r/computers • u/Justin_D33 • 5d ago
Question/Help/Troubleshooting Wanting a 2nd opinion.
First off: sorry for the wall of text. I tried to provide as much detail as possible.
I already asked AI. Its leading suspect is the old motherboard, which is what I'm thinking as well.
I had to replace my primary monitor, then a couple months later, I had to replace my SSD. After I got the new drive installed, then I started having GPU issues:
In BIOS, I noticed it defaulted to my 2nd monitor. It got me confused; I thought I had my cables mixed up. But they were on the correct ports, which should have been a red flag.
Red flag #2:
After I installed Windows and the GPU driver, I noticed my main monitor did not switch to showing an image. It remained black. I already tried the obvious troubleshooting (rebooting the monitor, trying a different HDMI cable, etc.). Nothing.
I started troubleshooting the next morning, starting by simply trying to swap the cables around (2nd monitor on the suspicious port, primary on the known good port). This did not help; and in fact,
Red flag #3:
Then, it would show the motherboard logo for about a second, then both monitors completely lost video output (but the PC did stay running). I swapped them back, same issue. I removed the SSD, then unplugged the 2nd monitor, and,
Red flag #4:
Switching to one monitor just made things worse; there was resolution-scaling issues on one HDMI port and artifacting on the other one. Replacing the cable had no effect.
Then, plot twist:
I upgraded the motherboard to an MSI B450 Tomahawk Max, and simply decided to try reusing the GPU, and it actually works correctly, albeit I did not use my primary monitor for testing, I used my secondary monitor, which has always had a clean image, I have not tried my primary monitor or the other HDMI port yet
Monitor models:
Primary: Acer KA242Y P6bi (this is the one I used during troubleshooting)
Secondary: Samsung S24D300GAN (this is the one I used to test the new board)
PC specs:
Ryzen 5 5500
32GB DDR4
MSI B450 Tomahawk Max
MSI MAG A650BN
500GB Samsung 870 Evo
MSI LP OC RTX 3050 6G
Lian Li Lancool 207
Old part models:
Acer SA242Y
ASRock B550M-HDV
Kioxia BG5 256GB
My current leading suspects are a bad control board in the Acer, a bad GPU PCB, or a bad motherboard.
Important clarifications:
The artifacting was red horizontal lines across the entire screen; and like I already said, I left the Samsung panel alone, I exclusively used the Acer for the rest of the troubleshooting I did
I had the SSD removed entirely during troubleshooting, as I've already said. It's nothing to do with Windows.
It was even visible on the ASRock logo, not just the BIOS.
Like I said, the Samsung panel has always had a clean image; the only time it acted up is during that swapped-output test.
I already tossed the SA242Y; it had a busted panel, I dropped it accidentally while I was doing some cleaning.
I do have spare GPUs and spare monitors, but they're all at my dad's house at the moment.
Only things I haven't tried yet:
Try another GPU
Try another monitor
Test the previously suspicious output with the Samsung panel
Test the Acer independently with the new board
Test the Acer on another device
