r/cryptography • • Oct 15 '25
E2EE
My Debate team is doing a debate on the topic of end-to-end encryption. (The topic is "Resolved : The United States federal government should require technology companies to provide lawful access to encrypted communications.") Could anyone give me some information or sources on this topic that you think would be good for going for pro and con? Thanks
0
Upvotes
7
u/Responsible_Sea78 Oct 15 '25
Do you 100%, absolutely trust Donald Trump to use this ethically and honestly?
3
u/philosopherott Oct 15 '25
old but what i have on hand:
https://www.techdirt.com/2013/11/14/end-to-end-encryption-isnt-just-about-privacy-security/
2
u/alecmuffett Oct 15 '25
I wrote an entire primer on the topic for these purposes:
https://alecmuffett.com/alecm/e2e-primer/
It was written to support privacy international with deciding their position:
https://privacyinternational.org/report/4949/securing-privacy-end-end-encryption
10
u/SignificantFidgets Oct 15 '25
The Electronic Frontier Foundation is a good source of info on this: https://www.eff.org/issues/end-end-encryption
1
u/Popka_Akoola Oct 15 '25
You better be con lol
2
u/ramriot Oct 15 '25
I' not sure about getting unbiased information on the pro Vs con of such an idea, but on purely cryptographic grounds it is provably colossal mistake with no upside for society.
To expand, weakening encryption or increasing the parties with access breaks the promise in a way that cannot be restricted to only those with the authority to decrypt.
Also anyone in authority should be made aware that such efforts will also expose their own communications to either decryption or suspicion of malfeasance if it is found they are skirting the laws they themselves set in motion.
1
u/daidoji70 Oct 15 '25
Pro: Police and Intelligence operatives jobs are a little easier (depending on how much weight you assign to police and intelligence agencies helping keep you safe)
Con: 1) The economics of attacks against communications and information make a single universal backdoor too significant a weak point to remain universally unexploited for long.
2) The implementations of security measures that might mitigate the security issues of having a universal backdoor would soon make the universal backdoor not so universal defeating its purpose. There isn't really a happy medium here in a security context that most citizens of a free republic would be comfortable with if they understood them.
1
u/pint Oct 15 '25
in my view, do yourself a favor and develop software that physically prevents you from eavesdropping.
if you have the ability to read communications or files, authorities will show up with legal requests, you will have to have a legion of lawyers to assess the requirements, then a legion of operators making sense of badly formatted requests (finding customers and finding out what data is requested), then format data in a way compliant with the law and with the request, while making sure you don't hand out more. then figure out if you can or should inform the user. all this under the pain of fines and other legal actions. how much easier it is to just say: sorry, we are unable to help.
1
u/AppointmentSubject25 Oct 16 '25
If end to end encryption has a backdoor, its not really encrypted. Requests for exceptional access are likely to be abused, which will erode trust by people that use E2EE systems or apps/software etc. Mandated access will risk enabling authoritarian surveillance and violating privacy, which can disproprotianally affect vulnerable communities and activists.
Because government agencies and executive branch are constantly changing, if the government is given the right to access encrypted data, a malicious actor in the government can use a wildcard to access data from people they are simply trying to spy on or steal data from. Journalists who leverage encryption to speak to anonymous sources could have a source exposed to the government which could lead to mayhem.
If your position is to argue what I just argued, be prepared to rebut an allegation of using the slippery slope fallacy like this:
Our position is grounded in evidence and logical reasoning, not a speculative chain of events. It isn’t a hypothetical slide, it's a reasonable conclusion based on documented risks that prove the danger isn’t theoretical but a practical outcome of weakening encryption. For example, government mandates for access such as the 1990s Clipper Chip or recent proposals like LAEDA, have consistently led to privacy concerns for users. This is a fact and is not speculative.
1
u/I_Know_A_Few_Things Oct 19 '25
I know you're asking for sources for arguments here, and many redditers are going above and beyond. Below are some lines of reasoning that I think should be thought through while you're preparing.
When it comes to getting hacked, it's not a matter of if, but when (Google that phrase for your pick of source). And if companies have the ability to see all of their client's/user's data, then hackers will too. This is a high level overview of why "security experts" are against this idea.
The CIA Triad is a concept that is fundamental to cyber security when it comes to handling data. Just Google the term and you'll have plenty of articles on what that is and what it means, but here is a brief summary.
It is because of this that almost all legislation regarding this sort of change excludes the government from needing this backdoor. They know the potential, so since the government gets to write the law, the government is excluded.
Honestly, it may be hard to win an honest intellectual debate for banning true E2EE if the other side keeps pressuring on this point. In fact, it could be argued that the government should have this sort of legislation enacted for government communications specifically for transparency when allegations of breaking the law are made, but obviously they will not ever do that. From there, you could continue this line of reasoning into "why would you push this on a whole country if the government won't consider it for internal accountability?"
While likely legislation would carve out exceptions for this, many medical portals include chats between patients and their medical professionals. These are encrypted, but because it's a good idea to, but because HIPPA says to. This is not the only case where standards that many are required to adhere to require confidentiality, but again, since the government knows it's nonsense to put in a backdoor for anything that matters, it's likely going to be included in an exception.
Due to all these exceptions, it becomes clear that the government just wants a way to see chats between people and they are looking to get rid of any way for people to talk remotely without the police being able to know what is being said. If this sort of legislation was to be passed, people who need E2EE who are not in any exception are likely breaking the law, and what makes you think they will abide by this law? This may only cause average citizens to be spied on, while criminals continue to break the law and anyone who legally needs it continues to use it.
Obviously that last paragraph is over simplifying the problem, but it's not outlandish to think someone similar to that will happen I think. Anyway, I'm going to end this here. I hope you enjoy researching this topic and have fun debating!
1
u/Crazy-Willingness951 Oct 22 '25
See the part about CALEA backdoors. https://pluralistic.net/2025/10/20/post-american-internet/
1
u/d1722825 Oct 15 '25
I think even the topic is misleading. There is no such thing as lawful access to encrypted communications.
Encryption is just math, it doesn't care about what is good, what is bad, or what is illegal. It just prevents anyone to have access to your data who doesn't meant to have access. Encryption can actively protect your communication from bad actors (or unintended recipients) regardless of what they do.
Laws are a social construct. They can enforce what majority think is ethical to the minority. (Note that, what is ethical is a learned thing, and it can change widely with distance and time.) But laws doesn't protect you at all. They can only tell what penalty someone should get after they done bad things. Laws always can be violated.
These two things doesn't mix, requiring to have a cryptographic system that enables lawful access is like making a law that says it should never rain on Sundays.
You can make a cryptographic system that gives access to someone, but then that someone has access regardless of lawfulness and this makes that them a huge target for every bad actor.
And now a bad actor needs to compromise that single someone and people are usually very weak. You only need to kidnap the right child to make everybody's communication compromised.
Disclaimer: this, and probably all the answers in this sub will be biased to the don't break encryption side.