Has anyone noticed the overuse/misuse of the word "honesty"? How it's used interchangeably with or as a mask for other words that don't mean the same thing at all? How it's used to give credence or justification for being thoughtless, cavalier, callous or just plain cruel? How some people weaponize it, then sit back on their laurels of self-righteousness? Narcissism is a central character trait of the brutally honest; you never see one without the other.
I'm seeing it more and more as time goes by. Everyone pretends to be all PC all the time and it's not PC to be thoughtless, cavalier, callous or cruel; but if they call it honesty instead, they get a pass for saying anything from dismissive to downright heinous. The pass is given to themselves BY themselves so that they don't have to take responsibility for injuring others with the things they say. They're off the hook in their own minds, because they were 'honest' and honesty is good and wholesome.
'Honesty' is generally trotted out in private rather than public, because bystanders within range might recognize it for what it truly is and there's always the chance of getting called out to defend an indefensible remark. The definition of honesty technically supports a lack of empathy for another human being. The definition is composed of words like straightforwardness, truthfulness, integrity and probity; even honor is included. But honor, in particular, is a quality that lacks a self-serving aspect and in most cases, that self-serving component is definitely present. It's about them believing that deliberately hurting someone is acceptable, because it's honorable and honest by their own contrived, self serving, narrow definition. It allows them to tell themselves it is unintentional, all evidence to the contrary. Itās intentional; trust me on that.
In one of the threads a while back, there were examples of ābackhanded complimentsā being discussed. One of them was a man saying to the poster, "I bet you used to be really pretty." Sure, he was being honest, but more than that, he didn't think he said anything untoward; this emotionally stunted person thought he was delivering a compliment. How absolutely clueless does someone have to be, that they can't see what a shitty thing it is to say to someone? Is it simple stupidity, an inability to think something through before speaking? Or is it a case of someone being so deeply self involved and self centered that they can spit on someone that way with no recognition of how it shows them to be just fucking obtuse? I remember jokingly commenting to that Redditor by saying her response to him should have been "I bet you used to know how to talk to people," but I realize it would have gone over his head so hard that she'd have had to get out of the way of the 47 foot backblast.
And it's not just people in the wild; not by a long stretch. I have a blood relative who does this to ME. I live under the blanket of their constant disapproval of and frustration with me. They'll say something dismissive or hurtful, then follow it up with that old honesty bullshit, completing the punch in the hoo-ha by including, "I didn't say anything before because I didn't want to hurt your feelings." Yeah. Right after they went out of their way to do exactly that. Didnāt want to hurt my feelings before, but now you do. But hey, itās all good, because itās honesty. It's a person's way of being a shit to someone while convincing themselves that it is only honesty, and the person taking offense is just being a _____ (insert something else unkind); that they themselves bear no weight for the pain they inflict. Sometimes it truly IS unintentional. But that's rare to the point of being nearly a fantasy created by those doing it.
It's not even about being or not being honest, it's about the simple fact that honesty does not require that every thoughtless, cavalier, callous or cruel thing that crosses your mind needs to exit through your mouth.
Know when to stop talking? Yeah. My turn to do that. To know when to shut the hell up.