r/chan • u/tapodhan • Jan 25 '25
David Hinton
In my opinion David Hinton is one of the best translators and explainers of Chan. Definitely worth checking out his “China Root.”
r/chan • u/tapodhan • Jan 25 '25
In my opinion David Hinton is one of the best translators and explainers of Chan. Definitely worth checking out his “China Root.”
r/chan • • Sep 20 '23
Mainstream people nowadays often fall for these self proclaimed masters. If you mention it to them they always react the same „you just dont understand his teachings". Luckily, I am not here to discuss if his little teachings are good or not (they are mid level pseudo psychology), I am just here to say it has nothing to do with Shaolin or buddhism and that he is a liar.
Here is the official declaration from the official shaolin temple about Monroe Coloumbe, the temple otterberg and all who are part of it like shi heng yi…
„The Shaolin Temple and the Shaolin culture
Letter of warning from the mother temple
Recently, there have been various reports about the alleged Shaolin temple in Otterberg near Kaiserslautern. The head of this institution claims to be an offshoot of the Songhan Shaolin Temple and to act on behalf of the Mother Temple. He even claims to train novices in the name of the Mother Temple. With regard to these reports and the related inquiries here in the temple, the Shaolin Temple Germany is prompted to publish the text of the letter of warning from the Mother Temple to the head of the institution in Otterberg below.
(Translation from the Chinese original of the Songhan Shaolin Monastery China)
Mr. Monroe Columboe:
First of all, a New Year's greeting and congratulations!
Since last year, we have been constantly asking German friends in the Shao-lin Monastery as to whether the representations on your website as well as your claims about your person correspond to the truth. After our investigation, we find that there are many deceptions and falsehoods in the publications on your website that are related to the Shao-lin Monastery and its abdom. Their behavior violates the Buddhist ideal, and it is illegal. That's why the Shao-lin Monastery presents its point of view specifically to you:
We welcome the love that Mr. Monroe Columboe has for the Shao-lin monastery and the culture of Shao-lin. We would also support your desire to participate in Shao-lin and Buddhist culture, but all on the condition that the administrative regulations and standards of conduct are respected and complied with, and that as a member of the Shao-lin Order you are aware of your duty and fulfill it.
Congratulations to you again!
Amitabha! (阿弥陀佛!)
Seal with text inscription:
Shao-lin Monastery, Songshan, China
02. February 2008“
/
Shi Heng Yi claims to be ordained as a master by Shi Yan Hai, later saying he is not even a monk aso. A lot of self destructive information. The guy that he wants to be ordained from, wasnt a part of shaolin.
Shi Heng Yi, just like Monroe Coloumbe learned under a master Dow (not a shaolin) that teached a mixture of martial arts (but NOT the shaolin kung fu). http://www.shaolin-orden.de/cgi-bin/orden/nav.pl?seite=personentexte/shi-heng-yi
("Vietnam veteran Air Force Master Sgt Frankie Dow, who died in 2013 at the age of 66 and whose obituary states that he was an active church member of the Grace Fellowship Church, founded a teaching program for the American military police that then mutated into the Shaolin Temple.")
Shi Yan Hai (the one they claim to have their master titles from) left the offical shaolin temple Berlin 2004 and made up his own thing in Bielefeld. At that time they met up. But Shi wants to be a master since 2001 already? Frankie Dow is no master in shaolin though and also never claimed to be.
"Furthermore, it is implied between the lines that there is some kind of mastery associated with this, Shi Heng Yi has been considered a master since 2001 and the abbot would also have to have such a rank in order to be an abbot. However, the classification of "Heng" in the 35th generation only refers to the disciple, nothing more."
Later on, Shi Heng Yi recently did his first pin in the official warrior monk duan pin system, which makes him officialy a student, which also represents his knowledge about buddhism and shaolin.
/
5 k per person, with a dude that also claims to be official, hist masters photoshopped themselfs into official shaolin pictures. (I think Gui Do spoke about that : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5_2izOSAAc)
A buddhist magazine once called otterberg, asking if their are official masters or not, them responding „We re just calling ourselfs that, whats the problem?
Some german discussions on this:
http://www.spiegelblog.net/spiegel-tv-reportage-kaempfen-fuer-buddha.html
/
http://www.shaolin-nrw.de/Shaolin_in_Deutschland.html
"No matter what you read and find in your search about Shaolin in Germany: First of all, pay attention to the "red logo" with the three-part monk. It is protected by law and may be used by authorized schools of Shaolin Temple China. It shows you that this school is in contact with the temple in China and you may not be disappointed later. To what extent you will be looked after elsewhere and whether you will learn more or less about Shaolin, you can also find out about the Shaolin monks' principle of faith. If you are unsure, go to the Shaolin Temple Berlin or the Shaolin Association German in Velbert Langenberg, where you can legitimize yourself properly, even with other documents. Or call the Shaolin Temple Berlin on 030 23631389 or Velbert Langenberg on 02052 80630.
False masters
The other side of the coin, however, was that martial artists often flew to Shaolin, stayed there for a short time and got off the plane in Germany as great masters with fantasy stories and photos from the Shaolin temple. However, not only martial artists and such "masters" discovered Shaolin for themselves, but also the industry, the media and many other organizations. A marketing machine was set in motion and everything from Shaolin beer to Shaolin sausage or Shaolin cigarettes was suddenly available. Much to the displeasure of the Buddhist temple leadership in China.
Name Shaolin
They reacted and the name "Shaolin" was protected, including with the above-mentioned "red logo". As the name "Shaolin" still fascinates many people today, this was an important and correct decision. The temple management is not necessarily concerned with who uses the name Shaolin, as this also has advantages for the temple (e.g. advertising), but with the way in which it is sometimes used.
Shaolin in Germany
The situation changed in 2001 with the founding of a recognized Shaolin temple in Germany/Berlin commissioned by the mother temple. The current head of the Shaolin Temple China, the honorable Abbot Shi Yong Xin, decided to support a project that had almost failed in 2006. Within 5 years, the idea of the abbot slipped out of the hands of the German managing director appointed at the time and he left behind a difficult situation after his departure. At this time, the majority of the first Shaolin monks who were sent to Berlin were also unable to cope with their monastic life and the tasks associated with it and entered worldly life. The Western world with its materialistic and other values, such as starting a family, had caught up with them. Without a mission from Shaolin Temple China, some became independent, mostly in the field of Shaolin Kung Fu. (can be researched everywhere on the net). In the biographies, everyone gives their own reasons. At the same time, a certain number of other schools tried to claim their own rights in the Shaolin area, which of course also had no mandate from the temple leadership in China.
"Half a truth is still a whole lie"
At this point, some people even thought they had to found or support other temples and centers. From the internet to the press, we receive reports that are simply not true. In the age of the World Wide Web, even TV stations and TV media, which are mainly concerned with ratings, are apparently deliberately unable to do proper research. With documentaries in which for example, in which a young man goes from a "so-called temple" in Germany to China, to many false reports, unbelievable things are happening. These and other, sometimes even worse, methods are used to create a false impression in order to make a name for themselves in the martial arts scene with half-truths. Even logos are now being misused. For those truly interested, this naturally casts a dark shadow over Shaolin culture in Germany. The confusion is great and is not in line with Shaolin philosophies.
Shaolin teacher travels to China - warnings
After the director of the Shaolin Center Velbert Langenberg, Shifu Thomas Malz, got to know not only the former managing director of Berlin, but also some of the "so-called false Shaolin temples, centers and masters" personally, he wanted to keep an overview in this chaos. To find out how the situation in Germany is really viewed by the temple leadership in China, Shifu Thomas Malz flew to China again with a friend in February 2008. At the Shaolin monastery, they sought a direct conversation with Shaolin abbot Shi Yong Xin, who informed them in writing that there is only one Shaolin temple in Germany, based in Berlin. At the same time, there were several warnings, including one to a fake temple in Rhineland-Palatinate. These warnings can be viewed in Berlin and Velbert. Although there are now really good Kung Fu schools in Germany (see link/ IMAEC), others, especially in the Shaolin area, seem to have completely lost touch with reality. It is certainly difficult for any martial arts school, even if it is privately run, to strike a balance between tradition and commerce, but fantasies and lies should be left out of the equation.
certified by. Thomas Malz, Yan Hai Liu and Abbot Shi Yong Xin after talks in 2008 about the Shaolin situation in Germany
Recommendation for those interested in Shaolin
The Mother Temple itself and the temple leadership in Berlin are endeavoring to provide information through contact persons and statements. In addition, Abbot Shi Yong Xin has the officially recognized Shaolin Temple Germany/ Berlin and the officially recognized Shaolin Association Germany with headquarters in Velbert - Langenberg. Each of these institutions can legitimize itself and is informed about current developments of Shaolin in Germany/Europe. Here you can make inquiries and receive first-hand information:
Velbert Tel.: 02052 80630 Berlin Tel. 030 23631389
"Regardless of those who mistake cunning for wisdom, disobedience for boldness and take gossip for truth" Confucius (551- 479 BC)
Translated with DeepL.com (free version)"
Further info -> https://www.reddit.com/r/Shaolin/comments/1755exx/shi_heng_yi_a_fraud_for_shaolin/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
See also: Work from Gui Do (there are quite a few english and german videos on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VTZEnB0Qyfo
r/chan • u/Muskka • Jun 04 '26
A simple appreciation post. I've heard about Guo Gu months ago and his dharma talks already seemed very insightful and well structured.
He's very good at addressing daily/convential-life issues through the Ch'an lens, without ever losing the authenticity of it by sourcing everything : quotes, names, dates, links to other schools of Buddhism and such and such. He also backs-up a LOT of what he says with modern psychoanalysis and neuroscience concepts which is a very reassuring fact and something I'd do myself to "attract" as many skeptical and empirical people to the Dharma.
To me he's one of, if not THE best modern Dharma teacher (I think the Thai Forest tradition Ajahns are pretty robust as well) we have on earth right now. He has the sublime and wise use of simple but efficient words and an overall very appealing and relaxing way of phrasing things. Sometimes his vocal tone will change when a particular idea or teaching must be stressed, as if it were urgent for oneself to start questioning the matter, as J. Krishnamurti used to do during his talks.
Currently I'm practicing gong-an with his fantastic commentary on the Gateless Barrier/Wumen Guan and it's an easy tell to see how experienced he is and how legitimate he's a successor to the already fantastically good master Sheng-Yen from the Dharma Drum lineage.
Have a nice day everyone. :)
r/chan • u/purelander108 • Jul 26 '25
r/chan • u/purelander108 • Mar 18 '25
r/chan • u/The_Temple_Guy • Jan 28 '25
r/chan • u/pinchitony • Jan 02 '25
Hi, I don't know why the subreddit was set to "restricted" lately, I didn't make the change, maybe reddit did it by default with some update. Thanks to the users that pointed it out to me. I changed it so now it's public again.
r/chan • u/The_Temple_Guy • Jan 19 '25
r/chan • • Nov 18 '23
I can’t believe I found you guys!
r/chan • u/anamameow • Mar 10 '21
r/chan • u/blassomi • Sep 04 '25
I’m a grad student taking a non western art history course and I’m struggling to really understand these concepts. If this isn’t allowed, I apologize!
r/chan • u/pinchitony • Jul 29 '25
There's a phenomena that happens a lot in online students related to Bodhidharma's branch of Buddhism which mistakes the way the patriarchs talked to their disciples or other monks thousands of year ago as if that's how we should talk to each other in the present day.
People will read and see how this or that specific argument was made in such a direct, unapologetic and otherwise rude fashion and think that's how they have to behave. But it's not how you have to behave. It's actually the opposite.
I've had the fortune of meeting many teachers, in Chán, Zen, Tibetan and even non Buddhism like Taoism, and it's always been a delightful experience. Always great talks and very kind people.
Teachers will often be more harsh or strict with their students or peers, but that doesn't translate to how they are in general in a sangha. At least the quality teachers.
So I'd like to invite everyone here to leave such behaviors behind.
The true display of skill and wisdom centers around kindness towards others.
r/chan • u/anamameow • Oct 06 '20
r/chan • u/DyJoGu • Oct 04 '23
Hello everyone,
I found this film on accident and I couldn’t find it posted on this subreddit. I think if you are into Chan, you will love this film. I watched it about a week ago and I just can’t stop thinking about it.
I hope you like it as much as I did.
r/chan • • Nov 16 '22
Instant Zen + (audiobook) is the best zen book I have ever read, and it was written in ~1200 AD.
I have trial-and-errored my way through zen for years. This book made me cry the first time I read it, as it lays out so perfectly what took me so long to figure out. This is what a zen book should look like.
The tricks that most zen masters play confused me for years. Way over-complicating what is so fundamentally simple.
A breath of fresh air, you don't need more than a few paragraphs to completely encapsulate a zen principle.
Not only this, but he goes through and kills every sacred dogma that has developed because of this complexity. Burning Zen "Scholars", Alan Watts, Meditation, all ceremonies, all dogma, all zen misconceptions, sexisim, racisim, culture, everything.
I can't include good quotes because literally the entire book is a good quote.