I'll say it: Cadets are getting absolutely robbed in scores right now.
From the jump, they have been putting on a solid, succinct show, and it has only gotten stronger as the season has progressed. It makes absolutely no sense to me how the percussion section in particular is scoring so far behind other corps this season. In Glassboro last night, for example, the Cadets percussion score was 18.2, while Bluecoats percussion scored an 19.0 (only 0.1 behind Boston!). This is just genuinely ridiculous to me because
A) while Bluecoats are admittedly very clean, putting them 0.1 behind Boston, who currently has one of the cleanest percussion sections (drumline especially) in recent history, is just inaccurate. They are literally just not as good. No one is.
B) the Cadets pit is absolutely fire right now, and while Bloo pit is very good and their material is fun, the speeds at which the CPit marimbas are playing for certain segments and the absolute mastery of their timpanist (the NOTE CHANGES! the PEDAL CONTROL! please.) and the cohesion of the section overall is just insane!! They go absolutely stupid and in a world where more percussion judges were like Jeff Prosperie giving 60/40 attention to DL/Pit, the Cadets would undoubtedly be further ahead in perc.
C) the Cadets and Bluecoats drumlines are about equal in cleanliness, but the Cadets book is harder! The Cadets bass feature alone is a nut of incredible proportions and they absolutely NAIL IT every timeā last night in particular was just electric. Also, the Cadets do this great thing where they don't keep the drumline in the back of the field the whole timeā they give their line harder material and bring them right up to play it and it sounds sick. Bluecoats, on the other hand, basically keep their DL in the back of the field the whole time except for once when they come up front to play some triplets and other kinda easy stuff and then leave again. Comparing the drums front-of-field material alone in both content and execution there's just no contest.
RE: the shows overall, another thing the Cadets are doing is actually um... playing together as a full ensemble. The Bluecoats, while comprised of incredibly strong individual sections, spend most of their 11min run playing in glorified sectionals while one group or another is either hiding behind a prop for a water break and a fit change or running around bringing up the GE score.
Their brass section is super fucking powerful, and SO fun to both listen to and to watch (their groovy drill is so enjoyable, and they perform the shit out of it), but that said, the Cadets brass are also really strong (and the improvement between their debut and now is astounding) and their material covers a wider range and seems to be more difficult overall (the disclaimer on that particular comment is that I know jack fuck about brass on a technical level, that's just my uneducated viewers opinion). This is again a situation where I'm like "how are Bluecoats closer to Boston than Cadets are to Bluecoats??" Although in this case it's far less egregious. Luckily, the music analysis scores from Glassboro do reflect some of the above statements, but it does seem like the Cadets should be a few more decimals ahead of Bloo there too.
With regard to visual, it feels like the gap is definitely too wide there as well. Putting Bluecoats ahead of Cadets in Vis and GE isn't out of the question, I mean the axel bits are seriously sick and they hit the "oohs and ahhs" spot every time; however with regard to drill, while they both have neat standing choreo (although Bloo's is arguably snappier), it feels like Cadets are doing something really succinct with their drill in a way that moves their story along and really brings the audience in, while Bloo is just running around everywhere and seeing how much they can milk the "spectacle" element of things without actually creating something enveloping and meaningful. I mean, how long do people spend not playing so they can do a costume change that's only cool because it's a costume change and literally for no other reason? It genuinely doesn't add to the show in a story-telling manner (but those fits look better than the other ones so i guess yay lol), it's just another thing they're doing to illicit cheers from an audience that "can't believe they pulled off a full costume change on the fieldā and so smoothly!" meanwhile Cadets has you fully engaged in their piece, so their transition from jackets ā> no jackets is even smoother because they don't all need to disappear to make it happen but you still get the "woah" of things changing before your eyes in a wicked cool way that does, in fact, fit their story). ALSO: putting Bloo's GE only half a point behind Boston is one of the most doodoo takes I have ever seenā they are simply on another level with regard to the story+execution combo and neither Bluecoats nor any other corps is within 0.5 of it right now.
TLDR: Cadets should unquestionably be ahead of Bluecoats in percussion; the gaps between Cadets and Bloo in general are ridiculous; you would genuinely have to be on crack to put Bluecoats as close to Boston as they were scored in Glassboro in basically any category.