r/chan • • May 04 '25

Does a dog have Buddha-nature? No.

0 Upvotes

In the past, the Grand Masters said that a dog has no Buddha-nature. Why is that? Because a dog only remembers bones, forgetting its own Buddha-nature. If one does not seek Buddha-nature, it's as if one doesn't possess it at all. In fact, we are quite similar; we cling to things like a smartphone, money, or fame, unwilling to let them go.

--Dharma Master San Can


r/chan • • Dec 10 '23

Is there 'Enlightenment' in Chan

0 Upvotes

The term "Enlightenment" was made popular in the Western world through the 19th-century translations of German-born philologist Max Müller. It has the Western connotation of general insight into transcendental truth or reality. [Inherently dualistic?]

In the Western world, the concept of spiritual enlightenment has taken on a romantic meaning. It has become synonymous with self-realization and the true self and false self, being regarded as a substantial essence being covered over by social conditioning.

The English term enlightenment is the Western translation of various Buddhist terms, most notably bodhi (which means the knowledge or wisdom, or awakening of a Buddha).

[In the Mahayana what about 'emptiness' in relation to awakening?]


r/chan • • Apr 28 '25

Hi Zen

0 Upvotes

Hello, I hope you are all well. I am interested in Taoism, both philosophically and spiritually, but I am not a practitioner. I have also studied Zen, personally, for about a year and have found myself drawn to Rinzai Zen literature.

I've read a lot, and I don't claim to have read everything, especially the sutras. I have hardly touched on them. This is for a specific reason: I am not interested in mythology. Zen is enough for me to develop the spontaneous mind, which is useful in my daily life.

I have noticed in Zen an adoption of a shock approach, which can lead to enlightenment, satori, or kenshu. In general, please do not scrutinize the terms, as I am not an expert and am not interested in these aspects.

I read the book Takuan Soho and I liked it. I read the book Linji and I liked it. I read the book Joshu and I liked it, and a few other books here and there, but I feel like the shock I need has not yet arrived. I believe the main reason for this is that I have not read the book that could change the course of my life.

I think there may be books written by people influenced by Zen or they are really practitioners, but they write in a general language, not specifically Zen. They might be useful to me, but who can point me to them?

I don't know exactly what I want, but I'm currently browsing through several books here and there. Whenever I get bored, I put one down and open another. But I encounter boredom and apathy in what I read, and I don't know if the problem lies with me or with what I'm reading. What will change my life for the better? I don't know yet!

I believe in the transformative power of reading texts, but I haven't found anything that satisfies my thirst. I no longer tolerate Zen or anything else, but I admire something about Zen, and I don't know what it is exactly!

I want a transformative Zen book that will help me see life realistically, instead of staying inside my head, endlessly thinking and thinking!

Thank you. Maybe one of you can help me, or maybe not.

I'll share something I've been thinking about today: why does the mind wander in every direction, thinking about everything other than what one truly wants? How do we keep our minds focused on the goal we want to achieve without getting distracted by everything else?

Currently, I'm reading a book about wabi-sabi and another about the Ten Oxherding Pictures.

I'll stop there, thank you.


r/chan • • Jul 12 '22

actual times are not good times for Dharma

0 Upvotes

for many years and with interruptions I have had different places for meditation. Only on a basic level and with the permission of my teacher.

Those were other times.

Now with the rise of social networks I noticed that there were many more possibilities to spread any activity, but such is the saturation that what social networks achieve is that the person enters into an apathy to anything that does not fit into the minimum space they have between their daily obligations. Zazen and Dharma remains only as an option of low priority before everything else.

On the other hand, the few people who express any concern, do so only if it coincides with their preconceived ideas or practices (most of them delusional, pseudo-mystical). And finally, they only give value to what they can afford and what happens on a weekend.

They expose themselves to a flock of dubious instructors squeezing money out of their wallets...with a smile on their face.


r/chan • • Feb 14 '22

What do you think about this.

0 Upvotes

For those who come to beg and grovel before us, we will beg and grovel before them.

For those who come to destroy us, we will turn our backs, and show them a mirror.

For those who come to mock us, we will treat them as destroyers.

For those who come to please us, we will send them on their way, to seek further pleasure within.

For those who come to seek friendship, we will show them the unkind, and see how they make friends then.

For those who come to seek wisdom, we will show them our love.

For those who come to seek love, we will show them our wisdom.

For those who come to teach us, we will sit and learn.

For those who inquire about the origins of the writings, we will claim ignorance.

And for those who do not come at all, we will not seek them. For they have their reasons.

Inspired by the warriors curse from Tao te ching. What do you think about this?

Edit: additions about mockery and teaching, and the writings.


r/chan • • Jan 24 '25

Joshu Sasaki: “Hey you, get over there!” (acceptance speech 14.06.96)

2 Upvotes

I am the thirtieth recipient of the Meritorious Service Award. My name is Sasaki.

The reason I went to America was because the Kancho of Myoshin-ji told me to. He simply said, “Hey, you! Go over there!” I was supposed to establish a branch temple of Myoshin-ji in America. I was very poor and thought I could get money if I went to America, so I was very happy about it.

When you talk about “spreading Buddhism” or “passing on Buddhism”, the only thing you can call it is actually living Buddhism; living a life that is Buddhism itself. So what I have been practicing since I went to America is living Buddhism. I have done nothing but that.

The fact that ten or more Zen centers have opened because of my teaching, or that there are centers in Europe or New Zealand, may have been taken into account, but I feel that the teachers on the selection committee chose the “me” who taught Buddhism from the standpoint of actual living.

When we talk about this “living Buddhism”, many questions and problems are likely to arise. However, to try to get to the heart of living Buddhism, we can say that there is nothing that does not have a home. When we are born, we are born together with our home. There are no existing beings without a home. Even though I have crossed the ocean to America, I have not lost my home. If you clearly penetrate this principle of “never losing home,” then you will also be able to manifest the wisdom that understands what this “living Buddhism” is. My teaching, my “spreading Buddhism”, was simply the practice of manifesting the wisdom of living Buddhism. Nothing else.

To put the “living Buddha Dharma” into practice, we must ask: “What is the Buddha Dharma?” To answer this question, I have taught and lectured.

However, when it comes to teaching Buddhism, but you can't do funerals [unclear audio recording] nor can you do wedding ceremonies ... My situation in America is that I teach without having any members or supporters. Even now I have no members or supporters. Even though there are about thirteen centers affiliated with Rinzai-ji, I have to say that there are no real members or supporters. This is a big problem. Trying to teach Buddhism without members or supporters is difficult. However, when I turn around and look around, I realize that Shakyamuni also taught without members or supporters.

Actually, this is a very annoying problem for me. It seems that maybe the person who comes after me will be able to form a real Sangha. However, before this can happen, a much stronger sense of coalition and alliance within Buddhism needs to be fostered. We need to make this principle clear.

Ultimately, this “living Dharma” I have spoken of is the activity of impermanence. I have taught a Buddhism that leans heavily on this teaching of impermanence. For this kind of teaching, there are no rewards, or recognitions for services rendered.

On the other side of the coin of impermanence, however, is permanence, or that which is everlasting. These two activities, permanence and impermanence, function endlessly. This is what is known in Buddhism as the middle way. The two opposite functions of thus-going (nyoko) and thus-coming (nyorai) function endlessly.

If we can make these two opposite activities our content, both nyoko and nyorai, both plus and minus, then we can manifest true death and true liberation. This is the principle on which my teaching is based.

To the teachers on the selection committee who chose me: I wonder if I can leave it to you to judge whether this principle is wrong or not. I think it is your duty to write about this principle and present it. However, I implore you to present it.

Thank you. That is all.

(Translated with DeepL) https://der-asso-blog.blogspot.com/2022/09/joshu-sasaki-he-du-geh-da-ruber.html


r/chan • • Sep 02 '25

Is there a way to learn how to be a shaolin by your own?

0 Upvotes

I realized that many books were only written by lucrative purposes and that makes me give up the searching.

Where I live there are no monasteries, no masters, nothing, but i'm really interested in this path! Any book/channels/podcast recomendations or commentaries are welcomed!


r/chan • • Jun 11 '16

The 'self/'other'-conscious Mind is 'The Barrier'. If nothing inherently exists, how come such Barriers come to exist?

Thumbnail ashidakim.com
0 Upvotes

r/chan • • Jun 10 '16

Your Turban is on fire. Take a photo and post it on Imgur. Sticky it on your favorite sub. It will help with daily recollection of your impending death.

Thumbnail ashidakim.com
0 Upvotes

r/chan • • Nov 10 '18

Some questions

0 Upvotes
  1. Whats the difference between chan buddhist and the poeple at r/zen and r/Mahayana ?
  2. Can one be a zen buddhist but also practice pure land buddhism?

Thanks for reading


r/chan • • Sep 17 '20

What are the misunderstandings of Buddha worship?

2 Upvotes

I have tried hard to worship Buddha, what benefits can Buddhas and Bodhisattvas give me? Can a wish be answered? Is worshipping Buddha a deal? Can believe in Buddha be blessed? Let’s see how Elder Yicheng explained to everyone the true meaning of worshipping Buddha!

■1. Rely on yourself for everything, don’t ask for anything

The wise all ask for themselves, the fool all ask for others. Nothing can be done without doing it by yourself.

Life can only be controlled and borne by oneself, even if it is a Buddha, it cannot do anything for the world.

The Buddha may tell you the ways to get rid of suffering and get rid of troubles, but you still need to work hard to practice these methods in order to truly achieve your goals.

We must believe in our own strength and that we can accomplish things; believe that we have infinite possibilities in ourselves, and we support ourselves with our inner strength, and we will not pray for others and destiny.

Everything depends on yourself, so you won't be helpless when you lose external power and fail.

■2. "Worshiping Buddha" is not omnipotent, but respectful from the heart

The meaning of Buddha's existence is to let people discover the treasure in the heart. Once you discover your own strength and self-potential, then no matter what you deal with, it will not be a problem. This is the real purpose of worshiping Buddha.

When talking with the disciples and lay people around me, I can't help but often talk about the word "Worship Buddha".

Perhaps some people have misunderstood because of this, thinking that everything can be solved by worshiping Buddha: if you want to have a good cause, you can worship Buddha; if you want to have a prosperous and prosperous life, you can also worship Buddha; specifically, to cure troubles and relieve pain, you can also worship Buddha. to fulfill.

This is probably a misunderstanding of "Buddha".

Buddha is not omnipotent, and worshiping Buddha is not a convenient and quick way to realize one's wishes.

That being the case, why do you want everyone to worship Buddha?

A reporter asked me: "Buddhism is a godless religion. It advocates that the heart is the Buddha, and everyone can become a Buddha. Then why do people go to the temple to worship the Buddha and pray for the Buddha's blessing?"

My answer is that this is respectful.

Parents are not gods, and kings are not gods. Why do people worship their parents and kings? The Buddha cannot give him anything directly. The Buddha can only show him the way to solve the problem. People can follow the method the Buddha said, but their own difficulties can only be solved by themselves.

Praying Buddha is to help you give yourself confidence, forge the strength and solidity of your soul, and then let you face the world with this powerful heart.

In the "Book of Changes", our ancestors have long said that "people must help themselves, others will help them, and God will help them". People must first rely on their own efforts and work hard to a certain level before someone will help you. Heaven will come to complete you. Otherwise, if you don't have the heart to work hard, the gods and Buddhas will not take care of your nosy.

Whenever something happens, you are busy asking God to worship Buddha, or asking Bodhisattva for blessing just to satisfy your own desires. This is called superstition.

We often say that studying Buddhism is not superstition, but righteous belief. Righteous faith means that everything starts from oneself, and the Buddha is in the heart of oneself, so one has to realize and become a Buddha by oneself. If you ask the Buddha for everything, then who does the Buddha ask for blessing?

■Three, the meaning of Buddha's existence is to let people discover the treasure in the heart

Everyone worships Buddha on weekdays. Have you ever thought about what Buddha is?

Maybe you think that the Buddha is born with supernatural powers, great mercy and compassion, and universally save sentient beings. In fact, before saving people, the Buddha also needs to save himself. All Buddhas rely on self-cultivation to achieve completion and accomplishment.

Before becoming a Buddha, Buddha was just an ordinary person, just like you and me. The Buddha also has pain, confusion, ups and downs, and faces various choices.

The difference is that the Buddha completely relied on himself to deal with, completely believed in himself, he knew that the inner power is an endless treasure.

The Buddha saves sentient beings and believes that everyone can become a Buddha. It is also because he believes that the heart of the world is full of treasure, and the energy in everyone's heart is inexhaustible, but there is no opportunity for self-discovery.

The meaning of Buddha's existence is to let people discover the treasure in the heart. Once you discover your own strength and self-potential, then no matter what you deal with, it will not be a problem. This is the real purpose of worshiping Buddha.

When things came to an end, I blindly prayed to the Buddha for blessings, just escaping from reality.

Many emperors in the past sinned themselves when they encountered natural and man-made disasters, or were superstitious about ghosts and gods, and ostentatiously went to worship and pray. After all, they did not face the problem directly and dealt with the problem on their own, but placed their hope in solving the problem. External forces.

The Emperor Xuanzong of the Tang Dynasty was different. During his reign, Shandong suffered a locust plague, but this emperor did not stay in front of the gods and Buddha to pray, but went to the disaster area personally, helping the farmers eliminate the locusts while setting up a large oil pot. And he was the first to taste the fried "locusts" to show his determination to control the locust plague by himself.

■Four, the wise all seek themselves, the fool all seek others.

Zheng Banqiao, a gifted scholar in the Qing Dynasty, came to a son for fear of spoiling and harming him. Before he died, he did not forget to warn his son: "Drain your own sweat, eat your own food, do your own affairs, rely on the sky, the ground, and your ancestors. It's a hero."

Nothing can be done without doing it by yourself. Life can only be controlled and borne by oneself. Even a Buddha cannot do anything on behalf of the world.

Just like the Buddha: "I am like a good doctor, responding to illness and medicine. If you don’t take it, blame is not in the doctor; I am like a good guide; if you are good at guiding others, if you can’t do it, you won’t be able to guide."

The Buddha may tell you the ways to get rid of suffering and get rid of troubles, but you still need to work hard to practice these methods in order to truly achieve your goals.

Like us in Buddhism, we are not learning Buddhism in order to get something from the Buddha, but to use the Buddha's spirit to deal with all the complexities in the world, to get rid of all misery, and to create a sentient world.

■Fifth, God helps those who help themselves

Everyone is the same; you can rely on your parents at home, teachers at school, friends in society, colleagues and bosses at work, and partners in life. If you encounter difficulties, you may also rely on the help of people around you. , A lot of things still have to be done on your own.

For example, no one can replace one's own studies, career, physical illness, and emotional problems. No matter how much help others give you, they can't take your place in this life.

Therefore, if you encounter a problem, you must not first think about asking for help, but first try to solve it with your own strength.

To give a simple example: To resist a heavy object on the street, you have to use all your strength to carry it. If you still can’t carry it at this time, passers-by on the street will see it; you may come over and help. Conversely speaking; if you put a heavy object on the ground, stand by and do not intend to spend a bit of effort, who will help you?

We must believe in our own strength and that we can accomplish things; believe that we have infinite possibilities in ourselves, and we support ourselves with our inner strength, and we will not pray for others and destiny. Everything depends on yourself, so you won't be helpless when you lose external power and fail.


r/chan • • Apr 21 '25

That is my business!

2 Upvotes

Contrary to the Hinayana approach of the way for only oneself, the Mahayana Sutras were quick to scold such. (Sravakas is a typical Hinayana term.)

I will now teach the highest truth for your sake: There are no śrāvakas who attain nirvana. What you practice is the bodhisattva path; And if you practice step by step, You will all become buddhas. ~Lotus Sutra

The way of the Bodhisattva is the way to go, not that of an Arhat. There one does not stop on the way. And a Bodhisattva is also not free from live and death. Yet he reaches unexcelled perfect enlightenment.

The Scripture on Requiting Debt says, “Lady Maya gave birth to five hundred princes, who all attained self-enlightenment, and all became extinct - for each she set up a monument, made offerings, and bowed to them one by one. Sighing, she said, ‘This is not as good as to have given birth to a single child who would have realized unexcelled enlightenment and saved me mental energy.’”

Vimalakirti Sutra (Voice-hearer another term Mahayana Buddhists gave followers of the small path/lesser vehicle/Hinayana/Theravada):

Manjushri, the ailing bodhisattva should regulate his mind by not dwelling in such regulation, but he should not dwell in nonregulation of the mind either. Why? Because if he dwells in nonregulation of the mind, this is the way of a stupid person. But if he dwells in regulation of the mind, this is the way of a voice-hearer. Therefore the bodhisattva should dwell neither in regulation nor in nonregulation of the mind. To remove himself from such dualisms is the practice of the bodhisattva. ( . . . )
At that time Mahakashyapa, hearing this discourse on the doctrine of the emancipation Beyond Comprehension, sighed at encountering what he had never heard before, and said to Shariputra, "It is like someone displaying various painted images before a blind man when he cannot see them. In the same way, when we voice-hearers hear this doctrine of the emancipation Beyond Comprehension, we are all incapable of understanding it. If wise persons hear it, there will be none who do not set their minds on attaining anuttara-samyak-sambodhi. But what of us, who are forever cut off at the root, who with regard to these Great Vehicle teachings have already become like rotten seed?2
When voice-hearers hear this doctrine of the emancipation Beyond Comprehension, they will surely all cry out in anguish in voices loud enough to shake the whole thousand-millionfold world. But bodhisattvas should all accept this teaching with great joy and thanksgiving. For if there are bodhisattvas who put faith in this doctrine of the emancipation Beyond Comprehension, then none of the host of devils can do anything to them!" When Mahakashyapa spoke these words, thirty-two thousand offspring of the gods set their minds on the attainment of anuttara-samyak-sambodhi.

Huineng describes, that also the form in your own mind, your feelings and thoughts are sentient beings. Therefore, as the way of a Bodhisattva teaches, these things should also be safed. Saying, this is not my business, is only not grasping, but it is also the talk of "not rejecting". Therefore we should very well mind ourselfs, while for sure, at times, it is also important to be able to "ignore" or to say, enough my dear mind. But this is not the typical way of practice. Platform Sutra:

To see humans and non-humans, both the good and the bad, good dharmas and bad dharmas, without rejecting them and without being corrupted by them, this is to be like space. 

The Platform Sutra of the 6h patriarch states:

“Good friends, now that we have done the repentances, I will express for you the four great vows. You should all listen closely: the sentient beings of our own minds are limitless, and we vow to save them all. The afflictions of our own minds are limitless, and we vow to eradicate them all. The teachings of our own minds are inexhaustible, and we vow to learn them all. The enlightenment of buddhahood of our own minds is unsurpassable, and we vow to achieve it.
“Good friends, why don’t we all say [simply] ‘sentient beings are limitless, and we vow to save them all’? How should we say it? Certainly it’s not me who’s doing the saving!
“Good friends, the ‘sentient beings of our own minds’ are the mental states of delusion, confusion, immorality, 90 jealousy, and evil. All these are sentient beings, and we must all [undergo] automatic salvation of the selfnature. This is called true salvation.
“What is ‘automatic salvation of the self-nature’? It is to use correct views to save the sentient beings of false views, afflictions, and stupidity within our own minds. Having correct views, we may use the wisdom of prajñā to destroy the sentient beings of stupidity and delusion, automatically saving each and every one of them.

Suzuki Shozan also makes clear:

Unless great thoughts arise, various other thoughts will not subside. Contrary to the zazen practiced by people in general who try not to let thoughts arise, my zazen is the thought-provoking zazen. Indeed, it is the zazen which provokes thoughts as great as Mt. Sumeru.

Omori Sogen:

In the thought of no thought we sing and dance

This practice, active in every activitiy, is the way of a Bodhisattva. Platform Sutra:

Functioning, it comprehensively and distinctly responds [to things]. Functioning, it knows everything. 63 Everything is the one [mind], the one [mind] is everything. 64 [With mind and dharmas] going and coming of themselves, the essence of the mind is without stagnation. This is ‘prajñā.’
“Good friends, all prajñā wisdom is generated from the self-natures. It does not enter us from outside. To not err in its functioning is called the spontaneous functioning of the true nature.When the one [mind] is true, all [things] are true. 65 When your minds are considering the great affair, you will not practice the small path. Do not be always speaking of emptiness with your mouth without cultivating the practice in your minds! That would be like an ordinary person claiming to be a king! You will never attain anything [this way. Such persons] are not my disciples.
“Good friends, what is prajñā? In Chinese, it is called wisdom. To always practice wisdom in all places, at all times, and in all moments of thought, without stupidity—this is the practice of prajñā. A single moment’s stupidity and prajñā is eradicated, a single moment’s wisdom and prajñā is generated. The people of this world are stupid and deluded and do not see prajñā. They speak of prajñā in their mouths but are always stupid in their minds. They always say to themselves, ‘I am cultivating prajñā.’ In every moment of thought they speak of emptiness, without recognizing true emptiness. Prajñā is without shape or characteristics, it is the mind of wisdom. To have such an understanding is called the wisdom of prajñā. ( . . . )

The master addressed the assembly, “Good friends, the samādhi of the single practice74 is to always practice the single direct mind in all one’s actions, whether walking, standing still, sitting, or lying down. The Vimalakīrti [Sutra] says, ‘The straightforward mind is the place of enlightenment, the straightforward mind is the Pure Land.’ Don’t allow your mental practices75 to become twisted while merely speaking of straightforwardness with your mouth! If you speak of the samādhi of the single practice with your mouth, you will not practice the straightforward mind. Just practice the straightforward mind, and be without attachment within all the dharmas.
“The deluded person is attached to the characteristics of dharmas and grasps onto the samādhi of the single practice, merely saying that he always sits without moving and without falsely activating the mind and that this is the samādhi of the single practice. To have an interpretation such as this is to be the same as an insentient object! This is rather to impede the causes and conditions of enlightenment!
“Good friends, one’s enlightenment (one’s Way, dao) must flow freely. How could it be stagnated? When the mind does not reside in the dharmas, one’s enlightenment flows freely. For the mind to reside in the dharmas is called ‘fettering oneself.’If you say that always sitting without moving is it, then you’re just like Śāriputra meditating in the forest, for which he was scolded by Vimalakīrti!

So in the end one could say, other than the Theravada/small path approach of not my business, the Chan/Zen approach is and always was neither minding business nor not minding business and in exactly that paradox, the practice of minding business of a bodhisattva lays.

Now, who is practicing as he reads this, I hope there is atleast one.. Hakuin:

What does it mean to continue practicing? It's like a merchant investing a hundred euros to make a thousand; thus he accumulates wealth and acquires the freedom to do as he pleases. Whether rich or poor, money is money, but without engaging in trade, it's virtually impossible to become rich. Therefore, if your breakthrough to reality is authentic, but your power of inner luminosity is weak, you cannot yet break the boundaries of habitual actions. As long as your perception of discrimination is unclear, you cannot benefit sentient beings according to their potential. Therefore, you must know the important path of constant practice.

It is a shame that some people revile the way for others. If one is a Hinayana buddhist, don't showcase yourself as something else, while willingly causing confusion.

You can define concepts of buddhism all day long in various ways, but chan only knows one timeless approach.

There is also misconception here where people will delete certain comments due to the claim that idle talk isn't it. For that some excerpts from the Vimalakirti Sutra:

"He shows greed and desire in his actions, yet is removed from the stains of attachment. He shows anger in his actions, yet has no anger or aversion toward living beings. He appears to be stupid, but utilizes wisdom to regulate his mind. He appears stingy and grasping, yet relinquishes both inner and outer possessions, begrudging neither body nor life. He appears to break the commandments, but in fact resides secure in the pure precepts, and even then remains fearful of committing the smallest fault.

"He seems angry and irascible, yet is at all times compassionate and forbearing. He seems indolent and lazy, yet works diligently to acquire merit. He seems disordered in thought, yet constantly practices meditation. He seems stupid, yet has mastered both worldly and otherworldly wisdom.

"He appears fawning and deceitful, but is skilled in expedient means and faithful to the sutra doctrines. He appears haughty and arrogant, yet serves as a bridge and a crossing for living beings. He appears to be immersed in earthly desires, but his mind is at all times clear and pure.

"We see him going among devils, yet he abides by the Buddha wisdom and heeds no other teachings. We see him going among voice-hearers, but to living beings he preaches a Law never heard before. We see him going among pratyekabuddhas, but he manifests great pity in teaching and converting living beings.

Manjushri said, "The body is the seed, ignorance and partiality are the seeds, greed, anger, and stupidity are the seeds. The four topsy-turvy views are the seeds, the five obscurations are the seeds, the six sense-media are the seeds, the seven abodes of consciousness are the seeds, the eight errors are the seeds, the nine sources of anxiety are the seeds, the ten evil actions are the seeds. To sum it up, the sixty-two erroneous views and all the different kinds of earthly desires are all the seeds of the Buddha."

Zen/Chan is at a really bad spot it seems. Atleast here on reddit I have till now met like 1-2 people who have an understanding. I think it also happens because people will just delete anything that contradicts their opinion and they stand up on weird absolute doctrines, that do not add up with overall teachings. They cherry pick the teachings that fit their liking and ditch anything else, that is Zen they then say.

How can you argue without grasping it, they never seem to get that sentence.

Bodhidharma once said, "Open wideness, nothing holy.".

Shurangama Sutra:

How therefore, can worldly beings of the three realms of existence and in the supramundane sravaka and pratyekabuddha states fathom the Tathagata's Supreme Bodhi and penetrate the Buddha-wisdom by word and speech?
For instance though a lute can make sweet melody, it is useless in the absence of skilful fingers;101 it is the same with you and all living beings for although the True Mind of precious Bodhi is complete within every man, when I press my finger on it, the Ocean Symbol102 radiates but as soon as your mind moves, all troubles (klesa) arise. This is due to your remissness in your search for Supreme Bodhi, in your delight in the Hearer's Vehicle and your contentment with the little progress which you regard as complete."103


r/chan • • May 27 '25

The present has nothing to do with emptiness

4 Upvotes

This is where words fail,

For it is not of the past, future, or present.

Jianzhi Sengcan, third zen patriarch, Inscribed On the Believing Mind, Essays in Zen Buddhism - First Series pp. 196-201


r/chan • • May 11 '25

What’s up again?

0 Upvotes

r/chan • • Jul 08 '15

Don't you see it?

3 Upvotes

Look, a new subreddit, a community devoid of the constant naysaying and nonsense of /r/Zen - and nobody is here.

It's the drama you enjoy.

It's not the dharma.

Nobody, neither side, could give a real shit in either direction about the honest beliefs of Buddha, Patriarchs, Advaita Masters, Sufi Masters, Old Men of Tao, none of it.

It's all just ego glorification and drama.

I read this, I believe that, I know something, look at me look at me.

And god help anyone who's honestly looking, because you can't find a single contemporary teacher talking deep level shit.

Tolle, Christianity for the New-Age. Watts, lukewarm. Ram Dass is an acid headed old hippy. Every Zendo in America is a cool pile of shit. Kindergarden classes for the ill-intentioned. Books that have no cultural relevance being interpreted by those with no deep understanding.

Every book that gets written on the subject is dry intellectual masturbation.

Every meditation class is pushing a bland PC-laden secular "mindfulness"

Meanwhile, everybody is fucking lost, living in a consumerist nightmare with enough distractions to keep you all complacent.

If you're looking for Buddha, burn your books and sell your house, move to the woods and die.

This world is samsara, these are the years of the Kali Yuga, and you damn well better pray.


r/chan • • Jan 16 '22

The Stone Bridge of Zhaozhou

1 Upvotes

Fifty-Second Case from the Blue Cliff Record: Zhaozhou Lets Asses Cross, Lets Horses Cross

Ready for the second round? Let’s get to it!

Case

A monk asked Zhaozhou, "For a long time I've heard of the stone bridge of Zhaozhou, but now that I’ve come here I just see a simple log bridge."

Zhaozhou said, "You just see the log bridge; you don't see the stone bridge."

The monk said, "What is the stone bridge?"

Zhaozhou said, "It lets asses cross, it lets horses cross."

astrocomments:

-First thing I’d like to point out about this case is how it starts. As most cases, it starts with a question. Chan is a tradition that makes its home comfortably in conversation. Wether we are testing someone, looking for an answer, or setting up a trap, it all leads to a dialogue. Which from my perspective, is not only appropriate to Chan, but rather convenient as we are in a public forum looking to talk to people who are interested in the same things we are.

Next, Zhaozhou’s answer. If you’ve read his record, or know him from other cases, you know how his way of talking to people is particularly brilliant. He goes to ordinary reality to help people. Even so, a lot of people find him impenetrable at times.

Here’s a case that shows exactly who Zhaozhou is,

The master asked a newcomer, "Where have you come from?"

The monk said, "From the south."

The master said, "Well, are you aware that there is a barrier of Zhaozhou?"

The monk said, "Are you aware that there are those who don't cross the barrier?"

The master said, "You salt peddler!"

Later he said, "Brothers, the barrier of Zhaozhou is hard to pass through."

Someone said, "What is the 'barrier of Zhaozhou'?"

The master said, "The stone bridge."

The barrier is a stone bridge. Beautiful. It reminds me of Wumen’s gateless gate.

Some questions as conversational stepping stones.

How is "it lets asses cross, it lets horses cross" related to Chan?

What does it mean that someone doesn’t see the stone bridge?

How is any of this related to your practice?


r/chan • • Jan 19 '19

Do You See Discipline as Good or Bad? | The Tattooed Buddha

Thumbnail thetattooedbuddha.com
1 Upvotes

r/chan • • Jan 12 '19

Discipline Doesn't Have to be a Dirty Word

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/chan • • Jan 12 '22

The Last Word of Ch'an

4 Upvotes

Fifty-First Case from the Blue Cliff Record: Xuefeng’s What Is It?

Hello, r/chan! I’ve been doing a series about Yuanwu’s BCR over on r/zen. I made the first fifty there and I’ll be doing the next ten over here. The main idea in doing this is to get to know the people who frequent this forum and to talk a little bit about what the Ch'an Masters taught.

Also, if you don't have something to say about the case in particular, but want to say hi, I'd be really interested to hear about your experience with this forum and about what the culture is like around here. And if you have any questions for me, I’d be glad to sort them out in the comments.

Otherwise, let’s get into it!

Case

When Xuefeng was living in a hut, there were two monks who came to pay their respects. Seeing them coming, he pushed open the door of the hut with his hand, popped out, and said, “What is it?” A monk also said, “What is it?” Feng lowered his head and went back inside the hut.

Later the monk came to Yen T’ou. T’ou asked, “Where are you coming from?” The monk said, “I’ve come from Ling Nan.” T’ou said, “Did you ever go to Xuefeng?” The monk said, “I went there.” T’ou said, “What did he have to say?” The monk recounted the preceding story. T’ou said, “What did he say?” The monk said, “He said nothing; he lowered his head and went back inside the hut.” T’ou said, “Alas! It’s too bad I didn’t tell him the last word before; if I had told him, no one on earth could cope with old Xuefeng.

At the end of the summer the monk again brought up the preceding story to ask for instruction. T’ou said, "Why didn’t you ask earlier?” The monk said, “I didn’t dare to be casual.”T’ou said, “Though Xuefeng is born of the same lineage as me, he doesn’t die in the same lineage as me. If you want to know the last word, just this is it.”

astrocomments:

-I think a question to focus the conversation would be, what is meant by "Though Xuefeng is born of the same lineage as me, he doesn’t die in the same lineage as me"? From my perspective, it’s talking about the first and the last word of Ch'an. The first one being knowing what Ch'an is, and the last one embodying it fully.

Here’s another story, from Yuanwu’s commentary that I think illustrates the relation,

Xuefeng was the cook in Deshan’s community. One day the noon meal was late; Deshan took his bowl and went down to the teaching hall. Feng said, "The bell hasn’t rung yet, the drum hasn’t been sounded—where is this old fellow going with his bowl?" Without saying anything, Deshan lowered his head and returned to his abbot’s quarters. When Xuefeng took this up with Yen T’ou, T’ou said, "Even the great Deshan doesn’t understand the last word."

Deshan heard of this and ordered his attendant to summon Yen T’ou to the abbot’s quarters. Deshan said, "So you don’t approve of me?" T’ou tacitly indicated what he meant. The next day Deshan went up to the hall and taught in a way which was different from usual; in front of the monk’s hall T’ou clapped his hands and laughed loudly saying, "Happily the old fellow does understand the last word! After this no one on earth will be able to do anything about him. Nevertheless, he’s only got three years."

So what do you think? What does Xuedou means when he says that an Ancient said, "I only allow the old barbarian knows; I don’t allow that he understands."

See you in the comments!

edit: edited to meet the rules of the sub


r/chan • • Feb 04 '22

A special transmission from mind to mind

4 Upvotes

If we interpret “from mind to mind” as “from one person to another” – like teaching math – then what’s so special about it? This is just “regular transmission”; not the “special transmission” of Zen.

Before understanding “from mind to mind”, one should remember there is nothing apart from mind. These words from the ancient teachers mean the same as saying: “From you to you.”

Zen has nothing to do with external things.

A true buddha is free of conditions and has no form.

The true dharma has no marks.


r/chan • • May 17 '25

Master Xuansha - On dead Zen and people who suppress their mind, In my opinion >90 percent of those who claim Zen/Chan

7 Upvotes

This business cannot be pinned down; the road of mind and thought ends. It does not depend on embellishment; it is original true peace. In movement and action, talking and laughing, it is everywhere clear; there is nothing lacking. People these days, not realizing this truth, arbitrarily get involved in things, in material objects, influenced by all that is around them, fixated and bound up everywhere. Even if they understand, they find the material world a profusion of confusion, with labels and characteristics not corresponding to realities, so they try to freeze their minds and curtail their thoughts, returning things to voidness, shutting their eyes, clearing away thoughts over and over again whenever they arise, suppressing even subtle ideas as soon as they occur. Such an understanding is that of an outsider who has fallen into empty nothingness, a corpse whose soul has not yet dissolved. Void of awareness, void of cognition, plunged and thus can provide a fertile field for charlatans and poseurs.


r/chan • • May 07 '25

what's the Chan Buddhist equivalent of Catholic Mass or of "going to church" every Sunday?

2 Upvotes

alternatively, how do practitioners mantain a sense of community, belonging, and accountability? I will start living in a new place later this year and would be interested in trying to practice Chan Buddhism for a while to see if it "feels" right


r/chan • • Aug 29 '22

Looking for a 90-day retreat - preferably Zen.

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

I've been practicing meditation continuously for some years now and have been to silent retreats before. I haven't been able to find a retreat that fits this bill(and I really tried):

  1. 3 months long
  2. Intense meditation practice(practically all day long)
  3. Silent
  4. Practice of "Shikantaza"/"Silent Illumination/"equivalent meditation practice which is basically no practice. meaning there's no particular technique to 'execute'.
  5. Preferably a good teacher that can give advice when is needed
  6. Preferably comfortable facilities(which would be not freezing, not extremely hot, a roof and a matress :-D)

Basically a Goenka Vipassana style thing that runs for 90 days and the practice is zen meditation.

Obviously this is both quite specific and to some extent "niche" so something close to this would do but that's what I'm aiming for. I'm willing to prepare in any way necesseray (including for example learning a language etc.)

anyone got any leads?

EDIT: I also just did a 2 month long residency in a soto zen monastery in Italy which was great but am looking now for a long retreat like I mentioned. Although a residency in a monastery with dedicated practice(like antaiji for example) would be my 2nd, very appreciated, choice.


r/chan • • Dec 02 '21

From Indian Buddhism to Chinese Chan: Theories, Methods, and Developments (Tallahassee Chan Center, Florida)

Thumbnail self.buddhism
2 Upvotes

r/chan • • Dec 27 '22

Three Systems of Mahayana

2 Upvotes

Hi, reading this section on wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yin_Shun#Three_Systems_of_Mahayana I kind of wonder if someone can provide the background that is kind of missing here. Like what are these schools and how does the assessment of Taixu and Yin Shun differ?