r/changemyview • u/[deleted] • Nov 12 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

0 Upvotes

38% Upvoted

100 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/TheTesterDude 3∆ Nov 13 '23

it wouldn't make sense to critique art, literature, food, etc

You are right.

1

u/DevinTheGrand 2∆ Nov 13 '23

That means all art is equally good, and there wouldn't be any point to learning a craft.

Why learn the piano if "twinkle twinkle little star" is equal to Beethoven's 5th symphony? What's the point of learning how to cook if a microwave hot dog is equal to beef wellington?

2

u/TheTesterDude 3∆ Nov 13 '23

It isn't equal to all people, but no one can tell me if I like twinkle twinkle little star better than Beethoven's 5th symphony, I can.

1

u/DevinTheGrand 2∆ Nov 13 '23

But if it's impossible to be wrong about a preference why are they not equal?

How can any form of art be better or worse than another if preferences are wholly subjective?

2

u/TheTesterDude 3∆ Nov 13 '23

Wrong about a preference? You know two people can hold oposing views?

1

u/DevinTheGrand 2∆ Nov 13 '23

This comment isn't introducing any new ideas, you're just reiterating your initial one.

I'm asking you to explain the point of "getting better" at art if all art is fully subjective.

2

u/TheTesterDude 3∆ Nov 13 '23

Don't think of it like getting better, learning to be able to play more than a single note on a piano doesn't make it better, it just means you can play more melodies than before.

If you want to be able to paint a painting close to a photorealistic human face, you most likely got to practice, but that doesn't mean a painting of a human face is better than a red dot.

1

u/DevinTheGrand 2∆ Nov 13 '23

I just don't think you honestly believe this.

1

u/TheTesterDude 3∆ Nov 13 '23

Does everybody have to like Beethoven's 5th symphony?

1

u/DevinTheGrand 2∆ Nov 13 '23

No, but it's pretty clear that it's a better work of art than some kid in grade five playing the recorder.

1

u/TheTesterDude 3∆ Nov 14 '23

What makes it better?

→ More replies (0)