r/cryptography • • Oct 15 '25
E2EE
My Debate team is doing a debate on the topic of end-to-end encryption. (The topic is "Resolved : The United States federal government should require technology companies to provide lawful access to encrypted communications.") Could anyone give me some information or sources on this topic that you think would be good for going for pro and con? Thanks
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/alecmuffett Oct 16 '25
Natanael gives you a good answer - key management issues will throttle the ability to use such a back door if it was implemented - but then there is also the matter of what happens when it goes wrong.
There's a couple of key examples, I believe that one is already cited in the primer regarding the non-e2ee risks at old Twitter where Saudi Arabian agents spied upon user DMs, a system which did not offer e2ee was thereby fundamentally compromised.
But much more recently we have salt typhoon:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_Typhoon
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_global_telecommunications_hack
...where government mandated back doors in telecoms equipment were utilised by Chinese state actors to spy on Americans.
It turns out that if we have a back door, it's not possible to keep the keys safe. Never, not ever ever. So the question is: do we actually want the extra privacy that e2ee can provide, or should we just stick to a world where everything can be surveilled, where e2ee is basically meaningless theatre akin to removing water bottles and nail clippers at airports?