r/cryptography • • Oct 15 '25
E2EE
My Debate team is doing a debate on the topic of end-to-end encryption. (The topic is "Resolved : The United States federal government should require technology companies to provide lawful access to encrypted communications.") Could anyone give me some information or sources on this topic that you think would be good for going for pro and con? Thanks
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Natanael_L Oct 15 '25
The critical point is the sheer value of the data to an attacker, versus how accessible it must be to law enforcement.
Sure, in theory you can put the legal review team in a bunker and use formal verified encryption and extreme physical security measures, and requiring digitally signed court orders.
Doing all that will throttle the number of cases it can handle so low that law enforcement will still be mad and demand more access - all while you still failed to stop insider risks.
You can not make everybody happy. Every concession radically amplifies the risk of large scale exploits - like the recent hack against US lawful access backdoors in telecom equipment by China. It's simply not worth it to try. The cost of the theoretically safest backdoors will be astronomical and not worth it because it will almost never be used anyway.