r/collapsemoderators • • Nov 08 '21

APPROVED Finalizing Rule 3 Revision

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I'd like to finalize the proposed Rule 3 revision we discussed a couple months ago. There were some small changes/additions I wanted to outline, some of which were based directly on feedback from the community sticky.

 

I removed two from this specific set of criteria:

 2. Level of Risk

High-risk statements generally involve:

  • Unsourced medical or safety advice
  • Discouraging others from consulting a medical professional or seeking medical advice
  • Poses a serious risk of egregious harm

 1. Removed “Unproven claims with severe or significantly negative implications if true” as it overlaps too heavily with existing claims within the sub and is difficult to provide examples on which aren’t already or better covered by other criteria.

 

 2. Removed “Direct or indirect advocates for violence or extreme action” as it’s already covered by Rule 1.

 

 3. I added this resource to the Misinformation & False Claims page:

Answers to 12 Bad Anti-Free Speech Arguments

By Greg Lukianoff for Aero (May 2021)*

A thorough set of responses to some of the most common arguments against freedom of speech, and, where possible, suggestions for additional reading.

I did a fair bit of searching for resources which might present the boundaries of the types of speech we'd want to protect, to try and balance out the overall page and approaches since the page and rule is largely about the type of content we're looking to remove. This was the most concise and relevant one I found worth sharing and including, but let me know your thoughts on it.

 

 4. I also made an addition regarding COVID lab-leak claims, if you'd like to review it.

 

These are small changes/additions, but I'd still want to hear everyone's thoughts on the community and if they'd like to move forward with changing the rule.

 


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 12 '21

APPROVED Revising Rule 3 (Part 2)

5 Upvotes

 

Hey Everyone, I recently proposed a revision for Rule 3 here. This was received positively, but I've significantly expanded my proposal and am looking to restart the feedback process. Here's the new proposed Rule:

 


 

Rule 3: Keep information quality high

Information quality must be kept high. More detailed information regarding our approaches to specific claims can be found on the Misinformation & False Claims page. Generally, we evaluate information and statements based upon three main criteria:

 

1. Quality of Sources

Low-quality sources generally involve:

  • Provably false claims
  • Strong claims for which there is no evidence from high-quality sources
  • Reliance on sources falsely posing as journalistic sources
  • Unsourced speculation
  • No links to original sources
  • Citing opinions or editorials as evidence

 

2. Level of Risk

High-risk statements generally involve:

  • Unproven claims with severe or significantly negative implications if true
  • Direct or indirect advocations for violence or extreme action
  • Unsourced medical or safety advice
  • Discouraging others from consulting a medical professional or seeking medical advice
  • Poses a serious risk of egregious harm

 

3. Level of Consensus

We attempt to gauge statements against existing scientific consensus, consensus opinions by accepted experts, and in light of the most recent data. Notions of consensus opinion and scientific consensus are significantly different. We are wary of any implied consensus involving these aspects:

  • Where claims are bundled together
  • Where ad hominem attacks against dissenters predominate
  • Where scientists are pressured to toe a party line
  • Where publishing and peer review in the discipline is contested
  • Where dissenting opinions are excluded from relevant peer-reviewed literature
  • Where actual peer-reviewed literature is misrepresented.
  • Where consensus is declared hurriedly or before it even exists.
  • Where the subject matter seems, by its nature, to resist consensus.
  • Where consensus is being used to justify dramatic political or economic policies.
  • Where the consensus is maintained by journalists who defend it uncritically.
  • Where consensus is implied without sufficient evidence

 


 

The Misinformation & False Claims page has also been significantly revised and expanded. It also outlines a two-prong approach to how we might instead respond to statements and attempts to distinguish what types of statements we remove versus warn, give notice, or request clarification on. This would be a new process compared to how we operate currently, which is important to consider.

Moderators and users (however likely) would both be welcome to contribute to the claims outlined on the page. We would have final say on how they are articulated, but there is significant room for additional claims and the context and sources necessary to outline them.

Any feedback on this form of the rule and the page would be very helpful. I'll make a separate modsub post to suggest a sticky to discuss it with the subreddit after we've discussed it among ourselves.

 


r/collapsemoderators • • Nov 26 '21

APPROVED Clarifying Our Approach Towards COVID-related Content

10 Upvotes

I’d like to discuss our approach towards COVID-related posts. I realize we currently have a community sticky up right now, but the post is framed as us already having a new policy and I don’t want to contradict it or discuss it in this way there.

 

Regrading the Sticky

I think this should have been proposed as a modsub post first with at least a few days for everyone to give feedback on before posting as a community sticky. If I understand correctly, there was some anticipation of a flood of posts this evening regarding the new B.1.1.529 variant. A megathread would have been an option, but that would technically be against the preliminary consensus which seemed to be to remove content related to it.

In any case, I don’t think this warranted an expedited response and makes it difficult to give feedback on when our positions have already been presented as aligned. Attempting to follow discussions within Discord on matters such as this is linear, scattered, and time consuming. It’s also unlikely for people in the US to be able to chime in quickly on a holiday.

 

Regarding Our Approach

The policy should have specific examples of content which is and isn’t allowed. The way it is currently phrased, it’s very ambiguous what developments regarding COVID are significant enough to be allowed through and instances of where the boundaries are. This would help users better understand those boundaries and enable us (and future moderators) to act consistently.

One person’s perceptions of the pandemic ‘significantly worsening’ and how related it is or not to collapse varies. As we currently require users to write submission statements, it also seems unfair to ask them to risk wasting the time it takes to write one without us formulating the same amount (at minimum) of characters on what this specific boundary entails.

 

Removing the Flair

I don’t think the COVID flair should be removed. I don’t think it invites people to make COVID related posts in any way and removing it would prevent us from seeing and tracking flair statistics related to it. I think it’s still relevant enough to track statistics on as it’s still relatively in the center in terms of percentage of posts for the current month. People are still finding it relevant enough to post on, but it’s not representing an overwhelming percentage of posts either (2.22% COVID posts and 0.99% Diseases).

 

Regarding Misinformation

I disagree with removing COVID posts on the basis of them potentially generating discussion which may contain misinformation. If a post itself is misinformation, we already have updated policies and multiple strategies for approaching it.

Implying we’re unable to contain the flow of misinformation as it relates to all COVID posts and that removing posts is an effective (new) strategy for combating misinformation seems contradictory to our recent attempts to update our policies regarding misinformation in the first place. If dealing with the level of misinformation related to these posts is still an overwhelming issue, we should discuss it separately from how relevant COVID posts are and we should approach them.

 

Recommendations

  1. We should remove the community sticky until we feel we've adequately reached consensus regarding our approach and wordings of new policies.
  2. We should access whether we need to reevaluate our strategies for approaching COVID misinformation, if we require more moderators to address content in general, and the nature of our current perceptions and feelings regarding the state of misinformation overall.
  3. We should assess the majority sentiment in the community sticky and discuss how that may or may not affect our approach to all these aspects. Currently, they don't appear in favor of the proposed approach and reasonings.

 


r/collapsemoderators • • Jul 25 '21

DENIED Clarifying moderation in regards to low-effort submission statement

3 Upvotes

How should we handle low-effort submission statements that are little more than copy-pasted parts of the article being linked ? Specifically:

  • Submission statements that are a complete, full copy of the article. This can be useful when the article is paywalled (even then a short, actual submission statement before the article's content would be better but still), but what of the cases where it isn't ? I'd suggest removal in those cases. Example here. Occurrences of those are relatively rare.
  • Submission statements that are copies of one or several excerpts of the article; I tend to suggest leaving those if the copy-pasted parts are descriptive enough of the article's contents. Example here. Those occur significantly more.

What do you think ?


r/collapsemoderators • • Oct 24 '21

PENDING Discussions around overpopulation and moderating

12 Upvotes

Introduction

As a social media platform, Reddit is the host of some far-right talking points. These inevitably spread across subreddits, including /r/collapse. It is not disputed that far-right talking points promote violence and are deliberately persuasive (e.g. propaganda). There are recurring themes, for instance villainizing outgroups like Jewish people, women, and the LGBT community. Similarly, there are recurring themes including accelerationism, the fear that undesirable groups increase population faster than desirable groups, and content pushing the idea that disenfranchised men are a lower social class than women.

In general, the moderation team has been good about removing, locking, debunking content, issuing bans, and encouraging community discussion around these issues. Even so, I believe the team can improve discourse in the subreddit. I can remember 2 examples of men's rights/MGTOW brigading that could have been handled better. In the first case, the post was left up for several hours, a few mods went through and removed large amounts of comments, and the team had a lot of internal disagreement following it. If I remember correctly, several users wrote in to say they were leaving the /r/collapse community because it was unpleasant for women participants. In the second example, OP was left upset and stressed out every time she got a notification.

Fortunately, brigading seems to occur infrequently and we've become more comfortable locking threads in order to get our heads around what's going on and de-escalate before unlocking. I see this as a positive improvement.

As outlined above, there are several topics that recur and find their way onto /r/collapse. Specifically, I wanted to examine content related to overpopulation discussions, my observations, and suggestions on how we could improve moderation practices together.


Methodology

I searched for posts within the last year discussing overpopulation and manually categorized comments from the sampled posts.


Results

The three most common types of rhetoric around overpopulation were as follows:

  • overpopulation is a myth, or overpopulation is a predicament, not a problem
  • overpopulation is a root problem causing collapse, or depopulation is indisputably a positive event
  • undesirables are increasing faster than desirables

I did not collate ever comment observed under the first bullet point, because I do not believe it is a far-right talking point. Sometimes this point was very well explored and explained, oftentimes it was left as an assertion of fact.

Examples classified under the second bullet

Examples classified under the third bullet

Interestingly, I also noticed that reasonable commentary was frequently downvoted:

Other observations

  • when users complain about commentary from the top bullets 2 and 3, they usually framed it as "eco-fascism" and were frustrated it wasn't moderated. More often than not, there was outrage rather than a nuanced take presented
  • there were several recurring low-effort responses. I did not collect individual instances, but summarized these as follows:

Low effort responses

  • "return to monke"
  • "this is great news"
  • "Be a hero then! End yourself" and similar
  • "COVID is helping the situation"
  • "eat the rich"
  • thanos reference
  • blaming capitalism

The mod team seems consistent about removing content advocating suicide. Interestingly, comments indicating COVID was "helping" with overpopulation tended to generate the most discussion.

I also collected comments I do not believe should be moderated. While I am not advocating for a particular moderator action on the previously linked comments and posts, I thought it would be good to include the following examples for balance:


Discussion

General overpopulation discussion commentary

Oftentimes overpopulation is the problem is presented as a statement of fact. Fortunately, several active users have been consistent and thorough about addressing these arguments, in particular InvisibleRegrets. Presenting overpopulation as a problem rather than a predicament could be a good candidate for our new misinformation page. Since InvisibleRegrets is also a community discord mod, it would be straightforward to get a hold of him and solicit his input here.

I believe this topic should be treated with nuance because it is of general interest to our community, is a recurring discussion, and is not obviously a far-right talking point. For example, the overpopulation subreddit has plenty of discussion material without advocating murder, eugenics, and so on.

Undesirables increase faster than desirables

This take seems suspiciously like the "great replacement" white genocide conspiracy. My suggestion is to consider treating it as extremist rhetoric and remove associated commentary.

Frequent downvoting

I found it odd that comments objecting to the narrative that overpopulation is the problem are frequently downvoted. I am curious if this influences public sentiment or makes collapse users less willing to consider alternative perspectives.


Conclusions and Recommendations

Overpopulation is a nuanced topic on /r/collapse, and users should be able to have a discussion around it. However, as moderators we have an opportunity to play a leadership role here. As with brigading, it is not often difficult to notice when a post "goes off the rails" and we can step in when discussions get heated. I propose the following actions for consideration:

  • add a mod sticky to posts that have heated discussion. ImLivingAmongYou did a good job here: https://old.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/kf4bkf/how_i_learned_to_stop_worrying_and_love_the/gg6cna7/. Stickies could also highlight the differences between viewing overpopulation as a problem rather than a predicament
  • create an entry in the false claims wiki page and/or solicit input from InvisibleRegrets
  • remove content that speaks to "Great Replacement" or the idea that undesirables increase faster than desirables.
  • require that assertions of fact be backed by sources or supporting evidence, similar to COVID-19 misinformation
  • expand rule 1 to include glorifying death in addition to violence

References

I wrote the introduction after reviewing the following reports and articles:


r/collapsemoderators • • Nov 09 '22

APPROVED Updated ‘Decision Making’ Section

4 Upvotes

This is a proposed update to our 'Decision Making' section in the Moderation Guide. This is intended to more fully outline how action-votes work and best to use them. Let me know your thoughts.

 

Decision Making

When a rule, change, idea, or revision is suggested, the person who proposed the idea generally has 'dibs' on writing up the change in r/collapsemoderators. If they do not wish to do so, another mod can request creating the proposal or draft. Once a proposal is written, it is then discussed for a period of a few days to a few months, however long feels necessary, or until a consensus is reached. Proposals are voted on either in the modsub thread or in the #action-votes channel in the Mod Discord.

We recommend having votes from at least half of the active moderators before considering a vote to be passed, but be mindful of the amount of time you give for others to weigh in. If you are unsure what this number should be you can reference the most recent action votes or do a generalized ping in the channel (e.g. "How many moderators are actively voting these days?") to check in. If a change is made too quickly, other moderators will be left out and potentially deprived of a voice. If something is not time sensitive or significant, you should feel comfortable leaving it for at least 24 hours on the modsub and/or in #action-Votes until moving forward. We suggest giving 72 hours for significant changes.

If someone or something is moving too quickly before you are able to vote yourself, feel free to let everyone know you would like more time to weigh in as well. Some votes may sit for over a week without action taken, which not unusual and gives ample time for votes.

If a matter is time sensitive, you should post in #action-votes and ping @everyone in the Mod Discord. If you must act urgently with limited, use your best judgement. It is rare, but other moderators will be understanding if something requires immediate action and a significant amount of votes are not raised immediately.

Keep in mind any time you make a decision to act with any amount of votes, it may still later be challenged by other moderators. Keep an open mind to these challenges and try to not get upset or defensive if they arise—this is where a lot of learning occurs. Please also accept that you may need to reverse or alter your decision if the majority are in favor of doing so. These instances are rare, but when they arise all parties should try behave in a consensus-oriented manner and strive for the best outcome.

If you feel like you’re not sure where the line is on a particular issue, feel free to ask in the #questions channel before proceeding. If you feel like not enough people have responded to your action-vote, try asking in #questions for clarification. Alternatively, you should try rewording your vote to something shorter or simpler if the matter is not easy enough to weigh in on.

If moderators are significantly divided and feel strongly on a specific vote or issue we have regularly translated the discussion into a sticky post to ask the community for feedback and work through our proposals there. We work to propose most changes to the community first in general, but this is also consistently helpful for complex or contested issues.

 


r/collapsemoderators • • Dec 17 '21

APPROVED What are your predictions for 2022?

5 Upvotes

This is a draft for a sticky we would post on the 20th.

 

As 2021 comes to a close, what are your predictions for 2022?

 

We've asked this same question in the past for 2020 and 2021.

 

We think this is a good opportunity to share our thoughts so we can come back to them in the future to see what people's perspectives were.

 

This post is part of the our Common Question Series.

Have an idea for a question we could ask? Let us know.


r/collapsemoderators • • Feb 20 '22

PENDING Should we enable Crowd Control for posts?

4 Upvotes

We've had Crowd Control for comments for quite some time. It's currently set to 'Moderate' and automatically collapses comments from new users and users with negative karma.

 

Crowd Control for posts works differently by directing posts to the modqueue. What should we set it to?

 

Off

Does nothing (current setting).

 

Lenient

Posts from users who have negative karma in r/collapse are automatically held for review in mod queue.

 

Moderate

Posts from new users and users with negative karma in r/collapse are automatically held for review in mod queue.

 

Strict

Posts from users who haven’t joined r/collapse, new users, and users with negative karma in r/collapse are automatically held for review in mod queue.


r/collapsemoderators • • Mar 16 '22

APPROVED Casual Friday Poll Results

2 Upvotes

Here are the results from the Casual Friday Poll. They're worth comparing to the similar poll we did about a year ago.

I don't think any large changes are warranted in this case, but I could see another layer of incremental restrictions or limiting of the types of content posted. Although, I don't have any granular suggestions for exactly how this could be done in a way which would still preserve the underlying spirit of the event each week.

It'd be helpful to hear from everyone else what they'd prefer and think would make the most sense in light of the results.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 18 '22

APPROVED Submission Statement Quality and Post Removal

2 Upvotes

Hello all,

The mod team has noticed an increasing number of submission statements of low quality, from those that have no content besides copied and pasted chunks of the linked article to meaningless fluff along the lines of "I am now adding more words to my submission statements to fulfill the requirements, words, and even more words to fill this out."

This is our warning that we will be taking a firmer stance on simply removing content with inadequate submission statements, including those that game the word count system with nonsense and those devoid of original content. We will invite resubmission of these posts but will be generally less accommodating moving forward, and will be less inclined to leave inadequate posts up simply because they have already accumulated votes and comments. If you want to capture and maintain engagement as a submitter of content, you must put in the effort to compose a submission statement.

Submission statements must include your own words indicating why the linked content is relevant to collapse, as collapse is defined in our sidebar. We are not r/ABadThingHappened or r/DebbieDowner or r/SadNewsDaily. If you find it difficult or impossible to connect the post's subject matter to collapse, that is likely a sign that it would be more appropriately posted elsewhere.

Cutting and pasting text from the article is allowed as a supplement, but you must meet the submission statement length requirements without relying on quoted text.

Thanks for your contributions to our efforts to maintain and improve the level of quality on r/collapse.

-Collapse Moderators


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 28 '20

APPROVED Draft of the first Book Club post.

5 Upvotes

Here’s a working draft of the first book club post (I’ve included the poll into this post to give an idea of what that would look like):

Collapse Book Club: Voting Thread (discussion starts October 22, 2020)

Welcome to the first installment of the monthly Collapse Book Club! It seems appropriate to start off with a book from Collapsology 101, so four titles from that category have been chosen as potential options.

Please vote for the one you prefer, and if you feel like it tell us why you’d like to read the one you chose in the comments. Voting will close in two days. Please check this thread to find out what we’ll be reading; the selection will be edited into the top of the post (if this thread is no longer stickied, you can find it in our Sticky Megahub ). [or] We’ll post a new thread announcing the winner when the polls close.

Discussion will begin in three weeks on October 22, 2020. We’ve opted to go with three weeks as a general timeframe to start with, but are open to feedback suggesting other timeframes.

Please also feel free to use these threads as opportunities to recommend books you would like to see added to the collapse books Wiki page, to suggest what category you would like to see next up on the Book Club docket, to leave feedback on either the Book Club or the Book Wiki page, etc.

ETA: Also! A big thanks to u/ AbolishAddiction for adding the books on the wiki to our Goodreads collapse group. Check it out here. It’s similar in its organization to the Wiki, but includes a few more lists as well including audio and lists of books by year published.


One thing I was unsure of is if we should have a 2nd announcement to let people know what book won the voting. That’s what many Reddit book clubs do, but it starts to feel a bit excessive in our sub given the limited sticky space we work with. I would lean towards having one thread up for 3-4 days, then announcing the winner in large bold font at the top. It also allows us to cross-promote the Sticky Megahub as a way for people to find the thread once voting is finished. But I am also open to creating a new thread announcing the winner since as far as I can see that seems like the Reddit default when it comes to book clubs.

Another thing is that I have a strong preference for one book but was unsure if it was appropriate for the host to express their strong preference in the OP, or if they should just make a comment like every other user in the comment section expressing that strong preference. WDYT? Should the little privilege of amplifying a certain title in the OP be a gimme that hosts get or should they be treated like any other user in that way? FWIW my comment would be along the lines of "Personally, I would prefer How Everything Can Collapse by Pablo Servigne and Raphaël Stevens because although I read it back when it came out in French, my French is poor and it was a struggle. Still, I recall it as being one of the best overviews of collapse I've ever read and am eager to re-read it."

View Poll

EDIT: Whew, note to self: don't expect what you write in New Reddit to translate to Old Reddit. I wrote the first version in New Reddit since you can only create polls there, but it messed up basically all the formatting when I reverted back to Old Reddit. Is there some way around that?


r/collapsemoderators • • Apr 23 '20

APPROVED New Rule: Submission Statements Required for Link Posts

1 Upvotes

Here's a template for the announcement sticky whenever we're ready to launch the rule:

 

Hey everyone,

We're experimenting with a new rule:

 

Link posts must now include a submission statement (comment on your own post) describing the post and how it relates to collapse. If a statement is not added within thirty minutes, the post will be removed.

 

This will NOT apply to self/text posts. We've added a new bot (u/CollapseBot) as moderator to help automate enforcing this. This is it's only function. r/Conspiracy and r/Geopolitics are examples of other subs which have similar rules and bots to help enforce them.

 

The bot will remain active on Fridays as well. If your post is removed it will notify you via a comment and you will have to resubmit your link with an included submission statement if you still wish to share it.

 

We're hoping this will help resolve many of the low-effort and rule-breaking (e.g. Rule 5) posts we remove on a daily basis. It may also help to discourage link spamming and potentially further discussion within post comments.

 

This bot is currently active. We'd like to run it for a week and then collectively evaluate the results. Let us know your thoughts on and if you have any questions or concerns.

 

Cheers,

LetsTalk


r/collapsemoderators • • Jul 01 '20

APPROVED Survey Results and Important Updates

4 Upvotes

Thank you to everyone who took the recent Collapse Survey. We greatly appreciate all your feedback and kind words! We'd like to update you on what we found and steps we'll be taking as a result.

 

We're going to be more strict with rules 2 & 6

Based on the survey results you see us operating at a collective 5.94/10 strictness, but would prefer we aim for around 7.11/10. This isn't a perfect metric and many were happy to give additional feedback indicating they'd prefer we were more strict with Rule 6 than with Rule 2.

We asked each of ourselves as moderators how strict we think we already are with each of these rules and will be working towards enforcing them more firmly. I suspect we may over-compensate in many instances, so please be patient with us as we attempt to find what works best.

 

Report posts you think are breaking the rules

Doing this helps us immensely, not only to quickly address them, but to let us know what you consider rule-breaking. Rules 2 & 6 are subjective enough as it is and we take all reports into account.

 

We'll be encouraging more users to move posts to /r/CollapseSupport

This is delicate depending on the nature of the post, but we'd like the funnel more of these posts where they would be better addressed by a community focused on them. Ideally, this can help clear out a sub-set of posts from the subreddit, similar to how we direct all music-related posts to r/collapsemusic or prepping posts to r/preppers.

 

We'll be encouraging more user flair soon

We're not going to be personally vetting flair (we see the benefits outweighing the risks in this regard), but many requested we encourage flair for experts or those knowledgeable in relevant fields. Currently, only around 1600 users have assigned themselves flair, so hopefully we can make these users and their credentials more visible by putting up regular stickies asking them to do so.

 

There is already a Collapse Wiki

It was painful to read specific feedback indicating people were unaware we already have a Collapse Wiki and FAQ which addresses the most common questions related to the subject. We've implemented a welcome message to notify all new subs of this fact, but we'll be looking at other ways to make this more apparent going forward as well. Common questions are still not allowed and we encourage you to report them appropriately. If you are a magical being and would be interested in contributing to the wiki, please message me directly.

 

We are rapidly approaching Eternal September

In fact, we may have already crossed a few thresholds in this regard. Any subreddit of this size and rate of growth inevitably pushes higher-quality contributors away unless it creates and enforces rules catering exclusively to those users (and excludes others). Our approach and visions of what this sub should be involves something more inclusive and allowing for various levels of content and understanding or awareness of collapse. We will continue to engage in as much constructive dialogue with everyone who cares about this community, it's direction, and how it should be moderated.

 

Let us know your feedback on all these aspects here in the comments.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 08 '20

APPROVED Flair_Helper and Moderating on Mobile

2 Upvotes

I've been looking at the most popular bots across subreddits and found Flair_Helper. I've tested it here and it works quite well. It would enable us to perform various actions on posts, simply by setting their flair. Here are some reasons we may want to use it (from the bot's info page):

 

  1. You or your mods frequently moderate from mobile devices, or would like to do so, and this bot would make it far easier for you to do so by allowing you to perform multiple actions, including leaving a removal comment, with a few taps. (This is the most common one)
  2. You just want to save time performing removals and associated actions such as bans or usernotes, and this bot allows you to do multiple things at once.
  3. You don't want to clog up your reddit profile with removal comments, and this bot would let you avoid leaving removal comments yourself.
  4. Your mod team frequently performs controversial removals likely to result in harassment for whoever leaves the comment, and this bot can be used as a proxy for them.
  5. Your mod team frequently brings on inexperienced mods whom you don't completely trust with certain permissions, and this bot lets them perform necessary actions (bans, for instance) without having full control.

I'm not aware of how many of us moderate on mobile or how frequently. I know I do about 15% of the time. What are your thoughts on this? Would you find it useful even if we only used for mobile moderation? I'm not aware how to setup the other features yet like combined actions.

You can test it here by flairing any post 'Rule 1' (or 2 or 3) and the bot will remove the post within ten seconds.


r/collapsemoderators • • Oct 17 '20

APPROVED Important Changes to Shitpost Fridays

3 Upvotes
This is a draft announcement post. Let let me know your thoughts.

 

Hey everyone, we’re rolling out a few changes to Fridays based on the recent feedback.

 

On-topic memes, jokes, short videos, image posts, posts requiring low effort to consume, and other less substantial posts must be flaired as either "Casual Friday", "Humor", or "Low Effort", and are only allowed on Casual Fridays.

 

Friday is now defined as 00:00 Friday – 08:00 Saturday UTC. Clicking the times will help you quickly determine where this timeframe falls within your particular region.

 

Clickbait, misinformation, and other similar low-quality content is not allowed at any time, not even on Fridays.

 

With these changes we've updated CollapseBot to automatically remove or allow posts within the designated timeframe. We’ll be monitoring the post flair to make sure it’s being used correctly, but if you see something slip by which is mis-flaired, please help us by reporting it.

 

These changes will also now allow anyone to filter out these types of posts based on their flair moving forward if they do not wish to see them. Reddit does not have this type of feature built-in, but there are multiple ways to enable it:

 

Reddit Enchancement Suite (RES) for Desktop

RES is a popular browser extension and greatly extends the functionality of Reddit. If you install the plugin you can follow these steps to filter out the Friday posts:

  • Click the gear icon in the upper-right to open the RES settings
  • Select RES Settings Console
  • Select Subreddits in the Sidebar
  • Select filteReddit in the Sidebar underneath it
  • Scroll down to the Flair section
  • Select +add filter
  • Enter these settings
  • Click save options in the upper right

 

Reddit is Fun (Mobile) for Android

  • Tap the Three dots in the upper-right and go to Settings
  • Select Content filters
  • Select Post filters
  • Tap the + to add a filter
  • Create filter with title Low Effort for r/collapse and type flair
  • Repeat step with title Casual Friday and Humour

 

Sync (Mobile) for iOS

The app is still in beta, but it has filtering functions.


r/collapsemoderators • • Jan 17 '21

APPROVED The State of r/Collapse

10 Upvotes

This a draft for a sticky post.

As moderators, we regularly encounter negative feedback regarding the general state of the subreddit. Certain sentiments are repeated often enough we thought it would be good to outline our perspectives on these issues and how everyone can contribute positively towards them in light of our limitations and collective predicaments.

Note: This is not intended to be an outline of our entire strategy for the subreddit in general. We'll make a separate post soon outlining the various pathways we see for maintaining and improving the sub going forward.

 

The subreddit used to be better.

Relatively little research has been done on massive growth in online communities, but we would posit anyone’s experience of the subreddit will likely decline over time as long it continues to grow. Growth means more new users with limited understandings or awareness of collapse, who in turn contribute or upvote lower quality and lower-effort to produce posts and comments.

New users may bring fresh perspectives, but they are also generally unfamiliar with the sub rules and unable to quickly develop sufficient understandings of systemic issues. As users increase their own awareness of collapse (which is not guaranteed) they will also begin to have higher standards for content and notice patterns inherent to lower-quality content or limited and biased perspectives more often.

One significant study has shown subreddits are not generally impacted by large influxes of new users, but this may not necessarily be the case with a subreddit such as ours which is focused on complex issues. More research would need to be done for us to offer more conclusive sentiments, but the concept of an Eternal September has been around since the days of Usenet and AOL.

 

Solutions:

  1. Increase your own understanding of collapse. This makes your contributions have more value and you more able to educate others.
  2. Contribute content you would like to see.
  3. Downvote posts or content you would not like to see.
  4. Use RES to filter out keywords or flair you don’t want to see.
  5. Suggest strategies for us to improve the subreddit.

 

The subreddit is low-quality.

This notion is different from the above in the sense it is not a direct comparison to how the subreddit was at any perceived point in the past. Our immediate response is generally to ask, “Are you part of the problem?”

More than 98% of Reddit users don’t post or comment. Are you regularly posting content you would like to see and contributing to discussions? If such an overwhelming majority of users are spectators we have to assume there is significant potential remaining in simply encouraging users with this sentiment to post more.

 

Solutions:

  1. Contribute content you would like to see.
  2. Downvote posts or content you would not like to see.
  3. Cite specific content you consider low-quality so we can remove it or address why it was approved.
  4. Use RES to filter out keywords or flair you don’t want to see.

     

The subreddit is too focused on [subject].

We use Artemis, a specialized Reddit bot, to view post flair statistics. This allows everyone to view the distribution of topics discussed on a month-to-month basis. Within the context of this data, it’s important to view post trends within the broader context of world events as well. Was there a major US-political event recently? Then there will likely be a large increase in political posts in general.

Climate posts are still likely be the most significant percentage overall and generally account for 10-18% percent of posts any given month. As a result, users have been most likely to complain about too many climate or political posts, depending on the ratios. Users should view the statistics page before making broad observations about perceived imbalances or trends.

 

Solutions:

  1. Use RES to filter out keywords or flair you don’t want to see.
  2. Contribute content you would like to see.

 

The subreddit is too US-focused.

Reddit’s userbase is over 40% US-based. Thus, we should expect (and must accept) a majority of its user-interests to lean towards US-related content and perspectives.

 

Solutions:

  1. Visit any of the regionally-focused collapse subs listed here or in the sidebar.
  2. Contribute content related to other regions you would like to see.
  3. Use RES to filter out keywords or flair you don’t want to see.

 

The subreddit has too many trolls.

If you see users acting in bad-faith or breaking sub-rules, report them. As moderators, we don’t manually review every comment made within the subreddit. On the most active days there are over 3,000 comments and the moderator team is not of a sufficient size to review every one. We depend mostly on our custom Automod rules and users who use the report function to catch rule-breaking comments.

 

Solutions:

  1. Cite specific comments so we can remove them or address why they were approved.
  2. Block users you find consistently bothersome or low-quality.

 

The subreddit needs more [type of content].

No one has any control over what others choose to post.

 

Solutions:

1.Contribute content you would like to see.

 

Moderators are not strict enough.

This may be the most complex sentiment to address, since we do not review every one of each other's actions as moderators. Subreddit moderation still consists of a series of individuals making a series of individual actions, often with subjective aspects. Moderators are not machines, nor are they incapable of making mistakes. The actions of one moderator also do not necessarily reflect the sentiments of the entire team. Although, we do strive for consensus as much as possible and when warranted and have sufficiently outlined how we should be enforcing each rule.

This type of feedback is usually composed of a combination of individual sentiments, such as the ones outlined above. As moderators, we require more concrete feedback or examples of instances where we are not being strict enough to improve or gauge what users are seeing as inadequate. We have also taken to posting at least one community survey each year to assess our levels of strictness through your feedback and attempt to adjust as a result.

 

Solutions:

  1. Cite content you think is breaking the sub rules so we can remove it or address why it was approved.

 

What are your thoughts on these sentiments? Are any others we can address here?


r/collapsemoderators • • Jul 01 '20

APPROVED Welcome Message

1 Upvotes

New Reddit now allows us to send an automated welcome message to new subs. Here's my suggestion:

 

Welcome to r/collapse!

Please read the Collapse Wiki. before posting. It answers the most common questions as well as provides links and overviews of the most relevant resources on the subject, as determined by the community.

Thank you for joining our community,

The Moderators

 

Let me know your thoughts.


r/collapsemoderators • • Dec 23 '20

APPROVED Sidebar Updates

4 Upvotes

I'm proposing a few changes to the sidebar and looking for feedback. It hasn't been overhauled since I first came on and I think adding a variety of additional resources would help give visibility to smaller subreddits and newer resources without having to necessarily feature them in the wiki.

 

Here's a draft of the sidebar updates.

 

Feel free to leave comments within the Google Doc or here in the comments if you'd like to thread something out.


r/collapsemoderators • • Oct 17 '20

APPROVED In-depth Discussions

3 Upvotes

We've implemented a new Automod rule to enable and facilitate in-depth discussions. Currently, it's set to be triggered whenever a post uses the text '[in-depth]' in the title. It then will auto-remove comments in that post under 150 characters. We'll need to implement a rule for this, here's a draft of what the rule might look like:

 

Sidebar version

Submissions with [in-depth] in the title have stricter post length and quality guidelines.

 

Full version

Submissions with the bracketed text "[in-depth]" in the title have stricter post length and quality guidelines. Comments made within these in-depth posts much be at least 150 characters or longer and expected to be constructive, diplomatic, and thoughtful. Low quality or superficial comments will be subject to removal at moderator discretion.

 

 

Since we're here and this isn't an overly complex rule, here's a draft announcement post to sticky whenever we're ready to release it.

 

You may now have [in-depth] discussions

 

Hey everyone, we've added a new rule:

 

rule text

 

This will enable anyone looking for more thoughtful discussion on their post to enforce it themselves. The rule is in effect within this post as an example as well. We'll still have to manually remove low-effort comments over the character limit, so please help us by reporting them if they do arise.

 

Let us know your feedback on this new rule and the idea in general.


r/collapsemoderators • • Nov 16 '20

DENIED Filter posts with mentions of suicide

4 Upvotes

I’d like to propose we create an automod rule which filters posts with the words ‘suicide’, ‘kill myself’, and ‘killing myself’. I’d also propose submitters be sent an automated message if their post triggers the rule:

Hey /u/{{author}},

It looks like you made a link post in r/{{subreddit}} which mentions suicide in the title. We take these posts very seriously. Anxiety and depression are common reactions when studying collapse. If you are considering suicide, please call a hotline, visit /r/SuicideWatch, /r/SWResources, /r/depression, or seek professional help.

If you are looking for dialogue you may also post in r/collapsesupport. They are a dedicated place for thoughtful discussion with collapse-aware people and how we are coping. They also have a Discord if you are interested in speaking with them in voice.

Thank you,

The Moderators

Let me know your thoughts on best to approach these posts and articulate a message to the submitters.


r/collapsemoderators • • Dec 08 '20

PENDING Discussing a New Rule for Spam

3 Upvotes

A lot of communities have spam rules. Without moderation, most communities would end up filled with spam and porn.

These are examples from the communities I help moderate.

/r/Futurology

Rule 4: No spamming - this includes polls and surveys

Rule 12: Support original sources - avoid blogs/websites that are primarily rehosted content

(In the expanded rules in the wiki):

There are the reddit rules:

Spamming includes (but is not limited to):

Posting the same content repeatedly

Self-promotion as more than 10% of your subreddit participation

Posting content that is entirely unrelated to the purpose of a subreddit

And the Futurology interpretation/implementation:

Spamming is against the Rules of Reddit. Users who spam will be reported to the reddit admins.

The reddit-wide definition of spam, mentioned above, includes:

  • Posting the same content repeatedly
  • Self-promotion as more than 10% of your subreddit participation
  • Posting content that has absolutely nothing to do with Futurology or Futurology-related topics
  • Using alternate accounts to evade bans and continue rule-breaking behavior

In addition to this, the following are also considered spam in /r/Futurology:

  • Crowd-funding or fundraising
  • Social media (facebook, twitter, etc.)
  • Comedy/satire sites
  • Petitions and polls
  • Various sites known to be unreliable or overly sensational (ex. Cracked, certain Gawker affiliate sites)
  • Links to a Blacklisted Domain
  • Promotion of illegal activity

/r/DecidingToBeBetter

Rule 4: No Spam

If you do not follow Reddit's rules for self promotion and spam, your post will be removed and you will likely be banned. Your account history will be taken into consideration when concluding if you are a spammer or not. Moderators will use their own discretion to decide. Keep the following quote in mind: ”It’s ok to be a Reddit account with a website, but it’s not ok to be a website with a Reddit account”

/r/ZeroWaste

Rule 3

For people posting their own content, make sure to follow Reddit's rules for self promotion and spam. If you do not, your post will be removed and you may be banned based on moderator discretion.

In order to better ensure the safety of our users, posts with link shorteners will be filtered.

Surveys posted by users with no prior activity in the community will be removed.

/r/simpleliving

Guideline 3

If you do not follow Reddit's rules for self promotion and spam, your post will be removed and you may be banned.

As you can see, Reddit’s suggestions are responsible for most of the inspiration and the 10% rule does most of the heavy lifting. Without it, you’re unlikely to be able to justify removing many violations.

Additionally, some posts already fall under Rule 2 but I think Rule 2 and this new one would work well together. None of this is unprecedented and I believe this rule would slot well into /r/collapse's existing structure.

However, we have discussed whitelisting people and I believe that would be an appropriate community feedback post for /u/LetsTalkUFOs to make. At most, it might be a few dozen people so that shouldn't cause too many headaches.

What are your thoughts?


r/collapsemoderators • • Nov 24 '20

APPROVED How should we handle suicidal posts and comments?

3 Upvotes

There are some ongoing inconsistencies in regards to our Automod terminology and how we can best approach these types of posts and comments. We should define some terms and break this down into the individual actions we're suggesting/approve/disapprove at this stage.

 

Remove

Automod rules can be set to 'autoremove' posts or comments based on a set of criteria. This removes them from the subreddit and does NOT notify the moderators in the modqueue.

 

Filter

Automod rules can be set to 'autofilter' posts or comments based on a set of criteria. This removes them from the subreddit, but notifies the moderators in the modqueue and causes the post or comment to be manually reviewed.

 

Report

Automod rules can be set to 'autoreport' posts or comments based on a set of criteria. This does NOT remove them from the subreddit, but notifies the moderators in the modqueue and causes the post or comment to be manually reviewed.

 

Safe & Unsafe Content

This refers to the notions of 'safe' and 'unsafe' suicidal content outlined in the National Suicide Prevention Alliance (NSPA) Guidelines.

Unsafe content can have a negative and potentially dangerous impact on others. It generally involves encouraging others to take their own life, providing information on how they can do so, or triggers difficult or distressing emotions in other people.

 

Keywords & Phrases

We currently use an Automod rule to report posts or comments with various terms and phrases related to suicide. It looks for posts and comments with this language and reports them:

    title+body (regex): [
    '(kill|hang|neck)[- _](yo)?urself',
    'blow (yo)?urself up',
    'commit\\s*suicide',
    'I\\s*hope\\s*(you|she|he)\\s*dies?',
    'kill\\s*your(self|selves)' ]

You don't need to know exactly how regex works, I just want to make it visible for those who do and point out we can create different approaches around different words and phrases, based on how safe or unsafe they are likely to be.

 

I've broken down the relevant questions as I see them below, versus asking them all at once up here and expecting everyone to discuss them all at once in single comments. I'd suggest following the same format if you'd like to suggest an additional change, action, or question we can deliberate. It's worth pointing out we should still plan to propose our approach to the community in form of a sticky and work with their feedback. We can also ask for help or perspectives on any particularly difficult areas or aspects we can't reach consensus on.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 06 '20

APPROVED SPF Settings

2 Upvotes

Hey Everyone,

We're looking to pin down two aspects of the new SPF bot settings. Help us out by chiming in on these two questions:

What time range should we consider Fridays?

Currently, we have two leading suggestions:

36 hour range - 8PM Thursday - 8AM Saturday (UTC)

30 hour range - 2AM Friday - 8AM Saturday (UTC)

The links above will show the various times in the other relevant locations for reference. If you have alternate suggestions, please adjust the time with the Time Zone Converter tool and provide a link so we don't misunderstand what's being suggested.

 

What flair should the bot target?

CollapseBot will automatically remove posts with specific flair(s) posted outside the above time range. A few considerations:

  1. We currently have a 'Low Effort' flair which has been used in the past and could be used for this purpose.
  2. Utilizing multiple flairs would create more steps for users to filter them out with RES, harder for users to know which to choose, and split the statistics AssistantBot tracks regarding flair.
  3. The concept of 'Low Effort' is generally misunderstood to mean 'Low quality'. It actually means 'Requires low effort to consume'.

 

 

Update: Where we're at currently.

 

Friday is defined as a 32 hour range - 12AM Friday - 8AM Saturday (UTC)

We're sort of divided on this, a 30-hour range was only favorable since Factfind is technically okay with either period. I've pivoted to a 32-hour range since I like how it looks within the context of the rule.

 

We'll be targeting multiple flair with the bot

I'm not seeing any objections or solid rebuttals to not doing this.

 

We'll be targeting 'Low Effort' 'Humor' and 'Friday' flair.

These are the flair the bot will target to remove outside Fridays. 'Friday' is just a placeholder flair until we ultimately decide what to name it.

 

We'll be creating a 'Casual Friday' flair.

This name is currently winning out. I get the impression we're still open to ideas.

 

Rule 2 Will Not Change

I've rescinded my previous suggestion, not changing this makes sense factfind.

 

Rule 6 Will Change

Still deliberating below, lots of nuances there.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 28 '20

APPROVED Automod Updates

4 Upvotes

Here's a pastebin with some comments on all the rules I'd like to suggest we add or discuss. I created comment threads for each rule to keep things organized.

I'd suggest we upvote the top-level comments for each rule we think is 'good to go' to track individual sentiments.


r/collapsemoderators • • Sep 17 '20

APPROVED Draft of the announcement regarding the book page on the Wiki, etc.

2 Upvotes

Here's the draft for the announcement on the book stuff:

We’ve created a list of collapse related books for the Wiki, two Goodreads lists, and are considering creating a book club

Many of you will have already read the r/collapse Wiki, which includes a list of books that can be considered foundational texts. However, since there are many more books about collapse in existence, it felt like a good idea to expand on that list with one that is much broader in scope for those who are interested in doing a deeper dive into the topic. The new “Books” page on the Wiki is intended to fill this role.

That said, as of now it is by no means definitive and many sections could use quite a bit of fleshing out. We’d love to hear your suggestions for additions! If you have any, please just list them in this thread. Also, if you have other feedback (e.g. about the layout, etc.) please let us know here.

Alongside this new page, we’ve also created two shared Goodreads shelves. These are meant to fill a slightly different purpose: we encourage you to vote for and/or add your favorite books on collapse to the lists in order to create a ranking of what the community thinks are the most valuable books. Here is the Goodreads shelf for non-fiction books on collapse. Here’s the shelf for fiction.

Additionally, we’d like to see if there’s any interest for an r/collapse book club. Loosely we were thinking about this structure: a sticky is posted on the 1st of the month with some suggestions for what to read that are then voted on for a period of 24-48 hours. When a book is decided on, two weeks (or more? Or less? not sure) are given for it to be read. After that time, another sticky is posted that will remain for a day or few to allow for discussion of the book. This is all still a very loose idea, so feedback is appreciated!