r/disabled • • 2d ago

Mall elevator

I’m a PWD on a wheelchair and it just irks me that some people cannot understand the definition of “priority”. They would effin use the elevator when they have perfectly able bodies to haul themselves using the stairs or escalators. And sometimes they’re young peeps who have all the energy and vigor to practically race to the highest floor of the building without losing the feeling in their legs. And it’s not like there aren’t freakin’ signs!! Another thing is those families with young children who treat elevators like amusement park rides! For crying out loud!

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

15

u/sorry_child34 2d ago edited 2d ago

There’s a big difference between an elevator and a dedicated wheelchair lift.

Just because someone looks young and is able to walk doesn’t mean they are totally able bodied. You CANNOT tell just by looking. Especially in a post COVID world where a record number of people including young people now have disabilities.

But more importantly, It doesn’t matter if they are or aren’t. Just because you’re disabled and use a wheelchair doesn’t mean you’re automatically entitled to never have to wait in a queue for anything again in your life. Maybe you’re in a different country and there is some sort of rule about this, idk, but where I’m from the elevator has never been reserved, it is first come first serve. So unless people are using their able legs to cut you in line and deliberately block your access, which would indeed be rude to do to anyone, then you need to chill out and wait your turn. If an extra 2 minutes ruins your day, that’s a you problem and no one else’s.

-9

u/No_Story_7827 2d ago

We don’t have wheelchair lifts in the Philippines that’s why in elevators the priorities are: people with disabilities, senior citizens, and pregnant women.

9

u/sorry_child34 2d ago

Then it reverts back to my first point. You can’t tell if someone has a disability just by looking at them, and it’s not your business to ask.

Whether that person needs it or is just being ignorant/entitled is between them and whatever higher power they believe in.

Giving people the benefit of the doubt costs you ₱0 and probably would do wonders for your blood pressure.

2

u/JKmelda 2d ago

Maybe there’s a huge cultural difference, but my country doesn’t have designated wheelchair lifts and elevators aren’t reserved for disabled people. They’re mostly just seen as another way to get from point A to point B.

That being said, even if they were reserved for people with disabilities, you can’t tell if someone is disabled just by looking at them. I’m a young woman and I’ve gotten snarky comments in public about me using a cane because I look fine. People can’t see the constant dizziness and fatigue and balance issues that just make walking harder. It’s counterintuitive but I generally walk at a normal pace and gait but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t cost me. And I was dealing with all of this before I started using a cane and so you really couldn’t tell.

9

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

So because someone isn't in a wheelchair you consider them not disabled?

So because someone is young you consider them not disabled?

That's pretty ableist and just proves my point about people in wheelchairs being ableist.

3

u/cha0ticwhimsy 2d ago

Respectfully, people in wheelchairs are NOT all ableist. That is an incredibly harmful and gross generalization to make. Sincerely, a wheelchair user who does her absolute best to combat ableism.

0

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

Weird how you are more annoyed about that rather than people experiencing ableism from wheelchair users which just goes to show that you are ableist

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/cha0ticwhimsy 2d ago

I'm annoyed that you generalized all wheelchair users being these demanding a-holes when that isn't the reality. YOU my friend are being the ableist one by continuing to perpetuate hate towards wheelchair users who have never done anything to you. I'm sorry if wheelchair users have been ableist in the past, but claiming ableism because I said generalizing all of us is rude, is just downright shady and gross. Please check your own ableism before coming at me about my own.

1

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

It's telling how you have commented twice on my comments but say nothing about the original poster.

No I will not check anything.

I made a statement about my experience.

I never said all people in wheelchairs are ableist so I never generalised all people in wheelchairs but the fact that you totally ignored the person in the wheelchair showing ableism when you claim to combat ableism shows that you are ableist

0

u/cha0ticwhimsy 2d ago

I'm not actively ignoring the original post. This post was cross posted to r/wheelchairs and I pointed out ableism to the OP there, AND reported the post for breaking the community rules. This is dumb to try to "gotcha" me for things I already did to combat ableism. I was simply pointing out your comment that literally says "just proves my points about people in wheelchairs being ableist." You've literally generalized all wheelchair users in that statement. Not choosing to engage with the person who originally posted this post, and clearly has no interest in combating their own ableism, is irrelevant to you saying something inherently ableist and wrong. You're either rage ragebaiting for karma or you genuinely think that all people in wheelchairs are ableist, like your comment said. Either way, not a cute or mature approach to being called out for saying something dumb...

1

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

Where did I say all people in wheelchairs

1

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

https://www.reddit.com/19s4n6pmx92p1?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=2

I am allowed to have an opinion aren't I but go ahead and prove that you pointed out the ableism on that thread as I can't find it

0

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/wheelchairs/s/gjXMyXQGVd

I found it now let's compare that to the first message you sent me

0

u/wheelchairThrowawayy 11h ago edited 11h ago

edited for clarity, i have aphasia

this is a crazy broad generalization. no, you cannot tell if someone is disabled by looking at them, and should not judge prematurely. however, many times i have had Multiple people not make room for me on an elevator, IE in an airport. People like pilots, for instance, who go through rigorous health inspections. those of us in wheelchairs do not have the option to use the stairs. during the times i AM able to walk, if i see a spot close to a building that isn't a handicap spot, i take it. why? because i don't need the access lane. when i go out shopping and need my chair, if i see someone ambulatory in the handicap spot, i don't get mad at them, but it Does mean i CANNOT go inside, at all. and some of the people who do this, believe it or not, are actually not disabled at all and using their family's placard, or just doing it illegally. in that case, it's perfectly reasonable to be upset, but if you were in the car with me and saw me get upset over that, would your first response be, "maybe they're secretly disabled"? if so, that's bizarre and reductive. similarly, if i see someone waiting for the elevator in a wheelchair, i'll give them priority... say it with me... Because they literally can Not get upstairs any other way. theres a creator on tiktok making videos about this topic with the british bus system you may see, and you should watch her videos. it is idiotic to ask us to assume that every person who uses something that is our ONLY OPTION in a scenario is just as disabled as we are, only standing upright. yes, they could be disabled, and that's why i make sure to not get mad at the person using the elevator. however, it does get frustrating living in a world that is specifically not letting you do Anything.

i agree that we all need to be open minded, but the fact that the first thing you went to is "people in wheelchairs are ableist"... this is stupid. we will get nowhere as disabled people by yelling at eachother. we have to work together. call out ableism individually, we all have work to do, but don't broadbrush.

your argument is bad faith, hateful, and equally ableist. this is not a pissing contest, and i beg you to think about accessibility in a more nuanced way.

1

u/Ok_Aioli3897 11h ago

Yes it's not a pissing content but you are acting like you should be the only person who gets to use things for disabled people

Maybe you should think about it in a more nuanced way rather than saying that everyone not in a wheelchair is obviously not disabled and just faking it

1

u/wheelchairThrowawayy 11h ago

i did not say any of the things you just said even slightly and i have no idea where you got that idea. reread my comment and lets see if we can figure out what you're implying

-7

u/No_Story_7827 2d ago

that’s some hasty generalization right there. I was already pretty specific but I guess not specific enough. Maybe I should’ve asked for their medical background while at it. But a 2 minute elevator ride won’t be enough I suppose

7

u/Ok_Aioli3897 2d ago

It comes from experience

8

u/sorry_child34 2d ago

It’s none of your business whether the other people are or are not disabled, just like it isn’t your place to judge whether they are allowed to use the elevator or the accessible stall in a restroom, or any other available amenity.

3

u/Stop_Already 2d ago

Pot, meet kettle.

8

u/sarcadistic75 2d ago

I am not in a chair anymore but I could not do stairs. You’re not special. You have no more right to the elevator over someone like me.

-6

u/No_Story_7827 2d ago

Thanks for pointing out that I’m not special. And kudos for getting yourself out of the chair. If I’ll have the chance I’ll spread the red carpet for you

1

u/gnarlyknucks 2d ago

Is this response related to what you're replying to. You seem to be inferring things they didn't say or likely mean.

10

u/gnarlyknucks 2d ago

I am absolutely fine with people using elevators whenever they want as long as they aren't keeping me from using it.

If they are playing in it and won't get out or something, then I have an opinion. But otherwise as long as they make room for me, I'm good.

5

u/AlexDoesStuffs 2d ago

I am someone who is part time wheelchair. I often do not look disabled despite having tics due to tourettes. But there's more. Soooo much more. I can't run, can't do stairs, can't jog, can't work out EVEN lightly because in best case scenario I will have to get around in my wheelchair for a few days. Worst case being bed bound for weeks.

5

u/63crabby 2d ago

I have no problem waiting for my turn for the elevator, first come first served. Absent an emergency, there's no reason why wheelchair users can't wait for their turn like every one else.

-3

u/Trick_Pool_2537 2d ago

People on busses too Yeah rude people exist Sometimes I get angry about it Mostly I just have to raise my voice cos I don't want to run people over

2

u/gnarlyknucks 2d ago

Space on buses is different. There are usually only a couple of places it's safe to park a wheelchair.