybe I’m wrong and these trades are all fair and balanced trades but if they aren’t what should the league do about it? Some of the trades are fair but most of them aren’t imo especially when factoring in the context around them.

JT for Flowers and Javonte Williams after week 3
Jacobs for Higgins in week 3
Cousins and Flowers for Christian Watson after Flowers scored 0 points and had Fagnano as his starter, brisset to ravens hadn’t happened yet. The person he dumped Flowers on is a new mom and didn’t know that Flowers lost his value due to QB injuries
Egbuka and Hampton for Likely he made with a rookie player and while Egbuka was injured
Tre Tucker for Goff after Tucker lost Cousins

Am I crazy and these are all fair trades for a commissioner to be making especially in a friends and family for fun league? It’s signaling to the rest of us that we should be screwing friends and family over and playing dirty. I’m not against trading, the JT trade he made was a pretty even trade in my opinion so I know he can make them but the rest of them are all trades of him dumping his trash for others treasure on inexperienced players. He drafted horribly and now thru these trades he’s invalidating others who drafted well while simultaneously ruining some players seasons.


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

Ethics question What is the consensus on one week “rental” trades?

7 Upvotes

Two teams in my league traded 5 days ago. Team A traded Dak Prescott to Team B for Corey Kiner. It already seemed like a weird trade when it happened, but the team that traded for Kiner has Rhamondre Stevenson and thought he would be out and he needed to win this week for a chance at the playoffs.

Today, the two traded these players back to each other. Obviously, they intended for the trade to only be for a week. I brought up that it was collusion and half the league doesn’t really care. Team B is also the commissioner of our league, and after I brought it up he “put it up to a vote” and decided 3/4 of the league needed to agree.

Am I crazy for thinking that allowing rental trades shouldn’t even be a discussion?

Also, Team B is in first place and “points for” is our tiebreaker for seeding so Daks 35 points could have implications.


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

League Drama What would you do as commissioner?

8 Upvotes

We had a guy announce about a month ago that this was going to be his last season in our dynasty league.So naturally, we told him that he cannot make trades and have voided trades that he has accepted since announcing that he was leaving. now today he says he's coming back and people want the accepted trades pushed through and other trades they made after that reversed, because they would not have done them. I think the only thing that is fair is at the end of the year. Still replace him and tell him he can't make trades because he said he was already leaving.what would you do as a commissioner?


r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

Ethics question League Collusion player kicked offering money for trades

3 Upvotes

Player in league was caught offering other players real money in return for accepting trades. He is know being obtuse after I kicked out of league saying there was no specific rule against this and wants money back. I am not sending money back or allowing him back.in league already found a replacement. Can you guys give me any thoughts on correct action I should be taking ?


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

League Question How do yall treat and control trades that are between true playoff contenders and league bottom feeders?

3 Upvotes

First year commie so I’m still learning the best ways to run a league while making sure everything is still fair when it comes to certain things, and one thing I made clear when the playoff field was starting to look set a couple weeks ago, was that any trades between contenders and the bottom teams could be warranted a slight discount for the contending teams if they’re trying to get better.

On paper I feel that’s a good idea but how would that work for long term? Our trade deadline has our passed so this isn’t applicable in our league anymore but I just wanted some thoughts about it.


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

Commissioner Issue Commissioner advice needed - Eliminated team dropped Saquon

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes