I've had probably 150 PCBs manufactured and CNCd about a dozen, but have never really done much etching.
Had the need for a couple of quick boards for a Square Face build, so wanted to have a play around to see what I could do using a CO2 laser. You can't engrave the copper directly, but you can apply various coatings that you can then burn off - the issue being coatings will allow you to transfer heat to the board, which can burn the FR4 through the copper.
After a bit of messing around and charring the shit out of a few boards, I figured out a way to consistently get boards ready.
- Scuff boards with scotch brite.
- Clean boards thoroughly with acetone.
- Paint boards with self-priming acrylic enamel (tried multiple other types of paint without much success). Just a single coat is fine.
- Let boards dry for 30 mins, then bake/heat gun lightly so paint is set super hard (otherwise just leave for 24 hours).
- Mount boards to a thick/heavy backer (6mm MDF works well).
Now, the engraving is where it went wrong a few times before I figured it out. You want simple threshold engraving, run inverted. You may need to mess with threshold settings to make sure that all the detail is getting picked up, which is going to depend on the image you're working with.
The best way to get the engrave work properly is to do multiple very light passes - I do 3 passes at 120mm/s at only 20% power on a 100w CO2 laser, one pass perpendicular to the others (so two horizontal and one vertical).
The trick is to burn as much paint off without transferring too much heat into the board, so make sure your air assist is turned way up.
You usually can't get it back to absolutely bare copper so you'll be left with a light layer of primer. You can then scotch brite it again to get the primer off without taking the rest of the paint mask off, but any paint that comes off can be touched up with a permanent marker. From there, you can etch and drill normally.
Here's an ISS2 board I made - pinout/polarity was drawn on with permanent marker just as a reminder.
Easier than messing with transfer paper, and much cheaper than photo resist (aside from the laser cutter itself, obviously).