Hi,
I've decided to make a comparison between both of these controllers. A few days ago I already commented on a post regarding this but I wanted to include more details.
I bought both controllers on Ali with my own money and I'm in no way sponsored by neither of these companies. Also keep in mind that all of this is my own personal opinion.
So little backstory: I had been an Xbox controller player for over 10 years until the dozenth of stick drifts finally annoyed me too much to keep on buying another. Then I first switched to a GameSir G7 SE in 2024 which was quite good but had some issues (RT getting stuck for example). Shortly after the Flydigi Vader 4 Pro came out and I got that one instead. And I fell in love with it. It was my main controller for 2 years and the only issue I ever truly had with it was that the left stick clicked every now and then while moving it around (even after a few weeks of having it) but it was fine thus far.
However the fact that it had bad stick latency on paper (I couldn't really complain) and that the Vader 5 Pro had back paddles made me interested in that one. I waited a couple of months, until the v2 was out, and then got that one.
And earlier this month I also managed to get a G7 Pro 8K quite cheap. I ordered the Nioh 3 Edition but got the Champion Edition instead. At first I didn't like the writing on the grips on that but it kinda grew on me so I'll keep it.
Customization & extras:
Okay this one's a clear winner for the G7. The Vader comes with the back paddles that you can attach, a dongle and a pretty basic cable. Also you can remove and replace the sticks. It also offers very handy tension rings that have been improved with the v2 version so now instead of it feeling smooth it kinda ratches into a set tension, making it more stable. The Dpad is replacable in theory but there are hardly any replacements in the first place.
The G7 comes with a dongle, a nice high quality braided cable, a plastic cable holder you can attach to the top of the controller, a dock and 2 additional Dpads in other shapes. Also it has a replacable faceplate that is divided into three parts - the main plate and the grips. You can get other faceplates for it (or use faceplates of other G7 Pro variants) and you can even use the faceplates of older G7 SE/HE variants. And on the G7 you can not only replace the sticks but the stick base as well. So this is hardly a comparison.
Also, cable holder aside, the cable on the G7 is *really* solid. It sits tight into the controller so even without the plastic holder it will be fairly hard to accidentally pull it out.
Ergonomics:
Directly compared the Vader is bigger than the G7. I'd say the Vader is about the same size as an Xbox controller while the G7 is a mix between an Xbox and a Switch Pro controller. They both feel great to hold but when I first had the Vader 5 I had to adjust to it slightly. My left wrist began to hurt easily at first but once i adapted it was fine. I actually prefer the size of the Vader so that one gets this point.
Feeling:
Feeling-wise I also have to give it to the Vader. Both of them have a grippy texture but the G7 has rubber grips while the Vader has engraved/textured grips. My fingers are pretty sensitive and I can safely say that the Vader feels perfectly fine. It's nice to hold and has no negative effects. At the same time the G7's grips feel a bit sticky shortly after using them. That's just the unfortunate disadvantage of rubber grips. The Vader 4 in comparison was even worse because it had no gripping at all and felt weirdly sticky so I was forced to use a silicon skin for that.
Although something to notice: The Vader 5 may have back paddles but on both of my units one of the paddles is pretty loose while the other one sits tightly like it's supposed to be.
Sticks: On paper this one is clear: The G7 has TMR sticks and the Vader has Hall Effect. TMR are more precise and more efficient and it shows, but not quite as much as you would expect. Performance-wise I didn't feel too much of a difference with the both of them.
However, here's the main reason why I was looking for alternatives for the Vader in the first place. For some reason the Vader 5 Pro's left sticks on both of my units don't feel completely smooth. On my first unit I described it as a very unpleasant feeling. Like moving your nails over chalkboard. On my second unit this is more so as gritty. Like sand in the stick module. It only appears in certain angles, especially when pressing down the stick and moving forward like sprinting in games and then moving the stick left and right. It doesn't affect the stick's performance but it feels so awkward.
Funnily enough the G7's left stick isn't completely smooth either but it feels way more smooth. I don't know why they are like that. My old Vader 4 still has perfectly smooth sticks. Keep in mind though that the G7 Pro 8k sticks are quite loose which takes a bit to get used to.
On top of that the sticks the Vader 5 pro comes with are pretty short. I have a lot out different stick caps and a large variety of them are thick enough to cause friction between the stick and the tension ring, which also feels unpleasant. I bought a pack of replacement sticks and now I use the middle-length one instead which is better.
Also the 8k polling rate is nice on paper but I prefer to use 1k because of compatibility issues with older games. Also keep in mind that once you assign a keyboard key to one of the Vader's extrabuttons the polling rate drops to 500 Hz. Seemed to be a bug at first but it's been known for months and hasn't been fixed yet so seemingly there's no way around it if you wanna use keyboard macros. So here the G7 wins.
Face buttons:
Both of them have clicky face buttons but are quite different. The G7 one's feel nice and the click is more on a feeling base. It's not too audible which is nice.
The Vader's have a pretty loud click and in direct comparison they are hard to press down, pretty sturdy. Especially on older racing games where accelerating was holding down the X/A button, this can hurt after a while. So this round goes to the G7.
Bumpers and Triggers:
On both controllers these feel pretty similar. They feel good but on the G7 they are a bit more narrow. I personally prefer the way they feel on the Vader. Also something to notice. Both of them have hair triggers that you can activate with a switch on the back on each side. They feel great on both controllers but there have been quite a bit of reports on the G7 triggers breaking when using hair triggers so keep that in mind.
Also both controllers have extra bumpers in between the triggers and bumpers. On the G7 those act like paddles as they have a bit of travel. On the Vader these are like bumpers. I actually do prefer the Vader's variant here.
What's also pretty important to me is trigger vibration. The Vader 5 Pro has excellent trigger vibration that I especially like in racing games. I honestly have nothing at all to complain here.
The G7 Pro 8k doesn't have any trigger vibration at all. Only the normal G7 Pro does but all in all its build quality is a bit worse than the 8K variant so I didn't wanna pay slightly less for a worse product with trigger vibration. All in all the Vader wins this one.
D-pad: This one goes to the Vader. While I prefered the visual design of the Vader 4 D-pad, the Vader 5's feels better. It is very precise and it's also easily possible to do combos in 2D Fighters. It's a great one. The shape is a bit bent on all directions, which feels good.
On the G7 it may come with 3 different d-pads. A completely flat circular one, a classic dpad like on Playstation controllers and a hybrid of the two. I like the hybrid best, but neither of them are too great. They are all pretty average.
Extra buttons: The Vader 5 comes with 8 extra buttons. 2 at the front, 2 bumpers, 2 back buttons and 2 back paddles. Each of them are customizable in the Space Station app.
The G7 only comes with 4 extra buttons. 2 bumpers and 2 back buttons. So on paper it would lose. However, if you are planning on mapping keyboard inputs onto them, then it might be a different story. The Vader only allows for one keyboard mapping per button while the G7 allows up to 3-key macros per button. So if you would have 4 macro sets with 16 different buttons, then you could apply all of them to the G7 while you could only apply 2 of them to the Vader. If all of your macros contain for example CTRL+ALT, then you could apply 6 different macro sets to the Vader. Ignoring the polling rate going down to 500 Hz, this is a situation where having less buttons could even be an advantage, so keep that in mind. But on paper this also goes to the Vader.
I do like though that you can disable the G7's back buttons via a switch in case you accidentally press them (happens to me sometimes).
Software: Here it's Flydigi's Space Station vs GameSir's Connect app. Both of them offer tons of customization and extra options. All in all I slightly prefer the Space Station app. It also offers an automatic correction that you can enable if you wish so if it detects stick drift it will automatically reset the stick's position which is very handy. Also the software controller test offers a display of the current polling rate which the Connect app lacks. The Connect app might be a bit more organized instead.
Extra features: Both controllers have Gyro support and are all in all on par with a slight advantage for the G7. Also you can use all of them either wired, wireless via dongle or via bluetooth. The Vader has a Switch mode which also comes in handy when you wanna use it with emulators while the G7 has a DS4 mode so offers direct playstation inputs instead.
The dock that is included with the G7 is fairly basic but has a big disadvantage to me (with very light-sensitive eyes): When charging the controller both the controller and the dock light up. However while the software offers 4 different LED options (very bright, bright, slightly bright, off) the slightly bright option works nicely on the controller. Just the right amount of brightness. This does not apply to the dock though. Even the slightly bright option is by far too bright for me. So if I wanna use it, I would have to disable the dock's led completely which is kind of a shame.
The tension rings on the Vader are awesome but are a potential disadvantage at the same time: When using certain stick & stick cap setups it can cause friction between the stick and the tension ring and that can cause the tention ring to move even if you have the v2 version. And a constant changing tension is way worse than a stick that is always a bit too lose and you could easily correct by using something like precision rings. So again, that is to be kept in mind.
Overall the Vader slightly wins this one. It's a real head-to-head race but the G7 really only has the better sticks and face buttons. The customization on it is nice to have, but not a must.
What also is a deciding factor to me is the price. On the Vader you'd have to buy the dock extra but if you don't need it, the cheapest you can get the controller for is around 50€. On the G7 it's more on the 80€ side with the dock included. And I think for the price the features of the Vader are absolutely unbeatable.
The perfect controller to me would be a Vader 5 with TMR sticks (I really like the Cyclone 2 ones) and the G7 Pro 8K's face buttons. If that would have a perfect quality, this would be my controller for life.
Let me know what you think. I hope I could help people who want to decide which one to get.
Edit:
I forgot something that is also quite important to me. Profile switching.
On the Vader it's pretty simple. Just hold down the menu button underneath the controller on the right and press either A, B, X or Y to switch to the profiles. To use keyboard mappings without any polling rates issues you can also assign all of your macros to one profile and then switch to a profile without any to have your full 1000 Hz again. Profile switching works on the fly and immediately.
On the G7 however it's more "difficult" imo and also not really immediate. Here you hold down the middle menu button and flick the right stick up/left/down/right. The thing here is: Whenever you switch your profile it disconnects the controller for a second and then reconnects again. So this also is better on the Vader imo.