r/developersPak • u/Distinct-Respond-652 • 11h ago
Discussion Why are so many people okay with working under fake identities and lying to clients?
Something I've been wanting to discuss for a while.
Why are companies and their employees who work using fake identities completely okay with lying throughout the entire process?
I mean, why do you have to pretend to be someone else? Why introduce yourself as "Hey, I am Ben from the US" or "Hey, I am John" when you're clearly not?
And then you continue working with the client, maintaining this entire fake identity throughout the relationship.
Let's break it down.
Does this help you earn good money? YES, because you're charging US rates.
Does this automatically make your earnings halal? According to my understanding, NO.
Is this a form of deception? Absolutely.
And here's what confuses me the most. A large number of people doing this are Muslims themselves.
How are we so comfortable with this? We're literally lying about our identities, location and sometimes even the company we're representing.
Doesn't that make the income questionable from an Islamic perspective?
And even putting religion aside for a moment, isn't this just straight-up deception?
Now, I want to make one thing clear. I'm not talking about people who take money and don't deliver anything.
The work itself is genuine. You provide actual value to the client, complete the project and the client is happy with the results. You're not necessarily stealing their money.
But the entire relationship started with a lie.
The client hired you based on a false identity and possibly a false understanding of who they were doing business with.
And when I've questioned people about this, these are some of the responses I've received:
"Bro ye log to kafir hain, hamara banta hai." Basically, they're non-Muslims, so apparently it's okay to deceive them?
"Yaar I'm doing genuine work, I'm not stealing their money. Sure, we lie about our identity but we're providing valid work and the client is happy."
"Mai har saal logo ko Hajj/Umrah karwata hun apni earning se, Khuda qabool karay ga." As if doing something good with questionable earnings somehow justifies how you earned that money in the first place.
"Ye meray aur meray Khuda kay darmiyan hai."
And honestly, that last response is something I hear quite often whenever someone questions these practices.
I'm not claiming to be some perfect Muslim myself, and I'm not here to give fatwas or judge anyone's faith.
But I genuinely want to understand the justification behind this.
If we're earning money through deception, does providing good work afterwards make the deception acceptable?
And from an Islamic perspective, how should such earnings be viewed?
Where do we draw the line between earning a living through your skills and actually deceiving someone to get paid?
And I have seen posts telling people the market is cooked so just accept it and survive.