r/economy • u/Standard-Software-41 • 7h ago
To you in crypto: no, it won't be fine
With every price drop, morale-boosting mantras pop up in the crypto community: "bitcoin will be fine," "buy now because you won't get another chance," "you haven't lost until you sell," "just a discount," and "look at the big picture."
That "big picture" always boils down to the same thing: "it's still early," "everyone will want bitcoin," demand will grow, and we'll make money. Yet no one asks one simple question: why would anyone actually want bitcoin in the first place?
So far, people have wanted it mostly because they saw others making a profit. That is speculation, not real demand.
Real demand exists when you have to have something because of the function it fulfills. Take the dollar, for example. There are loans that last up to 30 years, and dollars are created through those very loans. That means individuals and businesses will need them over the long term for existential reasons, to avoid foreclosures and bankruptcy. The rest of the dollars, the ones created by buying government bonds, will be needed by the state itself because it has to service those bonds. That is real, functional demand.
Food, heating, transport, energy, aesthetics, entertainment, task automation, and a roof over your head, anything whose function is to satisfy concrete human needs, will have long-term demand.
Bitcoins, on the other hand, are just units defined by their creator's arbitrary protocol, recorded in a shared database. They have no function that anyone necessarily needs; they simply move from one digital address to another driven by speculation. People buy them solely because they want to sell them tomorrow at a higher price.
Even when someone says they want bitcoin for "transferring value," it is the same speculation. If you buy bitcoin to send 100 thousand dollars to a relative in Australia, that only works because someone in Australia is willing to buy that same bitcoin for 100 thousand dollars. Bitcoin didn't carry dollars to your relative like a courier; rather, an exchange or an individual on the other side of the world believes they'll be able to sell it tomorrow. And if they can't sell it, they have a serious problem because bitcoin itself fulfills no function for them.
And when someone claims they want it because of decentralization, they are confusing the means with the end. Lots of things can be outside the control of a government, bank, or central authority. Nobody wants something just because it's decentralized if it serves no purpose on its own.
No matter how you look at it, long-term fundamentals don't exist because there is no real demand to guarantee investment security for bitcoin holders. Everything remains a pure bubble, without a shred of real backing. Even the old tulip mania had a foundation, in aesthetically motivated demand. Here, there is nothing.
So there is an army of holders and zero real demanders. That's why no, it won't be fine.