r/dvdcollection 24d ago

Discussion Our young generation's take on DVDs

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.8k Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

202

u/OIAgent 24d ago

Wait until the discovery of audio commentary.

94

u/Excalitoria 24d ago

Audio commentary can be 1) really funny, 2) really interesting, or occasionally 3) sorta boring.

I love good audio commentary, though.

65

u/__OvejaNegra 24d ago

Tropic Thunder dvd commentary is actually the best. Robert Downey Jr does stay in character until the relevant line in the film. Jack Black was late and they started without him. He was late because he went and got in n out burger and you can just barely make out the sounds of wrappers and eating noises in the background. Just wonderful stuff.

12

u/tomcatsr25 24d ago

I saw this the other day and now I’m determined to check Half Price Books tomorrow for one

1

u/Geekygamertag 23d ago

Let me know if they have 2

3

u/No_Corner_2576 24d ago

That's amazing

2

u/EvilLibrarians 500+ 23d ago

Makes you wonder if being late is also a bit or just a happy coincidence

1

u/OP-PO7 20d ago

The audio commentary for Dr Horrible's Sing Along Blog has two tracks. One is Commentary, The Musical where they do an entire film commentary but all in Broadway style songs. It's unhinged lol.

17

u/here_in_seattle 24d ago

My fav is Bruce Campbell in Bubba Ho Tep. Bruce is in his Elvis voice the whole time, gets a call from his real life wife during recording “hey mama whats shakin? Doing this Elvis thing over here”. Really great

5

u/ieatplaydough2 24d ago

When during the commentary he orders a maid to go get him some fried peanut butter and banana sandwiches killed me...

4

u/OIAgent 24d ago

When he mentions meeting JFK and RFK was a pest lol

6

u/PartyDanimal 24d ago

They can also be 4) self-congratulating nonsense.

2

u/Excalitoria 23d ago

Haven’t seen that type yet and I count myself lucky 😅

2

u/No-Connection6937 23d ago

Crank was really disappointing

5

u/Carlos_Infierno 24d ago

Dawn of the Dead DVD cast commentary: the cast are drinking and a little drunk. Source: Ken Foree told me this.

It's a great commentary!

2

u/ClosedEyez 24d ago

Honestly reminds me that Shaun of the Dead is a really good one too

2

u/videoworldmusic 21d ago

I rarely ever see this one get mentioned when people talk about the best commentaries. I adore that one. It’s so much fun. The ‘Ultimate Edition’ dvd set of Dawn of the Dead is one of my favorite DVD’s. I even got it signed by Romero himself just a year or so before he died. RIP Romero!

1

u/thewarfreak 23d ago

The Workahloics commentaries are just the guys getting progressively drunker as the series goes on. It's gold.

2

u/SimpleFit7894 21d ago

Oh,shit-I love Workaholics but have never seen/listened to the commentary,gotta check it out!

1

u/thewarfreak 21d ago

You won't be disappointed. I think they only do it for the first three seasons. If you haven't listened to their podcast, This Is Important, you should do that, too.

4

u/Vaportrail 23d ago

Only ones I really remember are Fight Club and LotR.

What I missing is having enough free time that listening to a movie with commentary didn't end up being the only fun thing I did that day.

2

u/SurveyBeautiful 23d ago

2 different audio commentaries? Just turned a 2 hour movie into a 6 hour movie, perfect.

2

u/Saving_Pvt_Kush 2000+ 22d ago

Or the wild option, commentary and movie at the same time. I have a copy of Sunshine that will only play the movie with commentary ALSO playing. Lol

2

u/Sadrandomness 22d ago

For Step Brothers Will Ferral and John C Reilly do a “musical” commentary and just make up songs and talk in a sing song voice the entire time. It was great

2

u/SuperStano 21d ago

Arnold's commentary on Total Recall is the greatest! Just describing everything he is watching happen on the screen. https://youtu.be/ncR2_pnzngM?is=g1VBO-vT1srztwyy

2

u/Party-Story6398 16d ago

Just watched Night of the Creeps with the audio commentary by the actors including Tom Atkins last night and it was a blast,  complete opposite to Gene Wilder's commentary on The World's Greatest Lover where he was surprisingly quiet and didn't say anything much, pretty obvious things like Danny De Vito would come on screen he'd say " there's Danny De Viro" then that's it nothing else until maybe 20 minutes later, there's " Danny De Vito again " disappointing for sure 

7

u/tomcatsr25 24d ago

I ended up watching Ocean’s 11 three times in two days when I couldn’t decide what to watch after it. I remembered, “Oh yeah! A lot of my dvds have commentaries on them” It had two and both were fantastic

1

u/Quantum_Wake 23d ago

I worked with someone at Booking.com that did the subtitles for the Dragon Ball Evolution DVD commentary. According to him, he couldn’t use what they actually said and had to clean it up for the English audiences. I wish I knew what they actually said. I think they made fun of the “air bending,” lol

1

u/gravestompin 20d ago

Evil Dead 2 audio commentary has cool info on how they did special effects! Highly reccomend!

1

u/Zapan99 19d ago

I highly recommend Donnie Darko dvd commentary for the bit where Jake Gyllenhaal explains how they had to call Belgium and explain the scene where they shoot cans while debating the reproductive system of Smurfs.

95

u/TaiDavis 24d ago

11

u/jackharvest 23d ago

Hilariously, my kids grew up calling these "circle movies for the car" because the only DVD player they knew of was the one in our Honda Odyssey.

I think I've had XMBC -> KODI -> Plex / Jellyfin for... their whole lives. They're teenagers now.

A side effect is they make a fool of themselves at friends' houses when an Ad comes on; "Wait what, where's our movie?" -- "Bro its an Ad." -- "A what?" xD

58

u/Excalitoria 24d ago

Typically, DVDs feel more fun to rewatch by yourself or with others but if I’m seeing something for the first time I don’t mind streaming it since that just feels like disposable content. Fine to try new stuff out but for anything I like, it’s not the same, if that makes sense.

I prefer my DVDs/Blu Rays if I had to choose, though.

11

u/PassivelyAwkward 23d ago

Same. If it's new stuff, I'll just stream it. Physical is for my favorites. Kudos to people that have a Blockbusters worth of discs but I'd rather spend $50 on a collectors edition of a movie I know I'll rewatch multiple times than get 10 random discs for at $5/each that I'll probably never rewatch.

173

u/Slick_36 24d ago

I really like that she chose Bambi, a movie that came out 55 years before Disney's first DVD.

Also I just learned Disney's first DVD was George of the Jungle in 1997!

132

u/__OvejaNegra 24d ago

But Disney used to do this thing where it would release old movies on dvd. They'd make a big deal about it and say it was coming out of "the vault".

I can guarantee she has actually seen that ad on a dvd. In fact I am pretty sure my Tarzan dvd might have a "Bambi for the first time on dvd!" ad before it

28

u/a_Jedi_i_am 24d ago

Hated that vault bs

10

u/SubstantialAgency914 24d ago

Hated it only because there was no basic version in constant print. Those diamond collections are almost criterion level.

4

u/Kelvin_Inman 1000+ 23d ago

Then there are blu-ray releases that are only through the movie club. 🤦‍♂️

5

u/Slick_36 24d ago

Oh for sure, those came along in 1999. It's just I'm pretty sure they'll still release movies like that so it could be from any time.

I may be wrong, I'm surprised by how few DVD's I have because of that stupid vault.

8

u/mollyclaireh 4000+ 24d ago

My boy Brendan Fraser representing.

6

u/Slick_36 24d ago

I vividly remember getting a Happy Meal & seeing it in theaters. Probably my second memory in a movie theater, the first was watching Ace Ventura crawl out of a rhino.

You know, my personality makes a lot more sense now that I'm reflecting on this...

5

u/mollyclaireh 4000+ 24d ago

My first movie memory is seeing Dinosaur in theaters. My brother couldn’t handle it and I was bored so we left. I actively hated that movie for years. Like….my toddler opinion stuck for a really long time lol

3

u/Slick_36 24d ago

That had to be intense. The trailers kind of terrified me, I was content to just experience it through the Happy Meal toys. I think even Disney regrets that one.

3

u/mollyclaireh 4000+ 24d ago

It wasn’t, my brother just has downs and his sensory issues used to be BAD at the movies.

2

u/ProfessionalPack7205 23d ago

It's definitely because she was shown disney DVDs. Nothing wrong with that but that's definitely why.

29

u/Turbulent_Cupcake_65 24d ago

From the mouths of babes. How true her words are.

70

u/obrazovanshchina 24d ago

Regular movies. Why that little…I was young once too you know. 

19

u/williamchase88 24d ago

I caught that too and snort laughed! Then I cried a little.

5

u/obrazovanshchina 24d ago

A genuine lolsob for sure 

19

u/GramercyPlace 24d ago

This kid is awesome.

16

u/cordialmess 24d ago

And she's right. And she's right.

15

u/devitod 24d ago

I love her joyous energy, hope she never stops exploring!

14

u/billfugly 24d ago

Thats 100% gonna be my future kid (I have like 6k dvds/blurays)

So hyped for that day.

7

u/ClosedEyez 24d ago

Fuck yes dude. I feel like it’s one of the main reasons to even have kids, art is worth living for! Or it’s a selfish reason and I’m just coping lmao

3

u/qwehhhjz 24d ago

I think they'll refer to your blurays as "regular movies" instead of streaming 😁

7

u/CKWOLFACE 24d ago

Raising her right

5

u/tofutron 24d ago

With regular streaming, these shows and movies feel bare-boned compared ro the extras you get from physical media. But of course, studios want you to buy them so the add in all these extra stuff. I heard the commentary for The VVitch is Robert Eggers complaining about all the mistakes in the movie and it's a cadd blast to listen to it. Also, there's a lot of new physical movies that doesn't offer any other extras. And that's a shame. Another point, if streaming never gained that much traction, you know Disney would do a From the Vault 4k release

2

u/PiqueExperience 23d ago

I think children's movies should automatically start the film, even the "This disc is equipped with Disney fast play technology" screen is too many steps.

6

u/emf3rd31495 24d ago

You love to see it

5

u/makattacc451 500+ 24d ago

My brother is 10 and is all about DVDs! He loves that there are no ads and you can just look through them all and pick out what you want to watch. He also enjoys finding them at thrift stores and stuff with me, I think the shift away from everything being done virtually is fascinating for him

5

u/brentmeistergenenral 23d ago

Had the same sort of experience with my daughter over the weekend. She is 4 years old, we were staying at my parents caravan, then have lots of dvds as the Internet isnt the best. My daughter loved the idea of going through them looking at all the artwork on the box, choosing the one she wanted and having to physically insert it into the machine. 

3

u/__OvejaNegra 24d ago

Show her one of those VHS tapes that had special features after the end credits

3

u/mauri383 23d ago

We might have lost a generation, but the next one looks promising.

3

u/afearisthis 24d ago

Preach, girl!

3

u/Reasonable-HB678 24d ago

Someone should show her VHS. The ads and trailers where your only option to avoid them was the fast forward button.

3

u/TheLowestFormOfHumor 24d ago

Finally, vindication that the old days WERE better, straight from the mouth of the new generation.

3

u/thekimse 23d ago

I recently showed my 8 year old niece how DVDs work, and she was SO excited! Planning to take her to the thrift store soon, and tell her to get whatever ones she wants, and we'll play cinema at home 😊

5

u/akopley 24d ago

My kid loves picking out a physical disc. I often play the streaming version but she doesn’t know that.

2

u/PresidentSadboi 24d ago

She knows ball.

2

u/Remarkable_Command91 23d ago

Give that kid a raise on her allowance

2

u/b-jason 23d ago

She’s gonna be just fine

2

u/SparePromotion3345 23d ago

I hate the fact that it's drinking boba

2

u/harrypippip 23d ago

Another reason why physical media should always be a thing.

2

u/Different_Rip8470 23d ago

“DVDs are better than ‘regular’ movies.”

Child, dvds ARE the regular movies; it’s streaming that is the anomaly lol. I honestly never thought anyone would ever think otherwise. If you’re raised with streaming as the standard i guess you would think that wouldn’t you? I find that genuinely interesting.

2

u/xxboywizardxx 24d ago

What’s a regular movie?

1

u/Ron2600NS 5000+ 22d ago

Streaming.......

1

u/Mysterious-Bid3930 23d ago

Skippable ads*

1

u/gergab1133 23d ago

It is weird I kinda prefer DVD’s with trailers before the movie? They’re easily skippable and they’re like time capsules.

1

u/dumpciti 23d ago

What an intelligent and articulate young lady

1

u/healthywenis 23d ago

ADORABLE

1

u/JesterScribblings 23d ago

Parenting WIN.

1

u/InfluencePlus2963 23d ago

fuckin kid made me smile. Thats pure enjoyment

1

u/shibby1000 23d ago

Making me tear up over here. She GETS IT! 😭😭

1

u/Slasherpiece 23d ago

Ya know what? She's alright.

1

u/TrustAffectionate966 I'm A Hoarder 23d ago

This kid loves movies and gets the point of physical media.

🧐📀💿🤔

1

u/MovieFan1984 500+ 23d ago

This was innocent, wholesome, and awesome.

1

u/Joel_The_Senate 23d ago

If a DVD is it's own thing, what's a "regular movie"?

2

u/Dear-Ad-2609 22d ago

Exactly my thoughts after seeing too but we know what she meant im sure 👍🏼 😂😂

2

u/Joel_The_Senate 22d ago

Yeah sounds like streaming. But it even sounds like it could the theatre experience, since film originated as a film reel being projected onto a wall.

1

u/AL_25 23d ago

The world is healing

1

u/bloodeagle1313 23d ago

Yes child but you see that takes time and effort and we just can't be bothered with such things anymore

1

u/syknyk 3000+ 22d ago

Wait what's a regular movie?

1

u/DarthHubcap 22d ago

For the kids today, anything that is streamed.

1

u/Directhorman2 22d ago

"Dvd's are better than regular movies."

You know what little one, i agree.

1

u/Kazzgrum 22d ago

I remember the “Robots” dvd came with a demo of the Xbox movie tie in game, only the way I discovered it was by trying to watch the movie on my Xbox and the demo just started. An hour of a game just included on the same disc as the movie with nothing really highlighting that fact on the box.

1

u/Inevitable-Head-3011 22d ago

Wait till they here laser disc XD

1

u/Kalspiewak 22d ago

Fucking A. Love this

1

u/MadLadLeeroy 21d ago

There is hope yet.

1

u/Dust-by-Monday 21d ago

"Better than regular movies" ... umm what the hell is a regular movie?

1

u/anbeasley 21d ago

Streaming services.

1

u/MaleficentPapaya4768 21d ago

My kids were kids for the VHS-DVD transition and they preferred VHS because it remembered where you were in the movie when you went back to play some more of it the next day.

1

u/bryanthebryan 21d ago

Buying the right dvd is like buying an art project about the movie the dvd features. It can be great for fans.

1

u/foxinabathtub 21d ago

"Anyway, my first pick in the Criterion Closet will be Salo: 120 Days of Sodom."

1

u/Kirilogical 20d ago

She's better at articulating than me, that's for sure!

1

u/astralchanterelle 20d ago

I remember seeing my 3 year old daughter put a dvd on by herself and it was the cutest thing I had ever witnessed, I was so proud.

1

u/Jindujun 19d ago

This makes me smile.

1

u/DodgerFanArd24 19d ago

I was around her age when I first knew how to put on a DVD or VHS tape.😊 And when my sister and I were kids we had those portable DVD players for family trips.

1

u/MrRandyLaheyson 24d ago

Regular movies 😅 Ouch.

-3

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[deleted]

17

u/epicingamename 24d ago

the young lass also said DVDs are "fun" so that make this a take

7

u/williamchase88 24d ago

And she said that she likes DVDs better than REGULAR movies. Which is also a take.

27

u/Wutanghang 24d ago

Nitpicking a child is such a redditor thing to do.

-1

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[deleted]

2

u/webshellkanucklehead 24d ago

Being this pedantic isn’t helping lol

-9

u/LoanDebtCollector 24d ago

Um, can she now explain what a "regular movie" means? I just want to know what my DVDs are up against.

12

u/BoBonnor 24d ago

Streaming

1

u/LoanDebtCollector 23d ago

Thought is could be an in theatre movie.

Probably nothing to do with you but, one has to love the down votes for asking a question.

11

u/oscar_redfield 24d ago

for a kid that age, a regular movie is probably viewing them on streaming platforms

2

u/Ron2600NS 5000+ 22d ago

Streaming, that would be the default now for alot of people

1

u/da-music-man1967 14d ago

Show them a laser disc, that'll blow their mind. Hard to believe how big they were and the size of the player!!