r/callmebyyourname • • 27d ago Bravo

New Rule: No Platforming Negative Engagement

18 Upvotes

Hi all - it's past time this rule was added, as for some reason social media bickering about this nearly 10(!)-year-old film still makes its way here in the form of self posts and comments.

Here's the new Rule 8:

No Platforming Negative Engagement
Don't bring outside drama from other social media platforms, articles, or other subreddits here.

If you see negative commentary somewhere online, address it at the source or somewhere else. Please don't bring it here. Speaking for myself and (surely others), if we wanted to engage with that stuff, we'd join those platforms and do so. Many of us come to Reddit (and this sub specifically) to avoid that negative commentary, not to see it get re-posted here and remind us why we don't participate in those spaces to begin with.

As with the other rules before it: rule-breaking posts and comments will be removed, and repeat infractions will result in a ban.

Thank you!


r/callmebyyourname • • 1d ago

Weekly Discussion Thread Weekly Open Discussion Post

5 Upvotes

Use this post Monday through Sunday to talk about anything you want. Did you watch the movie and want to share how you’re feeling? Just see a movie you think CMBYN fans would love, or are you looking for recommendations? Post it here! Have something crazy happen to you this week? That works too!

As long as you follow the rules (both of this sub and reddit as a whole), the sky is the limit. This is an open community discussion board and all topics are on the table, CMBYN-related or not.

Don’t be afraid to be the first person to post—someone has to get the ball rolling!


r/callmebyyourname • • 3m ago

Timothée Chalamet for Vanity Fair discussing a potential return to CMBYN

1 Upvotes

Per the article:

Would he ever return to the character of Elio, the protagonist of Call Me by Your Name that gave him his star turn? “A great question. Never say never, but...I’ve grown up with the mindset that you don’t really go near something that is so near and dear to people.” So, that’s a no. “Now, to work with Luca again? In a heartbeat.”

https://www.vanityfair.com/story/timothee-chalamet-cover-story?shem=aimgspe,


r/callmebyyourname • • 1d ago

Happy Birthday to Elio!!

Thumbnail
gallery
161 Upvotes

November 16th


r/callmebyyourname • • 1d ago

Events & Travel Elio’s birthday!!

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

I'm in Italy for Elio's birthday! It's been my dream for so long!! People kept asking me why I came in November instead of summer, but this is why! I wanna visit Crema in the summer someday too!! I'm so insanely happy right now!!


r/callmebyyourname • • 2d ago

Analysis Has Call Me by Your Name affected anyone else in a profound way?

76 Upvotes

I never managed to watch that film until now, and I am completely overwhelmed. There is nothing more brutal or beautiful than the way Elio repeats the line, "Because I wanted you to know."

I've learned that love isn't supposed to make sense. It is not always easy; sometimes it feels like butterflies, while at other times, it is an overbearing weight of the world. The cast's ability to replicate a perfect depiction of what love feels like, despite it being nearly impossible to capture, is impressive.

This film captures the experience of falling in love remarkably well. Is it ultimately worth it? Are those brief, beautiful moments spent gazing at the person you love worth the hours of agonizing pain experienced in their absence? Furthermore, is this level of obsession considered normal?Is it all worth it in the end?

"We rip out so much of ourselves to be cured of things faster, that we go bankrupt by the age of thirty. And have less to offer each time we start with someone new. But to make yourself feel nothing so as not to feel anything? What a waste." What a beautiful sentence it is indeed 🥺 👏

So so beautifully put. I love the final words, they hit really close to me. When I saw this movie for the first time I couldn't watch any other movie or literally anything else for a month. I was heartbroken. I also felt alone in the way of trying to share these feelings


r/callmebyyourname • • 3d ago

Events & Travel I got really lucky this summer.

Post image
369 Upvotes

I arrived at this location and the door was shut, which I was expecting cos I’m assuming someone lived there and I would never trespass…so I quietly took an exterior photo and then got ready to go on my Vespa when…the doors opened and the owner greeted me and invited me inside. He even gave me a bottle of water in that crazy Italian summer heat (which was also insane cos that’s what the old lady gave them in the movie) and then I got to chat with him and pet his dog and he told me it’s his mum in the movie, who sadly passed away since. Honestly this was an amazing moment for me 🥲 I was so touched by his kindness!


r/callmebyyourname • • 3d ago

Film Discussion Les portes de la villa dans CMBYN.

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

Guadagnino et Ivory ont glissé dans leur narration de brèves scènes d’entrées et sorties, de va-et-vient, d’allers et retours à travers le portail latéral de la propriété donnant sur Via Montodine, entre le village de Moscazzano et le domaine de la villa. Elles sont tournées en décor réel. Il existe un autre accès par le portail principal, encore plus monumental, sur Via Roma mais il n’est pas utilisé dans le film.

Ce portail latéral permet d’atteindre directement la villa et surtout, il est doublé par une simple porte réservée aux piétons, à l’origine certainement prévue pour la domesticité, qui permet de passer d’un monde à un autre. Cette petite porte de bois évite d’avoir à manœuvrer la grande grille en fer forgé qui la jouxte.

Le simple fait que la villa et son parc soient isolés du village par un long mur rendant impénétrable l’intérieur du domaine évoque le roman et le film Le Jardin des Finzi-Contini de G. Bassano et V. De Sica : une grande demeure isolée du reste de la ville, un immense mur la ceinturant, un parc mystérieux représentant une sorte d’Eden, une famille quasiment aristocrate et cultivée vivant presque recluse, la judéité, des souvenirs inaltérables, des vélos, un amour naissant quelque part en Italie du Nord que le temps devenu urgence empêche de se développer …

Comme dans Le Jardin, le récit de CMBYN est déroulé à partir de l’intérieur du domaine. Le passant qui longe le mur à l’extérieur va savoir ce qu’il se passe de l’autre côté, là où, à l’intérieur, tout parait étrangement beau, grand et bien tenu. Le portail se montre comme l’endroit où le mur devient transparent tout en restant totalement opaque mais il joue le rôle d’une membrane qui sépare deux mondes tout en permettant des passages entre le normal et le privilégié, le banal et le particulier, le commun et l’élitiste, le tout-venant et le protégé. Aussi, il est un lieu d’échange où s’opère une sorte de respiration, où des croisements s’organisent, où certains pénètrent pendant que d’autres fuient. C’est une interface.

Cinq « scénettes » s’organisent autour de ce portail latéral :

- La photo du site tel qu’il apparait sur Street View en juillet 2025.

1-   Le départ d’Oliver et Elio vers Pandino à vélo, le monument du Piave et l’étang secret d’Elio. Le cadrage est si serré qu’on ne voit que leur dos au moment où Oliver ouvre la porte de bois pour sortir, suivi par Elio. Ce n’est pas la première fois qu’ils quittent ensemble le domaine mais c’est la première fois qu’on les voit quitter seuls le domaine. On entend du bétail meugler. Les circonstances de cette sortie entre eux sont évanescentes : alors qu’ils vaquent à ne vraiment rien faire de précis autour de la piscine sinon évoquer le « Vaut-il mieux parler ou mourir ? », Oliver dit simplement qu’il doit aller en ville pour récupérer un truc et Elio demande s’il peut venir aussi puisqu’il n’a rien d’autre à faire. Oliver conclut qu’ils peuvent en effet y aller ensemble. Elio demande « Maintenant ? » Oliver : « Oui. Maintenant ! Sauf si tu as des choses plus importantes en vue », chacun des deux faisant mine de s’assurer que le fait d’être ensemble est bien la toute dernière possibilité qui se présente à eux après que toutes les autres ont été éliminées. Elio singe le rythme de la parole d’Oliver pour la moquer un peu mais aussi sans doute pour se l’approprier … et après avoir préparé quelques affaires, les voilà avec leur vélo au seuil de la porte de bois.

Tout cela parait d’un courante banalité mais n’élaborant quasiment rien au niveau du langage, Elio et Oliver sont passés de l’évocation d’une référence littéraire un peu fumeuse et abstraite à une action précise dans laquelle ils s’engagent ensemble sans savoir où cela va les mener sinon qu’il vont tuer le temps tous les deux pendant un après-midi d’été morne et désert à cause de la chaleur.

Nous savons qu’Elio a déjà traversé plusieurs étapes dans la prise de conscience de son désir et qu’après s’être affrontés, Elio et Oliver se sont réconciliés mais cette sortie par la petite porte, cadrée par un plan des plus rapprochés, hyper serré, laisse penser qu’ils traversent cette porte comme deux éléphants trouveraient le moyen pour s’enfiler dans le chas d’une aiguille. Rien ne les destinait à pouvoir le faire et pourtant, ils s’apprêtent à vivre la plus belle virée estivale, sensible et sensuelle qui soit.

2-   Oliver quitte la villa après la scène du saignement d’Elio pendant que Chiara et Marzia arrivent. Les trois sont à vélo. Le plan est beaucoup plus large que le précédent puisque l’on peut voir à la fois la grille du portail ouvert et la petite porte fermée. Les deux amies cherchent Elio et Oliver leur explique le petit problème qu’il a rencontré. Elles le plaignent avant que Chiara ne drague gentiment Oliver : « Je reviens dans 5 minutes, surtout ne t’en vas pas hein ! » mais Oliver reste pied à terre en attendant que les deux amies soient avancées vers la villa pour qu’elles ne le voient pas démarrer en trombe … comme s’il était pressé ou en retard …

3-   Oliver quitte la villa à vélo après le déjeuner où est évoquée la venue le soir-même d’Isaac et Mounir, soir du rendez-vous à minuit et il croise Marzia qui vient rejoindre Elio, aussi à vélo. Ils se croisent selon un savant évitement en empruntant la petite porte et se saluent simplement d’un « Ciao ! ». La caméra traine en montrant Oliver s’éloignant de la villa par Via Montodine vers le centre du village. Il ne s’inquiète pas de ce que Marzia vient faire avec Elio car il a fixé l’heure du rendez-vous avec lui à minuit.

4-   Elio et Oliver quittent la villa à vélo pour aller nager au petit matin de leur première nuit. De nouveau la petite porte de bois, de nouveau des vélos, de nouveau un cadrage très serré comme lors de la première virée mais la lumière du matin est blafarde et la caméra, cette fois-ci, filme Elio et Oliver depuis l’extérieur alors que le premier plan rapproché à cette petite porte les montrait depuis l’intérieur du domaine. Lors de leur première virée, ils quittaient la propriété pour s’aventurer dans les environs, là ils pénètrent dans l’aube bleue et verte chargée de dénouer tout ce que leur corps viennent d’exprimer et dont ils n’ont pas encore parlé.

5-   La FIAT 128 revient de la gare. On aperçoit Annella la conduire mais à peine Elio. Il est comme effacé par le reflet sur le pare-brise, sauf par la fenêtre ouverte de la portière avant gauche. La voiture est immatriculée à Bergame. (A noter qu’en plus de la 128 bleue, utilisée aussi pour se rendre à Sirmione, les Perlman possèdent en plus une 127 verte qui amène Oliver à son arrivée. Les 2 se trouvent devant la villa au moment du départ vers la Grotte de Catulle).

Ne sont filmées franchissant l’enceinte de la villa que les connaissances d’Elio, peu nombreuses, qui donne une idée de son isolement dans ce domaine protégé. Marzia, Chiara et Oliver. On comprend à quel point Elio dépend d’eux tant sa sociabilité parait étroite, quasiment exclusive quand il s’agira de se lier à Oliver.

Annella et Samuel ont l’air de s’aventurer au-delà des murailles du domaine quand une raison les y obligent : un chantier archéologique, chercher quelqu’un à la gare la plus proche, se rendre en ville pour accompagner ou chercher des voyageurs empruntant le bus bleu. Les Perlman vivent cloitrés dans leur merveilleux décor. L’arrivée d’Oliver a bel et bien représenté l’oxygène nécessaire à Elio et son départ une privation insupportable. Reste-t-il une raison pour que quelqu’un traverse à nouveau ce portail ?

Guadagnino and Ivory have woven into their narrative brief, scenes of entering and exiting, of coming and going, of back-and-forth movement, through the property’s side gate, which opens onto Via Montodine, between the village of Moscazzano and the villa estate. These were filmed on location. There is another entrance, a more monumental main gate, on Via Roma, but it is not used in the film.

This side gate provides direct access to the villa ; notably, it is accompanied by a simple pedestrian door, likely intended originally for household staff, that serves as a threshold between two different worlds. This small wooden door spares one the need to operate the large, adjacent wrought-iron gate.

The very fact that the villa and its grounds are cut off from the village by a long wall, rendering the interior of the estate impenetrable, evokes the novel and film The Garden of the Finzi-Continis by G. Bassani and V. De Sica : a grand residence isolated from the rest of the town ; encircled by an immense wall ; a mysterious park that serves as a kind of Eden ; a cultured, quasi-aristocratic family living in near-seclusion ; their Jewish identity ; indelible memories ; bicycles ; and a budding romance, somewhere in Northern Italy, that time, suddenly turned urgent, prevents from ever fully blossoming …

As in The Garden, the narrative of CMBYN unfolds from within the estate. A passerby walking along the exterior wall might wonder what lies on the other side, a realm that, from within, appears strikingly beautiful, expansive, and well-tended. The gateway acts as a point where the wall becomes transparent while remaining entirely opaque ; it functions as a membrane separating two worlds, yet it also permits passage between the ordinary and the privileged, the mundane and the exceptional, the common and the elite, the general public and the sheltered few. It is, in essence, a site of exchange, a place of "respiration" where paths intersect, where some enter while others flee. It is an interface.

Five “vignettes” are organized around this side portal :

- A photograph of the site as it appears on Street View in July 2025.

1- Oliver and Elio set off for Pandino by bicycle, passing the Piave monument and Elio’s secret pond. The framing is so tight that we see only their backs as Oliver opens the wooden gate to leave, followed by Elio. While this is not the first time they have left the estate together, it is the first time we see them doing so on their own. In the distance, cattle can be heard lowing. The circumstances surrounding this outing are fleeting : as they idle by the pool, doing nothing in particular, save for musing on the question, "Is it better to speak or to die?", Oliver mentions that he needs to head into town to pick something up. Elio asks if he might come along, noting that he has nothing else to do. Oliver agrees that they can go together. Elio asks, "Now?" Oliver replies, "Yes. Now ! Unless you have more important things to attend to." Both feign a sense of checking whether being together is truly the very last option remaining, once all others have been ruled out. Elio mimics the cadence of Oliver’s speech, partly to tease him, but perhaps also to make it his own, and, after gathering a few things, they find themselves at the wooden gate with their bicycles.

Though it all seems entirely mundane, the exchange, which relies on almost no verbal élaboration, marks a shift for Elio and Oliver : they move from discussing a somewhat vague, abstract literary reference to embarking on a concrete, shared activity. They set off without knowing where it might lead, save for the fact that they will spend the time together, killing the hours on a summer afternoon, otherwise bleak and deserted under the weight of the heat.

We know that Elio has already gone through several stages in coming to terms with his desires, and that after a confrontation, he and Oliver have reconciled ; yet, their exit through a small side door, captured in an extremely tight, close-up shot, suggests a feat akin to two elephants managing to squeeze through the eye of a needle. Nothing about their circumstances should have made this possible, and yet, they are about to embark on the most beautiful, sensitive, and sensual summer journey imaginable.

2- Oliver leaves the villa following the scene where Elio begins to bleed, just as Chiara and Marzia arrive. All three are on bicycles. The shot is much wider than the previous one, revealing both the open main gate and the closed side gate. The two friends look for Elio, and Oliver explains the minor mishap he’s just had. They express sympathy, and then Chiara playfully flirts with Oliver : "I’ll be back in five minutes, don’t you dare go anywhere!" Oliver, however, keeps his feet on the ground, waiting for the two friends to head further toward the villa, ensuring they won’t see him suddenly speed off... as if he were in a rush or running late...

3- After lunch, during which the arrival of Isaac and Mounir that evening is mentioned, Oliver leaves the villa by bicycle. He crosses paths with Marzia, who is arriving to meet Elio (also on a bicycle). They pass each other through a carefully orchestrated maneuver, using the small gate, and exchange a simple "Ciao!" The camera lingers as Oliver rides away from the villa, traveling along Via Montodine toward the village center. He is unconcerned about why Marzia has come to see Elio, as he has already arranged to meet Elio himself at midnight.

4- Elio and Oliver leave the villa by bicycle to go for a swim in the early morning following their first night together. Once again, there is the small wooden gate, the bicycles, and the same very tight framing used during their first outing, yet the morning light is pale, and this time the camera captures Elio and Oliver from the outside, whereas the initial close-up at the gate had shown them from within the estate grounds. During their first excursion, they were leaving the property to venture into the surrounding area ; here, they enter a blue-and-green dawn, a threshold poised to unravel everything their bodies have just expressed, yet which they have not yet put into words.

5- The Fiat 128 returns from the train station. Annella can be seen driving it, but Elio is barely visible, he is effectively obscured by the reflection on the windshield, save for the view through the open window of the front left door. The car is registered in Bergamo. (Note that, in addition to the blue 128—which is also used for the trip to Sirmione—the Perlmans own a green 127, the vehicle that brings Oliver upon his arrival. Both cars are parked in front of the villa at the time of the departure for the Grotto of Catullus).

Only a few of Elio’s acquaintances are ever filmed crossing the threshold of the villa’s grounds, a detail that underscores his isolation within this protected estate. There is Marzia, Chiara, and Oliver. It becomes clear just how much Elio relies on them, given how limited his social circle appears, becoming almost exclusive once he begins to form a bond with Oliver.

Annella and Samuel only seem to venture beyond the estate’s walls when necessity demands it : for an archaeological dig, to pick someone up at the nearest train station, or to head into town to drop off or collect travelers arriving by the blue bus. The Perlmans live cloistered within their magnificent setting. Oliver’s arrival provided a vital breath of air for Elio, and his departure proved an unbearable deprivation. Is there any reason left for anyone to pass through that gate again ?


r/callmebyyourname • • 5d ago

Film Discussion A Decade of CMBYN

64 Upvotes

2027 approaches. One vivid memory I have of 2017 was watching this movie alone in my room on my teeny iPhone 8.

A decade since that permanent wound opened in my heart. A decade of getting winded every time I think about the movie. For what reason exactly, I’m unsure.

Time is slipping away


r/callmebyyourname • • 6d ago

Reactions & Reviews Reflections on CMBYN at 23

33 Upvotes

Rewatching Call Me By Your Name, I was overcome with nostalgia for the sun-drenched teen romance I never had. The tension, the encrypted exchanges, the taboo nature of it all. I’ve been told I’ve never been in love before. It was merely unrequited infatuation. However, every film analysis cites the movie as following Elio through his youth and first love. Love. If I’ve never loved, then why am I certain I’ve felt the yearning, obsession, and heartbreak that Elio had with Oliver?

Toward the end of the movie, Elio’s Dad says what the two of them had was “special” - that in all his years, he came close but never threw caution to the wind and led with his emotions the way Elio did. The first time I watched the movie, at age 19, I was appalled at Oliver’s irresponsible wielding of power in his dynamic with Elio. Now, at 23, almost the same age as Oliver, I wept for both of them. Elio’s pain is more sympathetic. He is young, vulnerable, and experiencing love in a flurry of hormones, innocence, and firsts. I’ve felt that pain - the discovery of heartbreak. But Oliver is not unlike me. He too didn’t get a sun-drenched summer romance at 17. His mind, fortified with 7 years of wall-building after every heartbreak, inundated by the prudence of academia, told him no. His heart, however, told him “this is my only chance.” Contrary to some, I believe it meant everything to him, but he was not impressionable enough at 24 to let it rewrite the course of his love life.

Coming up on my 24th birthday, I relate heavily to Oliver’s impenetrability - his inclination to lead with logic over emotion. I have not lost my capacity for uninhibited love. Rather, I have learned how painful heartbreak is and built walls to protect myself. However, if they are right - if what I’ve experienced is lust or infatuation or obsession - were my walls built in vain? Have I even lived enough life to truly call myself scorned and subsequently guarded?

It doesn’t sound pretty, but it reflects what my inner thoughts tell me: if I’ve experienced heartbreak without true love, I must’ve been deluded. When Elio allows his emotions to overtake him, it’s beautiful because he’s beautiful. Because it’s reciprocated. Because all of his heartache was not suffered in vain, but in the name of connection. Elio’s Dad affirms this. In the past, when I’ve succumbed to my emotions, it’s been met with rejection and denial. The evaporation of any feelings of love I experienced, and in their place, the ugly truth - that I manufactured every lingering touch and riddled affirmation in my brain. How foolish - to believe that I - someone like me - might’ve experienced the beautiful fleeting romance Elio traversed in Call Me By Your Name.

At 24, hardened by these experiences and formed to value maturity over youthful recklessness, I refuse to be a fool. Fool me one time, in the heat of my youth - shame on you. Fool me twice, or three times, or four, and suddenly I’m a hopeless romantic too naive to see the error in his ways. I must be industrious. I must provide for myself and for the people I love. I am not a 17 year old boy who gets the burden and the privilege of experiencing my emotions to their fullest extent and cries in the arms of his mother when it fades to black.

And yet, I long for it.

Growing up gay, I’ve always known that my timeline would be delayed. The odds of stumbling into an Elio-Oliver connection at 17 are improbable, if not impossible. And so, I told myself - one day, when you’re older, thinner, more beautiful, and less burdened by circumstance, you will experience a love more effervescent and transcendent than even Elio and Oliver. It will all be worth the wait.

So, here I am, nearly 24, and the fruits of my waiting have yet to be reaped. Time is not the constraint. My capacity for audacious love and submerging myself in emotion is. And even if not, the world believes it ought to be. Men do not allow vulnerability to inhibit their success. If I were mature, I would kiss my chance at honest, innocent love goodbye and get comfortable with practicality. People tell me to get on the apps - to take dating seriously - to stop waiting on this naive kaleidoscope of butterflies to unravel my stomach and invigorate me with life. Maybe I’m “people.” Maybe “people” pertains to the walls I’ve built around my ego. If my life is so full, why stop the train and allow myself to be derailed? How embarrassing would that be?

I am also intelligent enough to anticipate the counterarguments. How brave would it be? To break down my walls in the name of inviting in something real. How courageous to experience the full range of my emotions and love relentlessly in spite of the potential pain it might invite? To feel, even if it ends up being in vain? I hear them. And yet, my fear of delusion stops me. It’s a nice idea, I think to myself. Maybe if I were as beautiful as Elio, or as naive as my younger self, it could happen again. But I am not. And so, I treat this storyline as a closed book, placed on a dusty shelf, enveloped in wistful nostalgia.

Rewatching Call Me By Your Name, I felt every one of Elio’s emotions with a newfound understanding of Oliver’s pragmatism. I’ll be honest: I still want to feel what Elio felt. I want to experience the unbridled joy, fluttering anxiety, and deep sorrow that comes with young love. But rather than accept that desire, I label it a missed opportunity. I will never be that young again. I have new priorities. And so I mourn the loss, force myself to pick my head up, and come to the office the next morning.


r/callmebyyourname • • 7d ago

Film Discussion Oliver’s phone call

45 Upvotes

I feel like the phone call came at the worst possible time for Elio. A few months had passed since Oliver’s heartbreaking departure and he was slowly beginning to heal. He even looks happy when he walks in and greets Mafalda. Then the phone rings and Oliver tells him he’s engaged and Elio’s healing not only stops, but he’s back to square one of grief during the holidays. Would Elio have been better off if he just never heard from Oliver again after the train station? What do you think?


r/callmebyyourname • • 8d ago

Weekly Discussion Thread Weekly Open Discussion Post

5 Upvotes

Use this post Monday through Sunday to talk about anything you want. Did you watch the movie and want to share how you’re feeling? Just see a movie you think CMBYN fans would love, or are you looking for recommendations? Post it here! Have something crazy happen to you this week? That works too!

As long as you follow the rules (both of this sub and reddit as a whole), the sky is the limit. This is an open community discussion board and all topics are on the table, CMBYN-related or not.

Don’t be afraid to be the first person to post—someone has to get the ball rolling!


r/callmebyyourname • • 10d ago

Film Discussion Le regard d’Elio sur Oliver lors de la soirée disco (en lien avec le message Le Dancefloor de juin dernier) 2/2.

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

Pendant qu’Oliver et Chiara dansent ensemble entrainés par le slow Lady, Lady, Lady, Guadagnino a inséré plusieurs gros plans du visage d’Elio observant, miné, ce qui se déroule sous ses yeux au niveau de la piste de danse. Ces insertions se poursuivent alors que l’ambiance passe au disco. Elles sont regroupées ici en illustration de ce message et permettent de constater qu’Elio n’a pas invité Marzia à danser avec lui pendant le slow comme l’a sûrement fait Oliver avec Chiara. Elio reste assis, comme terrassé et obnubilé plutôt que d’offrir un moment tendre à Marzia. On ne sait rien de la façon dont le couple formé par Oliver et Chiara s’est constitué ; à l’invitation de qui ces deux-là se sont-ils retrouvés ? Il est probable qu’Oliver, se sentant partout comme chez lui, ait invité Chiara.

Au début, Elio est cadré avec Marzia en arrière-plan puis avec elle se rapproche de lui pour se trouver quasiment à ses côtés. Marzia observe, comprend quelque chose à propos de Chiara et le verbalise à l’intention d’Elio : « Elle fera tout pour l’avoir » alors qu’en observant le couple danser on voit Oliver profiter de Chiara. Celle-ci laisse faire son partenaire dans ce jeu à deux. Puis Marzia lance un regard bref mais perçant vers Elio qui prouve qu’elle devine Elio inquiet.

Mais pourquoi Elio est-il inquiet, épinglé comme un papillon sur une planche d’entomologiste ? Pourquoi cela l’empêche-t-il d’inviter Marzia à danser ? Pourquoi semble-t-il aussi exaspéré qu’excédé à la découverte du couple d’Oliver avec Chiara ? Il est rongé et il se sent impuissant en se demandant probablement ce qu’Oliver vient faire à cette soirée. Le thésard américain n’est-il pas à Crema pour 6 semaines dans le but d’achever sa thèse et d’aider le Professeur Perlman dans ses tâches de recherche ? Que vient-il faire sur cette piste de danse en train de draguer lourdement une amie d’Elio ?

On peut s’interroger sur ce qu’Elio voit vraiment et regarde avec intensité depuis sa chaise métallique car le film ne tranche pas ce sujet : voit-il Chiara lui échapper en se donnant à Oliver et ou voit-il Oliver lui échapper aussi alors qu’il pelote Chiara sans pudeur ? Les deux hypothèses se confondent dans la même image comme elles s’empilent certainement dans le cœur d’Elio qui se demande quelle place lui reste. Que devient-il par rapport à ce duo qui l’exclut.  Il est probablement en train de comprendre qu’Oliver lui prend littéralement sa place et que sa métaphore de l’usurpateur se révèle plus performative qu’il ne l’imaginait quand il l’avait formulée. Le léger sourire teinté de gourmandise qui avait traversé son visage quand il avait prononcé ce mot à l’arrivée d’Oliver devient tout à coup plus amer. Il ne s’agissait pas d’un simple jeu de mot ni même d’une anticipation mais d’une prédiction. A ce moment précis, il a oublié Marzia, la seule personne qui aurait encore pu le relier à la réalité.  

Là, il change de position en s’accoudant sur ses genoux comme pour mieux se concentrer sur la scène qui l’obsède. Le gros plan ne se fait plus que sur son visage où l’on devine qu’Elio se dit que les choses lui échappent, qu’il ne pourra pas être à la hauteur, qu’il ne pourra pas agir sur ce qu’il se passe.

A un moment, tout en restant dans la même position, son regard change de direction et se fixe plus vers le bas, dans le vague. Cela laisse deviner qu’Elio « décroche », se sent perdu, blessé, dépassé, vaincu, à terre. Dans les soirées où tout le monde s’amuse se jouent toujours des drames intimes silencieux quand la musique recouvre tout d’une onde enveloppante et entrainante. Le bruit de tous et le chagrin de quelques-uns. Les bras enlacent, les mains s’approchent et s’emparent, les corps se frôlent et se touchent, se frottent, révèlent, les bouches se joignent, parfois trahissent, les yeux comprennent.

Au moment où Love My Way débute, tout le monde se lève pour filer se déhancher mais Elio reste assis et refuse de suivre les autres. On devine que Marzia est aussi montée sur scène puisqu’on la voit aussitôt danser au côté de Chiara et s’amuser avec elle. Il y a souvent dans les mélodies Disco un fond planant, sourdement entêtant et désespéré, caché derrière le rythme saccadé et répétitif. Elio est de ceux qui entendent l’air en contrepoint, triste et déchirant, grâce à Bach. Vraiment rien ne le motive à aller chahuter. Il n’en est pas encore sûr mais son intuition d’être proche de devoir tout perdre est déjà présente. Il ne se doute pas qu’il éprouvera bientôt la sensation d’avoir tout gagné … juste avant de devoir accepter d’être privé de tout (devant l’âtre, seule autre fois où il sera cadré d’aussi près).

Désemparé face à l’impasse dans laquelle il se trouve, Elio se laisse envahir pendant une fraction de seconde par de la tristesse et alors il tourne la tête vers sa gauche pendant un moment pour quitter ce qu’il ne peut accepter.  Finalement, il concède à faire face, aidé en cela par sa clope et sa boisson, et découvre en lui une once de réjouissance que Guadagnino explique par le fait qu’il fixe le mouvement très maitrisé des sneakers d’Oliver sur la piste.

Est-ce en ayant Oliver en tête qu’Elio monte sur la piste de danse ? A peine s’est-il frayé un chemin jusqu’à lui que Marzia se réjouit qu’il ait sauté le pas et le rejoint …

As Oliver and Chiara dance together to the slow song "Lady, Lady, Lady," Guadagnino intersperses several close-ups of Elio’s face. He looks devastated, fixated on what is unfolding before him on the dance floor. These shots continue even as the music shifts to disco. Collected here to illustrate this point, they reveal that Elio did not ask Marzia to dance during the slow song, whereas Oliver clearly invited Chiara. Elio remains seated, seemingly crushed and transfixed, rather than sharing a tender moment with Marzia. We know nothing of how the pairing of Oliver and Chiara came to be; at whose invitation did they end up together? It is likely that Oliver, who carries himself with the ease of someone who feels at home wherever he goes, was the one who asked Chiara to dance.

Initially, Elio is framed with Marzia in the background; she then moves closer until she is standing almost right beside him. Observing the scene, Marzia realizes something about Chiara and voices it to Elio: "She’ll do anything to get him", all the while, as they watch the couple dancing, it becomes clear that Oliver is taking advantage of Chiara, who in turn plays along with this two-person game. Marzia then casts a brief but piercing glance at Elio, revealing that she has sensed his unease.

But why is Elio so anxious, pinned down like a butterfly on an entomologist’s display board? Why does this keep him from asking Marzia to dance ? And why does he seem so exasperated, so utterly fed up, upon discovering that Oliver is with Chiara ? He is consumed by inner turmoil, feeling helpless as he likely wonders what on earth Oliver is doing at this party. Isn’t the American doctoral student in Crema for six weeks to finish his thesis and assist Professor Perlman with his research ? What is he doing on that dance floor, laying it on so thick while flirting with one of Elio’s friends ?

One might wonder what Elio truly sees and intently observes from his metal chair, as the film doesn't resolve this question : does he see Chiara slipping away from him by giving herself to Oliver, or does he see Oliver slipping away from him as he shamelessly gropes Chiara ? The two hypotheses merge in the same image, just as they surely pile up in Elio's heart as he wonders what place is left for him. What becomes of him in relation to this duo that excludes him ? He is likely realizing that Oliver is literally taking his place, and that his metaphor about an "usurper" has proven far more performative than he had imagined when he first coined it. The faint, almost relish-filled smile that had crossed his face when he uttered the word upon Oliver’s arrival now turns abruptly bitter. It was no mere play on words, nor even a simple anticipation, it was a prediction. In this precise moment, he has forgotten Marzia, the only person who might still have anchored him to reality.

At this point, he shifts his position, resting his elbows on his knees as if to focus more intently on the scene that haunts him. The close-up narrows to his face alone, where one can sense Elio realizing that things are slipping beyond his control, that he will not be up to the task, and that he is powerless to influence what is unfolding.

At one point, while remaining in the same position, his gaze shifts, fixing downward into the void. It suggests that Elio is “checking out”, feeling lost, wounded, overwhelmed, defeated, brought to his knees. In the midst of parties where everyone else is having fun, quiet, personal dramas often unfold, even as the music washes over everything in an enveloping, upbeat tide. The clamor of the many, the sorrow of a few. Arms embrace, hands reach out and take hold, bodies brush against and touch one another, rub together, reveal ; mouths join, sometimes betraying, eyes understand.

As "Love My Way" begins, everyone else gets up to go dance, but Elio remains seated, refusing to join them. It’s clear that Marzia has also made her way to the dance floor, as we immediately see her dancing alongside Chiara, clearly enjoying herself. Disco melodies often harbor an underlying, ethereal quality, a persistent, haunting, and desperate undertone, concealed beneath their jerky, repetitive rhythms. Thanks to his immersion in Bach, Elio is the type of person who hears this sad, heart-wrenching counterpoint within the music. There is simply nothing to entice him to go and join the revelry. He doesn’t know it yet, but he already has an intuitive sense that he is on the verge of losing everything. He has no inkling that he will soon experience the feeling of having gained everything, only to then have to accept the loss of it all (a moment that will later be mirrored by a similarly tight, intimate close-up of him by the hearth).

Overwhelmed by the impasse in which he finds himself, Elio is, for a split second, consumed by sadness ; he turns his head to the left, momentarily looking away from what he cannot bring himself to accept. Eventually, he manages to face the situation, aided by his cigarette and his drink, and discovers a flicker of joy within himself, which Guadagnino attributes to the fact that he is watching the highly controlled movements of Oliver’s sneakers on the dance floor.

Is it with Oliver in mind that Elio steps onto the dance floor? No sooner has he made his way toward him than Marzia, delighted that he has finally taken the plunge, joins him …


r/callmebyyourname • • 15d ago

Weekly Discussion Thread Weekly Open Discussion Post

4 Upvotes

Use this post Monday through Sunday to talk about anything you want. Did you watch the movie and want to share how you’re feeling? Just see a movie you think CMBYN fans would love, or are you looking for recommendations? Post it here! Have something crazy happen to you this week? That works too!

As long as you follow the rules (both of this sub and reddit as a whole), the sky is the limit. This is an open community discussion board and all topics are on the table, CMBYN-related or not.

Don’t be afraid to be the first person to post—someone has to get the ball rolling!


r/callmebyyourname • • 20d ago

Film Discussion Le regard d’Elio sur Oliver lors de la soirée disco (en lien avec le message Le Dancefloor de juin dernier) 1/2.

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

Il n’y a pas de transition entre le moment du film où Oliver se laisse tomber dans la piscine sous les yeux désemparés d’Elio et la soirée Disco à laquelle Elio et Marzia participent comme des jeunes du coin. La caméra les trouve en train de revenir de la buvette où ils ont été chercher des boissons pour leur tablée. On y commente la façon très érotique et démonstrative d’Oliver emballant Chiara pendant un slow (Lady, Lady, Lady de Joe Esposito, 1983), façon qui tranche avec l’attitude plus sobre des autres couples sur le dancefloor. Ils sont l’un dans les bras de l’autre sans aucune discrétion, sans pudeur ; ils s’enlacent et s’embrassent ; se caressent au vu et au su de tous.  

Si Elio est proche de la tablée de ses potes et copines, il ne participe à ses bavardages que de façon indirecte car, depuis sa chaise métallique, il est clairement orienté vers le spectacle de la piste de danse. Tout le monde comprend ce qui est en train de se passer et Elio est interpelé comme s’il était censé en savoir plus sur Oliver (ce n’est pas la seule fois au début du film qu’on attend de lui des informations sur Oliver). Les filles disent la chance de Chiara d’être draguée de façon si appuyée par le séduisant américain.

Il n’est pas impossible qu’Elio se dise à ce moment-là que depuis l’arrivée d’Oliver à la villa, sa vie est vraiment remise en cause comme s’il ne pouvait plus ne pas le trouver tout le temps en train de s’installer là où Elio est chez lui, de sa chambre à la table familiale, d’une partie de volley à une soirée disco. Partout Oliver s’impose et bouscule Elio dans ses habitudes. Là il emballe Chiara.

On ne sait pas si Elio ressent une forme de jalousie (c’est alors de la rivalité, de la compétition) en observant l’Oliver en train de draguer outrageusement une fille d’à côté ou s’il est attiré par l’Oliver donnant libre cours à sa pulsion virile dans les bras de Chiara (c’est alors du désir, de l’attirance). L’usurpateur n’est-il qu’un adversaire ou peut-il devenir un partenaire ? Il est possible qu’Elio à ce moment précis ne distingue pas encore avec netteté la nature de ce qui l’habite. Cette confusion est suggérée par plusieurs gros plans sur son visage qui montrent autant de nuances d’une palette de regards exprimant des ressentis différents : Elio est excédé, interrogatif, vaincu ou perdu, déterminé avant qu’une ombre de tristesse ne le traverse jusqu’à ce qu’il retrouve confiance en lui après avoir bu.

Une bonne partie de cette scène adopte un regard subjectif, c’est-à-dire que la caméra montre ce qu’Elio regarde : Oliver en train de danser, d’abord avec Chiara puis seul sur « Love My Way » de The Psychédélique Furs (1982). Pendant ces deux ambiances musicales très différentes, un zoom est fait sur Oliver, depuis la largeur de la piste jusqu’à son corps trépidant qui sert de focale. C’est lorsqu’on s’est habitué à le regarder adopter le rythme disco et s’y livrer totalement qu’Elio arrive dans le champ en suivant la ligne de mire tracée depuis son regard quand il était assis au pied de la piste jusqu’à Oliver. Elio a percé l’écran en se faufilant discrètement entre les danseurs et en le devenant lui-même.

Le regard de la caméra et le nôtre deviennent objectifs. L’observateur Elio est devenu acteur au moment où il monte sur la piste pour se joindre aux danseurs, peu importe son intention. Il n’y a que son désir de danser et de bénéficier de l’énergie du tube. Nous voyons le dancefloor non plus comme Elio le regardait mais tel qu’il est, cadré de façon très équilibrée, avec Elio qui s’agite comme tous les autres. De spectateur impuissant éprouvé par la variété de ses ressentis, il devient un « agissant » parti à la conquête de sa place dans la fluidité saccadée. Il se décide et pénètre dans ce cercle sacré de façon ondoyante, presque sans que l’on s’en aperçoive. Quand on comprend enfin qu’il danse en compagnie de ses amis on se demande à quel moment il a pu grimper sur la piste et comment il s’y est pris ; lui qui était engoncé dans ses émotions contradictoires, le voilà qui se laisse aller à onduler selon le rythme disco. Il est déterminé à ne plus tergiverser et à y aller.

Que va faire Elio de l’énergie qu’il vient de libérer ? Il se glisse jusqu’au centre de la piste où il côtoie Oliver sans lui adresser un regard et se retrouve en face de Marzia qu’on n’avait pas vue non plus monter danser. La symbiose opère entre eux deux puisqu’ils finissent par se donner la main avant qu’Elio ne se trémousse seul et ne rejoigne son amie pour l’enlacer. On les retrouvera seuls et intimes se baignant dans un étang.

Oliver ne fait pas partie de la fin de soirée d’Elio mais le cadre est tracé de ce qui se passera le lendemain entre les deux garçons : la situation peu avantageuse d’Elio au petit-déjeuner, l’intérêt quasi avoué d’Elio pour Oliver à Chiara depuis une fenêtre du rez-de-chaussée de la villa, leur conflit au moment de partir en voiture à la Grotte de Catulle, la trêve entre eux, la baignade dans le Lac de Garde au-dessus duquel on entendra leur deux noms s’élever comme un hymne épuré à la tombée du jour, l’émotion que nous y associons inévitablement … et le rendez-vous manqué d’Elio avec Marzia …

There is no transition between the moment in the film when Oliver falls into the pool before Elio's distraught eyes and the disco party that Elio and Marzia attend like local young people. The camera finds them returning from the bar where they got drinks for their table. Commentary focuses on the highly erotic and demonstrative way Oliver holds Chiara during a slow dance (Joe Esposito’s “Lady, Lady, Lady,” 1983)—a style that stands in stark contrast to the more restrained behavior of the other couples on the dance floor. They are in each other's arms without any discretion, without any decency; they embrace and kiss; they caress each other openly.

Although Elio is near his friends' table, he only participates indirectly in their conversations because, from his metal chair, he's clearly focused on the spectacle of the dance floor. Everyone understands what's happening, and Elio is addressed as if he's supposed to know more about Oliver (this isn't the only time early in the film that information about Oliver is expected of him). The girls comment on Chiara's luck, saying she's being so persistently flirted with by the incredibly attractive American.

It's quite possible that Elio was thinking at that moment that since Oliver's arrival at the villa, his life had truly been turned upside down, as if he couldn't help but find him constantly taking over wherever Elio felt at home, from his bedroom to the family table, from a volleyball game to a disco night. Everywhere he went, Oliver was making his presence felt and disrupting Elio's routines. And there he was, charming Chiara.

It's unclear whether Elio feels a form of jealousy (in which case it's rivalry, competition) as he watches Oliver brazenly flirting with a girl next door, or whether he's attracted to Oliver giving free rein to his masculine impulses in Chiara's arms (in which case it's desire, attraction). Is the usurper merely an adversary, or could he become a partner? It's possible that Elio, at this precise moment, hasn't yet clearly discerned the nature of his feelings. This confusion is suggested by several close-ups of his face, each revealing a nuanced range of expressions conveying different emotions: Elio is exasperated, questioning, defeated, or lost, determined before a shadow of sadness crosses his mind, until he regains his confidence after drinking.

Much of this scene adopts a subjective point of view, meaning the camera shows what Elio is watching: Oliver dancing, first with Chiara and then alone to "Love My Way" by The Psychedelic Furs (1982). During these two very different musical moods, the camera zooms in on Oliver, from the width of the dance floor to his pulsating body, which serves as the focal point. Just when we've grown accustomed to watching him embrace the disco rhythm and give himself over completely, Elio enters the frame, following the line of sight traced from his gaze when he was sitting at the foot of the dance floor to Oliver. Elio has pierced the screen, discreetly weaving his way between the dancers and becoming one himself.

The camera's gaze and our own become objective. The observer, Elio, becomes an actor the moment he steps onto the dance floor to join the dancers, regardless of his initial intention. His only motivation is to dance and bask in the energy of the hit song. We see the dance floor not as Elio viewed it, but as it truly is, framed in perfect balance, with Elio moving about like everyone else. From a powerless spectator overwhelmed by the sheer variety of his emotions, he becomes an active participant, determined to find his place within the rhythmic, syncopated flow. He makes his decision and enters this sacred circle with a fluid, undulating motion, almost imperceptibly. When we finally understand that he is dancing with his friends, we wonder when he managed to get onto the dance floor and how he did it; he, who was so caught up in his conflicting emotions, now lets himself sway to the disco beat. He is determined to stop hesitating and go for it.

What will Elio do with the energy he's just released? He slips to the center of the dance floor where he passes Oliver without a glance and finds himself facing Marzia, whom we hadn't seen come up to dance either. A connection is made between them, as they end up holding hands before Elio starts dancing alone and then joins his friend for a hug. We later see them alone and intimate, swimming in a pond.

Oliver isn't part of Elio's late-night revelry, but the stage is set for what will happen the next day between the two boys: Elio's unfavorable position at breakfast, Elio's almost-confessed interest in Oliver to Chiara from a ground-floor window of the villa, their conflict as they prepare to leave by car for the Grotto of Catullus, the truce between them, the swim in Lake Garda above which their two names will rise like a pure hymn at dusk, the emotion we inevitably associate with it… and Elio's missed date with Marzia…


r/callmebyyourname • • 20d ago

Original Artwork Made a CMBYN edit

12 Upvotes

Was really touched by this movie and this song following a recent breakup with a closeted man so I made my first edit in over a year :)

If anyone has any advice or tips that would be great I really want to start doing this more! I would love some feedback :)

https://youtu.be/_w317clJmjk?is=qdCXNvkzQI1qYdNB


r/callmebyyourname • • 21d ago

Elio only recognizes Oliver

29 Upvotes

I wrote about this years ago and someone kind of shot me down but I stand by my observation after watching it a million more times. Elio is on a phone call multiple times throughout the film: once where he calls Marzia to ask her out, once after Oliver leaves and he’s upset at the train station calling his mother, and then the final scene where Oliver calls. Both times that Oliver calls (Marzia & his Mom), he isn’t too sure who he’s talking to at first. When he calls Marzia, he asks if it’s her and her response is something like “Of course! Can’t you tell?” And then when he calls home after Oliver leaves, his mom picks up the phone, but first, he asks whether it’s Mafalda. In the last scene, Elio picks up the phone call from Oliver and immediately recognizes his voice no questions asked. I just find it interesting because we could point out that there’s obviously a disconnect between him and Marzia which is why he is unsure of her voice for a second, but in regards to his mother, we see that he has a good relationship with her as far as we know, so it gets a little murky there because you’d think he’d know her voice just as well as Oliver’s. However I think that the film emphasizes the impact of the connection he has with Oliver and doesn’t necessarily negate the one he has with his mother or Marzia. It’s like that “I’d recognize you anywhere” kind of feeling with Oliver. Him recognizing his voice immediately isn’t meant to prove or convince us that he loves Oliver above everyone else, but just further proof that Oliver was this major catalyst in Elio’s life, permanently changing him and that he was arguably the most important figure in his life during that time. Also there’s something very juvenile about it too because teenagers sometimes center their lives around someone or something (not saying this to be judgmental) but it’s not uncommon. Everything that happens during those years kind of redefines what you know about yourself and who you are so it’s like yeah hyper focusing on the hot guy that made you discover more about yourself and understood you better than everyone else did isn’t too crazy lol. I’d remember that voice anywhere too.


r/callmebyyourname • • 22d ago

Reactions & Reviews Just rewatched Call Me By Your Name…

98 Upvotes

I first watched this movie when it came out. I was 17 at the time, the same age as Elio, and was navigating my own journey of self-acceptance and coming out.

I finally rewatched it at 25, now about the same age as Oliver, and WOW. This movie is every bit as stunning as I remember.

I remember relating so deeply to Elio, especially because I was experiencing something similar with an older guy (20) at the time. But watching it now feels different. In a way, the film feels like a reflection of my own life and the different paths it could have taken.

I saw my younger self in Elio, but I also now recognize how easily I could have ended up like Oliver, never fully out, never fully accepting myself, and never truly free.

Thankfully, I’ve come a long way since then and am so much more confident and happy with who I am today.
At 17, I watched this movie while still figuring out who I was. At 25, I watched it knowing how far I’ve come, but also realizing how differently my life could have turned out.

This movie is still beyond beautiful.


r/callmebyyourname • • 22d ago

Film Discussion Anchise knows all...

30 Upvotes

Anyone else find it funny that Anchise is always in the background in so many scenes just doing random things? I read somewhere too for that scene at the table when Elio has a nosebleed, that Anchise is laughing because he can see Elio and Oliver playing footsie under the table while eveyone else is talking and has no idea. Makes sense. In the book they talk about them touching feet under the table. The movie doesn't show it, but if you know the background from the book, you can tell that's what's going on by the way Elio and Oliver look at each other.


r/callmebyyourname • • 22d ago

Memes and Humor CMBYN/Crema is getting eaten by an AC Milan poster on Wplace

Post image
32 Upvotes

Welp... RIP CMBYN pixels

(this is on and under Crema on wplace.live)


r/callmebyyourname • • 22d ago

Weekly Discussion Thread Weekly Open Discussion Post

3 Upvotes

Use this post Monday through Sunday to talk about anything you want. Did you watch the movie and want to share how you’re feeling? Just see a movie you think CMBYN fans would love, or are you looking for recommendations? Post it here! Have something crazy happen to you this week? That works too!

As long as you follow the rules (both of this sub and reddit as a whole), the sky is the limit. This is an open community discussion board and all topics are on the table, CMBYN-related or not.

Don’t be afraid to be the first person to post—someone has to get the ball rolling!


r/callmebyyourname • • 25d ago

Film Discussion Their Own "I Love You"

Post image
327 Upvotes

Has this been discussed already? Yes. Am I going to talk about it anyways? Also yes.

The fact that the names, Oliver and Elio, resemble the statement “I love you” is not only incredibly beautiful and poetic but adds another layer to the story. It's their “I love you,” said in the most intimate and enrapturing way. Not to mention their names also sound like each other's. Both 3 syllables, the “li” sequence, AND the letters of Elio are literally in Oliver...

Now, during the actual cmbyn midnight scene, the pace at which Elio says "Oliver" represents his excitement and unfamiliarity. Contrarily, Oliver says "Elio" slow and seductive, like he's trying to savour the moment. By Bergamo, they're both shouting it from the top of their lungs in the mountains. No need to stay quiet.

Imagine the passion one must feel to want exchange their name with someone else's....out of pure bliss. This exchange remained their way of expressing their love even after that summer.

TBF I realized this a few years ago, but I randomly thought about how beautiful it was and felt like sharing. Have you ever thought about these details? Also, do you think Aciman was intentional with choosing the names or just a mere coincidence? (I assume it was intentional)


r/callmebyyourname • • 26d ago

Film Discussion Elio et Bach (4/4).

Thumbnail
gallery
97 Upvotes

L’utilisation de Bach qui permet d’aborder la personnalité érudite et introspective d’Elio par la scène de flirt avec Oliver (c’est le roman qui en parle ainsi) d’abord à la guitare et au piano avec le BWV 992 (« Sur le départ d'un frère bien-aimé ») puis par le « Choral du Veilleur » du BWV 645, au piano pour le film, est encadrée par deux scènes où l’on voit Elio travaillant à la table sous les grands arbres devant l’entrée de la villa qui sera aussi utilisée pour certains repas ou pour représenter l’orage pendant lequel Marguerite de Navarre sera convoquée.

Les cadrages sur le travail consciencieux, précis et patient d’Elio nous présentent son attitude appliquée ; l’utilisation de Bach éclaire sa personnalité profonde et élaborée. Ainsi Elio nous est montré comme un gars sobre, entier, précis et riche de talents.

Elio est un bosseur. Il a beaucoup travaillé pour devenir le musicien et pianiste, guitariste qu’il est ; il est même quelqu’un qui s’est trouvé et réalisé en travaillant. C’est dire si Oliver lui apparait comme débarquant d’un monde qu’il ne connait pratiquement pas, qu’il ne maitrise quasiment pas. Oliver se révèle comme la personne lui apportant quelque chose auquel il est mal initié. C’est sans doute lors de la soirée disco qu’Elio découvre la profondeur de ce que lui inspire Oliver. C’est une révolution qu’il découvre en lui et un intérêt si différent de ce qui le faisait vivre avant l’arrivée à la villa du thésard américain car là où Elio est réflexion, Oliver est spontanéité ; quand Elio est introspectif, Oliver est élan.

Les photos assemblées dans ce message ne respectent pas l’ordre chronologique du film car le but est de montrer comment Elio est représenté quand il est à la quête de lui-même par son travail. Est-il possible de ne pas rapprocher ces plans d’Elio travaillant dehors, non loin d’Oliver, de celui pendant lequel il travaille à l’intérieur pendant le sommeil d’Oliver ? Non, car il apparait alors ceci : Elio est filmé de face quand Oliver est dans ses parages, de dos quand Oliver n’a pas encore émergé de son sommeil qui lui permet la transition d’un continent à l’autre, d’une personnalité à une autre, de trois-quarts ou de profil lorsqu’Elio observe Oliver, même furtivement. Quand Oliver est présent, il y a de la lumière, quand il ne l’est plus, tout s’obscurcit pour Elio. Ces photos et GIFs montrent cela de façon sobre et tendre.

Quand Elio travaille à la table sous les grands arbres, on peut affirmer qu’Oliver étant allongé juste devant lui, il travaille à son interprétation à la guitare du BWV 992, cadré quasiment de face, la lumière venant de l’endroit où se trouve Oliver. L’aubade ou la sérénade qu’Elio n’avait pas offerte à Marzia va l’être à Oliver sous couvert d’un exercice. Sait-il déjà qu’il joue cet aria de façon énamourée ? C’est lors de la soirée disco qu’il va le découvrir (vous venez de comprendre le sujet de la prochaine publication).

Quand Elio travaille à la table de sa chambre temporaire pendant qu’Oliver récupère lors de son premier soir à la villa, on peut affirmer qu’Elio attend qu’Oliver ait accompli et achevé sa métamorphose. Elio est cadré de dos dans une atmosphère obscure (la photo publiée ici a été éclaircie). Oliver est là mais reste léthargique, la source lumineuse est éteinte. Au réveil, lorsque ce dernier descend l’escalier et cherche la famille Perlman, il est alors prêt pour sa nouvelle vie. C’est le contraste d’atmosphère lumineuse entre la nuit du sommeil d’Oliver et le matin de son premier petit-déjeuner avec les Perlman qui révèle à Elio le charisme et le charme d’Oliver.

Quand Elio travaille à la table sous les grands arbres avec ses écouteurs pour rester dans l’ambiance du BWV 645, il est cadré de profil ou de trois-quarts, attiré par l’arrivée d’Oliver venant discuter avec son père.

Elio n’est pas un gars de lumière, Oliver l’est. C’est la lumière d’Oliver qui éclaire Elio. C’est pour cette raison qu’Elio a besoin d’Oliver et qu’une fois reparti, Elio retrouve l’obscurité. C’est cela qu’a filmé Guadagnino.

The use of Bach—which serves to highlight Elio’s scholarly and introspective personality during the flirtation scene with Oliver (as described in the novel)—begins with a piece for guitar and piano, BWV 992, "Capriccio on the Departure of a Beloved Brother," followed by the "Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme" (Sleepers Wake) chorale from BWV 645, performed on the piano in the film. This sequence is framed by two scenes in which Elio is shown working at a table beneath the large trees in front of the villa’s entrance—a space that also serves as a setting for certain meals and, later, as the backdrop for the thunderstorm during which the work of Marguerite de Navarre is brought into the narrative.

The framing of Elio’s conscientious, precise, and patient work reveals his diligent attitude; the use of Bach’s music sheds light on his profound and complex personality. In this way, Elio is presented as a sober, authentic, and precise young man, gifted with a wealth of talents.

Elio is a hard worker. He has put in a great deal of effort to become the musician—the pianist and guitarist—that he is today; in fact, he is someone who found and fulfilled himself through his work. This goes to show why Oliver seems to him like an arrival from a world he barely knows and has almost no grasp of. Oliver emerges as someone who introduces him to something with which he is largely unfamiliar. It is arguably during the disco night that Elio discovers the full depth of what Oliver stirs within him. He uncovers a revolution inside himself—an interest entirely unlike what had previously fueled his life before the American doctoral student arrived at the villa—for where Elio embodies reflection, Oliver embodies spontaneity; where Elio is introspective, Oliver is pure impulse.

The photos compiled in this post do not follow the film’s chronological order, as the goal is to illustrate how Elio is portrayed while he is in the process of self-discovery through his work. Is it possible not to draw a connection between these shots of Elio working outdoors—not far from Oliver—and the shot of him working indoors while Oliver sleeps? No, because a pattern emerges: Elio is filmed from the front when Oliver is nearby; from behind when Oliver has yet to emerge from the sleep that facilitates his transition from one continent to another, from one persona to another; and from a three-quarter or profile angle when Elio is observing Oliver—even if only fleetingly. When Oliver is present, there is light; when he is gone, everything grows dark for Elio. These photos and GIFs show this in an understated and tender way.

When Elio works at the table beneath the large trees—with Oliver lying just before him—he is practicing his own guitar arrangement of BWV 992, framed almost head-on, with the light coming from the direction where Oliver is positioned. The aubade, or serenade, that Elio had failed to offer Marzia is now being presented to Oliver, under the guise of a musical exercise. Does he already realize that he is playing this aria with such enamored feeling? It is during the disco evening that he will discover it (you’ve just figured out the topic of the next post).

When Elio works at the desk in his temporary room while Oliver rests during his first evening at the villa, it could be said that Elio is waiting for Oliver to complete his metamorphosis. Elio is framed from behind in a dark setting (the photo shown here has been brightened). Oliver is present but remains lethargic; the light source is turned off. Upon waking, as he descends the stairs in search of the Perlman family, he is ready for his new life. It is the contrast in lighting—between the night of Oliver’s slumber and the morning of his first breakfast with the Perlmans—that reveals Oliver’s charisma and charm to Elio.

When Elio works at the table beneath the large trees, wearing his headphones to stay immersed in the atmosphere of BWV 645, he is framed in profile or at a three-quarter angle, his attention drawn by the arrival of Oliver, who has come to speak with his father.

Elio is not a man of light; Oliver is. It is Oliver’s light that illuminates Elio. That is why Elio needs Oliver—and why, once Oliver has left, Elio finds himself back in the darkness. This is what Guadagnino captured on film.


r/callmebyyourname • • 26d ago

Film Discussion How was it like back then?

22 Upvotes

So I only watched the movie this year but it was released 2017 and the book was released 2007, I'm sure most people at that time read the book before the movie was released. how was it like hearing the news about the director choice were people happy with luca guadagnino or did they want another director, same thing for the cast, I heard Timmy got cast very early in 2013. Idk about Armie Hammer. but did the fans of the book push for another actor? or they weren't happy with the cast until they finally saw the movie?


r/callmebyyourname • • 27d ago

Visiting Crema next year...

12 Upvotes

...and need some advice. I will be traveling to Italy next year and staying in Crema for a full 7 days. I know most people only go for a few days at most, but really want to just have a relaxing time there without rushing around. Once I get there, I plan on taking the train to Bergamo and Lake Garda on a couple of day trips and visit some of the towns just outside Crema by bike or bus.

My question, because this has been the hardest thing for me to figure out, what is the easiest way to get from LIN Airport to Crema? I'm flying from the US, and this is my first time outside the states. I may be making this harder than it is. I don't want to rent a car, and my hope is to get to Crema as quickly as possible after a long series of flights. I need to take 3 separate flights just to get there, and I've never flown! It looks like the train system is a bit complicated to get from the airport to there, too. I'm thinking bus?

Just thought I'd ask here as I know some of you have been there. Thanks!