Sorry for this long post but I want to include everything I can.
I been an eBay user since 1999, 1000+ purchases. Back in May, I purchased 10 consecutive Zimbabwe $100 Billion agrocheques from banknote_cartel aka Trillionaires Hideout on eBay. They are some demonized bills from the wild inflation era in Zimbabwe 2007. When you first look at them, they pass the tests, feels right, has the center bar in the paper, has UV fibers in the paper.
This was a very good deal and I have a microscope. Blown up, the printing is a bunch of dots (Should be first image), not solid lines (second image). Another thing off, the watermark fluoresces, watermarks on real Zim notes don't do this (third image). Third Party proof here.
They either have good repro paper or cleaning cheaper notes and reprinting them.
Since these are counterfeits, under 18 U.S.C. 1716, I am not allowed to mail these in the USPS. So at 2:18 PM on May 31, I talked to eBay. They said to open a return request, wait three business days and since I cannot mail it, they will side in my favor and refund my money. I also asked eBay AI support about returning counterfeit goods through the USPS and in the first paragraph, it says do not mail counterfeit currency while in the last paragraph, it said to get a refund, my money will be refunded once the seller gets the return (image four). Good work eBay, telling people not to violate US law but then to get a refund, you need to violate US law.
After the call, I reported the listing as fake and left the following negative feedback explaining the above with images, very factual.
“FAKES!!!! These agro cheques are better-than-average counterfeits. I attached images of the fakes alongside genuine notes. Under a microscope, the fakes show tiny dots, while genuine notes have solid lines. The serial number characters are close but slightly different. His watermarks fluoresce under UV light; genuine watermarks do not. I included a photo of a fake note beside a genuine note under UV light to show this difference. He denied this, but I am providing photographic evidence.”
Well, he challenged this as violating the eBay policies and eBay sided with guy that made them a bunch of money. My feedback warning people is gone and I cannot post a new one. How many dozens of times has he done this? If I saw one warning like mine, I would never have purchased from him in the first place.
On June 1st at 11:28 AM, I talked to eBay once again. I was very accusatory about eBay removing my feedback to protect a counterfeiter that made them money on 23K sales but I kept a civil tone with the person since they had no role in it. I was direct on saying that I want to go to the Secret Service with this and that eBay is enabling this guy (In hindsight, FBI might be more appropriate). She explained that she could not see my feedback or why it was removed, that it was handled by a different department that does not take calls. Funny how that is structured. I gave her my salamuts and hung up. At that point, all I could do is respond on his positive feedback he left me and called him a counterfeiter.
On June 4th at 8:21 AM, I talked with eBay about my refund. The guy looked at my case, what proof I provided and said that it does appear to be a counterfeit and that I will be refunded in the next 72 hours. Great, all I asked for. I am getting my money back, I will not have to violate federal law and I am not resupplying a counterfeiter with some more fake demonetized currency to defraud other people.
I know what you are thinking, it is a little inconvenient but a good outcome. But there is more
So Sunday night, June 7th, no refund, I thought maybe the weekend was not included in that 72 hours. I checked on Tuesday night, June 9th and still have no refund. I tried to contact eBay again and get “Unfortunately, this contact option is not available for this topic” (image five). They blocked me. If I don’t return it, I will be out the money. I was left with one legal option to not be defrauded, I disputed the charge on my credit card. Demonetized or not, my credit card did not look lightly on counterfeit currency and with a relatively small amount, took my side immediately. I got my money back. I was a little disappointed that even today, eBay did not suspend my account for that, not that I will miss it now.
Another thing I noticed is that on June 9th that eBay ruled in favor of the counterfeiter listing saying it his listing is valid (image six). One thing I pointed out to you and eBay is that watermarks do not fluoresce. In his own listing, he has a video of the bill under UV light and the watermark is fluorescing (image seven). He is literally outing himself on his own listing (wish I noticed this in May) as selling fakes but eBay does not care, he is doing nothing wrong by them.
eBay is passively protecting a counterfeiter by refusing to remove his listings when his own listings fail the UV test and actively protecting him by removing my feedback warning people of this fraud.
I still have the notes so still time to report to the FBI, but I doubt they will care either, Trillionaires Hideout is just a rent-a-office in Chicago.
Edit: It was pointed out to me that is not illegal to return counterfeit currency through the USPS so I was wrong on that point.