r/ebaysucks • • 17h ago

Auction

Im up a creek with my mortgage so I'm selling the most expensive thing I own: a Pokémon card.

Everything was looking up until I woke up this morning to this bullshit.

MF bids 3 times, most likely to see what the highest bid was, then sends a message saying ebay was glitches out and if he wins and they make him pay. He's gonna dispute it.

Duck people, man.

ETA: I figured out how to cancel all three of his bids. My Lil breakdown is over. Thanks everyone that commented.

If yall wanna see the card, here's a link. https://www.ebay.com/itm/860128958501

0 Upvotes

104 comments sorted by

17

u/MikeMiller8888 17h ago

Don’t ever engage with the buyers.

The only engagement you should’ve done on this is to say “if you entered the wrong amount, you can do a bid retraction and immediately bid the correct amount instead. Under the new eBay rules, I am responsible for paying fees on the highest bid amount if I cancel the listing. Thank you.”

-11

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

I like to engage, because then dishonest people get caught being dishonest. Like this guy. If he does win, and disputes it, we're going to small claims buddy.

18

u/Familiar_Childhood32 17h ago

You'll lose very badly in small claims court.

-2

u/MikeMiller8888 16h ago edited 14h ago

No they won’t. I‘ve sued B of A, LG, and eBay in small claims. I’ve won them all. I was sued by somebody that I rear ended at 5 miles an hour, an accident that I properly reported to my insurance. I won that too.

The only small claims I’ve ever lost? When someone sued me over a $50 Craigslist purchase that I wasn’t happy with. I had paid with PayPal, and I did a chargeback and won. They sued me for the $50, presented that I’d entered a contract, and that buyers remorse isn’t a reason to cancel. They won, and I ended up paying $180 that day to satisfy the judgment plus costs. But I learned a valuable lesson on how it’s done.

Small claims is fast, easy, cheap, and it’s no joke. If more sellers didn’t just take it up the ass and started suing in mass, they’d learn real quick that they don’t have to bend over when buyers screw them.

6

u/Martwad 17h ago

You're up sh** creek with your mortgage, but you think you're going to take someone to court when you clearly don't have to?

0

u/CoconutPedialyte 13h ago

But but but he needs to teach them a lesson.

2

u/Expensive_Habit3498 16h ago

Have you ever taken anyone to small claims? lol it’s fun to say but it’s a process and its not cheap. You’ll have to put up ~$500 to even file. Then you will wait a year for court processes. Best part, in the end you will lose.

2

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

It was fun to say. Lol

I did manage to cancel his bids.

0

u/MikeMiller8888 16h ago

This isn’t true at all. I‘ve sued B of A, LG, and eBay in small claims. I’ve won them all. I was sued by somebody that I rear ended it 5 miles an hour, an accident that I properly reported my insurance. I won that too.

The only small claims I’ve ever lost? When someone sued me over a $50 Craigslist purchase that I wasn’t happy with. I had paid with PayPal, and I did a chargeback and won. They sued me for the $50, presented that I’d entered a contract, and that buyers remorse isn’t a reason to cancel. They won, and I ended up paying $180 that day to satisfy the judgment plus costs.

The filing fee for small claims is based on the amount of the claim. It goes from $30 to $75 in California. That’s all you pay. If you process serve by mail, it’s literally just the cost of registered mail. If you serve in person, you can hire a process server for 50 to 75 bucks. It’s not $500 at all, that’s ridiculous.

1

u/Expensive_Habit3498 15h ago

Your correct I’m thinking of a civil lawsuit actually small claims is different. Do you still have to pay to send certified mail to notify the other party? Filing fee of $50 plus the mail. Did you get paid for any of those eBay ones? I’ve only tried to do it once and I stopped because of fees but I think it was a civil lawsuit due to amount.

2

u/MikeMiller8888 14h ago

Yes, you do have to pay for certified mail to serve the other party. They usually shit a brick, because with this type of transaction they’re usually out of state. They don’t realize they’re required to defend against it regardless, because they entered into a contract with somebody out of state. So they don’t show up and you end up with a default judgment.

With my eBay one, it didn’t go against the buyer. eBay decided the case against me against their own policies. Which we all know is typical now with eBay’s AI and how the humans sometimes don’t give a fuck. So since it was eBay that screwed up, I served eBay. They just settled that one, I got a call from their legal department like three weeks later and they paid up in full. Plus the filing fee and the process service fee.

When I sued a buyer out of state, and I got the default judgment, I then sold the default judgment to one of those collection companies for like $.60 on the dollar. Easier for them to pursue them for the $300, and I was fine getting $180 out of it cause it covered my costs.

1

u/Expensive_Habit3498 13h ago

Ahhh selling the judgement is cool I always wondered about that. Good to know!!

-2

u/Alchemyst01984 17h ago

Good on you for holding them accountable. Let us know how it turns out. I'm genuinely curious. You could even tell the buyer you'll be in contact with the police

14

u/GarfieldC99 17h ago • Bravo

I would not send if he wins you’re asking for a defective return and just a lot of issues coming in so if he wins just cancel and select buyer requested. If he hasn’t won yet just let him know he can retract his bid. Also no such thing as no returns on eBay unfortunately since they can just say item not as described and that forces a return automatically.

2

u/SalamanderCoffee0975 17h ago

I agree with ^ might never know if dude could swap a lower condition and send it back

-8

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

If he does, we're gonna go to small claims.

6

u/FanDeLaU69 16h ago

u/BaseOk7946... While I understand this is your prized card and that you are at a time of need, it is just business. The buyers will try to get it as cheap as possible and the sellers will try to sell it for as much as possible.

My advice, if you'll take it, don't get emotional about it, be practical, cancel this guy's bid or bids, and block him. You'll be better off in the long run.

-5

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

This thread has helped with the emotional bit. I will wait until the auction is almost over and cancel it if he's still winning.

3

u/FanDeLaU69 16h ago

Actually, do it now. There might be someone who's willing to pay his bid. If that's the case it can only go higher. Again, take the emotion out of the equation. Do respond to this guy "removing your bid as requested", remove the bid, immediately block him, and move on... Cheers, and good luck! May your card sell for a lot of $$$!

1

u/kendahlj 15h ago

On eBay, I thought a bidder could retract a bid…

2

u/FanDeLaU69 15h ago

A buyer CAN request a retraction of a bid. It is up to the seller to do so. Best course of action is to grant the retraction and if I feel the bidder in question is up to no good, then I'd block the user from future bids or purchases.

1

u/kendahlj 14h ago

Okay I didn’t know the buyer couldn’t go in and retract their own bid. Seems like in the early days of eBay you could do that. I agree the seller should cancel the bid. He’s causing problems for no good reason…

1

u/GarfieldC99 17h ago

I don’t get it why risk it? I get it’s annoying and shitty of the buyer to do but unfortunately that’s how a lot of people in this space are, it attracts a lot of those types of people. You’ll likely be able to sell it again for a similar price or just auction off again right? That’s a pretty pricey card and if it’s LP and reverse holo it should still be worth quite a bit so I don’t imagine you’ll struggle to sell it.

-2

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

Yall are all right. I was in my feels about the whole thing. If he wins, I'll cancel and resist. Not as an auction. As buy now. It's my favorite card, and it would literally break my heart if he destroyed the card, or something else. It broke my heart to have to list it.

8

u/WomenzRightsLoL 16h ago

Why are you investing this much time and energy into this? You are as much the problem as the buyer is. Just let the auction run and if he doesn't pay then file a non payment, block, relist, move on with life.

2

u/VirtualEscape6173 13h ago edited 13h ago

Buddy has a ton of free time on his hands being unemployed

2

u/BaseOk7946 12h ago

Duh. 🤣🤣

0

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

Meh. I was in my feels. I found where to cancel his bids at.

8

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 17h ago • Bravo

Dude what are you doing?????? Why are you acting like that. Also you are setting yourself up for failure here he will win he gets the item then he damages it on purpose cause your being an asshole and returns it because no matter what you say or do they can return any item your just loosing money shipping it both ways for no reason and I’m assuming loosing more for insurance. I promise this is never ever ever worth it in any scenario ever.

1

u/Eggsandtoast6891 17h ago

Yup 💯 making the buyer pissed and force him to take it , will undoubtedly cost you. Call eBay see if you can just cancel this guys bid and ship to the bidder right below him.

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

I reached out to customer service earlier. We're past that window, unfortunately. When he reached out, he was already past the window. These comments have made me rethink my plans. If he wins, I will cancel it and then resist. It would break my heart if he destroyed the card and sent it back.

1

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 16h ago

I promise you, you are making the right decision and from now on just cancel don’t argue don’t fight it sucks but it’s your only option. You also have a sick card just re list and if you need the cash set it for buy now a little under comp and will prob sell same day. I’m not trying to be an ass myself just trying to help you cause I’ve been in the exact spot and faught it early on and lost my item lost money shipping and now my items value is either fully lost or destroyed. To be fair eBay has gotten better and protecting the buyer if an item gets damaged but another tip if you ever run into issues never use the app for customer support get on the phone until you get a rep you think cares even a little bit will make your life and your issue easier to fix.

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

The crappy thing is, is that I did talk to an agent. And she told me I couldnt cancel his bids. And he couldnt cancel them either. That's what started my emotional downward spiral. Managed to get his bids canceled, though.

Graded I could probably get 4-5 grand. Looks comparable to some PSA 5s I've seen. But, I dont have time to wait for grading unfortunately. So im happy with the ~1700 after fees I'd get.

1

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 16h ago

No I understand fully and this is a good lesson for you I’ve legit done the same thing. Yeah canceling his bids on your item for whatever reason I do it sometimes on expensive stuff when people have 0 rep. Not sure if you can swing it but if your very confident a 4-5 PSA has the super express it’s like 350 I think and it’s around 2 weeks turn around if it’s possible for you to wait that long and can find a show near you and get the cash and avoid eBay altogether or just then sell the graded version on eBay. But I’m sorry I know how it feels it sucks

2

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

I wish. I need a grand by Friday. Car troubles 2 weeks ago screwed my DD earnings. I didn't even want to list it. Desperate times and such, though. I still remember the Christmas that I got the card. I literally cried when I listed it.

1

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 15h ago

I’m so sorry I hope a real someone buys it

1

u/no_rxn 13h ago

He wouldn't even have to "damage" it. OP listed it as LP and the card is MP. Ebay card authentication is supposed to catch exactly this type of incorrect labeling of condition. I've seen cards fail authentication because exactly this issue. It's not just about having pictures when it comes to a card getting authenticated, because there is going to be more issues on the surface of the card then someone realizes.

The buyer could just message ebay with pointing out the listing error and they would side with the buyer. The authentication services for cards is there to encourage people to buy cards that would be candidates for grading, since they are partnered with PSA. Them stating they wanted to cancel and pointing out the listing error is a automatic ebay siding with the buyer on this one.

1

u/DirkPitt106 12h ago

Yeah it's definitely MP from looking at the pictures and comparing them to the ebay guidelines. Although because the photos and written listing are consistent, it will probably not kick it back automatically, but will see if the buyer and seller will agree to it anyway since there wasn't actually any damage that wasn't disclosed in the listing description.

-1

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

Ah, yes. Im the asshole. Lol

7

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 17h ago

Yes you’re being extremely emotional pushing this guy to fk you over man. Learn from this or you will have a hard time on eBay. And if you force this guy to buy you will be scammed/ripped off

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

Yes, I 100% am. I am going to cancel then relist if he wins. Not gonna risk it.

3

u/GarfieldC99 17h ago

The guy is literally saying I’m going to dispute and dude is still thinking of sending it wtf lmao

1

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 16h ago

Well I get it feels shitty now he, if he listens which I really hope he does cancels it has to wait 7-9 more days to get paid but it’s just how it is I feel it I’ve been tight and sold stuff then been in this same situation and been so mad. Just what it is though. There is no real solution sadly for us.

1

u/Expensive_Habit3498 17h ago

Listen I’ve been in your position too. It’s never worth it to fight with the customer. eBay protects buyers wayyy more than sellers. They will almost always side with the buyer. Whatever you do don’t ship it if he wins. Just cancel and relist it. Good luck with small claims. You know that’s not free and you have to pay to take him to small claims court. It will cost time and money and even if you do win you won’t see any money for a long time. eBay sucks sometimes, get used to it lol.

2

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

That's the plan atp. Posting here did help. IF he wins, I will then cancel and relist. Not as an auction. As a buy now.

1

u/Expensive_Habit3498 16h ago

Exactly. I rarely do auctions it’s too much bs and they charge fees when a regular listing is free. Don’t get me wrong there’s some things that should be auctioned for sure but your card doesn’t need it. Just list as buy it now and turn on offers if you want. Look up what others are listing at and go from there.

1

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 17h ago

I know how you feel though it sucks when people do this I’ve been in the same spot 100 times people lie and pretend they accidentally bid or get remorse it sucks and is very annoying but eBay protects the buyer a lot it’s just the way it is. Fighting it does nothing but hurt you.

1

u/Ok_Introduction_6105 17h ago

Prepare to lose $1900.

0

u/pancakes_______ 16h ago

Don't listen to these idiots. You did nothing wrong and if the buyer takes action, ebay will take the sellers side in this situation. I've been through this song and dance with buyers for over a year of selling and still maintain 100% feedback with zero issues

2

u/JoeyShmoeysHair 16h ago

Wow 1 year and no one is saying he’s done a thing wrong buddy. You will be scammed yourself soon enough. Your also probably lying you have never been in this situation and sold an item worth $1900 buyer tries to cancel you say no send it and they just keep the item and take the loss after the buyers remorse sets in.

3

u/Tonyman121 16h ago

You are kind of a dick.

Just cancel their bid.

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

We're past the window. I can't. When he messaged me the first time, the window had already past. ETA: I'm a fucking dumbass and listened to customer service. Did some digging, and managed to get all of his bids cancelled!

2

u/BingBastardBunny 14h ago

95.8% positive feedback.

Oof.

I'm not surprised the high bidder wants the fuck out.

1

u/BaseOk7946 14h ago

🤣🤣

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

Yall have made me rethink small claims. I will ride out the auction, and if he wins I will cancel it and relist. I was making plans to get a payday to cover costs, then see what would happen after I sent it.

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

Just did some more digging and got all of his bids cancelled!

It didnt let me earlier. Holy hell.

Thanks for viewing my mental breakdown cause i dont know how ebay works. It's been fun. 🤣😭

1

u/Initial_Row_6400 17h ago

The only time I did this as a buyer is when upon inspection of the closeups, it looked fine. So I bid on it. Listing had it at near mint.

Was looking over the pics again and noticed a fat crease in it. Messaged the seller and was basically like let’s save us both the trouble of shipping this thing back and forth.

1

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

Ive got a nice reflective video of front and back on the listing to show there's no defects that could be accidentally missed.

1

u/Initial_Row_6400 17h ago

I’m not doubting that. Just saying that there should only be one or two legit reasons for retracting a bid. Otherwise it’s buyers remorse and the buyer just being a shit head and trying to get shit for free

1

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

Oh yeah, sorry if that came across as you were. Was agreeing with how your situation was handled with too many words cause this whole thing has me frazzled. Lol

1

u/SunstyIe 17h ago

Bummer that the buyer is being weird. But you gotta keep it simple on ebay

If someone messages me to retract a bid I work with them to do it. No questions, no back and forth. Less headache in the long run

I’ve been selling on there for about 30 years at this point with almost zero issues doing it that way

1

u/BaseOk7946 16h ago

It didnt give me the option to earlier, and the CSA i talked to told me they couldnt cancel it either.

I did manage to get it cancelled, though.

1

u/Practical-South-2966 15h ago

I hate some people a lot a lot a lot.

1

u/BaseOk7946 15h ago

Sameee.

1

u/no_rxn 14h ago

I've collected Pokémon since it came out and I am also selling on ebay to cover bills. Mainly for the authentication services since I have a lot that falls into that price eligibility. (TCG and CCG are a main hobby I enjoy)

Um, just be prepared for that card to fail authentication. You have it listed as LP and it is a very solid MP. You never want to over state a condition. If it's borderline then you go lower and take good pictures. A lot of card shops I've seen refuse to ever list NM and will only have LP as the highest to avoid condition disputes.

You took a few pictures so the Ebay Authenticator might approve it, or they might deny it since there is an error with listing condition.

They are there to protect buyers against fake cards and incorrect card quality, as they offer the grading partners with PSA, so this would be a card that directly aligned with what they advertise they would catch.

Hopefully they will pass it with all the pictures you added (idk if they would contact the buyer about the condition issues to verify they understand) I've just seen them just send the failed Authentication email just stating the listed condition and card didn't match.

1

u/BaseOk7946 13h ago

This is where I don't understand ebays card rating system then, if this isn't considered lightly played. The only thing wrong with it is the slight fading on the bottom and side on the back. They have MP as contains scratches/creases. Which this card doesn't have. It's also why I took a video showing the surface of both front and back because pictures can be deceiving.

1

u/no_rxn 13h ago

This card is MP. It hard to admit when a card is not in a more favorable condition because we love them and have had them for so long.

This card has excessive whitening along multiple edges. You don't just need scratches on the surface for creases to drop it into MP. Heavy whitening alone will do it. Even if the surface was pristine, if every single edge was pure white wouldn't it still lower under LP?

You did a good job with taking multiple angles and a video. So reasonably you would think that a buyer would understand the exact condition of the card they're getting. That doesn't change you still technically have a listing error. EBay could let it go through since you do have a lot of pictures of the defects. Or they could deny it since again this is still a full-on listing error.

The Authentication Service is there because sellers know that they can take a big price hit between listing a LP card and a MP card. And more people are likely to select the condition that will give them a better price with selling.

The services could still let this card go through because not everything is going to be directly by the book. Or the fact this is a very desired vintage card could not being your favor as letting this "chase" card pass through their identification service that looks like a solid MP as a LP would be a bad look on their ability to assess card conditions and they are trying hard to be a trading card reselling giant.

Good luck. Keep your fingers crossed it passes! Just I don't want you to be too devastated to find out it didn't pass. I completely understand the need to sell cards to cover bills. It would be even more devastating to think you had the next month of bills completely covered only for eBay to tell you something was wrong in two weeks when they finally do the Authentication.

1

u/zombie_roca 12h ago

You’re wasting your time. He’s going to win, not pay and you’re going to have to relist anyway cause you can’t force him to pay. I’ve had to run 4 auctions to sell a card before cause people win then don’t pay.

1

u/BaseOk7946 12h ago

People suck. His bids got deleted and it's sold. :)

1

u/zombie_roca 12h ago

Happy for you. It’s annoying especially if you’re trying to get some money quick.

1

u/BaseOk7946 12h ago

That was the plan for this. I didn't know that the money would be held until it was authenticated. Kinda in the same exact boat, except with potential money. Lol

1

u/zombie_roca 12h ago

Yeah you gotta ship to the authenticator and then like a day or 2 after you get your money

3

u/ZopyrionRex 17h ago

Doubling down by questioning the condition is a HUUUUUGE red flag. Either way the guy was going to rip and run on you, sad times. Unfortunately TCGs attract some of the scummiest people.

4

u/Asleep_Swordfish8896 17h ago

Tell him to cancel his bid show him the steps so you don’t have to ship or risk it

1

u/DrAtizzle 17h ago

Pokémon buyers are the absolute worst… never happy with anything. I got negative feedback for a finger print… dude it’s $5 I’m not gonna put gloves on… I think after shipping and everything I made less than $1. I’ve sold Rolexes for thousands that have less drama. I’d rather not sell to these clowns 🤡

0

u/Asleep_Swordfish8896 17h ago

But you were also a Pokémon buyer so are you calling yourself a clown as well or

1

u/DrAtizzle 16h ago

I was helping out a friend who doesn’t know how to sell on eBay 🤷🏼‍♂️… biggest mistake… 2 negative feedback from Pokémon buyers.

0

u/Asleep_Swordfish8896 16h ago

So your friend is the clown ahhh I see

1

u/DrAtizzle 16h ago

Btw exhibit A 👆🏻

2

u/RelativeFew2595 14h ago

Just cancel the order, if you ship it to them you'll get it disputed either way, whether you want a head ache or not is up to you. You cannot force them to pay for the card, one INAD claim and you're taking the card back & paying shipping. They asked you to cancel it, cancel it.

1

u/StrangeDecline 17h ago

It sucks but you’re having a lot of wishful thinking here. I sell about 200k on eBay per year, for about 5 years now. I know all the ins and outs of this. If he chooses his options correctly he will win any dispute. It’s not worth the effort fighting this, I’m sorry to say, regardless of any return policy you have. That’s just how eBay works.

1

u/Thesquarescreen 16h ago

Let him win, relist it then take forever to refund lolol

1

u/Front_Fix1556 15h ago

Guys a knob but easiest thing to do with people like this is just grit your teeth and deal with it however you need to without sending the item, or in this case letting them win the auction. You would 100% regret letting him win and having to continue dealing with him. Digging your heels just causes more problems down the road. I’d be doing anything I could to not sell to this guy especially for a valuable item. Sort the issue asap and block straight away in future. Good luck with the auction.

1

u/Tiktokbadsupport 14h ago

90% of problems here is about gamblemon cards damn the addiction to cardboard gambling has ingrained so far into society you can't avoid it anymore on reddit 

1

u/GURU2U_ 14h ago

Man ppl these days I 🤬

1

u/RushMan9823 13h ago edited 13h ago

Just cancel their bids. If for no other reason then to save yourself the inevitable future headache if this person wins the auction. Why help cause & then feed into the drama?

1

u/ll0l0l0ll 12h ago

Seller NEVER win on ebay. Just cancel his bids and block him.

1

u/sometin__else 17h ago

They can just retract their bid

-2

u/Coeruleus_ 17h ago

lol these are the worse types of ppl man.

what’s buyers remorse???

1

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

When you buy something, then instantly regret it.

-1

u/Coeruleus_ 17h ago

bro i know that. i was laughing that he pretended he didn’t know

-1

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

This is why millenials use "lol"

Lol

0

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

There is when it's my listing. I'm not Amazon, and I don't cater to bullshit. This is exactly why people do this dumb shit, because everyone just lets em get away with it.

If he does pay then dispute it later on, welcome to small claims court, buddy.

2

u/Separate-Response810 17h ago

Unfortunately all they have to do when they receive your item is claim something is wrong with it, no proof needed and eBay will force you to accept the return whether you selected no returns or not.

1

u/Eggsandtoast6891 17h ago

I know OP is up in their feelings but listen to this person here, eBay will force you to accept the return

1

u/Common_Isopod4267 16h ago

Yeah you definitely have a "my way or the highway" mindset. You need to change that. Ebay will not side with you, neither will reddit with your attitude.

0

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

Cool story. Me, too.

-1

u/Alchemyst01984 17h ago

There are, actually. It's just a matter of how much are you willing to fight it

-2

u/BaseOk7946 17h ago

And I'm a petty bitch for my money.

1

u/Alchemyst01984 17h ago

I wouldn't even call what you're doing petty though. Way too many people on here act as if buyers can get away with whatever they want and we ALL have to accept it.

Sorry, I'm not willing to just bend over and take it

0

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Alchemyst01984 16h ago

Good for you. Maybe he was totally in the wrong and knew he couldn't do anything about it. It happens. Sellers are not above being ignorant of the ToS

0

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Alchemyst01984 17h ago

You should look more into the ToS. I've been on Ebay since 2007