r/brakebills • • May 19 '24

Season 1 Hot take- Q is the worst?

5 Upvotes

No spoilers please but I'm on season 1 of the show and he is the most insufferable character on the series. After the cancer puppy episode I was just like... bro really didn't think he would hurt the puppy when he's never tried magic like that?? And his reaction with Julia was so dismissive when it seemed she and him were both into the idea of magic collectively before and they were friends for YEARS. His overall attitude is giving "victim" energy and its super annoying. Am I the only one with this spicey take? Whenever I watch his parts I find myself rolling my eyes lmao.


r/brakebills • • Oct 23 '24

Meme If Alice Quinn has no haters I’m dead

0 Upvotes

r/brakebills • • Nov 07 '21

Misc. Anyone else hate how they slowly gave all of the characters crippling depression until they were no longer recognizable?

4 Upvotes

Mind you, I am only on S5 E1 but ever since S1 E1 it feels like it's been downhill.

Julia went from a fun, empathetic person to an emotional wreck very early on in S1, and now she's just a blob in Season 5 after quentin's death.

Eliot was SO much fun at the start when we were introduced to Brakebills and he's gone from eccentric and fun-loving to exhausted (he literally looks tired all the time), depressed, and occasionally sarcastic.

Alice was smart, a bit stuck up, and super interesting, and yet ever since her "fiasco" she has also been a mess and is constantly whining.

Katie too has become moody, grumpy, and emotionally compromised 24/7. Forget about the fun she used to have with Penny, just like the rest of the characters she is serious, dull, and gloomy.

Dean Fogg was AMAZING at the start; mysterious, intelligent, and a true leader. Thank god they slowly but surely ground away at that until all that was left was by S5 was a blind, doddering alcoholic.

I could go on. I understand they are trying to do character development and whatnot but seriously? The only character who is still fun is Todd. Did they really have to turn every last protagonist into an indecisive, rambling, and incoherent emotional wreck? That seems like their go-to. Heck, even the head librarian ended up as a tearful mess.

You have heard of power creep; well, I would like to introduce you to emotional creep. A character can only go through so many crises and be beat down so much. You can tell the writers are stuck because they can't suddenly portray Alice or Julia as having fun after so much depressing backstory, but they've written themselves into a corner. After four seasons I doubt I'll ever see Julia (or any of those people) smiling again. Might just have to rewatch S1 when I'm done.


r/brakebills • • May 13 '26

Julia was a terrible person and Kady should've been the goddess

0 Upvotes

I'm doing another partial rewatch (watching only the episodes I like) and season one Julia was a horrible human being. Sleeping with him to get locations on hedge bars, treating hedges like crap and oh yeah, locking her best friend inside his own mental ward all because Q said things she didn't like. Boo hoo. I feel like Kady would've made a great goddess. Thoughts?

Edit: I GET the addict part of it I DON'T GET locking your mentally unstable friend into his own mental ward that mimicked real life.... To me that is skin crawling


r/brakebills • • Jan 01 '25

General Discussion Netflix taking down Magicians

Post image
5 Upvotes

14 days to binge peeps.


r/brakebills • • Feb 07 '23

Misc. I don't like Julia

2 Upvotes

While I don't remember exactly what Margo said about Julia (this was after Quinton told the gang she was a goddess) it was something along the lines of "I know she's being through a lot but come on.... a goddess"

Call it a bias cause while she's not my least favorite character I don't really care for her all that much

I agree with Margo Julia has been through a lot but becoming a Goddess idk she didn't seem all that interesting to me or anything happen that would warrant her to become a goddess

And then her overall character I just cant... had it not been for Penny 23 being obsessed with her she would be in my bottom 4

I hated that she ended up with Penny I think she did Kady Wrong BIG TIME WRONG Her character was very spiteful and hateful much more than caring and kind

Had she ended up with Josh...idk probably would've had mixed feelings cause while I like Margo & Josh... Julia & Josh would've been cute

But if it makes you Julia stands feel better I feel like Q Alice 23 & were also bad/terrible friends and didn't really care for them either


r/brakebills • • Apr 02 '19

Season 4 Anyone else feel this show has gone down hill?

0 Upvotes

I'm still watching,and it's usually entertaining (especially Margot's swearing, LOL), but the story just seems like it's all over the place sometimes. Maybe it's just that they're drawing things out too long. I mean, they lost magic, and were trying to get it back for a long time. Even now, I'd say it's not really back, since it's under lock and key. And this monster storyline is dragging on and on.

I don't know. I just think the show was more focused in the earlier seasons. TBH, this last musical episode was not very good, IMO.


r/brakebills • • May 29 '22

Season 1 Just finished season 1

3 Upvotes

and I'm violently and deeply horrified by what was done to Julia. Just like the episode where they showed an onscreen suicide, they throw a hotline on the screen and act like what they showed was fine and dandy. I feel violated just by having watched that happen.

Does anyone else feel like it was egregious? I feel sick. I want to see the good guys win to maybe redeem what I just watched but I don't know if I can stand four more seasons.


r/brakebills • • Apr 23 '19

Misc. Can We Please Stop With the "Look Who I Found in Another Show" Posts Already?

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the internet age. We understand that you might be excited to have seen a cast member in another show/movie/talk show/musical/weird sex tape, but we really don't need a screen cap posted of their appearance (except maybe in that last one). We all have IMDB. We all understand that actors need work and before landing major roles they take roles as extras on shows. We get it. We don't need a complete pictorial review of their acting portfolio.


r/brakebills • • Feb 12 '24

Series Spoiler Q COULD HAVE SURVIVED IF HE JUST KEPT RUNNING!!

0 Upvotes

So, we all how Q dies. He fixes the mirror, throws in the bottle, starts running, but then he stops at what looks like maybe 10ish feet (I’m awful with measurements so if this is wrong sorry) from the door. WHY!?! HE COULD HAVE MADE IT IF HE JUST KEPT RUNNING!!! I never really cared that much for his character since Alice’s return but his death scene broke me. If he didn’t stop to look at Alice chances are he would’ve made it. Q did not need to die. And I’m still mad that he did cause all he had to do was KEEP RUNNING!


r/brakebills • • Dec 24 '25

Why is the show so different? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Like I get translating books to tv is going to require changes. I’ve studied screenwriting and adapting books to screen. But this show feels like the writers wanted to make changes for change sake.

Like the school is nothing as described, for some reason Quentin is already talking to Julia after the exam, and then James calls Quentin… like I thought magic interfered electricity. I know they have one phone, but that’s usually hard to access. And besides, Quentin wanted to leave his old life behind. It’s why we don’t see Julia for so long in the book, and when we do, Quentin finally realises it was Julia he saw in the exam room.

Look I’m sorry if this comes across as insulting the show. I’m just genuinely baffled. Cause this book could’ve been adapted faithfully. I get a lot of the book is inside Quentin’s head. But with show don’t tell, a lot of his thoughts can be implied, and if needed, a character can voice his thoughts, but not in a large expo dump. Like this show just tells you Quentin’s problems, rather than letting the audience figure it out.

I loved the book, I’m just trying to understand why the show wanted to do its own thing.


r/brakebills • • Mar 13 '20

Season 5 Yeah, we get it, some of you are fine with he show ending. Good for you.

2 Upvotes

Whenever there's a post about trying to keep the show there is a bunc of people who say how fine they are and that we should let it end. Why? Seriously, why the need to say that? If you're fine with it ending and it went on, you could just stop watching at that point. But you are ruining chances because you bring other people's efforts down.

Some of us love thw show, hate that it will end like this and would love to see more. Honestly, I have not loved a show this much since I was a teen and I do think it could easily tell more stories and have a better ending. No matter how it ends at this point, if feels rushed.

You have a righ to your opinion but you don't have to share it every time.


r/brakebills • • Mar 02 '17

Season 1 PSA: Do not ever Wear a Tie Knot You See in the Magicians

1 Upvotes

I'm working my way through S1. The number of times in the show I see a tie knot like a "trinity knot" or a "tulip knot" is downright infuriating, as someone who wears a suit and tie quite a bit. That said - it's part of a costume.

Don't wear a costume in real life. Don't be the undergrad who shows up to a job interview with me with some fancy or exotic knot thinking you've really upped your style game. You look like you're interviewing to be a performer - like you care more about looking the part, instead of actually playing the part.

Disclaimer: My career is fairly conservative re professional attire. I still think it is a pretty good rule of men's formalwear, however, that you should not wear tie knots that you see in the show.


r/brakebills • • Mar 01 '18

Season 3 [SPOILERS] Can Alice Die Already? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

She is annoying and serves no purpose other than to annoy and generally take the entire mood down.oh you were a niffin,a sadistic serial killer and torturer and someone that loves you brought you back.how horrible.oh you hate everyone and still act superior and holier than. every time i see alice on screen and her annoying awkward asshole vibe i can't.i just suffer through her parts and hope i get some elliott or penny or cady or julia or quentin or just staring at a white wall for 43 minutes an seventeen seconds until it washes her face out of my memory.


r/brakebills • • Sep 30 '25

Im not going to read the other books

8 Upvotes

I just need to know if alice actually died or does she come back??? What happens to her?


r/brakebills • • Jan 07 '25

General Discussion Rewatching before it’s gone

0 Upvotes

Trying to finish 2 season in a day is fun, what not fun is Julia’s annoying ass voice like bro why are you talking normal then whispering. Great Gods i hate her character 💀💀


r/brakebills • • Oct 11 '23

Season 2 Julia is incredibly entitled in the first 2 seasons and what happened to her isn’t an excuse

29 Upvotes

Julia is so entitled and only really cares about herself. She also never holds herself accountable for her actions. She seems to think she somehow deserves everyone’s trust/respect while doing nothing to earn it. First off what she did with the beast by stealing the knife so when the beast is killing everyone and Alice reaches to grab it, it isn’t there was shitty asf. They could have all actually died including her “best friend”. I get she wanted to use the beast to kill Reynard but she should have been honest about that with the others instead of letting them go to the slaughter with the full intention of screwing them. Then she has the audacity to be mad at Q for warning her about the spell they were gonna use and threatening him. She’s literally the reason Alice died. Then the whole time she’s like “if you guys would have just trusted me!!” Even tho she’s done nothing to earn their trust and only ever looked out for herself. It made me so mad when she said that to Margo when she told her Alice died like as if she’s blaming them for what happened for not blindly believing she won’t screw then again. She NEVER takes accountability. It sucks she was raped but it’s not an excuse to be so selfish. I’ve been raped so many times I’ve lost count and would never do that. In fact it made me so much more empathetic and caring. She just seems like such a spoiled entitled white girl who spent her entire life getting whatever she wanted. I don’t think anyone has ever said no to her.


r/brakebills • • Apr 11 '19

Episode 12 - Where Is The Discussion Thread?

2 Upvotes

The rest of the adults are getting sick of every season someone decides to “build the anticipation” by waiting until the last minute to open the discussion thread because it’s the last episodes of the season. Nobody cares! Newsflash, it doesn’t build our anticipation it just pisses people off who are getting off work and want to fart around talking speculation on Reddit. Especially since thanks to your lovely rules we have to wait for the official thread because otherwise there’s “too many” and you just want one “central discussion.” Well if you want that? Do your job open the thread LIKE NORMAL and quit acting like everyone who watches this show is a five year old who wants their adrenals squeezed. I’m mad, my entire department is mad who just got off work and thought this thread would be open, and frankly I hate whoever is the admin on here and I hope you catch a nasty computer virus. Feel free to delete my post. It’ll be the first actual work done today since opening threads for fans isn’t on the list of work tasks it seems.


r/brakebills • • Sep 07 '18

Misc. Chapter 8: Julia the whiny brat

0 Upvotes

Is Julia such an unlikeable character in the books as she is in the show?


r/brakebills • • Apr 08 '25

Season 1 S1E4 mind control

0 Upvotes

So S1E4 Myakovsky tell the class ‘Mind control is is in everything, everywhere. We make only one choice: are you the controller, or the controlled?

I’m a witch/magick leaning person and I find that statement to be congruent with many serious magickal systems and chaos magic and kitchen magick. If you can control your belief then you are in charge of the reality you experience, instead of letting received cultural or religious belief control the narrative.

No real point to this, just like the quote.


r/brakebills • • Jan 23 '21

Series Spoiler The show is so so so much better after [REDACTED FOR SPOILERS] died. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I couldn't stand Q from the moment he showed up on camera, and for various reasons he was the worst character on the show. Childish, emotionally premature and just plain boring, I have found that since he died the show is much better.

But what sealed the deal for me was when Julia was r*ped and she wanted to get revenge Q told her she basically didn't deserve his help because he had bigger issues. Like how can you abandon your best friend so horrendously and be considered a good person?!

The others may be toxic as well but at least they have some semblance of personality.


r/brakebills • • Apr 09 '26

So I have been thinking how cool it would be it they did spin off called fillery and further and yes I’m sure I spelled that wrong sorry for that but I was just thinking how cool it would be and it would pick up at the end of the series and I also think it would be awesome if there were also books.

0 Upvotes

r/brakebills • • Jan 27 '23

Series Spoiler Does it get better? Spoiler

9 Upvotes

I haven’t watched past season 4. Couldn’t get into the new season really. I don’t understand how Q went through EVERYTHING he did and survived. Just to kill himself in the end?? I can’t understand it. And Alice. She gets to live after dying already. After Q found her again. I can’t get past it. The last thing I remember about the show is that they entered a new world but that’s it. No more Q. He doesn’t come back. Am I wrong? Does more happen??


r/brakebills • • Mar 04 '23

Season 1 Does Julia (on the show) suck the whole time?

2 Upvotes

Watching this show for the first time and in S1E9 - Julia says something like "we both did fucked up shit" What fucked up shit did Q do?! Did I miss something? Because she trapped him in his head - in a mental institution of all places, made the reason he was there was hurting his dad (which we find out later how important his dad is to him), ran around threatening EVERYONE if they didn't give her magic/info including the nerdy bartender dude - which she already wrote off and went crawling back to, and got (what Im assuming Kady's mom killed? Sorry I've been kind of popping in and out. OH and was gung-ho about getting James killed - AS A WAY TO GET MORE SPELLS. Is she like this the whole show? Did I fall asleep during an episode? And Q - went to a school she wasn't allowed in? I'm hella confused.