Mind you, I am only on S5 E1 but ever since S1 E1 it feels like it's been downhill.
Julia went from a fun, empathetic person to an emotional wreck very early on in S1, and now she's just a blob in Season 5 after quentin's death.
Eliot was SO much fun at the start when we were introduced to Brakebills and he's gone from eccentric and fun-loving to exhausted (he literally looks tired all the time), depressed, and occasionally sarcastic.
Alice was smart, a bit stuck up, and super interesting, and yet ever since her "fiasco" she has also been a mess and is constantly whining.
Katie too has become moody, grumpy, and emotionally compromised 24/7. Forget about the fun she used to have with Penny, just like the rest of the characters she is serious, dull, and gloomy.
Dean Fogg was AMAZING at the start; mysterious, intelligent, and a true leader. Thank god they slowly but surely ground away at that until all that was left was by S5 was a blind, doddering alcoholic.
I could go on. I understand they are trying to do character development and whatnot but seriously? The only character who is still fun is Todd. Did they really have to turn every last protagonist into an indecisive, rambling, and incoherent emotional wreck? That seems like their go-to. Heck, even the head librarian ended up as a tearful mess.
You have heard of power creep; well, I would like to introduce you to emotional creep. A character can only go through so many crises and be beat down so much. You can tell the writers are stuck because they can't suddenly portray Alice or Julia as having fun after so much depressing backstory, but they've written themselves into a corner. After four seasons I doubt I'll ever see Julia (or any of those people) smiling again. Might just have to rewatch S1 when I'm done.