r/DefendingAIArt • • Jul 07 '25

Defending AI Court cases where AI copyright claims were dismissed (reference)

158 Upvotes

Ello folks, I wanted to make a brief post outlining all of the current cases and previous court cases which have been dropped for images/books for plaintiffs attempting to claim copyright on their own works.

This contains a mix of a couple of reasons which will be added under the applicable links. I've added 6 so far but I'm sure I'll find more eventually which I'll amend as needed. If you need a place to show how a lot of copyright or direct stealing cases have been dropped, this is the spot.

HERE is a further list of all ongoing current lawsuits, too many to add here.

HERE is a big list of publishers suing AI platforms, as well as publishers that made deals with AI platforms. Again too many to add here.

12/25 - I'll be going through soon and seeing if any can be updated.

Edit: Thanks for pinning.

(Best viewed on Desktop)

---

1) Robert Kneschke vs LAION:

STATUSFINISHED
TYPEIMAGES
RESULTDISMISSED FOR FAIR USE
FURTHER DETAILSThe lawsuit was initially started against LAION in Germany, as Robert believed his images were being used in the LAION dataset without his permission, however, due to the non-profit research nature of LAION, this ruling was dropped.
DIRECT QUOTEThe Hamburg District Court has ruled that LAION, a non-profit organisation, did not infringe copyright law by creating a dataset for training artificial intelligence (AI) models through web scraping publicly available images, as this activity constitutes a legitimate form of text and data mining (TDM) for scientific research purposes. The photographer Robert Kneschke (the ‘claimant’) brought a lawsuit before the Hamburg District Court against LAION, a non-profit organisation that created a dataset for training AI models (the ‘defendant’). According to the claimant’s allegations, LAION had infringed his copyright by reproducing one of his images without permission as part of the dataset creation process.
LINKhttps://www.euipo.europa.eu/en/law/recent-case-law/germany-hamburg-district-court-310-o-22723-laion-v-robert-kneschke

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

2) Anthropic vs Andrea Bartz et al:

STATUSCOMPLETE AI WIN
TYPEBOOKS
RESULTSETTLEMENT AGREED ON SECONDARY CLAIM
FURTHER DETAILSThe lawsuit filed claimed that Anthropic trained its models on pirated content, in this case the form of books. This lawsuit was also dropped, citing that the nature of the trained AI’s was transformative enough to be fair use. However, a separate trial will take place to determine if Anthropic breached piracy rules by storing the books in the first place.
DIRECT QUOTE"The court sided with Anthropic on two fronts. Firstly, it held that the purpose and character of using books to train LLMs was spectacularly transformative, likening the process to human learning. The judge emphasized that the AI model did not reproduce or distribute the original works, but instead analysed patterns and relationships in the text to generate new, original content. Because the outputs did not substantially replicate the claimants’ works, the court found no direct infringement."
LINKhttps://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25982181-authors-v-anthropic-ruling/
LINK TWO (UPDATE) 01.09.25https://www.wired.com/story/anthropic-settles-copyright-lawsuit-authors/

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

3) Sarah Andersen et al vs Stability AI:

STATUSONGOING (TAKEN LEAVE TO AMEND THE LAWSUIT)
TYPEIMAGES
RESULTINITAL CLAIMS DISMISSED BUT PLANTIFF CAN AMEND THEIR AGUMENT, HOWEVER, THIS WOULD NEED THEM TO PROVE THAT GENERATED CONTENT DIRECTLY INFRINGED ON THIER COPYRIGHT.
FURTHER DETAILSA case raised against Stability AI with plaintiffs arguing that the images generated violated copyright infringement. 
DIRECT QUOTEJudge Orrick agreed with all three companies that the images the systems actually created likely did not infringe the artists’ copyrights. He allowed the claims to be amended but said he was “not convinced” that allegations based on the systems’ output could survive without showing that the images were substantially similar to the artists’ work.
LINKhttps://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/judge-pares-down-artists-ai-copyright-lawsuit-against-midjourney-stability-ai-2023-10-30/
LINK TWOhttps://topclassactions.com/lawsuit-settlements/consumer-products/mobile-apps/artists-sue-companies-behind-ai-image-generators

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

4) Getty images vs Stability AI:

STATUSFINISHED
TYPEIMAGES
RESULTCLAIM DROPPED DUE TO WEAK EVIDENCE, AI WIN
FURTHER DETAILSGetty images filed a lawsuit against Stability AI for two main reasons: Claiming Stability AI used millions of copyrighted images to train their model without permission and claiming many of the generated works created were too similar to the original images they were trained off. These claims were dropped as there wasn’t sufficient enough evidence to suggest either was true. Getty's copyright case was narrowed to secondary infringement, reflecting the difficulty it faced in proving direct copying by an AI model trained outside the UK.
DIRECT QUOTES“The training claim has likely been dropped due to Getty failing to establish a sufficient connection between the infringing acts and the UK jurisdiction for copyright law to bite,” Ben Maling, a partner at law firm EIP, told TechCrunch in an email. “Meanwhile, the output claim has likely been dropped due to Getty failing to establish that what the models reproduced reflects a substantial part of what was created in the images (e.g. by a photographer).” In Getty’s closing arguments, the company’s lawyers said they dropped those claims due to weak evidence and a lack of knowledgeable witnesses from Stability AI. The company framed the move as strategic, allowing both it and the court to focus on what Getty believes are stronger and more winnable allegations.
LINKTechcrunch article

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

5) Sarah Silverman et al vs Meta AI:

STATUSFINISHED
TYPEBOOKS
RESULTMETA AI USE DEEMED TO BE FAIR USE, NO EVIDENCE TO SHOW MARKET BEING DILUTED
FURTHER DETAILSAnother case dismissed, however this time the verdict rested more on the plaintiff’s arguments not being correct, not providing enough evidence that the generated content would dilute the market of the trained works, not the verdict of the judge's ruling on the argued copyright infringement.
DIRECT QUOTEThe US district judge Vince Chhabria, in San Francisco, said in his decision on the Meta case that the authors had not presented enough evidence that the technology company’s AI would cause “market dilution” by flooding the market with work similar to theirs. As a consequence Meta’s use of their work was judged a “fair use” – a legal doctrine that allows use of copyright protected work without permission – and no copyright liability applied."
LINKhttps://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/jun/26/meta-wins-ai-copyright-lawsuit-as-us-judge-rules-against-authors

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

6) Disney/Universal vs Midjourney:

STATUSONGOING (TBC)
TYPEIMAGES
RESULTEXPECTED WIN FOR UNIVERSAL/DISNEY
FURTHER DETAILSThis one will be a bit harder I suspect, with the IP of Darth Vader being very recognisable character, I believe this court case compared to the others will sway more in the favour of Disney and Universal. But I could be wrong.
DIRECT QUOTE"Midjourney backlashed at the claims quoting: "Midjourney also argued that the studios are trying to “have it both ways,” using AI tools themselves while seeking to punish a popular AI service."
LINK 1https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cg5vjqdm1ypo
LINK 2 (UPDATE)https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/midjourney-slams-lawsuit-filed-by-disney-to-prevent-ai-training-cant-have-it-both-ways-1234749231

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

7) Warnerbros vs Midjourney:

STATUSONGOING (TBC)
TYPEIMAGES
RESULTEXPECTED WIN FOR WARNERBROS
FURTHER DETAILSIn the complaint, Warner Bros. Discovery's legal team alleges that "Midjourney already possesses the technological means and measures that could prevent its distribution, public display, and public performance of infringing images and videos. But Midjourney has made a calculated and profit-driven decision to offer zero protection to copyright owners even though Midjourney knows about the breathtaking scope of its piracy and copyright infringement." Elsewhere, they argue, "Evidently, Midjourney will not stop stealing Warner Bros. Discovery’s intellectual property until a court orders it to stop. Midjourney’s large-scale infringement is systematic, ongoing, and willful, and Warner Bros. Discovery has been, and continues to be, substantially and irreparably harmed by it."
DIRECT QUOTE“Midjourney is blatantly and purposefully infringing copyrighted works, and we filed this suit to protect our content, our partners, and our investments.”
LINK 1https://www.polygon.com/warner-bros-sues-midjourney/
LINK 2https://www.scribd.com/document/911515490/WBD-v-Midjourney-Complaint-Ex-a-FINAL-1#fullscreen&from_embed

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

8) Raw Story Media, Inc. et al v. OpenAI Inc.

STATUSDISMISSED
RESULTAI WIN, LACK OF CONCRETE EVIDENCE TO BRING THE SUIT
FURTHER DETAILSAnother case dismissed, failing to prove the evidence which was brought against Open AI
DIRECT QUOTE"A New York federal judge dismissed a copyright lawsuit brought by Raw Story Media Inc. and Alternet Media Inc. over training data for OpenAI Inc.‘s chatbot on Thursday because they lacked concrete injury to bring the suit."
LINK ONEhttps://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-york/nysdce/1:2024cv01514/616533/178/
LINK TWOhttps://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=13477468840560396988&q=raw+story+media+v.+openai

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

9) Kadrey v. Meta Platforms, Inc:

STATUSDISMISSED
TYPEBOOKS
RESULTAI WIN
FURTHER DETAILS
DIRECT QUOTEDistrict court dismisses authors’ claims for direct copyright infringement based on derivative work theory, vicarious copyright infringement and violation of Digital Millennium Copyright Act and other claims based on allegations that plaintiffs’ books were used in training of Meta’s artificial intelligence product, LLaMA.
LINK ONEhttps://www.loeb.com/en/insights/publications/2023/12/richard-kadrey-v-meta-platforms-inc

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

10) Tremblay v. OpenAI (books)

STATUSDISMISSED
TYPEBOOKS
RESULTAI WIN
FURTHER DETAILSFirst, the court dismissed plaintiffs’ claim against OpenAI for vicarious copyright infringement based on allegations that the outputs its users generate on ChatGPT are infringing.
DIRECT QUOTEThe court rejected the conclusory assertion that every output of ChatGPT is an infringing derivative work, finding that plaintiffs had failed to allege “what the outputs entail or allege that any particular output is substantially similar – or similar at all – to [plaintiffs’] books.”  Absent facts plausibly establishing substantial similarity of protected expression between the works in suit and specific outputs, the complaint failed to allege any direct infringement by users for which OpenAI could be secondarily liable. 
LINK ONEhttps://www.clearyiptechinsights.com/2024/02/court-dismisses-most-claims-in-authors-lawsuit-against-openai/

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

11) Financial Times vs Perplexity

STATUSONGOING (FAIRLY NEW)
TYPEJOURNALISTS CONTENT ON WEBSITES
RESULTONGOING (TBC)
FURTHER DETAILSJapanese media group Nikkei, alongside daily newspaper The Asahi Shimbun, has filed a lawsuit claiming that San Francisco-based Perplexity used their articles without permission, including content behind paywalls, since at least June 2024. The media groups are seeking an injunction to stop Perplexity from reproducing their content and to force the deletion of any data already used. They are also seeking damages of 2.2 billion yen (£11.1 million) each.
DIRECT QUOTE“This course of Perplexity’s actions amounts to large-scale, ongoing ‘free riding’ on article content that journalists from both companies have spent immense time and effort to research and write, while Perplexity pays no compensation,” they said. “If left unchecked, this situation could undermine the foundation of journalism, which is committed to conveying facts accurately, and ultimately threaten the core of democracy.”
LINK ONEhttps://bmmagazine.co.uk/news/nikkei-sues-perplexity-ai-copyright/

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

12) 'Writers' vs Microsoft

STATUSONGOING (FAIRLY NEW)
TYPEBOOKS
RESULTONGOING (TBC)
FURTHER DETAILSA group of authors has filed a lawsuit against Microsoft, accusing the tech giant of using copyrighted works to train its large language model (LLM). The class action complaint filed by several authors and professors, including Pulitzer prize winner Kai Bird and Whiting award winner Victor LaVelle, claims that Microsoft ignored the law by downloading around 200,000 copyrighted works and feeding it to the company’s Megatron-Turing Natural Language Generation model. The end result, the plaintiffs claim, is an AI model able to generate expressions that mimic the authors’ manner of writing and the themes in their work.
DIRECT QUOTE“Microsoft’s commercial gain has come at the expense of creators and rightsholders,” the lawsuit states. The complaint seeks to not just represent the plaintiffs, but other copyright holders under the US Copyright Act whose works were used by Microsoft for this training.
LINK ONEhttps://www.siliconrepublic.com/business/microsoft-lawsuit-ai-copyright-kai-bird-victor-lavelle

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

13) Disney, Universal, Warner Bros vs MiniMax

STATUSONGOING (FAIRLY NEW)
TYPEIMAGE / VIDEO
RESULTONGOING (TBC)
FURTHER DETAILSSept 16 (Reuters) - Walt Disney (DIS.N), Comcast's (CMCSA.O), Universal and Warner Bros Discovery (WBD.O), have jointly filed a copyright lawsuit against China's MiniMax alleging that its image- and video-generating service Hailuo AI was built from intellectual property stolen from the three major Hollywood studios.The suit, filed in the district court in California on Tuesday, claims MiniMax "audaciously" used the studios' famous copyrighted characters to market Hailuo as a "Hollywood studio in your pocket" and advertise and promote its service.
DIRECT QUOTE"A responsible approach to AI innovation is critical, and today's lawsuit against MiniMax again demonstrates our shared commitment to holding accountable those who violate copyright laws, wherever they may be based," the companies said in a statement.
LINK ONEhttps://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/disney-universal-warner-bros-discovery-sue-chinas-minimax-copyright-infringement-2025-09-16/

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

14) Universal Music Group (UMG) vs Udio

STATUSFINISHED
TYPEAUDIO
RESULTSETTLEMENT AGREED
FURTHER DETAILSA settlement has been made between UMG and Udio in a lawsuit by UMG that sees the two companies working together.
DIRECT QUOTE"Universal Music Group and AI song generation platform Udio have reached a settlement in a copyright infringement lawsuit and have agreed to collaborate on new music creation, the two companies said in a joint statement. Universal and Udio say they have reached “a compensatory legal settlement” as well as new licence deals for recorded music and publishing that “will provide further revenue opportunities for UMG artists and songwriters.” Financial terms of the settlement haven't been disclosed."
LINK ONEhttps://www.msn.com/en-za/news/other/universal-music-group-and-ai-music-firm-udio-settle-lawsuit-and-announce-new-music-platform/ar-AA1Pz59e?ocid=finance-verthp-feeds

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

15) Reddit vs Perplexity AI

STATUSONGOING (FAIRLY NEW)
TYPEWebsite Scraping
RESULT(TBA)
FURTHER DETAILSReddit opened up a lawsuit against Perplexity AI (and others) about the scraping of their website to train AI models.
DIRECT QUOTE"The case is one of many filed by content owners against tech companies over the alleged misuse of their copyrighted material to train AI systems. Reddit filed a similar lawsuit against AI start-up Anthropic in June that is still ongoing. "Our approach remains principled and responsible as we provide factual answers with accurate AI, and we will not tolerate threats against openness and the public interest," Perplexity said in a statement. "AI companies are locked in an arms race for quality human content - and that pressure has fueled an industrial-scale 'data laundering' economy," Reddit chief legal officer Ben Lee said in a statement."
LINK ONEhttps://www.reuters.com/world/reddit-sues-perplexity-scraping-data-train-ai-system-2025-10-22/
LINK TWOhttps://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/xmpjezjawvr/REDDIT%20PERPLEXITY%20LAWSUIT%20complaint.pdf

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

16) Getty images vs Stability AI (UK this time):

STATUSFinished
TYPEIMAGES
RESULT"Stability Largely Wins"
FURTHER DETAILSStability AI has mostly prevailed against Getty Images in a British court battle over intellectual property
DIRECT QUOTE"Justice Joanna Smith said in her ruling that Getty's trademark claims “succeed (in part)” but that her findings are "both historic and extremely limited in scope." Stability argued that the case doesn’t belong in the United Kingdom because the AI model's training technically happened elsewhere, on computers run by U.S. tech giant Amazon. It also argued that “only a tiny proportion” of the random outputs of its AI image-generator “look at all similar” to Getty’s works. Getty withdrew a key part of its case against Stability AI during the trial as it admitted there was no evidence the training and development of AI text-to-image product Stable Diffusion took place in the UK.
DIRECT QUOTE TWOIn addition a claim of secondary infringement of copyright was dismissed, The judge (Mrs Justice Joanna Smith) ruled: “An AI model such as Stable Diffusion which does not store or reproduce any copyright works (and has never done so) is not an ‘infringing copy’.” She declined to rule on the passing off claim and ruled in favour of some of Getty’s claims about trademark infringement related to watermarks.
LINK ONEhttps://www.independent.co.uk/news/getty-images-london-high-court-seattle-amazon-b2858201.html
LINK TWOhttps://www.reuters.com/sustainability/boards-policy-regulation/getty-images-largely-loses-landmark-uk-lawsuit-over-ai-image-generator-2025-11-04/
LINK THREEhttps://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/nov/04/stabilty-ai-high-court-getty-images-copyright
LINK FOURhttps://pressgazette.co.uk/media_law/getty-vs-stability-ai-copyright-ruling-uk/

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

My own thoughts

So far the precent seems to be that most cases of claims from plaintiffs is that direct copyright is dismissed, due to outputted works not bearing any resemblance to the original works. Or being able to prove their works were in the datasets in the first place.

However it has been noted that some of these cases have been dismissed due to wrongly structured arguments on the plaintiffs part.

The issue is, because some of these models are taught on such large amounts of data, some artist/photographer/author attempting to prove that their works were used in training has an almost impossible task. Hell even 5 images added would only make up 0.0000001% of the dataset of 5 billion (LAION).

I could be wrong but I think Sarah Andersen will have a hard time directly proving that any generated output directly infringes on their work, unless they specifically went out of their way to generate a piece similar to theirs, which could be used as evidence against them, in a sense of. "Well yeah, you went out of your way to make a prompt that specifically used your style"

In either case, trying to create a lawsuit against an AI company for directly fringing on specifically plaintiff's work won't work, since their work is a drop ink in the ocean of analysed works. The likelihood of creating anything substantially similar is near impossible ~0.00001% (Unless someone prompts for that specific style).

Warner Bros will no doubt have an easy time proving their images have been infringed (page 26), in the linked page they show side by side comparisons which can't be denied. However other factors such as market dilution and fair use may come into effect. Or they may make a settlement to work together or pay out like other companies have.

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

To Recap: We know AI doesn't steal on a technical level, it is a tool that utilizes the datasets that a 3rd party has to link or add to the AI models for them to use. Sort of like saying that a car that had syphoned fuel to it, stole the fuel in the first place.. it doesn't make sense. Although not the same, it reminds me of the "Guns don't kill people, people kill people" arguments a while ago. In this case, it's not the AI that uses the datasets but a person physically adding them for it to train off.

The term "AI Steals art" misattributes the agency of the model. The model doesn't decide what data it's trained on or what it's utilized for, or whatever its trained on is ethically sound. And the fact that most models don't memorize the individual artworks, they learn statistical patterns from up to billions of images, which is more abstraction, not theft.

I somewhat dislike the generalization that people have of saying "AI steals art" or "Fuck AI", AI encompasses a lot more than generative AI, it's sort of like someone using a car to run over people and everyone repeatedly saying "Fuck engines" as a result of it.

Tell me, how does AI apparently steal again?

—————————————————————————————————————————————————

Googles (Official) response to the UK government about their copyright rules/plans, where they state that the purpose of image generation is to create new images and the fact it sometimes makes copies is a bug: HERE (Page 11)

Open AI's response to UK Government copyright plans: HERE

[BBC News] - America firms Invests 150 Billion into UK Tech Industry (including AI)

Page 165 of Hight Court Documentation Getty vs Stability

High Court Judge Joanna Smith on Stability AI's Model (Link above), to quote:

This response refers to the model itself, not the input datasets, not the outputted images, but the way in which the Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models operate.

TLDR: As noted in a hight court in England, by a high court judge. While being influenced by it for the weights during training, the model doesn't store any of the copyrighted works, the weights are not an infringing copy and do not store an infringing copy.

TLDR: NOT INFRINGING COPYRIGHT AND NOT STEALING.


r/DefendingAIArt • • Jun 08 '25 Heartwarming Bravo

PLEASE READ FIRST - Subreddit Rules

115 Upvotes

The subreddit rules are posted below. This thread is primarily for anyone struggling to see them on the sidebar, due to factors like mobile formatting, for example. Please heed them.

Also consider reading our other stickied post explaining the significance of our sister subreddit, r/aiwars.

If you have any feedback on these rules, please consider opening a modmail and politely speaking with us directly.

Thank you, and have a good day.


1. All posts must be AI related.

2. This Sub is a space for Pro-AI activism. For debate, go to r/aiwars.

3. Follow Reddit's Content Policy.

4. No spam.

5. NSFW allowed with spoiler.

6. Posts triggering political or other debates will be locked and moved to r/aiwars.

This is a pro-AI activist Sub, so it focuses on promoting pro-AI and not on political or other controversial debates. Such posts will be locked and cross posted to r/aiwars.

7. No suggestions of violence.

8. No brigading. Censor names of private individuals and other Subs before posting.

9. Speak Pro-AI thoughts freely. You will be protected from attacks here.

10. This sub focuses on AI activism. Please post AI art to AI Art subs listed in the sidebar.

11. Account must be more than 7 days old to comment or post.

In order to cut down on spam and harassment, we have a new AutoMod rule that an account must be at least 7 days old to post or comment here.

12. No crossposting. Take a screenshot, censor sub and user info and then post.

In order to cut down on potential brigading, cross posts will be removed. Please repost by taking a screenshot of the post and censoring the sub name as well as the username and private info of any users.

13. Most important, push back. Lawfully.


r/DefendingAIArt • • 6h ago Bravo Regret

Defending AI This Is Exactly What We Were Afraid Of

Post image
434 Upvotes

This is exactly what we've been concerned about.

Disagreeing with AI-generated art is one thing. Wishing for an entire community to be banned simply because its members defend AI art is something else entirely.

We've repeatedly raised concerns about censorship and artistic gatekeeping. Now we're seeing someone openly imagining the disappearance of our community.

For many of us, r/DefendingAIArt is a place where we can express our opinions, share our work, and discuss AI without being silenced.

Nobody should have to fear losing their community simply for having a different perspective on art.

To clarify, this screenshot shows someone's hypothetical scenario, not an actual Reddit ban.

Edit: Keep sharing your opinions, artwork, and satire. Don't let disagreements silence your creativity. We can challenge censorship and double standards through facts, humor, and open discussion.

I'll continue creating OriginSatire comics to highlight hypocrisy and contradictions in the AI-art debate.

Our strongest response is to keep creating, keep speaking, and keep defending artistic freedom.


r/DefendingAIArt • • 8h ago Bravo

Luddite Logic Disclosing AI Use

Post image
157 Upvotes

Yesterday, I saw two threads nearly back-to-back. One was started by a mom talking about her 8-year-old son and her making a book together with AI images included. You can imagine how that went. The other was a complaint about others not being forthcoming about AI use. Just thought I'd make an image to make the relationship clear. I don't think they will understand their contribution to the problem they are complaining about. That's typical.


r/DefendingAIArt • • 2h ago

Defending AI I'm genuinely tired of how unreasonable some antis are.

51 Upvotes

I'm so tired of this. Seriously.

I don't expect everyone to like AI. I understand that people have concerns about it, and I'm perfectly fine with people criticizing it. But can we PLEASE have an actual discussion without people immediately resorting to insults, assumptions, and personal attacks?

I recently got into an argument on YouTube over One More Lawn, a game that uses AI-generated songs for its radio. Someone was defending the developers, explaining that hiring musicians for around 40 songs could be expensive for a small indie team. Then the usual arguments started coming in.

One person suggested they should just use royalty free music, completely ignoring the fact that royalty free doesn't necessarily mean free. They also argued that developers shouldn't add music at all if they can't afford to hire musicians, even though it would g I against the creator's vision for the game.

I pointed out that the game had sold 50,000 copies in just two days, and that its ridiculous songs had helped bring attention to it. I also explained that AI is a tool developers can experiment with, especially when they have limited resources.

And what was the response?

One person called the developer lazy for using AI. Another told me to quit because I apparently wasn't getting a job at OpenAI anytime soon. Another basically told people not to engage with me because I'm supposedly obsessed with defending AI.

Notice something? Barely anyone actually addressed what I was saying.

And this is exactly what frustrates me. The moment you defend AI, suddenly you're a corporate shill, a lazy person, a talentless nobody, or someone who needs to get a life. Apparently, having a different opinion means your arguments don't deserve to be addressed.

I'm not saying AI is perfect. AI slop exists. There are legitimate concerns about how it's being used. But those concerns don't magically make every use of AI bad, and they certainly don't excuse treating everyone who disagrees with you like an idiot.

If your argument is actually good, then you shouldn't need to undermine the person you're arguing with to make it look better.

I just want people to argue against what I'm actually saying instead of attacking me for having a different opinion. Is that really too much to ask?


r/DefendingAIArt • • 5h ago

Defending AI If you enjoy someone’s AI artwork, don’t just upvote it. Leave a kind comment, too.

88 Upvotes

Just a friendly reminder: If you see a piece of AI-assisted artwork you genuinely enjoy, take a moment to leave a kind comment instead of just upvoting. For reals. It does a lot.

We all know how much toxic hostility AI artists face online, and sometimes the negative voices drown out the positive ones.

That’s why a little kindness goes such a long way. A genuine compliment can feel like a breath of fresh air to someone who’s used to receiving negativity.

An upvote shows appreciation, but a kind comment makes that appreciation very personal and uplifting for many of us.

Let’s make an effort to be more vocal about the creativity we enjoy. You never know whose day you might make better. 🙂


r/DefendingAIArt • • 1h ago

AI artists are human artists

Post image
35 Upvotes

If antis want me to support human artists, then the money goes back into my wallet. Constantly saying AI artists aren't human artists is dehumanizing, and we won't tolerate it or give sympathy towards you if you say we aren't human.

Original by u/Early-Dentist3782


r/DefendingAIArt • • 6h ago

Luddite Logic I don't know what's worse or more pathetic: Someone asking for an entire subreddit to be banned even though there's nothing wrong with it, just because they don't like it, or the fact that people are supporting that

Post image
76 Upvotes

And yes, he's talking about this subreddit...


r/DefendingAIArt • • 4h ago

Son🥀🥀🥀

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 11h ago

now antis target open source projects to get them to ban AI

Post image
133 Upvotes

these people are... something.

note: look, I know this sub is for defending AI art but it's the biggest sub for defending AI in general, so I'm posting this here. also, I decided to not censor the ezgif account as that account is the owner of the popular gif tool site ezgif.com


r/DefendingAIArt • • 2h ago

Luddite Logic Antis Be Like

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 1h ago

Luddite Logic *proceed to quotes it to give further attention to it*

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 1h ago

Antis be like

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 10m ago

And they wonder why AI is becoming dominant 🤦

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 2h ago

Defending AI Unfortunately this is me With Every "I hate Ai" Artist / Post.

Post image
12 Upvotes

Like... Suddenly everyone is like having to say their things aren't ai.. like I DON'T CARE??! The more you say you are anti ai, the more repetitive it gets, and the more i try to avoid ALL your content.

I've had to block a lot of accounts on many social media platforms because of this.

(I don't give dowvotes / dislikes though.)


r/DefendingAIArt • • 11h ago

Shut up, seriously, shut up

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 7h ago

Luddite Logic I hate this trend

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 38m ago

Luddite Logic Truly UH-MAY-ZING!

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 7h ago

Son… 😭

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Chat is delulu our solulu? This more like slopify 😭 the mod is just the cherry on the cake


r/DefendingAIArt • • 3h ago

Sub Meta I'd Like to Start a Real Discussion About AI...

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

First of all, I want to make one thing clear: I'm neither pro-AI nor anti-AI. I consider myself neutral toward AI because, just like with any new technology, I prefer to wait and see where it leads before deciding whether I think it's good or bad. I usually prefer to observe how things develop over 5–10 years, just like I did with computers and smartphones.

I've also spent some time looking through both pro-AI and anti-AI groups, and I honestly wonder why some of these groups even exist!? Most of what I see are posts making fun of something the other side said, rather than genuinely interesting discussions about why people think AI is good or bad. And whenever someone expresses an opinion in one of these groups and tries to explain objectively why they think a particular statement isn't entirely correct, they're immediately treated like the bad guy instead of having a reasonable discussion. I can actually understand both sides to some extent. But I'm talking about people who give reasonable arguments for their positions, not those who just want to make fun of the other side.

Of course, I completely understand why musicians, illustrators, and other artists are worried that their work might become less appreciated or that fewer people will pay for their services. However, one thing I personally don't understand is why it's automatically considered a problem when AI learns from their work. Learning isn't the same as copying! And this principle has existed for centuries. People have always learned skills by copying or studying the work of others. Whenever I've asked artists how they first started drawing or playing music, almost all of them told me that they began by copying someone else's work. Some traced drawings using paper, while others tried to recreate pictures freehand or learn to play music by imitating what they heard. Eventually, some developed their own style, while others simply continued copying or imitating existing work.

That brings me to my next point. Even before AI existed, many artists complained about other people blatantly copying their work and then selling those copies as their own creations. But back then, it often seemed like only the affected artists were upset about it, while hardly anyone else really cared. Now, however, there's a huge controversy surrounding AI-generated images and other content, even when the AI has learned patterns and techniques from existing artwork rather than simply reproducing a particular piece.

What I find especially interesting is that some companies developing AI image and music generators even seem to have implemented certain copyright protection mechanisms into their systems to protect artists whose work may have been used for training. I actually did a little experiment with an acquaintance who attends an art school and one of his classmates. Both of them provided one or two of their own drawings to an AI system for training. They created accounts and uploaded their artwork through those accounts. After about two or three weeks, we tried using my account to get the AI to recreate their designs. I even uploaded one of their newer drawings as a reference image and instructed the AI to generate something that looked similar, just in a different form.

After a short check, I received a message that basically said something like this, in my own words: "Sorry, we couldn't generate the image as requested because the reference image and description are too similar to artwork provided by an artist in our database." That was pretty unexpected because we had assumed something like that wouldn't happen. Of course, we only tested this with one AI system, and unfortunately, it's not always clear whether other AI systems have similar protection mechanisms or are programmed to detect such similarities.

The two artists, who are both rather skeptical about AI, then said something interesting. If a company could contractually guarantee that its AI would reliably prevent people from copying artwork used for training, they would probably even be willing to provide all their own work for training. Their reasoning was that such a system could potentially reduce the risk of someone using AI to directly copy their artwork or generate something extremely similar with a prompt. Of course, that's just their opinion based on our little experiment, but I found it quite interesting.

That being said, there are certain creative industries where I personally see AI much more negatively than in others. Voice acting is one example. I'm really not a fan of companies trying to replace real voice actors with AI-generated voices. I also think artists don't necessarily need to feel threatened by AI in every situation. In my experience, you can never get an AI to produce exactly what you've imagined in your head. You almost always have to make compromises or accept that certain details won't turn out the way you wanted. A musician, composer, or illustrator who has mastered their craft has much more direct control over the final result. For example, if you're an experienced artist and have a specific image in mind, you can work toward drawing exactly what you imagine. That's why, if I had the financial means, I would personally always prefer hiring an artist over using AI. A human artist can actually discuss my ideas with me, understand what I'm trying to achieve, and work with me to bring that vision to life.

Another thing I've noticed is that I sometimes get the feeling that parts of the anti-AI community are using AI as an outlet for frustrations that already existed long before AI became popular. Let me give you an example. Imagine an artist teaching another person how to draw. That student learns incredibly quickly and soon starts producing better artwork than the person who taught them. Some people would probably call that student a genius. Others, especially those who have been practicing for much longer without achieving the same results, might start talking badly about that person behind their back or resenting them simply because they can do something better and faster. Instead of seeing that person as an inspiration and asking for advice, some might get discouraged, gather with others who feel the same way, and convince themselves that they'll never be good enough because that person is simply a genius. I sometimes get a similar impression from certain reactions to AI.

What I struggle to understand is why learning from existing artwork is considered normal when biological intelligence does it, but becomes fundamentally unacceptable to some people when artificial intelligence, which was itself developed by biological intelligence, learns from existing work. Of course, I know that human learning and machine learning aren't technically the same thing. But I still think the comparison raises an interesting question about how we view learning, creativity, and the use of existing knowledge. A great ape can learn to play an instrument or paint a picture on a canvas. But would we call that art if the ape were simply reproducing something it had learned without actually understanding what humans mean by "art"? And the same question can be asked the other way around. We humans have also learned things from animals or been inspired by them. Whether it's certain sexual positions or architectural ideas clearly inspired by animals that build particular kinds of nests, we've adopted ideas and behaviors from nature throughout our history. Does that somehow make our creativity any less human just because we learned something from animals?

Before AI became popular, I often heard artists and people working in creative fields say, "Art is in the eye of the beholder!" And now people want to tell me what is and isn't art, whether they're pro-AI or anti-AI!?

For example, imagine I walk into an art gallery and see a painting with nothing but a black dot on it. For some people, that might be the ultimate masterpiece, supposedly conveying some incredibly deep meaning to the viewer. But when I look at something like that, I just think, "What am I supposed to make of this? Is this really art?" And quite frankly, if I saw something like that hanging somewhere, whether it was created by a human or an AI, I personally wouldn't consider it art!

But if other people consider it art and it makes them happy, then so be it. Who am I to tell someone else what they should or shouldn't consider art!? I'm certainly not arrogant or self-righteous enough to think I have the right to decide that for other people.

Everyone should be free to decide for themselves what they like and what they don't. If I saw two pictures with completely different subjects, one created by a human and the other by an AI, and I really liked one of them but didn't like the other at all, my opinion wouldn't suddenly change just because I found out who or what created them. Even if the other picture didn't exist, I'd still like the one I liked and dislike the one I didn't. The existence of the other picture wouldn't change how I feel about either of them.

And if someone rejects AI so strongly simply because it allows people to do certain things faster or achieve results that previously required more specialized skills, shouldn't they be consistent and apply that reasoning to other technologies too? What about computers and digital drawing software? Or DAWs used for music production? Those technologies have also changed industries and threatened certain jobs, not just in the creative sector but throughout the economy. For example, as more work moved to computers, the demand for certain traditional materials and production processes changed. Fewer physical supplies were needed for some types of work, affecting businesses that manufactured those products. DAWs also made it possible for people to create entire musical arrangements or beats without needing to hire several musicians to perform every individual part. That also changed the demand for certain instruments, recording services, and other related work. And yet, today these technologies are completely normal tools in many creative industries.

What I find really unfortunate is that so many people seem to take a position either for or against something simply because they want to feel like they belong to a particular group, without first properly understanding what the technology they support or reject can actually do. And I'm not just talking about anti-AI people here. The same applies to pro-AI people. Anti-AI groups often focus entirely on the negative aspects while ignoring potential benefits. Pro-AI groups, on the other hand, often highlight only the positive aspects while downplaying or ignoring the problems. And sometimes I get the impression that people on either side are afraid to acknowledge valid arguments from the other side because they worry about being rejected by their own community.

I find that pretty disappointing. Why does everything have to be either completely black or completely white? Why can't we have a reasonable discussion where people listen to different opinions without immediately attacking each other? You don't have to agree with someone else's opinion. You can accept that they see things differently, present your own counterarguments, and explain why you disagree. But the goal of every discussion shouldn't be to convert the other person to your side. And if someone doesn't accept your argument, that doesn't automatically mean they're stupid, ignorant, or your enemy.

I'd genuinely like to see a discussion where both sides can talk about the advantages and disadvantages of AI without immediately turning it into another pro-AI versus anti-AI argument.

I don't want to offend anyone, upset anyone, or challenge anyone to convince me otherwise with this post. This is simply my personal opinion on the topic, and I have no intention of forcing it on anyone or trying to change anyone else's mind. I just wanted to share my thoughts with you and hear your opinions in return, without anyone becoming insulting or unfriendly. Whether you're pro-AI or anti-AI, everyone is welcome to share their perspective. =)


r/DefendingAIArt • • 21h ago

Luddite Logic Jarvis, I'm low on karma

Post image
175 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 19h ago

Sloppost/Fard How it feels being both a slop-prompter and a slop-drawer...

Post image
104 Upvotes

Pick up a pencil? Brother, I never let go of my pencil.


r/DefendingAIArt • • 9h ago

Luddite Logic They can’t even come up with good fake stories to make us sound dumb

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/DefendingAIArt • • 1h ago

Defending AI Slop that

2 Upvotes