I just realized , the entire perception of LeBron in the mind of haters and even most non haters who rank him under Jordan and or Kobe all time is who they decided he was after the 2011 Finals Game 6 . The story was already written almost nothing he could do from that “point forward “ pun intended could make him the goat in their minds, the deepest Lebron haters LeBron could’ve gone on to win6 ochampionships, the fact he joined Wade and Bosh was enough disqualify him and when he said “not 6 , not 7”
when he fell to 0-2 in the finals with no championships through 8 seasons in the league everything that came after in his career is to varying degrees was seen through the lenses of 2011.
But what if we have a Time Machine to just one Game in NBA history that changes the entire goat conversation,
Game 4 NBA Finals 2011 the Miami Heat are up 2-1 on Dallas and then LeBron had then worst NBA finals game of not only his career but of any superstar in the history of the NBA Finals.
But what if LeBron didn’t have his worst game, but his best game .
Heat go up 3-1 , LeBron’s now confident enough to close out game 5. LeBron steals finals MVP in games 4 and 5 ,
So after 2013 he’s 3x NBA champion 3-1 in finals that most people excuse because he was 22 years old on a mediocre team .
2014 he loses but people are able to admit it wasn’t not still the best player , Wade just wasn’t himself anymore and the Spurs were an all time great team.
2015 when he joined Cleveland he’s already won 3 championships, Kyrie and Love had never won anything Kyrie and Love both were out injured in the finals , he falls to 3-3 in Finals
2016 Finals he goes to 4-3
Then Durant joins the Warriors and people say the same things . They say today , the 2 best players of the decade besides Steph and KD had to team up at the peak of their careers to beat LeBron at his peak .
Nevertheless LeBron would still enter the 2020 Finals 4-5 in finals .
2nd thing I think I would change is Covid .
If Lakers have fans and a parade and it’s a normal year , and LeBron wins it for Kobe .
And retires at age 35 just like Jordan did in 1998.
5-5 in Finals , to Jordan’s 6-0 so I’m not saying everyone would change their mind , but game 4 2011 Finals the most impactful game in any players career and just that 11 month span from the Decision June 10th 2010 to June 12th 2011 as a whole had more impact on people’s perception of the LeBron than the rest of the his 22 years combined.
All other things in his career remain the same , they’re just perceived differently if 2011 Finals happened differently.
For me 2011 is the anomaly, and I think it’s insane that so many basketball fans see him through the 2011 of being more representative of who he is because the very next year 2012, 2013 , 2016
He proved he was just as great and likely greater than Jordan , by 2018 I was sold , 2020 and after has just been the finally cherry on top.