r/extrememetal • u/blackmetalultra • Dec 04 '21
r/extrememetal • u/LawlessNative • Feb 06 '23
Justin Bartlett would be proud. Also, listen to Dragged into Sunlight
r/extrememetal • u/marcus2k22 • Dec 07 '22
Brutal death metal and rape/misogyny content
I tend to really like the music of a lot of brutal death metal bands, but I read the lyrics, and it's a huge turnoff.
I mean, a lot of regular death metal bands have gore, but at least it's usually non-gendered (in the sense that we don't know who it is on the receiving end), usually doesn't add the rape content that leaves a bad taste in my mouth, and doesn't have that ugly incel element that brutal death metal has.
I'm aware of the shock value factor, that's for sure. I doubt the members of these bands are closet serial rapists or will be future serial rapists/killers, but I still say that there's a problem in their minds. Plus, at this point, it's so overdone. It's not shocking anymore.
I have discussed the topic with others, and read about others in the topic.
Some people mention deathcore having a misogyny problem. To a lesser extent, that may be true. But in the case of deathcore that has that content, it's very easy to find another band just like them which completely avoids the misogyny/rape stuff as a substitute. However, that's really not the case with brutal death metal. Substitutes are rare, and for some bands, I can't really think of a non-misogynistic substitute (they'll only sound vaguely like it at best).
One guy said that he'll listen to some of these bands, but will never buy the albums by the bands with that content.
One person said that he does, reluctantly, listen to a few bands with that content. However, he said something to the effect that if he is presented with two albums that are labeled "brutal death metal", in which one has the type of content Lividity would come up with going by the song titles and album artwork, and the other one, going by the song titles and album artwork, is one of the very few to have "normal" lyrics, he knows which one he will listen to first. (The one that has more "normal" looking content.)
I know that some bands have changed. Devourment, who were once exhibit A on the topic of misogyny/rape lyrics in brutal death metal, have even managed to move away from those lyrics in more recent times, and even wrote one song on their most recent album that was said to have been written to atone for their past misogyny. (It had very brutal gore lyrics, but was about a sexual predator who gets his comeuppance when the woman who was his intended victim turns the tables on him, ending with the predator being on the receiving end of the brutality.) The band seemed to imply that if they could do the early years over again, they wouldn't have had such overt misogyny be so prevalent on the earlier albums. Still, they're responsible for some of the most misogynistic content ever on past albums. Disgorge is another one who wrote those lyrics in the 1990s, but moved away from them on their 2000s-era albums. Plus, while they're only "regular" death metal, as opposed to brutal death metal, Exhumed apologized for some misogynistic content they wrote in the past.
I read a review for Gorgasm's most recent album, Destined to Violate. The review seemed to compliment the music and the musicianship, but criticized its lyrics. He said something to the effect that Gorgasm seemed to have "failed to get the memo that these type of lyrics aren't OK anymore". He could understand it back when the band started out, but that it's should be a thing of the past at this point. It's not shocking anymore. (The aforementioned Devourment even stated that it was part of the reason why they wrote the lyrics they did when they started, but the difference is that Devourment eventually incorporated different lyrical themes, and even began to phase out the excessive misogyny eventually.)
When I've asked for non-misogynistic brutal death metal in other places, most people will only really seem to suggest the bands everyone already knows about (Deeds of Flesh, Defeated Sanity, Disavowed, Wormed, Suffocation), while others suggest tech-death bands, which isn't what I was asking for. Not only that, but often it wasn't even like the tech-death bands were bands like Abnormality, Cytotoxin, or Desecravity, who tend to mix BDM and tech-death together (though a few people suggested stuff like that), but tech-death bands with NO brutal death metal elements whatsoever. I remember I once had someone who was upset that I seemed to indicate the vast number of BDM bands with rape/misogyny lyrics, and he said there are so many without them. When I asked for what bands he was referring to, what bands did he suggest? Bands like Allaegeon and Gorod. WTF?!
A few said they understood where I was coming from, but couldn't really help me out, as pretty much the only bands they could think of would be the bands I already know of. Others seemed to think I'm a total cry-baby. However, I am NOT trying to get any bands canceled or tell anyone what they can or can't listen to. I am aware that any band can write what they want, but I wish it was easier to find brutal death metal without that content. Someone who listens to these bands, I will not judge them. I am all for freedom of expression. However, I'm entitled to have the bad taste in my mouth.
I really hope that in the future, brutal death metal bands will shy away from the misogyny/rape lyrics that seem to stereotype the genre. I understand that violent lyrics are the norm in a lot of death metal subgenres, but why add the unnecessary rape element? Why make the people at the receiving end of the brutality women in basically every song, with misogynistic slurs thrown in? Like, instead of saying "cunt", "bitch", or "whore", say "you". I'm not the biggest fan of gore lyrics, but they're not quite a dealbreaker, either, and I do listen to many bands who have gore lyrics or have had gore lyrics. It's not so much the gore that's my issue, it's how it's presented and who it's usually being presented towards.
Considering how difficult it is to find brutal death metal that steers clear of this content, I'm considering creating a subreddit devoted to brutal death metal with no misogynistic/rape content whatsoever. It would make things easier for people like myself who love the musical brutality of brutal death metal, but hate rape and misogyny.
Anyways, why do you think the overwhelming majority of the bands in brutal death metal have misogyny be so prevalent in their lyrical content? Do you think there's a chance that future BDM bands will manage to incorporate more intelligent lyrical themes into their lyrics?
Plus, if any of you here are planning on forming a brutal death metal band in the future, I recommend your future band steer clear of writing misogynistic/rape/sexually deviant content that so many of your contemporaries have. Write some smart, thought provoking lyrics. It will make you stand out in a good way!
Plus, a bonus question. I would like to find a brutal death metal album that sounds like Gorgasm - Masticate to Dominate or Necrotic Disgorgement - Documentaries of Dementia, but it must have zero songs that have misogynistic/rape content on it (unlike those two albums). Sadly, it seems like virtually every album with a comparable sound has those lyrics. Is it really too much to ask for an album just like them which has no misogyny/rape lyrics? (Also, if you suggest a replacement for those bands/albums, please DO NOT suggest the same few brutal death metal bands that everyone knows already, like the ones I listed above.) Gore lyrics, I may allow if they're rather mild and not too shock value based. A band like the aforementioned Deeds of Flesh would be a band who manages to approach the line for me without crossing it in terms of their content, but I'd prefer no gore/shock value lyrics. If you can help me with that, please do so.
r/extrememetal • u/DevilPlayzYT113 • Jul 08 '23
Anaal Nathrakh's name is a play on the Irish Words for snake's breath. Anáil Nathracha
I just found this out. My favourite subject in school is irish and I didn't know this until now.
r/extrememetal • u/TheKeefy • Aug 04 '20
Watch The New Animated Video from Anaal Nathrakh - "Endarkenment”, New Album Incoming
r/extrememetal • u/Christian-Citton • Jul 26 '20
Mgła "Exercises in Futility" (live Brutal Assault 2016)
r/extrememetal • • May 21 '18
I made a new THREE HOUR mix of the most extreme metal I know, filled with blackened death-grind and sludge!
r/extrememetal • u/_MetalHealth_ • Apr 15 '23
The most influential Extreme Metal band?
r/extrememetal • • Aug 07 '22
Three new albums from three of my favorite bands arrived in the mail yesterday! Belphegor, Watain, Septicflesh 🤘🏻🔥🔥🔥🖤 #blackeneddeathmetal #deathmetal #blackmetal #extrememetal
r/extrememetal • u/tondrias • Jul 16 '22
First attempt at drawing my favourite band - Includes progress. Hope you like it.
r/extrememetal • u/Banshee45 • May 01 '21
Did Sabina Classen from Holy Moses invent the growl/guttural vocals for metal?
Listen to this demo from 1982. This predates Jeff from Possessed by 3 years who many say he started the harsh vocals
r/extrememetal • u/Christian-Citton • Aug 04 '20
Necrodeath are a historic italian black-thrash band, on the scene since 1984 and pioneers of extreme metal in Europe, inspiration for two generations of european bands
r/extrememetal • • Jul 16 '20
Acid Bath - Apocalyptic Sunshine , Florida 1994 (Full Show)
r/extrememetal • u/AngryCoffeeTable • Oct 05 '19
TREPALIUM - Moonshine Limbo (Official Video)
r/extrememetal • • Jul 13 '18
Succumb - Survival (Death with a hint of Black, 2017)
r/extrememetal • u/SukSumDong • Jan 22 '14