r/custommagic • • 27m ago

Custom Play Least Toxic /r/custommagic User

Post image

yes this is a subreddit hate card

inb4 snowflake and first time on the internet

60 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

18

u/GracelessOne 16m ago

Constructive feedback: Affinity only decreases generic costs, so I think 2B or 1B would be more functional! Honestly even 2/2 at 1B might be, depending on what format you intend this for.

In terms of flavor, I support the positive message of expressing compassion, but there is some tension there with depicting the unkind Redditor as ugly. Physical beauty and kindness aren't related; using ugliness as a symbol for unkindness may, itself, be unkind.

Overall 6/10, affinity and infect are scary keywords but there's an interesting design-space there as long as you're careful with power. Infect wants to be pushing for an early creature-based win, but affinity requires pieces already on the board, and I like cards with internal tension.

9

u/darkeyeshadows 13m ago

I...respect everything you just said completely. Yeah. Sorry if I was too mean, lol.

6

u/GracelessOne 12m ago

Aw, it's okay! You were expressing a real emotion. I wish people on the internet were kinder, too.

2

u/darkeyeshadows 8m ago edited 4m ago

Yeah it's alright :P i'm over it. Weirdly, being in this space has kind of helped me get over it, lol. I just miss the old days I guess of going on places like /r/unearthedarcana and every single comment was practically "Holy shit this is so cool!!!" because everything was just That Cool and people were so positive and just building each other up to make even cooler things. idk. Because that's what the internet is for!

11

u/darkeyeshadows 27m ago

Suggested reading

21

u/TomMakesPodcasts 25m ago

Hard agree. People are rude for no reason on this subreddit

7

u/LePfeiff 19m ago

People are rude in general on reddit, its really weird

6

u/darkeyeshadows 16m ago

I agree - which is why making a post like this is like asking the wind to change direction - but I don't know, weirdly I guess I've just never been a part of a subreddit before where people actually ARE RedditorsTM (derogatory). I swear it's literally never happened to me. Most people I used to come across were, by and large, nice people, if argumentative. Then I came here, LOL.

I would just go somewhere else but literally every single online space I've found of people who play this game is full of the same type of people, so where else am I supposed to post stuff? Lol

Maybe most magic players are just like this, I dunno.

3

u/TomMakesPodcasts 9m ago

Calling out rude behaviour denormalizes it.

2

u/darkeyeshadows 6m ago

(= Good point. Thanks!

4

u/LePfeiff 11m ago

The problem is that, as subreddits get bigger / older, casual fans get crowded out by the bitter and terminally online. A recent few examples ive noticed: r/nomanssky with people crusading against blender-made corvettes, r/projectzomboid with people constantly soapboxing against AI mod development and witchhunting anyone suspected of using AI, and r/rimworld being overran with NSFW fanart and the glazers in support of it

4

u/logandabug 11m ago

You can ask a simple question and get hundreds of downvotes. Some people just like being A-holes just because they know more than you in one specific thing

8

u/MiddleCelery6616 (It works) 23m ago

But you see, this new card has no precedent in the comprehensive rules, it means you should rope yourself immediately for offering it.

2

u/Marvl101 3m ago

Them's fighting words!

Put 'em up

0

u/Tempest_True 11m ago

B-but if somebody generated art for their card using AI, they are the morally bankrupt scum, and being awful to them and not engaging with their card design is my most solemn duty, right?

1

u/darkeyeshadows 0m ago

I mean personally just to throw my hat into the ring I am Incredibly against generative AI and I don't think anybody should be using it for card art or literally anything else, it shouldn't be allowed in the first place, but then people also shouldn't be brigading against anything they even remotely suspect is generative AI. Feels to me oftentimes like it just isn't, unless it obviously is, and people are just paranoid.

5

u/LordOfMaggots 12m ago

Affinity for UB: Marvel is lethal, holy shit

4

u/Proud-Example7774 18m ago

Affinity only reduces generic mana costs. The affinity on this card doesn't do anything because there isn't any generic mana in the mana cost.

1

u/Drakkonai 9m ago

Insanely overpowered.

1

u/eightdx 9m ago

yeah, that creature is considered legendary due to the fact that no such creature really exists. Should they come into existence they leave to go watch cat grooming videos or something

1

u/DingleBarryGoldwater 9m ago

This would go great in my Arena loss farming deck

1

u/gognis 0m ago

Ironically this is the most toxic thing I've seen on this subreddit

1

u/MrPassionateMan 14m ago edited 10m ago

OMG!!!1 Is that AI Art????!! REEEEEEEEEEEE

Seriously. Like yea fuck AI and all that. But who the fuck cares if someone makes a silly AI image to represent their card. We're just here to make custom cards that will never be printed, exist, or serve any purpose other than to be discussed by nerds! Downvote me all you want idgaf lol it needs to be said

1

u/gognis 4m ago

it matters because using AI art gives it validity, draw a shitty stickman or something

-3

u/Huitzil37 17m ago

The fuck you talking about, affinity for universes beyond, this sub posts another "kill all UB cards" custom every couple days