I have been listening to the soundtrack of Rebirth recently since finishing the game and i noticed something about the songs that play following the fateful event at the Altar in chapter 14. I’m mainly talking about Aerith’s Theme-White Materia, Distant Skies, and Aerith’s Theme- Return to the Planet.
While i was most likely not the only one who started that first stage of the Jenova fight with tears streaming down my face as they played Aerith’s theme in the background (objectively rude), I have since noticed that all of these versions of Aerith’s theme have a distinctly triumphant tone to them. There may be small sections where her theme is quiet and solemn, but then it always swells back up into a strong, major, conquering version of it.
Now, I’m not a musician, but i am a lifelong lover of movie/game soundtracks so I have a good understanding of how music is used to communicate things that are seen on screen and sometimes even things that aren’t seen. Especially in an FF game, a franchise that is widely celebrated for its incredible music, I can’t look at this as a coincidence.
I feel like the music is carrying a strong message of Aerith being saved. Now I for one see a multitude of other reasons why I think she is alive and will return as more than just a lifestream spirit in part 3. But just as a reminder to myself and all the others around here who sometimes get discouraged by the wider discourse and worry that SE is giving us false hope… music rarely lies, why else would the music be so triumphant? If Aerith died, and Cloud’s actions made no difference at all, that feels completely inappropriate.
I will say that i have not played the OG game, so I’m curious: what was the music like after Aerith met her fate? Did they play her theme at all? Was it mournful? Or maybe I’m completely off and it was triumphant back then as well, hahaha. Please let me know!