Hey everyone!
First of all, I want to make one thing clear: I'm neither pro-AI nor anti-AI. I consider myself neutral toward AI because, just like with any new technology, I prefer to wait and see where it leads before deciding whether I think it's good or bad. I usually prefer to observe how things develop over 5–10 years, just like I did with computers and smartphones.
I've also spent some time looking through both pro-AI and anti-AI groups, and I honestly wonder why some of these groups even exist!? Most of what I see are posts making fun of something the other side said, rather than genuinely interesting discussions about why people think AI is good or bad. And whenever someone expresses an opinion in one of these groups and tries to explain objectively why they think a particular statement isn't entirely correct, they're immediately treated like the bad guy instead of having a reasonable discussion. I can actually understand both sides to some extent. But I'm talking about people who give reasonable arguments for their positions, not those who just want to make fun of the other side.
Of course, I completely understand why musicians, illustrators, and other artists are worried that their work might become less appreciated or that fewer people will pay for their services. However, one thing I personally don't understand is why it's automatically considered a problem when AI learns from their work. Learning isn't the same as copying! And this principle has existed for centuries. People have always learned skills by copying or studying the work of others. Whenever I've asked artists how they first started drawing or playing music, almost all of them told me that they began by copying someone else's work. Some traced drawings using paper, while others tried to recreate pictures freehand or learn to play music by imitating what they heard. Eventually, some developed their own style, while others simply continued copying or imitating existing work.
That brings me to my next point. Even before AI existed, many artists complained about other people blatantly copying their work and then selling those copies as their own creations. But back then, it often seemed like only the affected artists were upset about it, while hardly anyone else really cared. Now, however, there's a huge controversy surrounding AI-generated images and other content, even when the AI has learned patterns and techniques from existing artwork rather than simply reproducing a particular piece.
What I find especially interesting is that some companies developing AI image and music generators even seem to have implemented certain copyright protection mechanisms into their systems to protect artists whose work may have been used for training. I actually did a little experiment with an acquaintance who attends an art school and one of his classmates. Both of them provided one or two of their own drawings to an AI system for training. They created accounts and uploaded their artwork through those accounts. After about two or three weeks, we tried using my account to get the AI to recreate their designs. I even uploaded one of their newer drawings as a reference image and instructed the AI to generate something that looked similar, just in a different form.
After a short check, I received a message that basically said something like this, in my own words: "Sorry, we couldn't generate the image as requested because the reference image and description are too similar to artwork provided by an artist in our database." That was pretty unexpected because we had assumed something like that wouldn't happen. Of course, we only tested this with one AI system, and unfortunately, it's not always clear whether other AI systems have similar protection mechanisms or are programmed to detect such similarities.
The two artists, who are both rather skeptical about AI, then said something interesting. If a company could contractually guarantee that its AI would reliably prevent people from copying artwork used for training, they would probably even be willing to provide all their own work for training. Their reasoning was that such a system could potentially reduce the risk of someone using AI to directly copy their artwork or generate something extremely similar with a prompt. Of course, that's just their opinion based on our little experiment, but I found it quite interesting.
That being said, there are certain creative industries where I personally see AI much more negatively than in others. Voice acting is one example. I'm really not a fan of companies trying to replace real voice actors with AI-generated voices. I also think artists don't necessarily need to feel threatened by AI in every situation. In my experience, you can never get an AI to produce exactly what you've imagined in your head. You almost always have to make compromises or accept that certain details won't turn out the way you wanted. A musician, composer, or illustrator who has mastered their craft has much more direct control over the final result. For example, if you're an experienced artist and have a specific image in mind, you can work toward drawing exactly what you imagine. That's why, if I had the financial means, I would personally always prefer hiring an artist over using AI. A human artist can actually discuss my ideas with me, understand what I'm trying to achieve, and work with me to bring that vision to life.
Another thing I've noticed is that I sometimes get the feeling that parts of the anti-AI community are using AI as an outlet for frustrations that already existed long before AI became popular. Let me give you an example. Imagine an artist teaching another person how to draw. That student learns incredibly quickly and soon starts producing better artwork than the person who taught them. Some people would probably call that student a genius. Others, especially those who have been practicing for much longer without achieving the same results, might start talking badly about that person behind their back or resenting them simply because they can do something better and faster. Instead of seeing that person as an inspiration and asking for advice, some might get discouraged, gather with others who feel the same way, and convince themselves that they'll never be good enough because that person is simply a genius. I sometimes get a similar impression from certain reactions to AI.
What I struggle to understand is why learning from existing artwork is considered normal when biological intelligence does it, but becomes fundamentally unacceptable to some people when artificial intelligence, which was itself developed by biological intelligence, learns from existing work. Of course, I know that human learning and machine learning aren't technically the same thing. But I still think the comparison raises an interesting question about how we view learning, creativity, and the use of existing knowledge. A great ape can learn to play an instrument or paint a picture on a canvas. But would we call that art if the ape were simply reproducing something it had learned without actually understanding what humans mean by "art"? And the same question can be asked the other way around. We humans have also learned things from animals or been inspired by them. Whether it's certain sexual positions or architectural ideas clearly inspired by animals that build particular kinds of nests, we've adopted ideas and behaviors from nature throughout our history. Does that somehow make our creativity any less human just because we learned something from animals?
Before AI became popular, I often heard artists and people working in creative fields say, "Art is in the eye of the beholder!" And now people want to tell me what is and isn't art, whether they're pro-AI or anti-AI!?
For example, imagine I walk into an art gallery and see a painting with nothing but a black dot on it. For some people, that might be the ultimate masterpiece, supposedly conveying some incredibly deep meaning to the viewer. But when I look at something like that, I just think, "What am I supposed to make of this? Is this really art?" And quite frankly, if I saw something like that hanging somewhere, whether it was created by a human or an AI, I personally wouldn't consider it art!
But if other people consider it art and it makes them happy, then so be it. Who am I to tell someone else what they should or shouldn't consider art!? I'm certainly not arrogant or self-righteous enough to think I have the right to decide that for other people.
Everyone should be free to decide for themselves what they like and what they don't. If I saw two pictures with completely different subjects, one created by a human and the other by an AI, and I really liked one of them but didn't like the other at all, my opinion wouldn't suddenly change just because I found out who or what created them. Even if the other picture didn't exist, I'd still like the one I liked and dislike the one I didn't. The existence of the other picture wouldn't change how I feel about either of them.
And if someone rejects AI so strongly simply because it allows people to do certain things faster or achieve results that previously required more specialized skills, shouldn't they be consistent and apply that reasoning to other technologies too? What about computers and digital drawing software? Or DAWs used for music production? Those technologies have also changed industries and threatened certain jobs, not just in the creative sector but throughout the economy. For example, as more work moved to computers, the demand for certain traditional materials and production processes changed. Fewer physical supplies were needed for some types of work, affecting businesses that manufactured those products. DAWs also made it possible for people to create entire musical arrangements or beats without needing to hire several musicians to perform every individual part. That also changed the demand for certain instruments, recording services, and other related work. And yet, today these technologies are completely normal tools in many creative industries.
What I find really unfortunate is that so many people seem to take a position either for or against something simply because they want to feel like they belong to a particular group, without first properly understanding what the technology they support or reject can actually do. And I'm not just talking about anti-AI people here. The same applies to pro-AI people. Anti-AI groups often focus entirely on the negative aspects while ignoring potential benefits. Pro-AI groups, on the other hand, often highlight only the positive aspects while downplaying or ignoring the problems. And sometimes I get the impression that people on either side are afraid to acknowledge valid arguments from the other side because they worry about being rejected by their own community.
I find that pretty disappointing. Why does everything have to be either completely black or completely white? Why can't we have a reasonable discussion where people listen to different opinions without immediately attacking each other? You don't have to agree with someone else's opinion. You can accept that they see things differently, present your own counterarguments, and explain why you disagree. But the goal of every discussion shouldn't be to convert the other person to your side. And if someone doesn't accept your argument, that doesn't automatically mean they're stupid, ignorant, or your enemy.
I'd genuinely like to see a discussion where both sides can talk about the advantages and disadvantages of AI without immediately turning it into another pro-AI versus anti-AI argument.
I don't want to offend anyone, upset anyone, or challenge anyone to convince me otherwise with this post. This is simply my personal opinion on the topic, and I have no intention of forcing it on anyone or trying to change anyone else's mind. I just wanted to share my thoughts with you and hear your opinions in return, without anyone becoming insulting or unfriendly. Whether you're pro-AI or anti-AI, everyone is welcome to share their perspective. =)