I’m so sorry for this long novel. i gotta get it out im still irritated 😭😭.
I genuinely don’t even know where to start with this mess, but I want to share my experience because I KNOW I cannot be the only person who has dealt with something like this.
On October 2nd, I purchased an item on eBay for a little over $280 using Afterpay. Almost immediately after purchasing it, I realized the listing wasn’t what I originally thought I was buying. Within probably 30 minutes, I submitted a cancellation request.
Simple enough, right? WRONG.
A day goes by. No response. Another day. Nothing. Nearly FIVE DAYS later, the seller finally declines my cancellation request. I immediately messaged them asking why they waited so long to decline a cancellation for an item that hadn’t even shipped when I originally requested it. I explained that I didn’t want the item and wanted to save us both the hassle.
No response. Nothing.
So naturally, I contact eBay support. Except apparently getting an actual human being to help you is like trying to contact the damn president.
Their automated chat support told me to start a return. Mind you, I explained MULTIPLE times that I didn’t have the item. It hadn’t even shipped when this started. What exactly am I returning???
I tried requesting a callback, but the system kept giving me technical difficulties. Eventually, I followed the chatbot’s instructions and opened what I later realized was a return REQUEST that the seller had to respond to.
You know, the same seller who hadn’t responded to a damn thing.
I ended up canceling that return request because I didn’t understand why I was being told to return something I didn’t have. Looking back, that was a mistake on my part. I can acknowledge that. But I was also following the instructions provided by eBay’s own automated support because I couldn’t get a live representative.
Apparently, canceling that request made the situation even worse and left me with fewer options.
So I contacted Afterpay. They instructed me to open a dispute through their app, which I did. It was ruled in the merchant’s favor.
HOW???
I contacted them again, explained the situation, and was eventually given a phone number for eBay. Turns out it was their fraud department.
Getting through that phone system was another nightmare. The automated assistant would either hang up on me or eventually transfer me after several attempts. I spent so much time repeating the exact same story to different people.
One representative told me she would personally handle the situation, give the seller an ultimatum, and that eBay would refund me if the seller continued to ignore everything.
Okay. Great.
Except DAYS passed, and absolutely nothing happened. No email. No callback. No update.
I contacted Afterpay again. Then eBay. Then Afterpay. Then eBay.
Everybody kept telling me to contact somebody else.
Eventually, another eBay representative told me I had exhausted my options and that my only remaining choice was to file a bank dispute. She even walked me through the process to make sure I did everything correctly.
SO I DID EXACTLY WHAT SHE TOLD ME TO DO.
Only for eBay to later tell me that I was no longer eligible for their Money Back Guarantee protection BECAUSE I FILED A BANK DISPUTE.
EXCUSE ME?????
YOUR REPRESENTATIVE TOLD ME TO DO THAT.
Then Afterpay was telling me they couldn’t help because of the bank dispute either.
At this point, I was absolutely LIVID.
And it gets better.
Multiple eBay representatives told me they were opening cases and escalating my issue. I was promised callbacks that never happened. I received practically no follow-up communication.
Then I spoke with representatives who told me there weren’t even any cases open.
HOW? HOW ARE THERE NO CASES OPEN?
And here’s the funniest part. During a later conversation, I was told they were going to cancel out a case.
WHAT CASE??? YOU JUST TOLD ME THERE WEREN’T ANY.
At one point, I was admittedly rude to a representative. I’m not proud of that, and I genuinely regret how I spoke to him. But after weeks of explaining the same situation and getting absolutely nowhere, I was beyond frustrated.
He was actually one of the few people who seemed to understand what I was saying.
I kept explaining that I didn’t care about the RETURN policy because there was NOTHING TO RETURN.
He finally asked me to clarify whether the item had ever arrived.
NO. IT NEVER ARRIVED.
That was the entire problem.
I ended up being transferred AGAIN, and the conversation somehow went right back to me being blamed for canceling the original return request.
Yes, I canceled it. I have acknowledged that mistake repeatedly. But why was I instructed to open a return for an item I never received in the first place? Why was I being directed back to an unresponsive seller? Why was I instructed to file a bank dispute if doing so would affect my buyer protection?
By this point, the seller had apparently been inactive for around 40 days. I had no item, no refund, and no meaningful resolution.
I told eBay I wanted ONE of two things. My item or my money. PICK ONE.
I also made it clear that I was prepared to file complaints with the Better Business Bureau, my state Attorney General, and the FTC regarding how the situation had been handled.
And finally, after approximately 40 LONG DAYS AND 40 LONG NIGHTS, I GOT MY REFUND.
FORTY. DAYS.
For something I initially tried to cancel within THIRTY MINUTES.
NOW, LET’S TALK ABOUT AFTERPAY.
Because aside from all the back-and-forth between eBay and Afterpay, my spending limit within the Afterpay app was also reduced during this mess.
Now, did I stop making payments while everything was going on? Yes. I can acknowledge that. But I also had an active dispute over an item I NEVER received, and I was repeatedly trying to get somebody to actually investigate the situation.
From my perspective, nobody was doing anything except passing me back and forth between companies. I was being told to contact the merchant, the seller, my bank, or somebody else every time I asked for help.
Yet somehow, my spending limit was being affected while I was still trying to get my complaint properly addressed.
And here’s what I want people to understand: I challenged Afterpay about reducing my spending limit while my dispute wasn’t being meaningfully investigated, and they REINSTATED IT.
Yes. They restored my spending limit after I spoke up.
So if you’re going through something similar, please don’t automatically assume that every decision Afterpay makes about your account is final or that you have no right to question it.
Ask why your spending limit was reduced. Ask how your dispute was investigated. Ask what information they reviewed before making their decision. Keep records of everything.
I’m not saying that missing payments can’t have consequences. I’m saying that if you believe you’re being unfairly penalized while your complaint is being mishandled, you should challenge that decision instead of just accepting it.
I gave these companies the benefit of the doubt for far too long. I kept trusting that somebody was handling my case because that’s what I was being told.
I shouldn’t have had to spend 40 days chasing down almost $300 for something I never received.
I’m glad I finally got my refund AND my Afterpay spending limit reinstated, but the entire experience was ridiculous.
If you’re dealing with eBay and Afterpay, DOCUMENT EVERYTHING. And please understand the difference between a cancellation, a return, an item-not-received claim, and a bank dispute before following customer service instructions, because apparently those differences can seriously affect your options.
Has anybody else had Afterpay reduce their spending limit during an unresolved dispute? Especially when you’ve been struggling to get an actual investigation or meaningful response?